Muscular dystrophy drug rejected for use by NICE
Myasthenia gravis causes fatigue and muscle weakness, double vision, slurred speech, and difficulty with chewing, swallowing and making facial expressions."If you weigh up the cost of the drug against the hospitalisations, invasive procedures, surgeons and one-to-one care I have needed at times - I think prevention [with efgartigimod] is a cost-effective option," Mr Stephenson said."This is the first drug which has made a huge improvement and, unless you are a multimillionaire, you are not going to be able to afford to get it."
'Immense relief'
Mr Stephenson was diagnosed in 2003 when, after leaving the armed forces, he began to struggle to exercise, close his eyes or smile."Food would get stuck in my throat and I would have to reach down and pull it out," he said."When I was drinking, I was choking, and water was pouring out of my nose."You worry, 'how am I going to live like this, what am I going to do?'"The father-of-four's symptoms fitted in with a recent car crash, but physiotherapists referred him to a neurologist who tested for the condition.Mr Stephenson said: "The diagnosis was an immense relief."If you have a chronic illness, it's good to learn about it, because you're going to be stuck with it forever."Adults who took part in a trial for efgartigimod reported regaining the ability to walk daily, dress independently, and some returned to work or education."Anybody who is on the drug at the minute can stay on it, but for new patients, it's not going to be available to them."I feel so lucky to be on it," Mr Stephenson said."I feel honoured and privileged to have been on the trial."Doctors will be able to privately prescribe the drug, also known as Vyvgart, meaning patients who can pay for it will still be able to benefit.According to drug company Argenx, the price for one 400mg infusion vial is £6,569.73.The number of vials used for one infusion, which Mr Stephenson said he has fortnightly, depends on the individual.
'Disheartening message'
Andy Fletcher, chief executive of charity Muscular Dystrophy UK, said the decision not to approve the drug for NHS use "sends a disheartening message to those affected by rare and complex conditions"."Treatments are within their grasp, but their needs are not being prioritised," he said.NICE said efgartigimod was an add-on alongside other treatments, rather than a replacement.Argenx appealed against the decision on the basis that the drug is a replacement, but NICE rejected the appeal."They got ignored and that, for everybody, was so frustrating," Mr Stephenson said."Our story should've made some sort of impact, but it feels it got bypassed and overlooked."NICE said drugs like efgartigimod replace other treatments only temporarily, providing "small benefits".A spokesperson said effective and fast-acting treatments like efgartigimod would be "welcomed" by patients, given the side effects and slow-acting nature of current treatments, but NICE could not justify the cost."The cost-effectiveness estimates [for efgartigimod] are substantially above what NICE considers an acceptable use of NHS resources," they said."We know this decision will be disappointing for people living with this debilitating condition and those who care for them."Muscular Dystrophy UK said Wales and Northern Ireland tend to follow NICE guidance, meaning patients there will most likely also be affected.A separate decision process is under way in Scotland.
Listen to highlights from South Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
22 minutes ago
- The Sun
Terrified mum shares the chilling nursery snap of her toddler that saved his life – but can you spot the hidden killer?
LAURA Davies claims a photo of her son playing at nursery "saved his life" by revealing a potentially fatal hidden cancer. The picture caught a strange cloudiness in two-year-old Sidney's eye, which was actually a sign of retinoblastoma, a rare eye cancer that can affect young children. 6 6 6 "I've got to be honest I probably wouldn't have noticed it [without the picture]," the 39-year-old mum-of-two from Flintshire, said. Laura said her husband Tom Davies, 39, first noticed a strange cloudiness in their two-year-old son Sidney's left eye in April when it hit the light. "He was basically sat in his high chair opposite the French doors in our kitchen and my husband was like, 'his eye doesn't look right," she recalled. The mum searched online for information relating to cloudy eyes but all that came up was information about cataracts so she just made a mental note to keep tabs. But when Sidney's nursery took a snap of him as he enjoyed a day in the sensory room, the camera flash revealed his left eye was cloudy compared to his right. "It was almost like it was reflecting the light, it's really hard to describe. It was like his eye wasn't there, it was like a mirror," Laura said. After a visit to her GP and Specsavers, Sidney was eventually referred to Birmingham Children's Hospital and had an ultrasound. He was diagnosed with retinoblastoma, a cancer which starts in the retina, the inner layer in the back of the eye, on May 19. Doctors diagnose around 40 to 50 children with retinoblastoma in the UK every year, according to Cancer Research UK. Almost 99 to 100 out of every 100 children diagnosed survive for five years or more after they are diagnosed. "It was horrendous," the mum said. "We were so worried." Docs decided the best course of action would be to remove the eye and brave Sidney underwent the op on 27 May. Initially this really concerned Laura. "All the thoughts run through your head of how they are going to cope in school and kids are horrible and things like that. "But I was also looking at it [the eye] and thinking, 'I just want it out' because you could literally see it [the cancer]." She said it was "so scary" to watch their young so endure so many operations. "I think we went into mum and dad mode," she explained. "You kind of just get through it. 6 6 "Afterwards when we found out that he was okay and he didn't need any chemotherapy then it all hit me if I'm honest. "I burst out crying [when he got the all clear]. It was such a relief." Sidney currently has a temporary plastic shell fitted in his eye socket called a conformer but is undergoing another operation in July to have a prosthetic eye fitted. Laura said docs also discovered Sidney's retina was torn and had come away from the back of his eye, which can cause vision loss. They were not sure how long it had been since he had been able to see out of his left eye. "I don't know whether it was bothering him before, whether it was blurry. We'll never know really," the mum said. 'A new lease of life' The tot will have to wear protective goggles when he plays sport but other than that Laura hopes her son will be largely unaffected by the prosthetic. "In terms of the effects on him it's been quite minimal because he's already dealt with that himself, not being able to see out of that eye," she explained. "He will go down the steps very carefully unlike my other son who is older and who's like a bull at a gate. "You sort of think back and think, 'maybe that's why?' but he's a happy boy, he showed no signs of this. We didn't notice that he couldn't see out of his eye." She added: "It's funny because people have said when they see him on the school run and things that he's got a new lease of life. Laura's husband is taking part in a sponsored walk up and down Moel Famau, the highest hill in the Clwydian Range, 12 times in 12 hours with family and friends to raise money for Birmingham Children's hospital. The have launched a JustGiving page, wich has already raised £955 of it's £1000 target. The distance will be around 40 miles in total and Laura said she and their two children are planning to join him for the last summit. Symptoms of retinoblastoma Most children with retinoblastoma seem fine. But two common signs that parents first notice in their child are that: they have a white glow or white reflection in the centre of their eye (pupil) - this is also known as leukocoria their eyes are not looking in the same direction (a squint) - also known as strabismus The pupil might look white, like a cat's eye reflecting light. This is sometimes noticed in photos when a flash is used. The pupil appears white rather than the typical red colour. Other less common symptoms might include: you or the school noticing your child can't see properly inflammation and reddening of their eye uncontrollable movement of their eye from side to side (nystagmus) Children do not usually complain of any pain. In very few cases, a child might be referred to a specialist children's doctor (paediatrician) because they are: not gaining weight developing normally During their tests, the abnormal retinoblastoma gene usually shows up in a blood test. Specsavers Broughton Park Ophthalmic director Kelly Gibson said: "We're incredibly grateful that Laura attended with her son, Sidney, to see us after being alerted by a concern from his nursery. "It's reassuring to know that I was able to ensure he received the urgent care he needed. "We're relieved that his condition was caught early, and he received treatment in a timely manner. "Stories like this are a powerful reminder of how important it is to attend for an eye examination if you ever notice a change or feel that something isn't quite right with your eyes. "It also highlights the importance of eye examinations for children, whether it is due to a concern or a routine review, we look after all ages. "An eye examination can sometimes uncover signs of more serious health conditions, and acting early can make all the difference." 6
Telegraph
22 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Streeting: Half my colleagues use weight-loss jabs
Wes Streeting has revealed that 'half my colleagues' are on weight-loss jabs. The Health Secretary said the slimming drugs were 'the talk of the House of Commons' as he pledged to widen access. Robert Jenrick and Nadine Dorries are among the politicians who have admitted taking weight-loss jabs. The drugs, which include Wegovy and Mounjaro, were originally designed to treat Type 2 diabetes but are now in widespread use by those looking to lose weight. Speaking on LBC, Mr Streeting said: 'Weight-loss jabs are the talk of the House of Commons. Half my colleagues are on them and are judging the rest of us, saying 'You lot should be on them'.' Mr Jenrick, the shadow justice secretary, admitted to taking Ozempic last year but said he stopped after 'a short period of time'. He said: 'To be honest, I was overweight. I took Ozempic for a short period of time, didn't particularly enjoy it, but it was helpful. 'Since then I've just lost weight in the normal way by eating less, eating more healthily, doing some exercise – going to the gym, going running.' Ms Dorries wrote in the Daily Mail that taking the weight-loss jabs had given her the confidence to wear bikinis this summer. She said: 'My overall health is massively improved; my blood tests are all normal, the pain in my left hip has disappeared and the aches and niggles are now just what you would expect for a woman of my age. 'So, am I beach ready? Am I looking forward to my first post-Mounjaro summer holiday? In short, yes!' Mr Streeting told the media on Thursday morning: 'The thing is, if you can afford these weight-loss jabs, which can be over 200 quid a month, well, that's all right for you. 'But most people in this country haven't got a spare two-and-a-half grand a year, and often the people who have the worst and most challenging obesity also have the lowest income. 'So I'm bringing to weight-loss jabs the principle of fairness which has underpinned the NHS.' He added: 'It should be available based on need and not the ability to pay. And that's what we're going to do on weight-loss jabs, as well as a number of other things, including people getting more fit, more active, supporting people on diet and nutrition... that's the bit of the weight-loss jab debate that sometimes gets lost. 'It's not that you can have some weight-loss jabs and stuff your face with Jaffa cakes...' He said obesity costs the NHS billions a year, adding that taxes have been going 'up and up' to pay for the health service.
Daily Mail
23 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Young mother-of-two shares one piece of misinformation everyone needs to know about killer disease - after 'piles' turned out to be stage 3 bowel cancer
Busy working mother Jenna Borthwick could always find a reasonable explanation for feeling under the weather; she was tired, it was her period, it was just another flu from nursery. But in reality, she was one of the thousands of young Britons unaware that they are living with deadly bowel cancer. The 31-year-old, from the Scottish Borders, posting on TikTok, revealed the one bit of crucial 'misinformation' that might be stopping people from taking their symptoms seriously. In a series of images titled 'symptoms that led to my bowel cancer diagnosis in March 2025', she goes into greater detail about how it was discovered that she had an advanced stage of the disease. She wrote: 'So many people asking what my symptoms were: some of these like the tiredness/cramps/and catching colds could be traced back quite a few months but it's so easy to pin these down to something else. 'Busy working mum? Of course I'm tired. Cramps? Must be getting my period! Why am I catching every single cold/ flu going around? Must be my toddlers coming home from nursery!' She continued that it was only a few months before her formal diagnosis that more physical symptoms began to ramp up, and she thanks her doctor for taking her concerns seriously and agreeing that 'there was something not quite right'. Summarising how she was 'constantly ill in the lead up to my diagnosis', Ms Borthwick said that she needed the toilet every time she ate, had blood in her faeces, had abdominal cramps, and felt like she needed to empty her bowels constantly. 'The other symptoms only started two/three months prior to my diagnosis and I actually went to my GP quite quickly,' she added. 'I was super lucky that she ran tests quite early on and she knew there was something not quite right. 'We did however think it was piles to start with, and then inflammatory bowel disease as I think the symptoms are very similar.' Ms Borthwick then revealed the common piece of misinformation which could cost lives. She said: 'People always told me bright red blood wasn't anything to worry about and that dark blood was what you had to watch out for, this is so wrong. Get any sort of blood in your poo checked.' Due to the blood in her faeces, Ms Borthwick was referred for a colonoscopy—where a thin flexible camera is inserted into the rectum—by her GP who wanted to rule out conditions like Crohn's Disease, a type of inflammatory bowel disease. But it was during this initial investigation that doctors discovered a 'tumour so large it was close to being a full bowel obstruction'—and things began to rapidly escalate. Ms Borthwick recalled: 'I was bossing life at work on the Monday, told I had cancer the Tuesday, admitted into the hospital the Wednesday, and [had] surgery the Thursday.' Her cancer was found to be stage 3 an advanced stage that means while the cancer has begun to spread it has yet to reach distant parts of the body. Ms Borthwick underwent an eight hour surgery to remove the mass from the left side of her bowel. While the operation was a success she has to undergo a four month course of chemotherapy, to try and eliminate any remaining traces of the cancer. Before beginning the treatment, Ms Borthwick told her followers that she underwent an egg retrieval procedure at Edinburgh Fertility Clinic so she and her husband could hopefully fulfil their dream of having a third child. Her case comes amid a concerning and mysterious rise in rates of bowel cancer among under 50s. A recent global study found rates of bowel cancer in under 50 year-olds are rising in 27 of 50 nations. England is averaging a 3.6 per cent rise in younger adults every year - one of the highest increases recorded, with roughly 2 per cent rise among young people in the US. While the disease is known to be linked to obesity, experts have noted that it also seems to be occurring in fit and healthy patients. Some believe the explanation must lie in environmental factors young people have been exposed to more than previous generations, such as plastics and even pollution. Signs of bowel cancer include abdominal pain, a lump in the abdomen, bloating and feeling very tired or short of breath. Bleeding from the back passage, or blood in the stool, occurs when cancerous tumours bleed into the digestive tract. However, bowel cancer can also appear with no symptoms until it has spread, where it becomes harder to treat. Overall, just over half of bowel cancer patients are expected to be alive 10 years after their diagnosis. But cancers of all types are on the rise in young people. In a landmark study, Cancer Research UK examined 50 years of NHS data and found that the risk of developing cancer has risen sharply, particularly among young people. In this demographic diagnoses had risen by up to 23 per cent in people aged 20 to 49. Researchers are still trying to explore factors being the rise in early onset cancers, with some suggesting modern diets, exposures to microplastics, or a combination of several triggers could be to blame.
