Fossils unearthed in Grand Canyon reveal new details of evolutionary explosion of life
The newfound remains of fauna from the region suggest that it offered ideal conditions for life to flourish and diversify, in a 'Goldilocks zone' between harsh extremes elsewhere. This evolutionary opportunity produced a multitude of early animals, including oddballs with peculiar adaptations for survival, according to new research.
During the Cambrian explosion, which played out in the coastal waters of Earth's oceans about 540 million years ago, most animal body types that exist today emerged in a relatively short time span, scientists believe.
Back then, the Grand Canyon was closer to the equator, and the region was covered by a warm, shallow sea teeming with burgeoning life — aquatic creatures resembling modern-day shrimp, pill bugs and slugs — all developing new ways to exploit the abundant resources.
Researchers turned to the Grand Canyon's layers of sedimentary rock to unlock secrets of this pivotal moment in the history of life, digging into the flaky, claylike shale of the Bright Angel Formation where most of the canyon's Cambrian-era fossils have been found.
The study team expected to recover mostly the fossilized remains of hard-shelled invertebrates typical of the region. Instead, the team unearthed something unusual: rocks containing well-preserved internal fragments of tiny soft-bodied mollusks, crustaceans, and priapulids, also known as penis worms.
'With these kinds of fossils, we can better study their morphology, their appearance, and their lifestyle in much greater resolution, which is not possible with the shelly parts,' said Giovanni Mussini, the first author of the study published Wednesday in the journal Science Advances. 'It's a new kind of window on Cambrian life in the Grand Canyon.'
Using high-powered microscopes, the team was able to investigate innovations such as miniature chains of teeth from rock-scraping mollusks and the hairy limbs and molars of filter-feeding crustaceans, providing a rare look into the biologically complex ways Cambrian animals adapted to capture and eat prey.
The 'Goldilocks zone' for innovation
For most of the planet's 4-billion-year history, simplicity reigned.
Single-celled microbes remained stationary on the ocean floor, thriving on chemical compounds such as carbon dioxide and sulfur molecules to break down food. What changed?
Scientists still debate what drove the Cambrian explosion, but the most popular theory is that oxygen in the Earth's atmosphere slowly began to increase about 550 million years ago, said Erik Sperling, an associate professor of Earth and planetary sciences at Stanford University.
Oxygen provided a much more efficient way to metabolize food, giving animals more energy to mobilize and hunt for prey, suggested Sperling, who was not involved in the new study.
Animal Organ Fossils Grand Canyon
Researchers uncovered the internal body parts of Cambrian fauna, such as these bits of sternums from crustaceans. (Mussini et al. via CNN Newsource)
'The (emergence of) predators kicked off these escalatory arms races, and then we basically got the explosion of different ways of doing business,' Sperling said.
During the Cambrian, the shallow sea covering the Grand Canyon was especially oxygen-rich thanks to its perfect, 'Goldilocks' depth, said Mussini, a doctoral student in Earth sciences at the University of Cambridge in the United Kingdom. Ranging from 40 to 50 metres (about 130 to 165 feet) in depth, the ecosystem was undisturbed by the shoreline's constant waves shifting around sediments, and sunlight was still able to reach photosynthesizing plants on the seafloor that could provide oxygen.
The abundance of food and favourable environmental conditions meant that animals could take more evolutionary risks to stay ahead of their competition, Mussini said.
'In a more resource-starved environment, animals can't afford to make that sort of physiological investment,' Mussini said in a news release from the University of Cambridge. 'It's got certain parallels with economics: invest and take risks in times of abundance; save and be conservative in times of scarcity.'
Many soft-bodied fossil finds before this one have come from regions with harsh environments such as Canada's Burgess Shale formation and China's Maotianshan Shales, noted Susannah Porter, a professor of Earth science at the University of California in Santa Barbara who was not involved in the study.
'It's not unlike if paleontologists far in the future only had great fossil records from Antarctica, where harsh cold environments forced people to adapt. … But then found great human fossils in New York City, where people flourished,' Porter explained. 'We have an opportunity to see different sorts of evolutionary pressures that aren't like, it's really cold, it's really hot, there's not a lot of water.'
Weird adaptations of Cambrian animals
While some of the feeding mechanisms uncovered in the Grand Canyon fossils are still around today, others are much more alien.
Among the most freakish: penis worms that turned their mouths inside out, revealing a throat lined with hairy teeth.
The worms, also known as cactus worms, are mostly extinct today, but were widespread during the Cambrian. The fossilized worm found in the Grand Canyon represents a previously unknown species.
Due to its relatively large size — about 3.9 inches (10 centimetres) — and distinct teeth, it was named Kraytdraco spectatus, after the fictional krayt dragon from the Star Wars universe, Mussini said. This particular penis worm appears to have had a gradient of hundreds of branching teeth used to sweep food into an extendable mouth.
'It's a bit hard to understand how exactly it was feeding,' Mussini said. 'But it was probably eating debris on the seafloor, scraping it away with some of the most robust teeth that it had, and then using these other, more delicate teeth to filter and retain it within this long, tube-like mouth.'
Rows of tiny molars, sternal parts and comblike limbs that once belonged to crustaceans were also among the findings, which all date back 507 million to 502 million years. Similar to today's brine shrimp, the crustaceans used these fine-haired limbs to capture floating food from the water and bring it to the mouth, where molars would then grind down the particles, Mussini explained. Nestled among the molars, researchers even found a few unlucky plankton.
Other creatures resembling their modern counterparts included sluglike mollusks. The fossils revealed chains of teeth that likely helped them scrape algae or bacteria from along the seafloor.
'For each of these animals, there's different components, but most of what we found directly relates to the way these animals were processing their food, which is one of the most exciting parts, because it tells us a lot about their lifestyle, and as a consequence, their ecological implications,' Mussini said.
By Kameryn Griesser, CNN
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


CBC
12 hours ago
- CBC
Close encounter with a great white shark near Halifax
Geraldine Fernandez and Neil Hammerschlag tell The National about the moment a male great white shark made a surprise appearance during a research expedition off the coast of Halifax.


Global News
13 hours ago
- Global News
What killed the sea stars? Canadian researchers unlock 12-year-old mystery
A team led by researchers in British Columbia has solved the mystery of a gruesome disease that has killed billions of sea stars along the Pacific coast of North America, more than a decade after the die off. Melanie Prentice, the lead author of a new study, recalls a moment of 'not really believing it' when researchers found a strain of bacteria that was abundant in diseased sea stars and absent in healthy ones. 'My initial reaction was like, 'Okay, so I've done something wrong,'' she said. Prentice said the team spent months trying to disprove their findings, ultimately confirming they had cracked the code of the disease. They found the bacterium Vibrio pectenicida is a clear cause of sea star wasting disease. '(It's) a question that researchers have been trying to answer for about 12 years, so we're beyond thrilled,' said Prentice, a research associate at the Hakai Institute and the University of B.C. department of earth, ocean and atmospheric sciences. Story continues below advertisement The paper detailing the four-year research project and its findings were published online in the peer-reviewed journal Nature Ecology & Evolution on Monday. Alyssa Gehman, who helped launch the project in 2021, described the disease as 'gruesome,' causing sea stars to develop lesions, lose their arms and 'disappear into mush' about a week or two after exposure to the pathogen. It has been especially deadly for sunflower sea stars, killing about six billion of the species that can sprout 24 arms and span up to a metre. The giant sea stars are now considered functionally extinct across much of their former range off the coast of the continental United States, with losses exceeding 87 per cent in the 'northern refuges' where they still persist, the study said. The collapse has had cascading impacts, including widespread losses of ecologically, culturally and economically important kelp forests. 'I think we didn't really appreciate how important they were until we lost them,' Prentice said, describing the orange, purple or brown sunflower stars as a 'keystone' species with an outsized impact on their ecosystem. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy The giant sea stars are top predators, striking fear into other invertebrates. 'Almost everything that lives on the ground underwater runs away from them when they're coming,' said Gehman, a marine disease ecologist at the Hakai Institute and an adjunct professor at the University of B.C.'s Institute of Oceans and Fisheries. Story continues below advertisement They keep sea urchin populations in check, in turn ensuring the health of help forests that provide habitat and food for numerous other species. The devastation of the sunflower sea stars has caused a 'total ecosystem shift,' Prentice said, transforming biodiverse kelp forests into 'urchin barrens.' The bacterium that causes sea star wasting disease had remained elusive for more than a decade since sea stars were first observed dying in large numbers in 2013. The same bacterium has been known to attack scallop larvae. Prentice said the breakthrough came after the research team switched from examining diseased tissues to focusing on the sea stars' coelomic fluid, likening it to the blood of the sea star. Earlier research had involved running the tissues through tiny membrane filters that would have excluded bacteria, which are typically larger than viruses, she explained. The Hakai Institute team started by replicating the initial experiments, but they weren't able to cause disease in healthy sea stars, she said. 'We were doing everything we could and we were just never ever able to cause disease, and so to us that suggested that the pathogen is larger than a virus.' However, after pivoting to coelomic fluid, which Prentice described as 'essentially sea water,' the researchers did trigger disease in healthy sea stars. Story continues below advertisement 'That suggested that the pathogen was in that fluid, and so then we just end up working with a much cleaner, easier tissue type to investigate,' she said. From there, Prentice created a list of all the different microbial species found in wasting sea stars and compare it against the healthy stars in the lab. 'I finally got to a place where I generated these different lists and it was very evident right away that there (were) tons of different Vibrio species within our wasting sea stars and we weren't really seeing that in our healthy sea stars,' she said. Prentice said she then filtered the genetic data to look at each strain of Vibrio bacteria, which led to their eureka moment with Vibrio pectenicida. 'We just saw it in every single wasting sea star sample, and then we looked at our controls and it was just not in any of them,' she said. Prentice said other researchers had wished her 'good luck' when she joined the project, but there was skepticism over whether they would solve the mystery. It felt 'incredible' to be part of a discovery that could help make a meaningful difference in the recovery of sea stars and their ecosystems, she said. Gehman, too, said she wasn't sure the project would result in a singular answer. Story continues below advertisement 'I thought it would be complicated. I thought there would be multiple things relying on other things,' she said. 'This was much clearer than I was expecting.' The discovery allows researchers to turn their efforts to deeper questions, including the possible role of warming ocean temperatures and the potential to breed sea stars in captivity to promote disease resistance and spur recovery, she said. The disease now appears to be seasonal, with outbreaks occurring in the warmer months, suggesting temperature may be a factor, said Gehman, adding she will soon conduct temperature experiments to investigate further. 'Does Vibrio pectenicida grow faster at warmer temperatures and the sea star can sort of survive at the growth rates at cooler temperatures, but when you get to warmer temperatures, they can't, is that what's happening?' The findings could help researchers understand where sea stars may struggle or survive with climate change in the future, Gehman said. Prentice said there are 'remnant' populations of sunflower stars along the B.C. coast, and its 'very possible' some could be more resistant to the wasting disease. She said finding and selectively breeding sea stars with a higher capacity to fight off the disease could produce 'superstar' sea stars for reintroduction in the wild. 'It seems like science fiction sometimes, but people are working on it,' she said.


CTV News
13 hours ago
- CTV News
Retired geologist takes Calgarians on a fossil discovery tour outside a Safeway
The rocks outside the Kensington Safeway are full of ancient fossils estimated to be up to 450 million years old. Talk about a historical tour! A retired Calgary geologist hosted a fossil discovery tour Sunday through the heart of Calgary, where he showed participants examples of fossils that were 450 million years old. Best of all, instead of having to drive to Drumheller to discover the ancient rocks, the group met at the Safeway in Kensington. There, 10 large blocks of tyndall stone, originally from the famed Tydall Formation in Manitoba, which have been serving as rest spots for weary shoppers for years, are actually full of corals, sponges, nautloids, algae, pelecypods, starfish and brachiopods that are all preserved in the limestone. Koning hosted about 15 people Sunday, including a family from Kenya and a girl from Hong Kong. He's given the tour in the past, for the Canadian Energy Geoscience Association and the Alberta Wellness Association and Alberta Paleontological Association -- but when he first discovered that the Safeway limestone blocks were full of fossils, he didn't believe it. " I had never noticed it," he said. 'I've walked through here many, many times, and, and then suddenly I noticed this fossil, and that led to me checking out all these all these blocks here, and finding a whole different variety of fossils. 'And that led to me doing this tour.' Tako Koning Retired Calgary geologist Tako Koning hosted a fossil discovery tour Sunday in Calgary. (CTV Calgary) After examining the ancient rocks outside Safeway, Koning escorted the group up to SAIT, where he said the cladding on the John Burns Building is also full of fossils. Once he realized what he was seeing, Koning did some fact-checking. 'I checked with some experts, some expert paleontologist at University of Calgary, University of Saskatoon, and took pictures of these rocks, and then they confirmed that what I was looking at, the age I was looking at, and the species of fossils. So everything that I show here has been confirmed by experts in the field,' he said. Tour participants gave Koning's tour two thumbs up. 'This tour has done a really excellent job of making us all aware of the incredible pre-historic wonders that you can find, just on your doorstep,' said one woman. 'It's really, really cool.' 'Rocks hold a lot of history i them,' said a man, 'and most people are just sort of strolling by and this gives you another level of appreciation for history -- for maybe the history of Calgary and definitely the history of the planet.'