Why Punjab and Haryana HC will issue contempt of court notice against Punjab govt
This followed a day of high drama at the Nangal dam on Thursday, when the chairperson of Bhakra Beas Management Board (BBMB), Manoj Tripathi, was locked up in the BBMB rest house and not allowed to release water to the neighbouring state.
It is the latest in the recent disagreement between the governments of Punjab and Haryana over water-sharing. Here is what to know.
What happened on Thursday?
On Thursday, workers of the ruling Aam Aadmi Party (AAP) were led by Punjab Cabinet minister Harjot Bains in staging a dharna outside Sutlej Sadan, the BBMB guesthouse. They aimed to stop Tripathi from releasing water to Haryana, and locked him inside the rest house. He was later 'rescued' in a police vehicle and moved out.
The main gate of the resthouse was locked while the minister sat on a dharna for several hours. Later, Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann also arrived at the spot. The Punjab and Haryana High Court termed these events 'unbelievable'.
A day prior, the court had restrained Punjab and its functionaries, including police personnel, from interfering in the day-to-day functioning, operation, and regulation of the Bhakra Nangal Dam.
The Bhakra-Nangal project is among the earliest post-Independence river valley development projects, comprising dams on the Satluj – the Bhakra dam in Himachal Pradesh, and the Nangal dam in Punjab. The BBMB is tasked with distributing water between Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan, Himachal Pradesh, and Delhi.
At the start of every accounting year (roughly September-August, depending on the monsoon), it determines how much water will be allocated to each state. This year, it allocated 5.512 million acre-feet (MAF) to Punjab, 2.987 MAF to Haryana, and 3.318 MAF to Rajasthan.
Punjab claims that Haryana has already withdrawn 3.110 MAF — or 104% of its share for the year. This is even as the water levels on the Ranjit Sagar (on River Ravi) and Pong dams are 16.9 and 31.87 feet lower than at the same time last year, mainly due to scant snowfall in the Himalayas this winter. The water level at the Bhakra dam is 12 feet lower than last year.
In a May 2 BBMB meeting, the Union Home Secretary asked Punjab and Haryana to resolve the issue. He suggested that Haryana borrow 4,500 cusecs (cubic foot per second) of water from Punjab and return it during the filling season. He asked the BBMB chairperson to call an emergency meeting with them.
Tripathi called the meeting the next day, but Punjab boycotted it and called it illegal, saying rules permit BBMB to call a meeting only after giving seven days' notice. On Monday, the Punjab government called a special Vidhan Sabha session to pass a resolution against the BJP, which is in power at the Centre and three of the five BBMB states. It said the BJP was using the BBMB to divest Punjab of its 'rightful share' of water.
CM Mann also said that for the last two years, they had told Haryana it was taking more water than its quota, and that it should use water judiciously. They also alerted Haryana to their own water shortage in May and June. Further, Punjab said that Haryana's drinking water requirement is only 1,700 cusecs, and it is already giving them 4,000 cusecs of water on humanitarian grounds.
What did the HC rule?
Former Advocate General of Punjab, Gurminder Singh, submitted that the High Court had on May 6 directed the state to abide by the BBMB meeting's May 2 decision.
He said the bench was given the impression that the release of 4,500 cusecs of extra water to Haryana over eight days to meet its urgent requirements was decided during the meeting, but that was not the case. He argued that the May 2 meeting dealt with law and order issues and had no bearing on water allotment.
However, the High Court said there was a prima facie case against the Punjab government as the state did not comply with a court order directing it not to interfere in the working of the BBMB. A Division Bench of Chief Justice Sheel Nagu and Justice Sumeet Goel said a notice would be issued to the Punjab Chief Secretary KAP Sinha and the Director General of Police Gaurav Yadav.
If Punjab assured compliance with the order, the court said it would hold its hand till Monday. 'There is a judicial order that has been passed, rightly or wrongly. Until it is stayed or set aside, it stands and has to be complied with,' the court said. 'We are not sending your officers to jail, we are only issuing notice,' it added.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Print
9 minutes ago
- The Print
My statement on terrorism and religion deliberately misinterpreted: Prithviraj Chavan
'Everyone has the right to protest, but the real issue must be understood. The National Investigation Agency (NIA) is a central agency. The probe into the 2008 blast case has been ongoing since 2014. The court has ruled there was a blast, but did not identify the perpetrators due to lack of sufficient evidence,' he said. Chavan was speaking at a press conference after the Shiv Sena earlier in the day protested against his comments after the seven accused in the 2008 Malegaon blast case were acquitted by a Mumbai court two days ago. Karad, Aug 2 (PTI) Senior Congress leader and former Maharashtra Chief Minister Prithviraj Chavan on Saturday said his recent remark that 'terrorism has no caste, religion or colour' was deliberately misinterpreted for political gain. His statement was distorted to divert attention from core issues and create a political controversy, Chavan said. 'My words were twisted. I had said terrorism knows no religion, yet it was used to play politics,' he added. Chavan also questioned the government's failure to bring the culprits of the 2008 Malegaon blast to justice, stating, 'This was a serious terror act. Innocent lives were lost. If there is concrete evidence, punishment should be delivered. If not, why is the system failing to deliver justice?' The case, initially probed by the Anti-Terrorism Squad of Maharashtra Police, was later transferred to the National Investigation Agency, he said. 'Despite years of investigation, the real perpetrators remain unidentified. There is a need to investigate whether political pressure influenced the probe,' he said. Criticising the BJP-led state government, Chavan said, 'Industrial investment is declining in Maharashtra. In Beed, an extortion-related murder occurred over failure to pay Rs 2 crore. Even in Pune, industries are facing extortion threats.' He further claimed that extortion activities were flourishing under political patronage. 'Only the Chief Minister and Deputy CM can effectively act against such elements. No gangster can operate fearlessly without political backing,' he said. In his reaction to the judgement in the Malegaon blast case on Thursday, Chavan had said he was against the use of the term 'saffron terror' as saffron is the colour of Chhatrapati Shivaji Maharaj's flag and Warkari sect. While the BJP and several right-wing outfits latched on to the verdict to slam the Congress for allegedly coining the term 'bhagwa aatankwad' or saffron terror, Chavan had asserted that 'a terrorist who kills innocent persons has no religion'. On the use of the 'Hindu terror' term with regard to the Malegaon blast and the ensuing trial, Chavan had asked which religion the accused belonged to. 'The first act of terror was the murder of Mahatma Gandhi. Which religion did (the Mahatma's assassin) Nathuram Godse belong to,' the senior Congress leader had questioned. PTI MR KRK This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
Indian Express
9 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Maharashtra govt trying to erase Marathi: Uddhav
Shiv Sena (UBT) chief Uddhav Thackeray on Saturday launched a scathing attack on the BJP-led Maharashtra government, accusing it of systematically attempting to marginalise the Marathi language and culture. Speaking at his Bandra residence 'Matoshree', Thackeray also took aim at Chief Minister Devendra Fadnavis, dubbing him a 'helpless' leader who failed to act against ministers facing corruption allegations. Thackeray was addressing party workers during a function to announce the merger of Raju Shetti-led Shetkari Kranti Sanghatana with the Sena (UBT). 'Despite clear evidence presented by the Opposition regarding corruption involving several ministers, the government has merely issued warnings. I have never seen a chief minister as helpless as this. No one in this administration is accountable,' Thackeray said. He cited the example of NCP minister Manikrao Kokate, who has been under fire for allegedly playing online rummy during a session of the Legislative Council and making insensitive remarks about farmers. Kokate was quietly shifted from the agriculture department to the sports and youth welfare portfolio late on Thursday. However, Thackeray said the move was 'cosmetic' and demanded his resignation. The Sena (UBT) has also been demanding the dismissal of ministers Sanjay Shirsat, Sanjay Rathod and Yogesh Kadam — all from the rival Shiv Sena faction — over various graft allegations. Thackeray announced that his party will hold state-wide agitations to protest against what he described as a 'corrupt and indifferent' government. Later in the day, speaking at 'Shivalay', the Sena UBT's office near Mantralaya, Thackeray turned his focus to the controversy over language policy, claiming the government was trying to dilute Marathi's place in the state. 'We harbour no hatred towards any language, but do not impose another language on us. The government is trying to finish Marathi in Maharashtra,' he said. His remarks were in reference to two contentious Government Resolutions (GRs) introducing a three-language policy for Classes 1 to 5, including the mandatory introduction of Hindi. Following intense backlash and a rare show of unity between Uddhav and his cousin Raj Thackeray, the GRs were rolled back last month. The cousins had addressed a joint rally on July 5 to mark the rollback. 'The rollback happened because Maharashtra stood up. We will not allow anyone to trample over our culture and our identity,' Uddhav said.
Time of India
23 minutes ago
- Time of India
School edu min Ramdas suffers brain haemorrhage, airlifted to New Delhi
Jamshedpur/Ranchi: State school education and literacy minister Ramdas Soren was airlifted to a private hospital in New Delhi after he fell in his house here and suffered a brain haemorrhage in the early hours of Saturday. Ramdas, a three-time Jharkhand Mukti Morcha (JMM) MLA from Ghatshila, suffered a fall at his home in Ghorabandha in Telco and was taken to the Tata Motors Hospital in a state of unconsciousness. After emergency medical response, he was airlifted from Sonari aerodrome, accompanied by his family members. "Ramdas Soren was airlifted to Indraprastha Apollo Hospitals, New Delhi, earlier today. He is currently in a critical condition and on life support. A multi-disciplinary team of senior specialists is closely monitoring his condition and providing intensive medical care. Further updates will be shared in due course," the hospital said in a statement in the evening. Chief minister Hemant Soren, who is currently in New Delhi attending to his ailing father Shibu, shared a JMM post on his X handle and prayed for Ramdas' speedy recovery. "His struggle, dedication and sense of service to the people is our inspiration," Hemant's post read. Meanwhile, state health minister Irfan Ansari flew out to New Delhi to personally monitor the treatment of his cabinet colleague. "He is critical, but stable. I am hopeful he will return home soon," he said in a statement. Leader of opposition Babulal Marandi also prayed for his speedy recovery. The 62-year-old politician is a popular face among party cadres and led JMM's organisation in East Singhbhum and Kolhan division since former CM Champai Soren switched over to the BJP in August last year. Ramdas led JMM led INDIA bloc from the front in the last assembly election. The alliance eventually won 11 out of 14 seats across three districts. As rumours swirled about his health condition, several senior JMM leaders urged the public to wait for official information from verified channels. "Misleading news at this critical juncture could add to the stress of Ramdas Da's family members," JMM spokesperson Tanuj Khatri said. Get the latest lifestyle updates on Times of India, along with Friendship Day wishes , messages and quotes !
