Bhagwant Mann doubles down on attack on Modi's 5-nation trip—'don't we have the right to question MEA?'
'The MEA has reacted to my statement. Don't we have the right to question the MEA about our foreign policy? Which countries are you visiting? Do those countries support us later? When our relations with Pakistan went sour, not a single nation supported us. Why are you taking rounds of the world?' Mann asked during his speech.
Chandigarh: A day after the Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) termed Punjab Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann's comments on Prime Minister Narendra Modi's five-nation trip as 'irresponsible' and 'unwarranted,' Mann doubled down in the Punjab state assembly Friday, asserting his right to question India's foreign policy.
Not one to back down, Mann repeated in the assembly, 'The nations the PM visits, we haven't even heard of—'Magnesia,' 'Talvesia,' 'Galveaisa.' We don't know where these countries are, yet the PM is receiving their highest honours. Their population is 9,500. I only said that many people stop to watch a JCB in India. The PM should stay here, where the population is 140 crore, and solve their problems.'
'If you can stop the Russia-Ukraine war, why can't you stop the fight between Punjab and Haryana? The PM doesn't want the fight to stop; he wants it to go on forever. Haryana is our younger brother. This is a big political game, which is getting exposed,' Mann added.
'Our people are fighting over drinking water and sewage, and you're talking about Chandrayaan,' he added, critiquing Modi's focus on the Moon mission. 'First, fulfil the basic needs of our people, give us our fundamental rights, then you can go and become Vishwaguru.'
'[The PM wants] to become Vishwaguru, but they don't even send him invitations to swearing-in ceremonies. He goes around uninvited. It seems when the PM's plane flies over a nation, he asks, 'What nation is this?' and says, 'Let's land there,'' Mann said, as assembly members burst into laughter.
'The PM can get off in any country. He went to Pakistan, had biryani, and came back. But we cannot go there; he can,' Mann said, referring to Modi's 2015 visit to Lahore. He added, 'Punjab gets orders on when to have good relations with Pakistan and when to stop.'
'Diljit Dosanjh's film included a Pakistani artist months before the unfortunate Pahalgam incident, and the shooting for the film ended long ago, but the film is yet to be released, claiming that he's a traitor. Sometimes we're Sardars, sometimes we're gaddars [traitors]. You'll give us certificates of patriotism? We're sick of these games,' Mann said, referring to criticism of Diljit Dosanjh's unreleased film Sardaar Ji 3, reportedly starring Pakistani actor Hania Aamir.
Mann's speech came during a discussion on a resolution to withdraw the Central Industrial Security Forces (CISF) deployed at the Bhakra Nangal Dam, amid the Punjab-Haryana water dispute. Mann called the CISF presence symbolic of the Centre's interference in Punjab's riparian rights.
Responding to Mann's initial remarks, MEA spokesperson Randhir Jaiswal posted on X on 10 July: 'We have seen comments by a high state authority about India's relations with friendly countries from the Global South. These remarks are irresponsible and regrettable, and do not befit the state authority. The Government of India disassociates itself from such unwarranted comments that undermine India's ties with friendly countries.'
Addressing a press conference after the end of the Friday's proceedings, Mann, however, defended himself, saying, 'I want to know what he [Modi] went for—what did he achieve? Wherever he goes, Adani starts doing business there. This means someone is taking him there. Why not admit you're going to help someone with their business deals? I will question this. It's my right. No nation supported us against Pakistan, and the PM has taken three rounds of the world.'
Responding to a separate question on an FIR against cabinet ministers Aman Arora and Harpal Cheema by Chandigarh Police on the complaint of Congress politician and Punjab assembly Leader of Opposition Partap Singh Bajwa, Mann said that Union Home Minister Amit Shah had once been declared 'tadipar', and still, held such a key post now. 'Let FIRs be lodged against us. We don't care, even if they arrest us,' he added.
Reacting to Mann's statements against the PM and the HM, BJP leader Sunil Jakhar said in a video message that the Punjab CM spoke like a power-drunk man.'When a person's shadow starts becoming larger than his stature, it means the Sun is about to set. When a person's tongue becomes longer than his status, it means the downfall of that person has begun,' said Jakhar.
PM Modi returned to India Thursday from a five-nation tour from 2–9 July to Ghana, Trinidad and Tobago, Argentina, Brazil, and Namibia, including the 17th BRICS Summit in Rio de Janeiro. Four of the five nations—Ghana, Trinidad and Tobago, Brazil, and Namibia—conferred their highest civilian awards on Modi.
Since returning to power for a third term in June 2024, Modi has received 13 awards from other countries, including the Order of St Andrew from Russia, the Order of Freedom from Barbados, and the Order of Mubarak the Great from Kuwait.
(Edited by Madhurita Goswami)
Also Read: Months after mass deportations by Trump 2.0, ED raids in Punjab, Haryana find dunki rackets still thriving
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Indian Express
6 minutes ago
- New Indian Express
Attack during Modi's ‘Mann Ki Baat' programme in Tripura leaves seven BJP workers injured
GUWAHATI: Prime Minister Narendra Modi's 'Mann Ki Baat' programme at a Tripura village turned violent on Sunday, when an alleged group of Tipra Motha Party (TMP) 'goons' attacked BJP workers, leaving at least seven of them injured. TMP denied its involvement. TMP and BJP are allies and constituents of the state government. The incident occurred at the Taksapara village falling under the Asharambari Assembly constituency in Khowai district. Around 30 BJP workers had assembled at the place to listen to Modi. The injured were admitted to the Khowai district hospital. The condition of two was reportedly critical. About 15 bikes and two cars were also damaged by the attackers. Authorities deployed a large number of security personnel to the place after the incident. No arrest was made when reports last came in.
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
6 minutes ago
- Business Standard
PM Modi's praise for Bhopal's sanitation efforts boosted morale: CM Yadav
Madhya Pradesh Chief Minister Mohan Yadav on Sunday thanked Prime Minister Narendra Modi for appreciating Bhopal's sanitation measures during his monthly Mann Ki Baat' radio broadcast and said the praise has upped the state's morale. In the recently released Swachh Survekshan 2024', Bhopal was ranked the second-cleanest city in India, with MP's financial capital Indore bagging the top position for the eighth consecutive time. The PM's words have boosted the state's morale, said Yadav, who listened to Mann Ki Baat at an event in the city's Gulmohar Colony in Ward No. 50. He also planted a banyan sapling on the occasion. Prime Minister Modi ji inspires the power of every citizen for nation-building, Yadav said. Addressing the gathering, the CM said Modi's radio programme has become an effective platform for direct communication with the people of the country. It brings inspiring stories from across India that play a key role in nation-building, he added. Earlier, PM Modi lauded Sakaratmak Soch', a Bhopal-based organisation comprising 200 women, which works in the field of sanitation. They don't just clean, they also change mindsets. Cleaning 17 parks in the city together, distributing cloth bags, every step of theirs is a message. Owing to such efforts, Bhopal has now come a long way in the Swachh Survey, Modi said in Mann Ki Baat. Yadav said Bhopal residents deserve congratulations for the city's stellar performance in the cleanliness rankings. During his address, PM Modi also spoke about 12 Maratha forts listed as UNESCO World Heritage Sites and said there are such amazing forts in other parts of the country too, which have faced attacks, faced the vagaries of weather, but never let their self-respect bow down. He said that MP's Bundelkhand region also is home to several forts that were cultural symbols. ... Gwalior, Jhansi, Datia, Ajaygarh, Garhkundar and Chanderi. These forts are not just bricks and stones; they are symbols of our heritage. Sanskar and self-respect still peep from the high walls of these forts, said Modi. The PM also urged citizens to visit these forts, know their history, feel proud.
The Hindu
36 minutes ago
- The Hindu
MEA ‘nearly lost the plot' on Indus Treaty negotiations, says former Finance Secretary Subhash Garg
The Ministry of External Affairs (MEA) nearly 'lost the plot' over the Indus Water Treaty talks with Pakistan in 2016, as senior MEA officials entered into a tussle with the World Bank, before the issue was retrieved — the claim is made by former Finance Secretary Subhash Chandra Garg, India-appointed Executive Director at the World Bank (2014-2017), in his latest book, which recounts for the first time the tensions between the Modi government and World Bank President Jim Kim over the Kishenganga hydropower project. The point of contention was whether the World Bank, which has a limited role in guiding any disputes or differences between India and Pakistan, would decide to appoint the 'court of arbitration' Pakistan had asked for, or a 'neutral expert', as India wanted. After his controversial first book about his unceremonious exit from the Union Finance Ministry, Mr. Garg has now taken aim at the MEA in his new book, No, Minister: Navigating Power, Politics and Bureaucracy with a Steely Resolve, where he says he was sidelined during the initial stages of the Indus Water Treaty negotiations in 2016. He also claims that he was told to 'keep off the matter', and only attend meetings to be led by India's Deputy Chief of Mission Taranjit Sandhu (later the Ambassador to the U.S. before he retired and joined politics). '[However], by the middle of November, the MEA team was getting nervous. It was not able to nudge the World Bank team in the direction it wanted, i.e., to appoint a neutral expert and began to sense that the Bank was tilting towards Pakistan,' Mr. Garg wrote, in the chapter titled 'Bringing Indus Waters Arbitration Back From the Brink'. At this point, the book claims that Mr. Jaishankar made a visit to Washington and asked Mr. Garg to take charge of matters. Mr. Garg accepted the request, but insisted that no MEA official join the discussions, and even turned back then MEA Joint Secretary Gopal Baglay (now India's High Commissioner to Australia) from the meeting with Mr. Kim, although he had travelled non-stop for 20 hours to reach Washington. According to Mr. Garg, it was his own intervention, in a one-on-one meeting with Mr. Kim, that eventually helped ensure a neutral expert, Ian Solomon, was appointed, after the World Bank accepted Pakistan's demand for a court of arbitration at The Hague. The MEA did not respond to a request for comments on Mr. Garg's claims. The Hindu also reached out to Mr. Sandhu and Mr. Baglay for a comment, and they did not respond to or deny the claims. In Washington, World Bank officials privy to the negotiations confirmed the tussle between the World Bank and the Indian government, but said they could not comment on whether it was Mr. Garg's meeting with the World Bank chief or other interventions that eventually changed the course of events. The World Bank first ruled that having a neutral expert and court together could lead to 'contradictory outcomes'. However, subsequently, it facilitated the setting up of both an expert as well as a Chairperson to the Court of Arbitration. India has refused to attend the proceedings in the Court of Arbitration at The Hague. Pakistan has maintained that it is working within the terms of the treaty, whereas India says the treaty does not allow such parallel dispute mechanisms. When asked by The Hindu, Mr. Garg said this should not have been an 'institutional turf battle', and that he did not want India's case to be 'compromised' even as the World Bank, the U.S. and the U.K. had gone ahead with appointing experts to take the Pakistan application for arbitration forward. Allowing Pakistan's diplomats to continue the process unchallenged would have an impact on other negotiations, he added. After the Pahalgam terror attacks in April this year, India has decided to 'suspend' the Indus Water Treaty, but some of the book's revelations are significant for future decisions on similar issues. The book recounts Pakistan's campaign against the Kishenganga and Ratle hydropower projects in Jammu-Kashmir; India's objections to the International Monetary Fund/World Bank funding of the Gulpur hydropower project in Pakistan Occupied Kashmir; and China's objections in 2010 to multilateral funding for a hydropower project in Arunachal Pradesh, leading Mr. Garg to conclude that the government and the World Bank needed better communication between themselves. Mr. Garg also pointed out that Mr. Kim and Mr. Modi had a good relationship, and Mr. Kim's plan to fund schemes for 'stunted' or malnourished children had not gone down well with Mr. Modi. In Parliament this week, the Union Ministry of Women and Child Development said that about 37% of children under five years registered on their tracker were found to be stunted. 'I believe India's approach of not fine-tuning its stance in line with World Bank policies has harmed its own interests more than serving it,' Mr. Garg, who moved to India as Economic Affairs Secretary after his tenure at the World Bank ended, said. Differences with Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman led to his transfer as Secretary in the Union Ministry of Power in August 2019. He applied for voluntary retirement that same day, and retired after serving the mandatory notice period on October 31, 2019. (With inputs from Jacob Koshy and T.C.A. Sharad Raghavan in New Delhi.)
