
‘Barbaric': wildlife advocates criticize Florida bear hunt proposal
Then came a controversial new law that allows anybody to shoot and kill any bear perceived as a threat without fear of consequences, which animal advocates say could be bad news for any creature that inadvertently wanders into a back yard.
Now wildlife officials have advanced plans for a three-week hunt in December that could see the slaughter of almost 200 black bears, close to 5% of Florida's estimated total.
It is a proposal opponents are calling a trophy hunt based on bloodlust, not science, that would reintroduce long outlawed 'barbaric' practices including bear baiting, chasing and cornering the animals with packs of dogs, and killing them with bows and arrows.
'It's open season. It's just 'let's use everything we have against the bears now'. It completely blows my mind,' said Adam Sugalski, founder of Bear Defenders, a member of an alliance of wildlife and environmental groups urging members of the Florida fish and wildlife conservation commission (FWC) to reverse course ahead of a final decision in August.
'They already pulled every protection. You can't get in trouble for killing a bear, it seems, and now there's this unregulated hunt. I just kind of feel for these poor souls in the woods with no protections any more, and then they're about to release the hounds on them.'
For Sugalski, and other groups including the Sierra Club's Florida chapter, the Animal Legal Defense Fund, and Defenders of Wildlife, there is more to the story than just emotion. The FWC, they say, is using outdated and incomplete data of bear numbers to justify the hunt and falsely insist the killings are necessary as a conservation measure.
By the commission's own admission, the most recent tally of Florida's black bear population – an estimated 4,050 – took place more than 10 years ago, and the FWC has never put a cap on numbers beyond noting how many bears would be too many for available habitat and other resources.
'This is a rich man's hunt. It's not science-based conservation,' said James Scott, former chapter chair of the Sierra Club of Florida and campaign coordinator of the advocacy group Speak Up Wekiva.
'If we got to where bear populations were clearly exceeding the carrying capacity of any given unit, with the negative effects that come with that, that would be justification, a science-based, conservation-based approach to hunting. But they haven't got anywhere near justifying that.
'Instead you have some characters who have worked really hard framing hunting as a conservation tool, and some folks who have ingratiated themselves with commissioners. You also have a commission appointed by the governor, and most of them are land developers.
'So there are powerful interests that have a financial interest in limiting the growth of the bear population.'
Scott noted that the FWC's existing bear management plan, updated in 2019, did not propose the reintroduction of hunting, and stated that bears were still listed as a threatened species in Florida as recently as June 2012.
'Fortunately, the Florida black bear population is growing. We have more bears now than at any time in the last 100 years, but our conservation efforts are not finished,' the document said.
Also fresh in campaigners' memories is the debacle of the most recent Florida hunt in 2015, a planned week-long event that ended prematurely when more than 3,200 hunters descended on the state and massacred almost 10% of the state's bear population within two days.
The eventual death toll of 305 included mothers, cubs and numerous bears below 100lbs, all of which were supposed to be off-limits. Some hunters were found to have illegally baited their targets, and 112 bears were killed in 24 hours in a region of the Florida panhandle where the cap was set at 40.
FWC abandoned plans for hunts in subsequent years, until the proposal came up again this year for a 23-day event in December. The hunt, which was given preliminary approval in a 4-1 vote at a commission meeting earlier this month, seeks to 'remove' 187 bears across four zones, and hunters will pay $300 for a permit ($100 for a Florida resident), plus a $5 application fee.
A petition launched by Bear Defenders to oppose it has more than 40,000 signatures.
Commission officials point to a frequently answered questions page on the FWC website that says why a new bear hunt is required.
'There is a finite amount of suitable bear habitat, so if bear populations continue to grow unchecked, at some point bears will have to start living in more marginal habitats, like neighborhoods,' it said.
'Regulated bear hunting adds a positive value on bears by providing people with additional economic and recreational opportunities. Hunters can use the meat, pelt, fat and other parts of the bear they harvest. In contrast to all other current management action options, regulated hunting generates funding for conservation.'
Scott said that the meat argument in particular is spurious. 'That's bullshit. Nobody eats bear meat, it's greasy and not a fun meat to eat,' he said.
'You've got to think about the money and power of the folks that want to hunt bears. They're trophy hunters, the kind of guys that can afford to go to Africa and mow down cheetahs and giraffes and lions and stuff. Let's not kid ourselves here, these guys just want to have a head on a wall.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mail
18 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Pam Bondi on the brink: Epstein fallout gets nasty as Trump insiders reveal humiliating things colleagues are saying behind her back
Attorney General Pam Bondi is causing 'unnecessary embarrassment' for Donald Trump as the Jeffrey Epstein 'cover-up' claims overshadow his presidency, angry administration insiders say. A DOJ source told the Daily Mail that Bondi's 'communications failure' when it comes to the Epstein files has fueled a 'truckload of misinformation' surrounding the case.


Daily Mail
20 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Animal abuser screams 'Do you know who I am?' while cops try to stop him drowning dog on Miami Beach
Shocking new bodycam footage has captured the moment a Miami Beach man was tackled to the ground by police after allegedly trying to drown a dog in the ocean. Yerko Mendoza-Patino, 37, was arrested on February 28 after dragging a dog into the surf at South Pointe Beach, police said. The newly released video, obtained by NBC6, shows lifeguards racing to the scene around 7:15 pm as a man identified by the authorities as Mendoza-Patino stood waist-deep in the water. The individual was seen gripping his dog by the collar and dunking its head underwater 'several times' while wading deeper into the ocean - all as furious onlookers screamed at him to stop. 'Stop f***ing touching me!' the suspect yelled at lifeguards as they tried to separate him from the animal. 'Do you know who the f*** I am?!' Miami Beach Ocean Rescue struggled to free the dog as the individual resisted, at one point kicking water at those trying to help. Once officers arrived, the situation escalated as the suspect flailed and shouted profanities as police forced him face-down into the sand and slapped on handcuffs. Bodycam footage showed officers carrying him off the beach by his hands and feet as the crowd erupted in applause. Several witnesses told police they had seen Mendoza-Patino kick the dog in the head while dragging it into the surf. According to arrest documents, he initially gave police a false name and date of birth. Officers also noted he 'actively resisted by tensing his body, pulling his arms away, and refusing verbal commands'. The visibly shaken dog was gently led away by police officers, who comforted the pup before placing it in the back of a patrol cruiser. Authorities said the dog was taken into protective custody and is now safe. Mendoza-Patino was charged with animal cruelty, resisting an officer without violence, disorderly conduct, and providing false identification to law enforcement, WFOR reported. If convicted, Mendoza-Patino faces up to seven years in jail and $12,000 in fines, with the most serious charge, animal cruelty, carrying a maximum sentence of five years behind bars. The footage emerged a month after a Florida pediatrician has avoided jail for abandoning her dog in a dumpster, forced to eat it's own feces to avoid starvation. Anita Damodaran, 38, pled guilty Thursday, June 12 and was sentenced to just two years of probation. After which, her crimes may be expunged from her record.


Daily Mail
20 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Trans migrant sticks nose in the air as she appears in court accused of raping child in NYC park bathroom
A transgender migrant appeared in court yesterday after being arrested for raping a 14-year-old boy in a park bathroom. Nicol Suarez, 30, allegedly followed the boy into a bathroom at Thomas Jefferson Park in East Harlem back in February at around midday, police told the Daily Mail. The boy reportedly left the bathroom and flagged down people nearby, who called the police. The migrant was then charged with first-degree rape and stalking. Suarez wore head-to-toe beige prison garb and a full face of makeup as she stuck her nose up at her court appearance on Thursday. She scowled as officers led her into the courtroom, her expression even more pronounced due to her heavy contour, penned eyebrows and bright pink lip. As she sat down for the court proceedings, Suarez's neck tattoo peaked out from underneath her beige crewneck. She had spent the entire day waiting in Department of Corrections custody after the building was put on lockdown due to unknown reasons. Suarez required an interpreter to understand the proceedings as the two sides went back and forth over the status of her case, a court attendee reported. Suarez required an interpreter to understand the proceedings as the two sides went back and forth over the status of her case Her lawyer asked for more time to file her motions, but Judge Michele Rodney declined the request. After 10 minutes of deliberation, the Judge set a date for a pre-trial hearing in mid-September and Suarez was escorted back to the holding cells. The accused rapist is being housed at Rikers Island, a large jail complex in New York City, located on a 413-acre island between the Bronx and Queens in the East River. Originally from Colombia, Suarez was also wanted in New Jersey and Massachusetts and US Immigration and Customs Enforcement had a detainer on her. After her alleged crime in February, a source told the New York Post that they blamed New York City's sanctuary laws for the attack and said: 'ICE could just pick this person up and deport them back, but due to our sanctuary laws we can't do anything.' 'I feel really bad for the kid that has to go through this because his life will never be the same,' the source added. 'We worry about the migrants but what about the victim? This is a true victim.' A nearby deli owner, Azid Haime, described the incident as 'disgusting.' 'All my body is shaking; I want to sit. I can't explain how I feel. I'm more than angry,' he said, adding that many young kids come to his shop from the park. Suarez wore head-to-toe beige prison garb and a full face of makeup as she stuck her nose up at her court appearance on Thursday Prosecutors initially asked for $500,000 bail and a $1.5 million bond, but the amount was lowered by Democratic Judge Elizabeth Shamahs. Both of the crimes Suarez is accused of are felonies in New York. First-degree rape is a Class B felony with a minimum prison sentence of five years, and a maximum of 25 years. It is also a violent felony, requiring registration as a sex offender. Stalking in the first degree is a Class D felony with a maximum sentence of seven years in prison. It's also a violent felony, meaning a minimum sentence of two years is mandatory for those without prior felony convictions.