Why is Wimbledon blaming human error for a mistake by its new electronic line-calling system?
(You can now subscribe to our
(You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel
The All England Club, somewhat ironically, is blaming " human error " for a glaring mistake by the electronic system that replaced human line judges this year at Wimbledon The CEO of the club, Sally Bolton , said Monday that the ball-tracking technology was "inadvertently deactivated" by someone for three points at Centre Court during Anastasia Pavlyuchenkova's three-set victory over Sonay Kartal a day earlier in the fourth round. On one point, a shot by Kartal clearly landed past the baseline but wasn't called out by the automated setup - called Hawk-Eye - because it had been shut off.Bolton declined to say who made the mistake or how, exactly, it occurred or whether that person would face any consequences or be re-trained. She did note that there were other people at fault: the chair umpire, Nico Helwerth, and two who should have let him know the system was temporarily down - the review official and the Hawk-Eye official."We didn't need to put line judges back on the court again," Bolton said. "We needed the system to be active."Is Wimbledon using AI for line calls this year? Not really. But like most big tennis tournaments nowadays - the French Open is one notable exception - Wimbledon has replaced its line judges with cameras that are supposed to follow the balls on every shot to determine whether they land in or out.There are those, particularly in the British media, who keep referring to this as part of the ever-increasing creep of AI into day-to-day life, but Bolton objected to the use of that term in this case."The point I would want to emphasize - and perhaps contrary to some of the reporting we've seen - is it's not an artificial intelligence system. And it is electronic in the sense that the camera-tracking technology is set up to call the lines automatically, but it requires a human element to ensure that the system is functional," Bolton said. "So it is not AI. There are some humans involved. And in this instance, it was a human error."What happened on the missed call at Wimbledon? Russia's Pavlyuchenkova was one point from winning a game for a 5-4 lead in the first set against Britain's Kartal on Sunday when a shot by Kartal landed long. But there was no ruling from Hawk-Eye.After a delay, Helwerth decided the point should be replayed, which Pavlyuchenkova thought showed bias toward an opponent competing in her home country. With Hawk-Eye back up and running after a delay, Kartal won that game, but Pavlyuchenkova took that set and the match.The All England Club looked into what happened and found that the line-calling system actually was off for three points before anyone noticed.The system itself worked "optimally," Bolton said repeatedly."In this instance, sadly," she said, "it was the human part of the operation that made a mistake."Why was the Hawk-Eye system accidentally turned off during a match? Bolton said the system is shut down between matches - "and the humans are the people that need to do the activating and deactivating" - and someone accidentally did so during Pavlyuchenkova vs. Kartal.Asked why, Bolton responded: "Well, I don't know. It was a mistake, obviously. ... I wasn't sat there, so I don't know what happened."She said Helwerth could have made a ruling himself on the controversial non-call, the way he did on the prior pair of points, but instead just decided to pause the match."I'm assuming," Bolton said, "he felt he had not seen it properly."Pavlyuchenkova said after the match the official told her he thought the ball was out.What do players think about the use of technology at Wimbledon? Players are divided on whether there even should be electronic rulings during matches - unless it is fool-proof - or whether there should be a return to Wimbledon's old way of doing things.Since 2007 through last year, there was a combination of the human touch and technology: There were line judges on court to make calls, but players were allowed to challenge and ask for a video replay of a point if they thought there was a mistake."It's such a big match, big event," Pavlyuchenkova said. "Since we have already automatic line-calling and so much invested into this, we should probably look into something else to have better decisions."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
United News of India
2 hours ago
- United News of India
Djokovic storms into quarterfinals after shaky start
London, July 7 (UNI) Novak Djokovic recovered from a shaky start to defeat Alex de Minaur in four sets and advance to the Wimbledon quarterfinals here today, keeping alive his quest for a record-equalling eighth title at the All England Club. The 24-time Grand Slam champion looked out of sorts in the opening set but battled back with trademark resilience to win 1-6, 6-4, 6-4, 6-4 in a gripping three-hour and 18-minute contest on Centre Court. With the victory, Djokovic set up a quarterfinal clash with Italian Flavio Cobolli, who earlier edged Marin Cilic 6-4, 6-4, 6-7, 7-6. The 38-year-old Serbian, who hasn't lifted a Grand Slam trophy since his dominant 2023 season, fell behind 4-1 in the fourth set and faced break point that could have forced a decider. But he rallied in clinical fashion, turning the tide to seal the match and silence any doubts about his fitness or form. Djokovic was watched from the Royal Box by his former rival Roger Federer, prompting a heartfelt on-court tribute: "I wish I had the serve and volley and the touch of the gentleman standing right there. It's probably the first time he's watched me and I've won the match." After a sluggish start filled with unforced errors, 16 in the first set alone, Djokovic settled into rhythm, breaking De Minaur early in the second set and engaging in several high-quality rallies, including a 34-shot exchange he won to reclaim momentum. The match saw both players trade breaks, with De Minaur's trademark speed and low-slicing shots challenging Djokovic's timing. But the Serbian ultimately raised his level, especially in critical moments, using his baseline control and volleying touch to edge ahead. De Minaur, who missed last year's Wimbledon clash with Djokovic due to injury, had started strongly with two early breaks. But as the match progressed, Djokovic's precision and experience proved decisive. With this win, Djokovic continues to assert his presence against the emerging generation, including Carlos Alcaraz and Jannik Sinner, both aiming to usher in a new era in men's tennis. He now turns his attention to Cobolli in the quarterfinals, as his pursuit of an eighth Wimbledon title, and 25th Grand Slam overall, gathers steam. UNI BDN BM
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
Wimbledon 2025: Teenager Andreeva sets up quarterfinal clash with Bencic
Russian seventh seed Mirra Andreeva powered her way into her first Wimbledon quarterfinal with a 6-2 6-3 win over American 10th seed Emma Navarro on Monday, becoming the youngest player in the last eight of the women's singles since 2005. The 18-year-old looked at home on Centre Court, using her booming serve, regularly above 110 miles per hour, and power from the baseline to book a meeting with Swiss Belinda Bencic in the next round. In doing so she matches the feat of compatriot Maria Sharapova in 2005 at the exact same age - 18 years and 62 days at the start of the tournament. ALSO READ | Djokovic battles back against De Minaur to stay on track for Wimbledon glory With a light breeze swirling around the showcourt, Andreeva took an early break in the match thanks to a fine backhand past her 24-year-old opponent who was looking to reach a second successive quarter-final at the All England Club. Navarro struggled to return the Russian's serve, with Andreeva not giving up any points on her first serve throughout the first set. The American surrendered another break by hitting into the net from a fierce Andreeva forehand for 4-1. Navarro saved two set points but Andreeva converted the third courtesy of another unreturnable serve, taking the lead in the match after little more than half an hour of play. The second set brought an upturn in form for Navarro as the pair traded breaks and continued to slug it out from the baseline. However, Andreeva held on to a break advantage over her opponent and executed a beautifully weighted lob on her way to bringing up three match points. The teenager needed only one thanks to a fortunate net cord but had obviously lost track of the score as she lined up at the baseline again before apologising and running to the net to shake hands with her beaten opponent. 'Honestly, I kept telling myself I was facing break point and was trying to tell myself I'm not the one who is up on the score, I'm the one who is down and in the end I completely forgot the score. I happy I did it, otherwise I would have been three times more nervous on my match point,' she said on court. 'I felt like my serve was not bad today... happy that (coach) Conchita (Martinez) gives me nice advice and my serve keeps working,' added Andreeva.
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
Local electronics parts vendors plan non-Chinese JVs
Live Events Technical alliance Raising local value addition (You can now subscribe to our (You can now subscribe to our Economic Times WhatsApp channel Kolkata: As the deadline for submitting applications for the electronics component manufacturing scheme draws near, home-grown contract manufacturers such as Dixon Technologies Epack Durable , Micromax's Bhagwati Products and Optiemus are finalising most of their proposals with South Korean, Taiwanese and Japanese companies as equity partners, CEOs of these Indian firms development is significant as China was the largest sourcing market for products and parts, as well as partnerships and JVs till now. Their decision stems from India's tough stand against Chinese FDI, which needs multi-ministerial nod under Press Note 3 move could also be attributed to continued business related conflicts such as the neighbouring country's rare earth magnet export curbs imposed on India, among other Press Note 3 norms were issued after the border clashes with China in 2020. Since then only a handful of large Chinese companies have received such clearances.'There is no denying that China is far ahead in large-scale component technology manufacturing, but we are careful about the government stand, as not just the initial investment will need government clearance, but even the subsequent ones. Such clearances will take a lot of time, impact our plans and incentive payout under the scheme,' said a CEO of one of the largest players in the industry.'So, wherever we have found the technology in Taiwan and South Korea, we would use that while for others we are still dependent on China. But we are trying to negotiate for a technical alliance or a minority shareholding with them,' he said, requesting Enterprises will put in Rs 4,000 crore application under component manufacturing scheme which will be invested through the tenure of the scheme, CEO Jasbir Singh part of a joint venture with South Korea's Korea Circuit, a Rs 3,000 crore application for manufacturing of high density interface and semiconductor substrates and a Rs 1,000 crore application for printed circuit board manufacturing will be submitted, said Singh. Amber is the largest contract manufacturer for largest home-grown smartphone contract manufacturer Dixon Technologies' managing director Atul Lall said the company is currently finalising its applications and terms for joint ventures with South Korean and Taiwanese firms. 'There might be applications with Chinese too, but the terms are being finalised,' he Products is betting on Korean, Taiwanese and Chinese firms for equity joint ventures and technical collaboration depending upon the approval from competent authority, said its director Rajesh window for applications under the electronics component manufacturing scheme closes by the end of July. The scheme has a budget outlay of ?22,919 crore and is spread over six years, with one year as gestation is aimed at developing a robust component ecosystem by attracting large investments, increasing domestic value addition, which is at 20% on an average at present, and integrating Indian companies with global value government has said it expects to attract investment of Rs 59,350 crore to produce goods worth Rs 4,56,500 crore and generate additional direct employment of 91,600 people, besides many indirect jobs during its tenure. Already, over 100 applications have been received under the Gupta, MD (operations), PG Electroplast, said the company will submit 4-5 applications, including with non-Chinese Optiemus, Taiwanese companies are the first preference for joint ventures, said executive chairman Ashok Durable will submit two applications of Rs 300 crore in total for components for sound, printed circuit board assembly and display, said its managing director Ajay DD Singhania. 'Our first priority is non-Chinese partners from Taiwan, South Korea and Japan,' he said.A company CEO said that it was a sensitive issue for companies having Chinese brands as clients as the existing component manufacturers for those brands are all mostly Chinese. 'Some are Taiwanese too. So, we are talking to the clients too before finalising the applications,' he said.
