Recognising same-sex partnerships is vital for inclusive, diverse Hong Kong
The bill was introduced to comply with a landmark ruling by the Court of Final Appeal in 2023. The court held that the government has a positive obligation under the Hong Kong Bill of Rights to establish an alternative legal framework for the legal recognition and rights of same-sex partnerships. This obligation goes beyond requiring the government to introduce the bill to the Legislative Council, but requires the actual 'establishment' of such a legal framework.
In other words, if the bill is not passed and as a result no such legal framework is established, the legal effect is that the government will continue to be in breach of its human rights obligations. The order was suspended for a period of two years for the government to comply with the ruling.
The bill has understandably attracted criticism from both sides of the political spectrum. One camp has argued that the bill, which contains rights related to medical and after-death arrangements for same-sex partners, does not go far enough in protecting the core rights of same-sex couples. The other has complained that the bill has undermined traditional family values. Some have even gone so far as to suggest that Legco is not under any obligation to pass the bill.
It is hoped that a solution is found to break this impasse.
Justice should not only be done, but should manifestly and undoubtedly be seen to be done. It is imperative to maintaining public confidence in the rule of law in Hong Kong that court orders are not only complied with but that the terms of the court order are equally clearly and manifestly seen to be complied with.
At the risk of stating the obvious, in a period when Hong Kong is seeking to attract talent from overseas, it is vital that Hong Kong maintains its image as an inclusive and diverse city.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South China Morning Post
11 minutes ago
- South China Morning Post
US treasury secretary says meetings with Chinese have ‘advanced our talks'
US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said on Friday that meetings with his Chinese counterparts this week 'advanced our talks', but stopped short of confirming that US President Donald Trump approved the consensus that Beijing claimed they had reached. 'This week's negotiations in Stockholm have advanced our talks with China, and I believe that we have the makings of a deal that will benefit both of our great nations,' Bessent wrote on X. 'Thanks to the powerful bond between @POTUS and President Xi, I am optimistic about the path forward,' he added, without specifying where consensus stands following talks that ended on Tuesday. Since then, the US side is seen taking its time to confirm any new agreement reached with China, its third-largest trading partner, after neighbouring Mexico and Canada. China's vice-minister of commerce, Li Chenggang, who also took part in the talks, said before leaving Stockholm on Tuesday that a pause on new tariff increases – in place since May – would be extended, but neither Trump nor Bessent has made similar announcements. The Trump administration has instead delivered mixed messages.
South China Morning Post
an hour ago
- South China Morning Post
EU-China engagement shouldn't be reduced to a couple's therapy session
The 50th anniversary of diplomatic ties between the European Union and China should have been a celebratory occasion to reflect on the past and chart the course for the future. The 25th EU-China summit should have provided a space for such a commemorative moment, allowing both sides to display diplomatic pageantry and the symbolism of a forward-looking relationship. Instead, an initial two-day summit was watered down to a single-day event in Beijing on July 24, where President Xi Jinping and Premier Li Qiang met European Council President Antonio Costa and European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen There was no joint EU-China summit communique, a standard diplomatic practice to show that a summit concluded successfully. Mired in tensions and seemingly irreconcilable differences, EU-China relations have entered a midlife crisis. To be fair, even during better days, relations were never particularly cosy. Rather, it was a relationship built upon necessity: despite ideological differences, choosing each other was a geopolitical and strategic choice – a necessary evil – to safeguard multilateralism and multipolarity. China's diplomatic tradition has long valued symbolism and protocol. The toned-down summit ensued after a string of meetings between Chinese diplomats, including Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi , and their European counterparts over the past month to carefully craft and control messaging – a foreign ministers' strategic dialogue on July 2, the seventh China-France high-level dialogue on people-to-people exchanges on July 4 and the sixth EU-China high-level climate dialogue in Beijing on July 14. The 25th EU-China summit nonetheless served more as a face-saving event for China and a damage control mechanism for the EU. Despite the EU's acknowledgement of 'the importance it continues to attach' to its relationship with China and 'its commitment to deepen engagement', the summit was akin to a couples therapy session. EU leaders vented a list of grievances and expectations to China without proposing concrete solutions.
South China Morning Post
6 hours ago
- South China Morning Post
Labubu's soft power, Trump eyes autumn China trip: 7 US-China relations reads
We have selected seven of the most interesting and important news stories covering US-China relations from the past few weeks. If you would like to see more of our reporting, please consider subscribing 1. Trump eyes autumn China trip, but September visit off the table: sources Photo: AFP US President Donald Trump is keen to visit China but a September visit is not happening, according to sources, who said Beijing and Washington were working to secure a trip in October or November. Hurdles remain, but high-level officials 'share a consensus', sources familiar with the matter told the South China Morning Post. Read the full story here 2. Trump says Beijing making 'big steps' in controlling fentanyl Photo: AP US President Donald Trump said in July that Beijing is 'making big steps' in efforts to control the flow of fentanyl, an issue that the American leader has used to justify tariffs that he has slapped on imports from China. 'I think China has been helping out,' Trump told reporters in the Oval Office. Read the full story here 3. Has Apple been trapped by China? Not so fast, analysts say Photo: Shutterstock A new book contending that Apple went too far in consolidating its operations in China is prompting debate among analysts of the country – some of whom say the company may have had no realistic alternatives. 'If they were to have it to do over again, would they have done anything differently?' asked Meg Rithmire, a Harvard Business School professor.
