EU Parliament censure vote leaves von der Leyen weakened
The motion was tabled by Romanian MEP Gheorghe Piperea and signed by 77 members from the right-wing political groups, including the European Conservatives and Reformists (ECR), Patriots for Europe, and the Europe of Sovereign Nations. At the heart of their criticism lies von der Leyen's opaque handling of the EU's Pfizer vaccine procurement and her increasingly centralised approach to power.
Alberto Alemanno, Jean Monnet Professor of EU Law at HEC Paris, told Euronews that the motion's significance goes well beyond the numbers in Parliament, however.
'This motion of censure highlights many of the shortcomings that media and political observers have pointed out for some time—her presidential style, the centralisation of power, and her opacity,' Alemanno said.
He argued that while von der Leyen will likely retain the support of a majority of MEPs, the damage to her public image and political standing will be lasting.
'More and more citizens will ask themselves: is she really the right person to lead the EU in such turbulent times—negotiating with a potential Trump administration or playing a key role in Russia-Ukraine peace talks?'
Alemanno also noted that concerns about von der Leyen's leadership are not limited to the far-right. Her secretive handling of vaccine negotiations and unwillingness to engage with the media have drawn criticism across the political spectrum.
'This censure motion is acting as a lightning rod for broader frustration,' he added. 'It brings together complaints from multiple camps and highlights a growing desire for greater democratic accountability.'
A senior European Commission official, speaking on condition of anonymity, said the vote had been widely discussed within the Berlaymont headquarters.
'Officials see this as a warning. Her leadership style—extremely centralised and often politically ambiguous—has made her vulnerable. There's a sense she's become a prisoner of her own European People's Party (EPP),' the official said.
Time for von der Leyen to realign her agenda, says MEP
Von der Leyen and the centre-right EPP have faced criticism in recent months for accepting far-right support in several parliamentary decisions, breaking with the EU's traditional centrist coalitions involving socialists, liberals, and greens.
One EPP decision-maker told Euronews that von der Leyen must now realign her agenda more clearly with the party's values.
'She should draw the consequences. An EPP-dominated Commission must better reflect the EPP's platform,' the source said.
Dutch Green MEP Bas Eickhout suggested the damage from this episode could extend beyond von der Leyen herself.
'What's clear is that the centrist majority in Parliament isn't functioning well—and that reflects poorly not only on von der Leyen, but on Manfred Weber too,' said Eickhout. 'In terms of public image, Weber may have suffered even more.'
Despite the motion's expected failure, political observers believe it will intensify scrutiny of von der Leyen's leadership and further limit her room to manoeuvre in a second term.
'She won't walk away strengthened,' Alemanno concluded. 'Even if the vote fails, the pressure to hold her accountable will only grow.'
This will put her on the spot as debate turns from next week to the European budget, "which is expected to be very contentious within and among member states of the union", he said.
"Up to now, up to this vote, von der Leyen could rely on both majorities based on political convenience," he says, referring to the traditional centrist platform on the one hand, and tie-ups with the right wing on the other.
By the time of von der Leyen's State of the Union address to the Parliament in September, she will be constrained to pick one of the two that she can rely on, he said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Euronews
9 minutes ago
- Euronews
EU and Israel agree 'substantial' aid access for Gaza
The EU has negotiated a "significant" improvement of humanitarian aid access into Gaza including an increase of food trucks, and an agreement to 'protect the lives of aid workers', the EU's foreign policy chief, Kaja Kallas, announced on Thursday. T he steps agreed include delivery of "substantial" food and non-food items to enter Gaza; the reopening of crossings through Jordanian and Egyptian aid routes; and enabling the distribution of food supplies through bakeries and public kitchens throughout the Gaza strip, according to a statement from the spokesperson for Kallas. It also involves the resumption of fuel deliveries for use by humanitarian facilities; the repair and facilitation of works on vital infrastructure like the resumption of the power supply to the water desalination facility, said Kallas' spokesperson. Kallas dispatched a delegation to Tel Aviv including Christophe Bigot, the EU's Special Envoy to the Middle East over two weeks ago to negotiate an "end to the starvation and killing" according to a source close to the talks. Following the Israeli Cabinet's resolutions and the constructive dialogue between the EU and Israel, significant steps have been agreed by Israel to improve the humanitarian situation in the Gaza Strip', the statement concluded. The renewed agreement to allow food into Gaza comes at the time when NGOs and aid workers say children are sick and dying of malnutrition and injuries caused by constant violence and airstrikes. It also comes at a time when talks have intensified between officials from Israel and Hamas to reach a cease-fire. These measures are due to be implemented in the coming days, and the EU says there is a 'common understanding that aid at scale must be delivered directly to the population'. An EU official also confirmed to Euronews that the aid will be distributed through coordination with UN and other partners, and not in cooperation with the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation. The U.N. human rights office recently reported it had recorded at least 613 killings at aid points run by the U.S backed Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF). The statement also makes clear that 'measures will continue to be taken to ensure that there is no aid diversion to Hamas". A spokesperson also reaffirmed the EU's position for an immediate ceasefire and the release of all remaining hostages in Hamas captivity. A diplomat also said the agreement might also include the redeployment of the EU Border Assistance Mission for the Rafah Crossing Point (EUBAM) to monitor the crossing of aid into the Gaza strip. The plan comes before Kallas was due to discuss five options in response to Israel's breach of the EU-Israel Association Agreement at a meeting of foreign affairs ministers next week. The diplomat said Thursday's agreement will not affect the current talks regarding the EU-Israel Association Agreement. However, he said many diplomats were cautious about Thursday's plan and its rapid implementation. 'We need more clarity on security, on the actual mission, on the need to avoid being perceived as facilitating the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation,' the diplomat said.
Fashion Network
29 minutes ago
- Fashion Network
Trump issues more letters to countries in push for tariff deals
US President Donald Trump released a fresh set of letters to trading partners Wednesday, setting out tariff rates for seven more countries as Washington pushes to bring about a flurry of trade deals. The letters, addressed to leaders of the Philippines, Sri Lanka, Brunei, Algeria, Libya, Iraq and Moldova, spelled out duties ranging from 20 percent to 30 percent that would take effect on August 1. Similar to Trump's first batch of documents published Monday, the levels were not too far from those originally threatened in April, although some partners received notably lower rates this time. Sri Lanka's updated tariff was 30 percent, down from 44 percent announced in April, while the figure for Iraq was 30 percent, down from 39 percent. The Philippines, however, saw a 20 percent levy, up from 17 percent announced previously. While the president in April imposed a 10 percent levy on almost all trading partners, he unveiled -- and then withheld -- higher rates for dozens of economies. The deadline for those steeper levels to take effect was meant to be Wednesday, before Trump postponed it further to August 1. Instead, countries who face the threats of elevated duties began receiving letters spelling out US tariff rates on their products. Trump said Wednesday that he decided on the levies based on "common sense" and trade deficits. He added at an event that he would release more letters later in the day -- including for Brazil, which does not currently face a tariff hike come August. Trump's latest messages were near-identical to those published earlier in the week, and justified his tariffs as a response to trade ties that he says are "far from Reciprocal." They urged countries to manufacture products in the United States to avoid duties, while threatening further escalation if leaders retaliated. For now, over 20 countries have received Trump's letters including key US allies Japan and South Korea, as well as Indonesia, Bangladesh and Thailand. Analysts have noted that Asian countries have been a key target so far. But all eyes are on the state of negotiations with major partners who have yet to receive such letters, including the European Union. For now, the Trump administration is under pressure to unveil more trade pacts. So far, Washington has only reached agreements with Britain and Vietnam, alongside a deal to temporarily lower tit-for-tat levies with China. Trump on Tuesday said that his government was "probably two days off" from sending the EU a letter with an updated tariff rate for the bloc. "They're very tough, but now they're being very nice to us," he added at a cabinet meeting. An EU spokesman said Wednesday that the bloc wants to strike a deal with the United States "in the coming days," and has shown readiness to reach an agreement in principle. EU diplomats say the European Commission, in charge of trade policy for the 27-country bloc, could continue talks until August 1. The EU expects Trump to keep a 10 percent baseline tariff on its goods, with exemptions for critical sectors such as airplanes, spirits and cosmetics, diplomats told AFP this week. Legal challenges to Trump's sweeping tariffs are continuing to work their way through the US court system. Apart from tariffs targeting goods from different countries, Trump has also rolled out sector-specific duties on steel, aluminum and autos since returning to the White House in January. On Tuesday, Trump said levies were incoming on copper and pharmaceuticals. The planned rate for copper is 50 percent, he added, while pharmaceutical products face a levy as high as 200 percent -- but manufacturers would be given time to relocate operations.
Euronews
2 hours ago
- Euronews
Hundreds of migrants moved to Greek mainland as Libyan arrivals surge
More than 500 people were transferred to the port of Lavrio near Athens on Thursday after being intercepted south of the island of Crete, as Greece implements emergency measures to address a surge in Mediterranean crossings from Libya. The migrants, consisting mostly of young men, were transferred overnight aboard a bulk carrier after their fishing trawler was intercepted by Greek authorities. Service vessels helped bring them ashore at the mainland port. They will be sent to detention facilities near the capital. More than 200 migrants were transferred to the port of Piraeus near Athens, in separate operations from Crete. The transfers to the mainland were ordered because makeshift reception centres on Crete have reached capacity, with around 500 new arrivals per day on the Mediterranean island since the weekend. Prime Minister Kyriakos Mitsotakis announced on Wednesday that Greece would suspend asylum processing for migrants arriving by sea from North Africa for three months. The new measures are due to be voted on in parliament on Thursday as an emergency amendment. "This is an extreme and urgent situation, and we are taking extraordinary steps, ones that are difficult, tough, and strict. But they send a clear message," Manos Logothetis, secretary-general at the ministry of migration, told state television. "These measures are a clear statement from the Greek government — and by extension, from Europe — that we can no longer accept migration flows from North Africa," he said. "People there need to think twice before deciding to pay a large sum of money to come to our country." Logothetis said that Greece backed EU initiatives linking financial aid to African countries to their willingness to accept their citizens who were deported or agree to voluntary repatriation from Europe. The crisis on Crete coincided with a diplomatic spat between the European Union and Libya over migration cooperation. Earlier this week, European officials were turned away from eastern Libya following an apparent disagreement on the appropriate authorities to involve in discussions on curbing further crossings. Trying to reach Europe Authorities on Crete are struggling to provide basic services, using temporary facilities to house migrants, primarily from Somalia, Sudan, Egypt and Morocco, according to island officials. Greece remains a key entry point to the EU for individuals fleeing conflict and hardship in the Middle East, Africa, and Asia. Arrivals surged last year, with over 60,000 migrants landing in Greece — the majority by sea — compared to around 48,000 in 2023, according to UN refugee agency data. By mid-June 2025, Greece had recorded 16,290 arrivals, over 14,600 of which were by sea. With Greek authorities stepping up patrols along the eastern maritime border with Turkey, traffickers appear to be increasingly choosing the longer and more dangerous route across the Mediterranean from North Africa, using larger boats capable of carrying more people.
