logo
Gujarat HC rejects petition challenging election of BJP MP from Bhavnagar seat

Gujarat HC rejects petition challenging election of BJP MP from Bhavnagar seat

The Print06-05-2025
Article 84(a) of the Constitution outlines the qualification requirement for being a Member of Parliament Justice MK Thakker, in an order passed on April 30, noted the court was of the view that the petitioner has failed to establish that such 'improper acceptance' of the nomination form materially affected the election of the candidate.
Independent candidate Bhagvatiben Brahmkshatriya, among the losing nominees from the Bhavnagar Lok Sabha seat in the 2024 polls, had moved a petition in the HC with a prayer to declare election of Bambhaniya as void on the ground she had not filed her affidavit along with the nomination form in English and rather did so in Gujarati, thereby violating Article 84(a) of the Constitution.
Ahmedabad, May 6 (PTI) The Gujarat High Court has rejected a plea challenging the election of Lok Sabha MP and Union minister Nimuben Bambhaniya from Bhavnagar, observing the petitioner has failed to establish 'improper acceptance' of her nomination form materially affected her election.
Bambhaniya, a first-time MP from the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), is currently serving as the Minister of State for Consumer Affairs, Food and Public Distribution in the Modi government.
Mere non-compliance or breach of the Constitution or statutory provisions, as alleged by the petitioner, by itself does not result in invalidating the result of the candidate under section 100(1)(d)(IV) (of Representation of People Act, 1951, dealing with grounds of election to be declared as void), the court observed.
For the election of (winning) candidate to be declared void under clause 4 of section 100(1)(d)(IV) of the Act, there has to be a proof of the fact 'that such a breach or non-observance has resulted in materially affecting' the final outcome, the HC maintained.
'In other words, the violation of breach or non-observance or non-compliance with the provisions of Constitution or the Act, 1951 or the rules or the (apex court) orders made thereunder, by itself does not render the election of written candidates void under section 100(1)(d)(IV),' it said.
'The language of section 100(1)(c) clearly places the burden upon the objector to substantiate the objection that the result of the election has been materially affected,' the court contended.
Since the petitioner has failed to establish that improper acceptance of the nomination form was fatal to the elections, the court found no merits in her submission and dismissed the plea. PTI KA PD RSY
This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Lost in translation: PM Modi says ‘don't bother' as translator struggles at presser with UK's Starmer
Lost in translation: PM Modi says ‘don't bother' as translator struggles at presser with UK's Starmer

Indian Express

time11 minutes ago

  • Indian Express

Lost in translation: PM Modi says ‘don't bother' as translator struggles at presser with UK's Starmer

Prime Minister Narendra Modi and his British counterpart Keir Starmer shared a light-hearted moment when a translator appeared to struggle while translating a sentence from English to Hindi during the signing of the landmark free trade agreement (FTA) on Thursday in the UK. The incident happened when both the leaders were addressing the press, a translator began hesitating mid-sentence while translating Starmer's remarks about the 'historic' trade deal. 'Sorry…' she said, fumbling for words, speaking hesitantly about the trade deal benefitting consumers in the UK. Noticing her discomfort, PM Modi quickly stepped in: 'Don't bother… we can use English words in between. Don't worry about it.' The translator thanked him, clearly relieved. 'Sorry, His Excellency… I've lost the speech,' she added. Both leaders smiled and offered comfort. 'Yeah… no problem,' Modi said, while Starmer offered to repeat himself. 'I think we understand each other well,' he added with a grin. #WATCH | 'Don't bother, we can use English words in between. Don't worry about it,' says PM Narendra Modi candidly as translations for questions and answers were made at their press statement and the journalists' questions that followed. 'I think we understand each other well,'… — ANI (@ANI) July 24, 2025 The trade deal, signed in London, is the UK's biggest post-Brexit agreement and one of India's most significant in recent years. It will remove British tariffs on 95 per cent of Indian farm and food items — such as turmeric, pepper, cardamom, mango pulp and pickles — boosting profits for Indian farmers and helping both countries' manufacturing and tech sectors. Lauding the trade deal, PM Modi said in a post on X: 'A new chapter begins today in the India-UK economic partnership! The signing of the Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA) reflects our shared commitment to enhancing trade, driving inclusive growth and creating opportunities for farmers, women, youth, MSMEs, and professionals.' Starmer also wrote, 'A landmark deal with India means jobs, investment and growth here in the UK. It creates thousands of British jobs, unlocks new opportunities for businesses and puts money in the pockets of working people. That's our Plan for Change in action.'

PM Modi comforts translator struggling with Hindi in UK: ‘Can use English words'
PM Modi comforts translator struggling with Hindi in UK: ‘Can use English words'

Mint

time11 minutes ago

  • Mint

PM Modi comforts translator struggling with Hindi in UK: ‘Can use English words'

Prime Minister Narendra Modi was heard comforting a translator who was struggling to speak Hindi to him during the signing of the Free Trade Agreement (FTA) between India and the United Kingdom on Thursday, July 24. The video on the internet shows a translator attempting to translate UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer's statements from English to Hindi but struggling, prompting a reassuring gesture from PM Narendra Modi. As she finishes a sentence in Hindi with great difficulty, PM Modi tells her, 'It's okay, you can use English words in between,' instantly easing the moment. The moment brought a smile to Keir Starmer's face, who offered to repeat his remarks for the translator. Then, turning to PM Modi with a light gesture, he said, 'I think we understand each other well.' India and the UK signed a landmark free trade agreement, which, starting 2026, will see 99 per cent of Indian exports enter the UK duty-free, while reducing tariffs on British products such as cars and whisky. The deal, which comes days ahead of the US moratorium on higher tariffs coming to an end, aims to double the USD 56 billion trade between the world's fifth and sixth largest economies by 2030. While India has opened its market to various consumer goods, including chocolates, biscuits, and cosmetics, it will gain greater access to export products such as textiles, footwear, gems and jewellery, sports goods, and toys. While PM Modi termed the Free Trade Agreement a 'historic' deal, Keir Starmer said the agreement is one of the most significant since the country left the European Union (EU).

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store