Is it art, or is it stealing work? Album cover designers stare down an AI future
The Toronto musician and graphic artist admits it's a controversial choice, but over the past year, he's been using the tool to help design his band's new album covers. Each one showcases grand concepts, stunning imagery and ultimately a piece of art that demands attention in an era where all musicians are jostling to stand out.
'We're in the blockbuster age where people like to see big, big things,' Black says from his office.
'Whenever I have an idea, it's usually something beyond what we have the resources to do, and AI means you don't have to put a lid on those ideas.'
His work usually starts with typing a few descriptive words into AI software and collecting the images it spits back out. Then, he uses photo editing to fine-tune his favourites so they fit his original vision. Sometimes, he submits those altered images back into the AI to generate more ideas.
'There's quite a bit of back-and-forth where you're applying your own skill and then putting it back in,' he said.
'It's a little bit like arguing with a robot. You have to nuance it into doing what you want.'
One of his first experiments was the cover artwork for Finger Eleven's 2024 single 'Adrenaline.'
The illustration shows a curvaceous woman in a skin-tight red-and-white-racing suit, her head concealed under a motorcycle helmet. She's standing in the middle of a racetrack with her back to the viewer. A cloudy blue sky imparts an otherworldly calm.
Anyone who's seen recent AI artwork will probably recognize the hyperrealistic sheen of its esthetic. Other familiar AI trademarks are there too, including a landscape firmly rooted in a dream world.
Generative image models are trained on billions of photographs to learn patterns, such as recurring shapes and styles. They then use that information to construct images that can often seem familiar. Many fear that the tools also draw from copyrighted pieces without permission from their creators.
It's a legal quagmire that only skirts the surface of the ethical debate around generative AI models. Beyond the copyright risks, critics fear the technology will cost album cover designers and photographers their jobs.
But AI programs such as NightCafe, CoPilot and Adobe Firefly offer cutting-edge possibilities that many artists say they can't ignore.
Still, Black said he understands there are ethical concerns.
'I'm definitely torn myself,' he said. 'But I'm using it because it extends as far as my imagination can go.'
Other musicians have found that generative AI answers the demands of a streaming industry that pressures them to churn out new music, eye-catching lyric videos and other visual elements regularly. But some fan bases aren't sympathetic to those reasons.
Last year, Tears for Fears was slammed on social media after they revealed the cover of their live album 'Songs for a Nervous Planet,' which had several familiar AI image traits.
The illustration shows an astronaut staring straight at the viewer, their face concealed under a space helmet. They're standing in the middle of a field of sunflowers that stretches into the distance. A cloudy blue sky imparts otherworldly calm.
The cover's creator, Vitalie Burcovschi, described it as 'art created by AI using human imagination.' But fans were quick to accuse the band of using AI that might have scraped copyrighted work. As blowback intensified, the English duo released a statement calling it 'a mixed media digital collage, with AI being just one of the many tools used.'
Pop singer Kesha encountered similar flak for the cover of her 2024 single 'Delusional,' which featured a pile of Hermés Birkin bags with the song's name spray-painted across them.
Fans instantly recognized common flaws of an AI-created image: misspellings in the song's title, sloppy digital fragments. Some demanded she redo the artwork with paid photographers.
It took months, but the singer replaced the image with a photograph of herself tied to a chair. She assured fans it was created with an 'incredible team of humans.'
'AI is a Pandora's box that we as a society have collectively opened, and I think it's important that we keep human ramifications in mind as we learn how to use it as a tool and not as a replacement,' she said in an Instagram post in May.
Illustrator and musician Keenan Gregory of the band Forester says he used AI technology to extend the background of an old photograph so it could fit on the cover of the band's upcoming EP.
The original image for 'Young Guns' was taken in the 1940s as a vertical photograph and showed bass player Dylan Brulotte's grandfather strolling through the streets of Edmonton. Gregory needed a square shape for the album cover, so he put the shot into Photoshop's generative AI tool, which artificially extended the frame's left and right edges with more detail.
He removed certain background elements, like storefront signs, with a blend of traditional photo editing techniques.
'Typically, an artist would have to do that manually,' he said. 'But having AI provide you with options, which you then edit, is very powerful.'
Gregory said he considers AI one of a photo editor's many tools, adding he didn't use it to make the cover for Royal Tusk's 'Altruistic,' which earlier this year won him a Juno Award for best album artwork.
Even when musicians are transparent about using AI, some fans are not ready to embrace it, as British Columbia rock band Unleash the Archers learned last year.
Vocalist Brittney Slayes said their concept album 'Phantoma' told the story of an AI gaining sentience and escaping into the real world in the body of an android.
To explore the album's theme, Slayes said some of her songwriting drew inspiration from ChatGPT suggestions, while they used visual AI programs to create inspiration images for songs.
She said the band also filmed a music video for 'Green & Glass' and then fed the finished product into an AI model trained on artwork by Bo Bradshaw — the illustrator for the band's merchandise. It spat out an AI-animated version of the video.
'We paid to license all of his artwork … so he was compensated and he was credited,' she said.
But the reaction was swift. Some listeners accused the band of theft, alleging that despite paying for Bradshaw's work, the AI tool likely used other unlicensed art to fill out the visuals.
'We didn't realize that even though our model was trained after one artist, the program was going to fill in the blanks with others,' Slayes said.
'People didn't care. The second the word 'AI' was used, we were targeted. You know, the usual Twitter uproar, being like scraped across the internet as these terrible people that use AI in their music.'
Unleash the Archers responded on their socials, issuing a statement acknowledging they had unintentionally implied their video featured original artwork by Bradshaw when it was actually produced through an AI program without his direct involvement.
Their statement recognized how fraught the risks are for bands eager to explore new technology, saying that 'while we were expecting some controversy, we weren't expecting as much as we got.'
Wednesdays
Columnist Jen Zoratti looks at what's next in arts, life and pop culture.
Slayes said the backlash has forever sullied her connection to the album, which she originally intended as an exploration of an inevitable AI future. Instead, to her, it's become a reminder of how fast-developing AI technology is provoking deep-rooted anxieties.
'People are still afraid of it,' she said. 'And for good reason, because it is taking jobs.'
For other artists, she urges them to think carefully about how they introduce AI into their own projects:
'If you're going to use AI for your artwork, you've got to have a really good reason.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 10, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Edmonton Journal
2 days ago
- Edmonton Journal
Things to do in Edmonton this week: Oily art at Latitude, Cutoffs at River City, Legally Blonde at Citadel
Article content Oily: on fandom: Taking a look at the question 'What is Edmonton without hockey?' this six-artist, Latitude 53 group show looks at fandom and a unified sense of identity, but also the stranglehold the NHL team has here. Article content As the show's statement puts it, 'Whether a fan of the sport and the local team or not, it's impossible to deny the power a franchise has on this city. There seems to be no hesitation to hand over blank cheques for an arena while cutting vital services, and displacing the most vulnerable population for the optics, to appear 'world class' — desperately trying to believe we are something else.' Article content Among the artists are the brilliant AJA Louden, whose works have been commissioned by the organization to celebrate and amplify the team's Black history, and Veronica Fuentes, whose excellent 'Stop the Sweeps' stickers drew attention to the aggressive gentrification and displacement of city centre residents. Article content Article content Article content Cutoffs: The most delightfully smiley-punk Bob Prodor — longtime illustrator of Corb Lund swag — co-fronts terrific razor-rock band Cutoffs Friday, downstairs at River City Revival. Article content Hard-pounding, high-energy and well worth standing in the front row to watch, there's something a little rockabilly hidden under layers of SNFU-ish punkiness and buzzsaw metal guitar. But really, they're just an awesome rock and roll band, let's not complicate it. Article content Article content Legally Blonde: Opening its run 7:30 p.m. Saturday, this feel-good piece of musical theatre follows Elle Woods, a fashionable sorority queen who surprises everyone by enrolling at Harvard Law to win back her ex. Article content Based on the book and 2001 film which screenwriter guru Blake Snyder showcased as a template for the perfect three-act Hollywood movie, this partnership with Theatre Calgary is directed by Stephanie Graham. Recommended 13+.
Calgary Herald
2 days ago
- Calgary Herald
Ezekiel Mitchell delivers thrilling ride in Cody Snyder Charity Bullbustin' debut
Ezekiel Mitchell heard such good things about the annual Cody Snyder Charity Bullbustin' spectacle that he had to check it out for himself. Article content Hailing from Rockland, Texas, Mitchell had never ventured north to Canada before he decided to attend the 2025 Professional Bull Riders (PBR) sanctioned event at the Grey Eagle Resort and Casino on Tsuutʼina Nation. Article content 'All my Canadian buddies that come down (to compete at PBR events in the United States), they talk about how great this event is,' said the 28-year-old cowboy, who heard rave reviews from the likes of Lonnie West, Jared Parsonage, Ashton Sahli, Dakota Buttar and Nick Tetz. 'They say you get to get on a lot of bulls and have a good time and it's very laid back and they said they take care of the guys.' Article content Article content Mitchell took care of business on Tuesday's opening night of competition by posting a score of 85.5 points atop Dealing After Midnight. Article content Article content 'All the guys around here told me he was going to be a really good bull,' said Mitchell, who taught himself to ride bulls at a young age by watching YouTube videos and practising on a 55-gallon drum that was strung up in his yard. 'He's going to go either way. He decided to go right today. It wasn't the best decision for him, but good decision for me. I got to give him a few money chops and then it turned out to be 85.5.' Article content Mitchell's wild ride thrilled the packed crowd watching on from the stands constructed in the parking lot outside of the Grey Eagle Events Centre. Article content 'Everybody, they were giving me high fives and fist bumps,' said Mitchell, who has drawn inspiration from fellow Black rodeo competitors Lee Akin, Danell Tipton, Charlie Sampson, Chris Littlejohn, Bill Pickett, Fred Whitfield, Corey Solomon and John Douch. 'It's pretty cool the way they have this event set up. It's a great atmosphere. The crowd's right behind the bucking shoots, so you really get to feel the energy. You get to celebrate. You get to see how happy people are for you.' Article content Article content Unfortunately for Mitchell, he didn't fare as well on Wednesday as he was bucked off of Blue Nerve. Article content But the night before he finished in fourth spot behind Callum Miller (89.5 points on Surprise Twist), Andrew Alvidrez (89 on Write This Down) and Cody Coverchuk (86 on Carved in Stone). Article content Article content Mitchell wasn't too upset to see Miller win seeing as how they're teammates on the Texas Rattlers for PBR Team Series events. Article content 'Bull riding is just a big old family,' Mitchell said. 'If they draw better bulls than me and get to go ahead and take over that No. 1 spot, I'm just I'm happy for them. Hopefully, within this five days, I can have an event win from up here in Canada. That'd be really cool.' Article content Miller has been a regular Bullbustin' competitor ever since 2021 when he used to live in Innisfail, Alta. Article content 'They always put on a good deal for us and they've always got good bulls for us,' said Miller, 30, who's originally from Warwick, Queensland, Australia and now lives in Henrietta, Texas. 'The crowd's awesome and the sponsorship's great.'
Winnipeg Free Press
2 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
‘Incredibly ambitious and probably really stupid': R.T. Thorne's sci-fi debut '40 Acres'
TORONTO – R.T. Thorne says he could have played it safe with his debut feature. Instead, he swung for the fences, writing an epic sci-fi thriller about generational trauma, cannibalism and humanity's connection with land — all set in what he calls 'a post-apocalyptic world where the stakes are at the absolute highest.' 'For my first film, it was incredibly ambitious and probably really stupid to write something like that,' the Calgary-born writer-director laughs in a recent video call from Toronto. '40 Acres,' out Friday, centres on a Black-Indigenous family in a famine-stricken future where a fungal pandemic has wiped out all animal life on the planet. When a marauding group of cannibals closes in on their farm, ex-military matriarch Hailey Freeman, played by Danielle Deadwyler, clashes with her son Manny, played by Toronto's Kataem O'Connor, over the best way to survive a world in ruins. Deadwyler says she was drawn to the film's historical context — the Freemans are the last descendants of a Black family of farmers who settled in Canada after the U.S. Civil War. 'The connection between the American and Canadian history of folks getting to this northern liberated land, it was very much on my mind,' the Atlanta native says in a recent video call Los Angeles. 'You can talk about the Underground Railroad for sure — there were people escaping who got (to Canada) and established themselves. When we think about Hailey, she is coming from a place where she understands the century-plus-long history of her family on the land that they are fighting for.' Michael Greyeyes, who plays Hailey's partner Galen, considers '40 Acres' an 'Indigenous rights film' because it centres on people fighting to stay on their land. 'If you look at the world in general, colonialism, empire and taking land away from Indigenous populations is an ongoing threat,' says the actor from Muskeg Lake Cree Nation in Saskatchewan, reached by Zoom in Winnipeg. 'Our film actually states that the land belongs to the caretakers and that we resist empire and we resist encroachment.' Thorne says the earliest seeds of the film were planted in something more intimate: a desire to channel his relationship with his mother. 'She ran a strict household. I grew up with somebody who was so concerned and so vital in teaching me how to move in the world and what she felt was important in the world,' he recalls. Thorne got his start directing music videos for artists including Sean Paul and Keshia Chanté before creating the 2020 sci-fi series 'Utopia Falls' and helming the 2022 period drama 'The Porter,' both of which aired on CBC. With '40 Acres,' he set out to explore 'the universal generational conflict that happens in every family: the parents think they know what it is and as the young people grow up, they want freedom.' But as a self-described 'dreamer,' his ambitions quickly grew, envisioning a do-or-die sci-fi future where that family tension could play out on a much larger canvas. Originally conceived seven years ago as a microbudget project through Telefilm's Talent to Watch program, the Sudbury, Ont.-shot film expanded in scale and scope to match Thorne's creative vision. There were some growing pains. Just after the film's premiere at the Toronto International Film Festival last September, the union representing crew members on the shoot issued a statement saying they were 'profoundly disappointed' that some crew and vendors had yet to be fully paid for their work on the production. IATSE — which represents behind-the-scenes workers across film, TV and theatre — says all outstanding payments have since been made. At a public event in Toronto last week, '40 Acres' producer Jennifer Holness addressed the situation by saying that just before filming began in fall 2023, a U.S. distributor that promised a minimum guarantee asked for script changes that would have 'damaged the film and our vision.' Holness said the team chose to walk away, leaving the production '$2 million in the hole.' With an initial $8 million budget — including $3.2 million in public funding from Telefilm — Holness said the production became a week-to-week financial struggle. 'Every single week after the third week of production, we were in a situation of, 'How do we get to the end of the week and pay everyone?'' she said. 'We did 12 weeks up there, and we paid our crew every single week on time. We, the producers, had to come together and invest in the film ourselves. It was a journey. It was an incredibly stressful journey.' Weekly A weekly look at what's happening in Winnipeg's arts and entertainment scene. The film was picked up by U.S. distributor Magnolia earlier this year and heads to screens across North America this week. Thorne says all payment issues have been resolved and commends Holness for 'steadying the ship.' He adds there are many issues that occur during productions that people don't know about. 'You're always almost falling over to get it to the screen. The thing that I will say is that you come together as a community and you try to fix the mistakes and issues that you have and you make sure that people feel taken care of,' he says. 'And then you come out successful at the end when you do it. And the films that don't, you don't hear about them.' This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 3, 2025.
