‘You can't solve crime through illegal actions: Health Department on activists blocking foreigners
Image: Oupa Mokoena/Independent Media
The national Department of Health has expressed concern over several vigilante groups intercepting foreign nationals, blocking them from accessing healthcare at public facilities.
In an interview with IOL, spokesperson for the Department of Health, Foster Mohale said while the department does not condone illegal migration, the actions of the activist groups are concerning.
'We have noted with concern illegal actions around some parts of Gauteng and KwaZulu-Natal, in which individuals and organised groups prevent healthcare users, especially illegal migrants from accessing health services,' said Mohale.
'We also condemn people who illegally cross the border into South Africa specifically to access healthcare services.
'We urge those with concerns about this societal problem to raise them within the confines of the law instead of taking the law into their own hands because you cannot solve crime through illegal activities which may end you in jail,' Mohale told IOL.
Regarding the legal position of immigrants accessing healthcare in South Africa, Mohale said there are different legal frameworks relied on.
"This is not only a violation of constitutional rights, especially Section 27, but also a number of legal prescripts, the National Health Act, the Refugee Act, Immigration Act. Section 27 of the South African Constitution guarantees that everyone has the right to access healthcare services, including reproductive healthcare, and that no one may be refused emergency medical treatment.
"The National Health Act ensures access to primary healthcare services for all individuals in South Africa, regardless of immigration status. The Refugees Act protects the rights of refugees and asylum seekers to healthcare services, and prohibits denial of emergency medical care.
On the Immigration Act, while healthcare facilities are permitted to inquire about legal status, this should not hinder the provision of necessary care, especially in emergencies," he said.
Mohale said law enforcement agencies must act against anyone committing illegal actions.
'We are calling on law enforcement agencies to take firm action against those who interfere with access to healthcare and unlawfully obstruct our institutions,' said Mohale.
'We also call upon all residents to remain law-abiding and to express their concerns using the appropriate channels provided under our legal and democratic system.
"South Africa is a democratic state governed by laws which must be respected by all,' he said.
In 2022, IOL reported that chaos erupted outside Kalafong Provincial Tertiary Hospital in Tshwane when police fired rubber bullets and stun grenades, intervening in violent clashes between groups from the Economic Freedom Fighters and Operation Dudula.
The two groups were feuding over whether undocumented foreigners should be able to access medical services at the hospital.
Violent scenes of members of the two groups throwing stones and empty bottles at each other played out at the time then health minister, Dr Joe Phaahla, visited the facility to inspect the impact of the anti-foreigner protests on hospital operations.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
a day ago
- IOL News
‘You can't solve crime through illegal actions: Health Department on activists blocking foreigners
Clashes were previously seen at Kalafong Provincial Tertiary Hospital in Tshwane when police used stun grenades to disperse members of Operation Dudula who were vetting people entering the hospital. Image: Oupa Mokoena/Independent Media The national Department of Health has expressed concern over several vigilante groups intercepting foreign nationals, blocking them from accessing healthcare at public facilities. In an interview with IOL, spokesperson for the Department of Health, Foster Mohale said while the department does not condone illegal migration, the actions of the activist groups are concerning. 'We have noted with concern illegal actions around some parts of Gauteng and KwaZulu-Natal, in which individuals and organised groups prevent healthcare users, especially illegal migrants from accessing health services,' said Mohale. 'We also condemn people who illegally cross the border into South Africa specifically to access healthcare services. 'We urge those with concerns about this societal problem to raise them within the confines of the law instead of taking the law into their own hands because you cannot solve crime through illegal activities which may end you in jail,' Mohale told IOL. Regarding the legal position of immigrants accessing healthcare in South Africa, Mohale said there are different legal frameworks relied on. "This is not only a violation of constitutional rights, especially Section 27, but also a number of legal prescripts, the National Health Act, the Refugee Act, Immigration Act. Section 27 of the South African Constitution guarantees that everyone has the right to access healthcare services, including reproductive healthcare, and that no one may be refused emergency medical treatment. "The National Health Act ensures access to primary healthcare services for all individuals in South Africa, regardless of immigration status. The Refugees Act protects the rights of refugees and asylum seekers to healthcare services, and prohibits denial of emergency medical care. On the Immigration Act, while healthcare facilities are permitted to inquire about legal status, this should not hinder the provision of necessary care, especially in emergencies," he said. Mohale said law enforcement agencies must act against anyone committing illegal actions. 'We are calling on law enforcement agencies to take firm action against those who interfere with access to healthcare and unlawfully obstruct our institutions,' said Mohale. 'We also call upon all residents to remain law-abiding and to express their concerns using the appropriate channels provided under our legal and democratic system. "South Africa is a democratic state governed by laws which must be respected by all,' he said. In 2022, IOL reported that chaos erupted outside Kalafong Provincial Tertiary Hospital in Tshwane when police fired rubber bullets and stun grenades, intervening in violent clashes between groups from the Economic Freedom Fighters and Operation Dudula. The two groups were feuding over whether undocumented foreigners should be able to access medical services at the hospital. Violent scenes of members of the two groups throwing stones and empty bottles at each other played out at the time then health minister, Dr Joe Phaahla, visited the facility to inspect the impact of the anti-foreigner protests on hospital operations.
eNCA
2 days ago
- eNCA
Joburg clinic allegedly turns away foreign patients
JOHANNESBURG - A clinic in Rosettenville in the south of Johannesburg is allegedly turning away foreign nationals. However, the management is denying such allegations and says they are attending to everyone walking into the health facility. Some of the alleged foreign nationals in the queues say they have been waiting for assistance since Monday. Pregnant women and mothers with babies have been turned away by community members in support of the alleged action. They say that the people coming to the clinic do not have legal documentation and cannot use the services. The foreign nationals deny this. Meanwhile in KwaZulu-Natal reports have surfaced that Illegal Somalians and Ethiopians have been shot at by police, after they attacked a March and March member. They're also alleging to have attacked South African police,demanding free healthcare at Addington Hospital in KwaZulu Natal. Department of Health Spokesperson Foster Mohale says they are aware of the tensions in Rosettenville. But notes that this is not an isolated. He has condemned this action saying no one has the right to prevent anyone from accessing health care. "Everyone who happens to be in the country is protected by a number of prescripts including Section 27 of the constitution including the National Health Act, the refugee act,' he says. While there are claims that those seeking health services are illegal in the country, Mohale says while they condemn such actions of those who enter the country illegally no one has the right to take the law into their own hands. This he says is to respect the laws of the country.
IOL News
2 days ago
- IOL News
Operation Dudula's campaign against immigrants raises healthcare access concerns
In a controversial move that has sparked outrage and concern, the Operation Dudula Movement, led by Zandile Dabula, is intensifying its campaign against undocumented foreign nationals across South Africa. Image: Henk Kruger / Independent Newspapers With scores of undocumented foreign nationals currently being turned away at Addington Hospital in Durban and other health facilities in parts of the country this week, the leader of the Operation Dudula Movement, Zandile Dabula, has vowed to continue the movement's anti-foreigner healthcare campaign across the country. Eric Jean Butoki, who represents the Southern Africa Refugee Organisations Forum (SAROF), slammed the countrywide campaign, saying it is putting the lives of refugees, asylum seekers, and foreign nationals at risk. This comes as more than 50 patients, believed to be undocumented foreign nationals, have allegedly been turned away at Durban's biggest hospital since the start of the campaign outside Addington Hospital on Tuesday. "We are concerned about this operation, which has prevented foreign nationals, including asylum seekers and genuine refugees, from accessing medical help. Some of these people are on chronic medication and have made appointments to be treated on the scheduled dates. For us, we are disappointed by this Operation Dudula-sponsored campaign. As a result, Butoki has called on the government to establish permanent refugee camps to help resolve the matter. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Ad Loading In various videos circulated on social media over the past week, scores of immigrants seeking medical attention have been turned away, resulting in the South African Human Rights Commission issuing a statement stating that the South African Constitution allows foreigners, including asylum seekers and refugees, the same rights to healthcare as South African citizens. "The South African Human Rights Commission (SAHRC) reminds the public and all relevant stakeholders that the right to access to healthcare services in South Africa is a universal right afforded to anyone within the Republic of South Africa," the commission said. Citing Section 27 (1) of the SA Constitution 1996, the commission indicated that South Africa has a provision to give healthcare access to South African citizens, refugees and asylum seekers, documented and undocumented foreign nationals, including stateless persons. "The Constitution does not qualify or limit this right based on immigration status or citizenship. Furthermore, under Section 27(3), no one may be refused emergency medical treatment. This provision ensures that emergency healthcare must be provided unconditionally by both the public and the private healthcare facilities," it said. Responding to this statement, Dabula said: "We will not be bullied by the likes of the SAHRC, because firstly, they are advocating for people who are in this country illegally. When you come to this country, you must be properly documented, and if you are documented, then you need to have certain permits. For those who are here to work, they must have a work permit, and those permits must come together with medical insurance, but they do not do that. Even Section 17 of the Constitution says that." As a result, Dabula said South Africa cannot be expected to shoulder immigrants who do not have respect for the country's laws, which is why the ongoing campaign will be intensified. "We have always said life comes first, and we will not turn away someone we can see that they require emergency medical care and might lose their lives in the process. However, what needs to happen is that they need to be arrested for being here in this country, illegally, then they can access treatment," she added. ActionSA has also weighed in on the ongoing campaign, saying the SAHRC statement is promoting the abuse of South Africa's resources through the misapplication of Section 27 of the Constitution, which is why the party has recently called for the amendment of the Constitution. Reacting to the stand-off between Operation Dudula and the SAHRC, Dr Shadi Ganoe from the Wits School of Law, indicated that while students and other migrants are required to provide their medical care insurance, the Constitution insists that no one should be refused healthcare based on their citizenship. "For example, in terms of the Immigration Amendment Act 19 of 2004, any prospective international student must have medical cover with a medical scheme registered under the Medical Schemes Act 131 of 1998. This ensures that foreign students do not rely on public health services and can access private care. "This requirement is part of the visa process and is strictly enforced. This makes foreign students and other documented long-term visa holders easy to track and regulate health care costs. They are expected to carry the burden of their own medical needs, unlike undocumented persons or asylum seekers, who may have no formal coverage at all. Still, South Africa's Constitution remains firm: Section 27(3) says, 'No one may be refused emergency medical treatment.' This applies to everyone, citizen or not, documented or not," she said.
