logo
Farmers in England fear for nature after sustainable farming funding frozen

Farmers in England fear for nature after sustainable farming funding frozen

The Guardian05-04-2025
Farmers fear they will no longer be able to afford to restore nature in England and reduce their carbon footprint after government funding for doing this was frozen.
The environment secretary, Steve Reed, recently announced that the sustainable farming incentive (SFI), which pays farmers for making space for nature on their land, would be paused and overhauled before June's spending review. The scope of the scheme – and its budget – are being reassessed.
He is considering blocking farmers who make a lot of money from agriculture from applying for the scheme, which is part of a package of payments that replaced the EU's common agricultural policy and paid land managers for the amount of land in their care, with the aim of paying farmers to look after nature, soil and other public goods, rather than simply for farming and owning land.
In England, 70% of land is farmed, so if nature is to recover, farmers need support to make space for it on their land. This includes planting trees and hedges, digging ponds and leaving strips of land for wildflowers.
Amelia Greenaway, 24, farms native cattle and pigs on 365 hectares (900 acres) of the National Trust's Killerton Estate in Devon. She was applying for £94,000 worth of SFI payments when the application was frozen.
'We are already sustainable as we are organic. We have highland cattle and rare breed pigs which we conservation graze,' she said. But she wanted to go one step further.
'We were going to start growing our own pig feed to create a circular system in our farm, we were going to sow wildflowers in there as well, and it was going to be a good thing for pollinators. We now can't afford the seed to do that,' she said.
It is hard for tenant farmers to apply for schemes as they have to work with the landlords. Greenaway had been working on her funding application for months – time that has been wasted. 'The planning we have had to do over SFI has been immense,' she said. 'This has seriously wasted our time. We had to do so many paperwork applications that delayed the process.'
She said farmers were giving up on the government to provide funding and solutions for nature, and had to accept they would need to do it themselves. 'I hope this gives farmers the opportunity not to put their heads in the sand. We weren't reliant on subsidy but it was great to have that cash boost we could reinvest. Not having the reinvestment will make us become a bit stagnant if the SFI doesn't become available again.'
Greenaway says she is lucky to have a good landlord in the National Trust, which supports nature-friendly farming, but not all farmers are so fortunate: 'Since the shocking news of SFI closure, it's just reminded us of our gratitude towards the National Trust. Without the support of empathetic landlords who want to allow sustainable farming to be a viable business we wouldn't be a sustainable business. I am very stagnant now, not moving forward with nature recovery. I have to count my blessings, but I have to look forward to the future and work even more closely with my landlords.'
She feared other farmers may be discouraged from nature-friendly farming: 'I am really worried for the landscape actually; for those farmers who were considering going into regenerative farming, the chopping and changing has completely reduced confidence so it's caused them to want to intensify instead.'
Anthony Curwen, 63, is the country estate manager of Quex Park in Kent, which grows wheat, oilseed rape, oats, beans, potatoes and maize silage across 1,012 hectares (2,500 acres) of arable land.
He applied for the SFI just before the application window closed, and has now been left in limbo.
Sign up to First Edition
Our morning email breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters
after newsletter promotion
'It is just very shocking and surprising that it was withdrawn last week,' he said. 'What we are doing is helping sustainable farming, pollen and nature strips. We don't use insecticides, we plant cover crops. We have already started doing everything. We were hoping to get the money for doing it.'
Curwen has loved seeing nature come back to the farm. 'I've noticed more insects, more birds. Lots of things were here 40 or 50 years ago and disappeared then came back. We've seen turtle doves come back to the farm, we've seen yellow hammers which I haven't seen for a long time. It is joyous to see it all return.'
He is worried other farmers will not get this same opportunity: 'We've been on this journey for several years, but the vast bulk of farmers don't know what to do. They need persuasion, they need help. It will take a lot of rebuilding trust to hit government targets on biodiversity, carbon and soil regeneration. It is quite scary going on that route as it is very different to what they would have been doing.'
Curwen does not agree with the government's plans to means test it, as it will encourage larger farms to intensify food production with more pesticides and less nature. 'Who could say that nature doesn't matter on a big farm? Nature matters on every farm. Many big farms may go in the opposite direction and intensify and that will hurt nature. It is trying to divide and rule to be honest with you.'
Despite using fewer pesticides and creating more space for nature, productivity has not reduced on his farm: 'Less inputs and more circular farming actually give us more food security. This is all being put at risk because of the clumsy way this is all going on.'
He did not realise this would be the case to begin with, but now is a true convert and a member of the Nature Friendly Farming Network.
'I was sceptical of regenerative farming but we have now realised it makes a huge difference to everything around you,' he said. 'I am in despair. I am just saddened as I think it is going to be harder now. I thought we were a world leader in this journey and now it's all up in the air.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Keir Starmer & John Swinney face difficult ‘balancing act' after Donald Trump admits he's in a grumpy mood
Keir Starmer & John Swinney face difficult ‘balancing act' after Donald Trump admits he's in a grumpy mood

Scottish Sun

time44 minutes ago

  • Scottish Sun

Keir Starmer & John Swinney face difficult ‘balancing act' after Donald Trump admits he's in a grumpy mood

Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) SIR Keir Starmer and John Swinney face a difficult 'balancing act' in talks with Donald Trump - after the US President admitted he was in a grumpy mood. The Prime Minister will fly to Scotland on Monday morning to meet Mr Trump at his Turnberry golf resort in Ayrshire for a 'wide-ranging' summit on issues including trade and the Israel-Hamas war. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 3 Donald Trump is 'not in a good mood' before summit 3 The Prime Minister and First Minister are set to meet with the US President 3 He made the admission after he striking an EU trade deal Later, the PM and the First Minister will attend a banquet-style dinner hosted by the US leader in the north-east, ahead of him opening a new 18-hole golf course in honour of his late Scottish mother, Mary Anne Macleod, at Menie, Aberdeenshire, on Tuesday. But despite striking an EU trade deal, the unpredictable US President admitted he was 'not in a good mood' after a hectic weekend at Turnberry, where he juggled two rounds of golf with family time, presidential business, and a flurry of social media blasts taking aim at rivals back home. A senior SNP insider admitted that today's multiple summits - including an expected one-to-one between Mr Trump and Mr Swinney in the north-east - amounted to 'a difficult balancing act for everyone', with both the PM and FM expected to try to pressure Mr Trump on thorny issues including trade tariffs and reviving stalled Gaza peace talks. Speaking in the first of two press conferences with White House reporters, journalists suggested he seemed in a good mood. But Mr Trump replied: 'I'm actually not in a good mood' - prompting a nervous smile and a raised eyebrow from Ms von der Leyen. The President insisted it was nothing to do with imminent talks with EU chief Ursula von der Leyen, and asked why he was in a bad mood and if it was to do with his latest golf round, Mr Trump said: 'No, the golf was beautiful. Golf can never be bad.' But minutes later, a tetchy-sounding President launched into another of his trademark attacks on windfarms, which he famously battled against - in vain - off the Aberdeenshire coast. In a two-and-half minute blast, he claimed he would 'not allow a windmill to be built in the US' as 'they're killing the beauty of our scenery, our valleys, our beautiful planes - and I'm not talking about aeroplanes, I'm talking about beautiful planes, beautiful areas in the US'. He said 'almost all' were made in China and 'when they start to rust and rot in eight years, you can't really turn them off, you can't bury them'. Mr Trump said windmills 'kill the birds' and said: 'You have a certain place in the Massachusetts area that over the last 20 years had one or two whales wash ashore .. cause it's driving them loco. It's driving them crazy.' TRUMP V WINDMILLS Slamming windfarms off the Ayrshire coast, he said 'I mean, today, I'm playing the best course I think in the world, Turnberry - even though I own it, it's probably the best course in the world, right - and I look over the horizon and I see nine windmills right at the end of the 18th hole. 'And I said, 'Isn't that a shame? What a shame.' UK and Scottish government aides are known to be on edge about today's talks with Mr Trump, which will take place between the PM and President at Turnberry, before the pair fly together to Aberdeen, where Mr Swinney will then meet the US leader. All three will then attend a private ceremonial dinner said to involve a 'broad range' of guests including politicians and business figures. Sir Keir is under intense pressure from Labour backbenchers and opposition parties including the SNP to push Mr Trump for the US to revive Gaza ceasefire talks, and also to further the recent UK-US trade deal by pressuring for the removal of punishing ten per cent tariffs on products including Scotch whisky. And Mr Swinney is under fire from left-wingers in the SNP and at Holyrood for even meeting with Mr Trump. The First Minister was blasted by critics at the weekend for announcing £180,000 to help Mr Trump's Menie course to host a golf comp, which wannabe Greens leader Ross Greer claimed was like 'bending the knee' to the US President or 'giving the school bully your lunch money'. A senior Nats source defended Mr Swinney's approach, with the Tories also accusing him of hypocrisy after claims he had last wee 'whipped up' anti-Trump protests, but was now trying to curry favour with the world's most powerful man. The insider said 'There will be complaints about our approach to Trump whatever we do. 'The funding for the event at Trump International Golf Links was a positive announcement and it's our job to make the best of this visit as we possibly can.' Tomorrow morning Mr Trump will carry out the ceremonial opening of the Macleod course at his Menie estate, which it emerged on Saturday was set to get £180,000 from the Scottish Government's tourism and events organisation, VisitScotland, to support its hosting of the 2025 Nexo Championship next month. Police lock down Scots country park and beach ahead of Donald Trump's arrival HOLIDAYMAKERS have been ordered to leave a country park boasting one of Scotland's best beaches as police prepared for Donald Trump's visit to his nearby golf course. Visitors were told to vacate the beauty spot as security is beefed up ahead of US president's trip to his neighbouring Menie Estate in Aberdeenshire tomorrow. Officers locked down Balmedie Country Park and its coastal stretch — which has won 20 awards for the quality of its sand and water. Locals have vowed to protest after the Scottish Government announced a tournament held at his Trump International resort is being given £180,000 of taxpayers' cash. An onlooker said: 'Police were shutting off the beach and the park. 'It's one of the country's best and we're in the middle of the school holidays. 'Trump doesn't own it so it feels ridiculous that people who live here are being told to leave. "Loads of people were told to go. 'Is it any wonder most people around here hate him so much?' Downing Street last night said Mr Trump and Sir Keir are expected to discuss progress on implementing the UK-US trade deal agreed in May, hopes for a ceasefire in the Middle East and applying pressure on Vladimir Putin to end the war in Ukraine. It comes amid pressure on Starmer from Labour MPs to urge the US to rejoin Israel-Hamas peace talks, amid the starvation of kids in Gaza. No10 said in a statement that the 'strength of the UK-US relationship will be on display again' as the PM meets Mr Trump in 'for wide-ranging talks'. It said: 'The leaders are expected to talk one-on-one about advancing implementation of the landmark Economic Prosperity Deal so that Brits and Americans can benefit from boosted trade links between their two countries. 'The Prime Minister is also expected to welcome the President's administration working with partners in Qatar and Egypt to bring about a ceasefire in Gaza. 'Mr Trump's visit comes amid mounting global anger over the humanitarian conditions in Gaza. Police lock down Scots country park and beach ahead of Donald Trump's arrival Foreign Secretary David Lammy said access to aid in Gaza must be 'urgently accelerated', after air drops by Jordan and the United Arab Emirates yesterday. It came hours after Israel opened up aid corridors and 'refuted' the 'false claim of intentional starvation'. Mr Swinney said: 'My meeting with the US President during his visit to Scotland presents a significant opportunity to speak up for the issues that matter to people in Scotland on the highest platform. Global, humanitarian issues are rightly at the forefront of many people's minds. 'It is of utmost importance that we discuss what action can be taken to end the horrific suffering we are witnessing around the world, particularly the unimaginable hardship being endured by people in Gaza and the need for an urgent ceasefire. 'Both the US President and I share a fundamental desire to build peace across the world and to end the suffering endured by so many. I hope that our discussion helps to further that aim.' Mr Trump will visit the UK again in September for the official state visit announced earlier this year. But a senior whisky industry source warned: 'If the PM comes away from the Trump visit with nothing more on trade there will be serious questions to answer about whether he really fought as hard as possible for Scotland and the UK's interests, or if he just went there and tried not to upset Trump.'

EU urges Ukraine to uphold independent anti-corruption bodies; Zelenskiy signals swift action
EU urges Ukraine to uphold independent anti-corruption bodies; Zelenskiy signals swift action

Reuters

time44 minutes ago

  • Reuters

EU urges Ukraine to uphold independent anti-corruption bodies; Zelenskiy signals swift action

BRUSSELS, July 27 (Reuters) - European Commission President Ursula von der Leyen called on Sunday for President Volodymyr Zelenskiy to uphold independent anti-corruption bodies, with the Ukrainian leader signaling that supporting legislation could be adopted within days. "Ukraine has already achieved a lot on its European path. It must build on these solid foundations and preserve independent anti-corruption bodies, which are cornerstones of Ukraine's rule of law," von der Leyen said in a post on X after a call with Zelenskiy. After a rare outburst of public criticism, Zelenskiy on Thursday submitted draft legislation to restore the independence of Ukraine's anti-corruption agencies - reversing course of an earlier bill aimed at stripping their autonomy. "I thanked the European Commission for the provided expertise," Zelenskiy said in a post on X after his Sunday call with von der Leyen. "We share the same vision: it is important that the bill is adopted without delay, as early as next week." Von der Leyen also promised continued support for Ukraine on its path to EU membership. "Ukraine can count on our support to deliver progress on its European path," she added.

Donald Trump insists Gaza is not just ‘US problem' as Sir Keir Starmer prepares to push him to end war
Donald Trump insists Gaza is not just ‘US problem' as Sir Keir Starmer prepares to push him to end war

Scottish Sun

timean hour ago

  • Scottish Sun

Donald Trump insists Gaza is not just ‘US problem' as Sir Keir Starmer prepares to push him to end war

Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) DONALD Trump yesterday insisted Gaza is not just a 'US problem' — as Sir Keir Starmer prepared to push him to help end the 'unspeakable suffering'. The US President will host the PM at his Turnberry golf course in Scotland this morning for wide-ranging talks including on the Israel-Hamas war. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 Donald Trump insisted Gaza is not just a 'US problem' Credit: Getty 2 Sir Keir Starmer prepared to push him to help end the 'unspeakable suffering' Credit: Getty Mr Trump said Israel would have to 'make a decision' on its next steps amid kids starving as the crisis worsens. He complained that 'nobody had even acknowledged' his recent aid funding to Gaza. And he added: 'The US is going to do more aid for Gaza, but we'd like to have other countries participate. 'It's not a US problem — it's an international problem.' No10 said Sir Keir would press the President on 'what more can be done to secure a ceasefire urgently, bring an end to the unspeakable suffering in Gaza and free the hostages who have been held so cruelly for so long.' Jordan and the UAE air dropped aid into Gaza yesterday after Israel paused its operations. Meanwhile Mr Trump hailed a trade deal in which the EU will buy £550billion of US energy and pledge a further £450billion of investment. The US will impose 15 per cent tariffs on the EU — lower than the 30 per cent he threatened, but still more than the ten per cent Britain pays. Mr Trump said it was the 'biggest deal ever made' and will be 'great for cars' and agriculture. EU chief Ursula von der Leyen said it was a 'good deal' after calling the US President 'a tough negotiator'. US and EU agree landmark trade deal after months of talks, Donald Trump says Earlier Mr Trump — who found time for a round at Turnberry, escorted by an entourage of staff and Secret Service agents in golf buggies — blasted Europe for erecting so many wind farms. He said: 'We will not allow a windmill to be built in the United States. They're killing the beauty of our scenery.' After their talks, Sir Keir and Mr Trump will attend a private dinner of politicians and businessmen in Aberdeen.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store