Kane Cornes blasts the AFL's ‘dumbest rule ever'
The 'stand rule' was first implemented back in 2021 and has had a number of tweaks since, all designed to speed up play and theoretically increase scoring in the competition.
FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer.
The numbers don't reflect that intention, however, and the rule has led to instances just about every week of players, fans and commentators being left confused over 50 metre penalties related to the rule.
Port Adelaide premiership player Cornes believes it's time for the rule to be scrapped.
'It's an absolute mess … and I've had enough,' he said on Channel 7's The Agenda Setters.
'I've had enough of the dumbest rule the AFL have ever brought in and that is the stand rule.
'I'm so sick of it, I've given it a chance, it's been four or five years, it is just not working and it is far too complicated for everyone.'
The program played a number of examples of the rule being breached last weekend, including Collingwood's clash with West Coast and Sam Darcy coming out of the forward line to mark a Swans player at the SCG.
'How this is a 50 and a goal is just blowing my mind that we are asking our players to not move on the mark,' Cornes continued.
'Even when they do it well, like Sam Darcy here – what more could he do? What do you want him to do? And that's 50.
'How are we accepting of this as an industry? This is costing goals, (Darcy) couldn't believe it.'
Callum Mills is also shown being pinged in the same match against the Dogs, along with Lions forward Charlie Cameron against Geelong's Mark Blicavs in round 15.
'It hasn't done anything for scoring. The reason it was brought in, OK it was going to fix ball movement and scoring, well it's not,' Cornes said.
'It has done next to nothing when it comes to scoring and improving that.
'The stand rule, I've had enough, players have had enough, I'm sure those watching at home are sick of it.
'Nice try but let's just get back to footy the way it should be played and make life easier for everyone.'
On the same program, Lions veteran Dayne Zorko was asked what he finds the 'most frustrating element of footy right now' and he immediately mentioned the contentious rule.
'There's a number but I think guarding the mark is one of the hardest ones,' he said.
'Players normally nail most changes, I think we're still struggling with this one.'
Fans were left pretty divided over the rule change and the way it is interpreted.
Bill Williams wrote on X: 'In my opinion the stand rule is brilliant. Who wants to go back to watching the man on the 'mark' carrying on like a headless chook or the ball carrier having to constantly ask the umpire 'where's the mark' as the marker could be any distance from the actual mark. A great improvement.'
Ben Cameron tweeted: 'The decision against Mills in this clip is everything that's wrong with the current umpiring, Kennedy marks but Mills has no idea if it will be paid or not … if he lets him go & it's play on he looks silly, why not blow the whistle & let him get back behind the mark.'
Joyboy suggested: 'Why does it HAVE to be 50 metres? If the rule is so hard to follow, make it 10 metres or something.'
Another wrote: 'The stand rule is fine, the 50m penalty is the problem.'
One fan declared: 'Absolutely it is a joke and needs to go.'
The rules are regularly reviewed by the AFL, with a clarification on the 'stand' rule dropping ahead of the 2023 season.
'An opposition player cannot run toward the mark (and enter the protected area) and then elect to change their mind and retreat outside of the protected 5m area,' the AFL said at the time.
'Similarly, an opposition player cannot elect to leave the protected area and then change their intent and choose to come and stand the mark.
'Further all other players from the opposing team must be positioned behind the mark or otherwise outside the protected area.'
It seems it has all just added up to more confusion and some simplification – or in fact a scrapping of the rule – might be needed moving forward.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
34 minutes ago
- ABC News
NSW Blues player Payne Haas praises Broncos teammate and Queensland rival Gehamat Shibasaki ahead of State of Origin III
Payne Haas could see the difference in Queensland State of Origin bolter Gehamat Shibasaki from the moment he arrived at Brisbane training this pre-season. Teenage teammates at the Broncos, Shibasaki and Haas will play on opposing teams in a senior match for just the second time in next week's series decider. ABC Sport will have live blog coverage of the State of Origin series. But their path from Brisbane's U20s team in 2017 to Stadium Australia next Wednesday night could not be any more different. While Haas has been one of the NRL's best front-rower for the past five years at Brisbane, Shibisaki has been on rollercoaster ride to crack it in first grade. Like Haas, the centre debuted at the Broncos in 2018 but found himself out the door to Newcastle where he also struggled for game time. A move to Japanese rugby with the Green Rockets Tokatsu followed in 2022, before he took up a train-and-trial deal with the North Queensland Cowboys. The 26-year-old then spent last year playing Queensland Cup in Townsville, and time on a week-to-week contract arrangement with South Sydney during their injury crisis. Another a train-and-trial deal came at Brisbane this year, where Shibasaki was reunited with Haas and clearly a different man to the one who left. "He's way more dialled in," Haas said. "He took his training more seriously, the way was eating, the way he was preparing for training, it was cool to see. "I knew he was serious about it. I knew he knew this was his last shot. He took it with both hands and he's never looked back." The difference is telling. Shibasaki's selection for Queensland is about as left field as it gets, but it comes after a year where he has scored 12 tries in 15 games for the Broncos. The centre has become the first player in history to be picked to play Origin while on a development deal. Haas insisted Shibasaki's talent had always been there, even if it had taken until seven years after his NRL debut for him to become a top-grade regular. "He's always been gifted, he was one of the best players growing up when we were kids," Haas said. "He lost his way a bit the last few years. But he's found his way back and I'm super proud of him. "He worked so hard, this was his last shot and he's taken it with both hands. "I just hate that he's a Queenslander." AAP
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
‘Our best-ever season': Darby Racing passes century of winners for 2024-25
Scott Darby likens his successful racehorse syndications business to an evolving footy team. 'We are always trying to add an older, established 'player' to Darby Racing while continuing to bring in some younger talent,'' Darby explained. 'It's almost like trying to build a good football side. Although many of our owners might only be in one horse they are following all of our Darby horses so it is very tribal.'' Darby is an avid Wests Tigers supporter but it is fair to say he's having more success on the racetrack than his team is on the footy field. 'I am struggling with the Tigers because the season is going the way it has gone the last few years,'' he said. 'I am very competitive and I'm finding myself turning the Tigers games off before they are finished. I love an underdog and the Tigers are improving slowly, but too slowly.'' Fortunately for Darby, his Darby Racing Syndications business is making winning a habit on the racetrack with the owner's familiar racing colours of white, navy blue Darby Racing logo, navy blue armband and cap being worn by jockeys to more than 100 race wins this season. During 2024-25, Darby Racing-owned horses have won the Group 1 Winterbottom Stakes and have had Group 2 wins in The Ingham, Brisbane Cup, Sweet Embrace Stakes, Shannon Stakes and Ajax Stakes, Group 3 wins in the Sydney Stakes, Newcastle Stakes, Parramatta Cup, Queen Elizabeth II Cup and Liverpool City Cup, plus a host of Listed races including the Inglis Nursery and Inglis Banner. 'I think all-round with winners, stakes wins and prizemoney, this has been our best-ever season,'' Darby said. 'We are on track for 120 wins for the season. We have been trying to average 10 wins a month and we have 107 wins going into July.'' Robusto and Raging Force, who are both entries for Rosehill Gardens on Saturday, are representative of the Darby Racing ethos. Apprentice Ben Osmond ducks and weaves on Robusto and the @cwallerracing -trained gelding wins first-up ðŸ'Š — SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) July 20, 2024 The Bjorn Baker -trained Robusto, a relatively recent Darby Racing purchase, is a rising six-year-old but has had a career-best season and is chasing another feature race win in the Listed $200,000 Winter Stakes (1400m). Raging Force, the boom Peter Snowden -trained two-year-old, has looked exceptional winning both starts this winter and is looking to extend his winning streak in the Thank You ATC Members Handicap (1100m). Darby purchased Robusto for $160,000 as a tried racehorse last spring and the gelding struck a rich vein of form last summer including his win in the Group 2 $2 million The Ingham. 'Robusto has been unbelievable for us,'' Darby said. 'He was primed for the Stradbroke Handicap but it didn't quite work out for him that day. There is not much else for him and I would say he will run. 'He is better on a firmer surface so as long as it is not too wet, he will be racing.'' Robusto has topweight of 60kg and is at $6 in early TAB Fixed Odds betting behind stablemate Thunderlips ($4.80) for the Winter Stakes. Exciting colt Raging Force also has the number one saddlecloth after being allocated 59kg for the juvenile opener but his brilliant wins in the Red Crown at Muswellbrook and then at Kensington has him rated a dominant $2.10 favourite. That's a big win at Randwick to Raging Force, who makes it two wins in a row! ðŸ'° @TommyBerry21 @SnowdenRacing1 @aus_turf_club @Darby_Racing — SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) June 25, 2025 'We had him touted as a Golden Slipper horse early in the season but he went amiss in the Breeders Plate,'' Darby said. 'He went sore behind, it was the same sort of injury that Ozzmosis had early in his career. 'Raging Force surprised me at Kensington. I thought he could win but the way he did it was incredible.'' The Michael Freedman stable has accepted with two Darby hopefuls – the consistent Bunker Hut ($8) in the Foundation Female Member Handicap (1200m) and Queen Of The Mile ($12) in the Captivant At Kia Ora Handicap (1100m). Bunker Hut is resuming from a spell but has a good first-up record and he is effective on rain-affected going. 'Michael has given Bunker Hut three barrier trials so he is ready to go,'' Darby said. 'I would imagine he will kick off on Saturday, at least he can handle it wet. 'If Queen Of The Mile had got a firm track then she would just about win. She has returned in terrific order, her first-up run (fourth to Storm The Ramparts) was very good, but she doesn't like it too heavy. We will see what sort of track we get on Saturday.'' Bunker Hut was too good first up in the opener at Rosehill. @MFreedmanRacing @Darby_Racing @G1TySchil — SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) September 9, 2023 The Ciaron Maher -trained Rise To It ($21) and the superbly-bred Fleet Commander ($23, by Galileo out of Atlantic Jewel) from the Baker stable give Darby Racing two competitive chances in the Catanach's Jewellers Handicap (2000m). 'Rise To It is usually thereabouts, we would like to try and get another win out of him this preparation,'' Darby said. 'Fleet Commander has had two runs back from a spell and is coming up nicely. He's ready to run a good race.'' Darby set up his syndications business 17 years ago and has enjoyed consistent success over the years with the likes of Golden Slipper winner She Will Reign and Group 1 winners Yankee Rose, Overpass, Ozzmosis and Samadoubt. But the syndicator maintains success is borne out of 'hard work and luck' in an increasingly competitive market. $20k purchase She Will Reign wins the 2017 #GoldenSlipper! What a ride from @BMelham! — SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) March 18, 2017 'Obviously, like everyone in the game, we are fighting for some of that entertainment dollar and it can be very challenging,'' Darby said. 'There a lot of people doing syndications these days so it is hard to compete and stay relevant, to be exciting and entertaining, not just on the big days but all year round. 'We have different criteria when we buy yearlings compared to our tried horses but first and foremost we have to do our homework. 'With the yearlings, we need to check them out physically and also look at their pedigrees, with the tried horses we have to study their form 'Our team works very hard but you also need a lot of luck in this business, too. There are only so many boxes you can tick then you need some luck to go your way.'' â– â– â– â– â– Darby to use the Force one final time this prep Boom two-year-old Raging Force gets an opportunity to add his name to Darby Racing's lengthy list of potential spring carnival contenders in the Thank You ATC Members Handicap (1100m) at Rosehill Gardens on Saturday. Champion trainer Peter Snowden, who recorded the 50th Group 1 win of his career with Tashi in last week's Tatt's Tiara, has a big opinion of Raging Force. 'Raging Force is a lovely horse and he did win with a lot of authority last start,'' Snowden said. 'He has stamped himself as a possibility for the spring and I'd like to give him one more run this preparation. 'He needs to show us he is the real deal because you soon get found out (spring carnival) if you go there too early. 'I think he just lacks a bit of racing toughness so another run wouldn't hurt him to see exactly where he is at but he's very promising.'' Darby Racing's principal, Scott Darby, hopes Raging Force can join his spring team that already includes possible The Everest contenders Overpass and Caballus, brilliant filly Within The Law and Melbourne Cup hopeful Campaldino. Overpass! That's back-to-back Winterbottom Stakes and he extends his unbeaten record at Ascot to four! ðŸ'¯ Job done for @BBakerRacing and jockey @JoshuaParr8 ✅ — SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) November 30, 2024 Darby said he was hopeful of getting $10.5 million earner Overpass and talented young sprinter Caballus to The Everest but said the Sydney Stakes on the same day was the more realistic target for both horses. 'Overpass is back in pre-training and we will get him ready for another Sydney Stakes first-up,'' Darby said. 'There is some thought of Hong Kong for something different but it is hard to knock back Perth when he has won two Group 1 races (Winterbottom Stakes) there. 'Caballus had a throat issue and we had him gelded then when he came back into work he was flying going into the Ortensia Stakes at Scone where he won so well first-up. 'But then he was found to have two little trickles of blood coming out of his nostrils. It was nothing really but we have to treat him like a bleeder now. 'He had two months out and is due to start back in work next week. We thought he would target the Sydney Stakes but if he comes back really well he might be a chances for an Everest slot. 'It's the same with Overpass. His name will always be bandied around and if we knew he would get a slot he would go to The Everest without a lead-up run as his first-up record is incredible.'' Within The Law won three races – Inglis Banner, Inglis Nursery, Sweet Embrace Stakes – during a seven-race two-year-old season that also included narrow losses in the Champagne Stakes and Inglis Millennium. Her only unplaced run was in the Golden Slipper when she fell. The @inglis_sales Nursery goes to Within The Law, giving Jason Collett a Randwick double! @BBakerRacing | @Darby_Racing | @aus_turf_club — SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) December 14, 2024 'It was difficult watching what happened to Within The Law in the Golden Slipper, you are never prepared for something like that,'' Darby said. 'When you see it live, you think she has broken down and gone through the fence but it wasn't the case. 'She picked herself up and then returned to run well in two more races and almost won a Group 1. 'We feel she is an extra special filly, she is no fuss, nothing fazes her and she has returned bigger and stronger for the spring.'' Darby said he needs to discuss with trainer Bjorn Baker a likely spring campaign for Within The Law although the likely option is the Princess Series for three-year-old fillies which includes the Group 1 Flight Stakes. 'Is Within The Law a filly that will stretch out to a Cox Plate and Oaks or is she more a sprinter miler?'' Darby said. 'I tend to think she might be more a miler-2000m horse so she could do something similar to Yankee Rose and go through the Spring Champion Stakes and possibly the Cox Plate.'' Campaldino won the Orange Cup back in April to start a four-race winning streak culminating in his Brisbane Cup (3200m) win earlier this month. Campaldino is simply too good in the G2 Brisbane Cup with Tim Clark in the saddle! ðŸ�† @GaiWaterhouse1 — SKY Racing (@SkyRacingAU) June 14, 2025 'The rise he has made through the grades has been unbelievable,'' Darby said. 'When he won the Orange Cup I thought that day this horse has returned very well but he has kept on winning since. 'The Brisbane Cup was a bit of a sit-and-sprint and I said to the owners if the horse goes to the Caulfield Cup, it will be a very genuine tempo and you need to be a proper stayer. 'But if he can continue his improvement next season he might be a Caulfield Cup and Melbourne Cup horse.'' Darby said lightly-raced three-year-old Raikkonen would be aimed at the Golden Eagle, Iowna Merc and Sandpaper for the Epsom Handicap, while he rates Imperial Force as a horse to follow next season. 'Bjorn really likes Imperial Force and after he ran a close second in the Arrowfield Stakes we took him to Adelaide for a stakes race,'' Darby said. 'But he was disappointing that day and needed a break but we have had him gelded and think we can turn him into a serious racehorse next season.''
News.com.au
an hour ago
- News.com.au
‘I will hate him next Wednesday': Blues show Origin rookie Gehamat Shibasaki plenty of respect
Blues centre Stephen Crichton has downplayed the notion that his side will go after Gehamat Shibasaki next week when the Maroons centre makes his State of Origin debut with the series on the line. Shibasaki has earnt his spot on the back of three-straight try doubles for the Broncos, with Queensland coach Billy Slater opting to bring him in after he moved Hamiso Tabuai-Fidow to fullback to replace the injured Kalyn Ponga. Slater could have easily brought Reece Walsh in to play fullback but has instead backed Shibasaki to get the job done against arguably the best centre in the world. The pair met earlier this year when Brisbane ended Canterbury's six-match winning streak to start the season, with Shibasaki scoring one of their six first-half tries when Crichton was trapped at marker in defence. The Bulldogs skipper has nothing but respect for a guy whose NRL career was at a crossroads last year, with the Blues to have a significant advantage in experience out wide with Latrell Mitchell up against Roosters rookie Robert Toia. 'Not really,' Crichton replied when asked if NSW would target the Origin debutant. 'I feel like there are two parts to the game – the physical side and the mental side. 'It's mental all the way up until game day for me as I try to get my role right at training before putting it out on the field. 'The physicality comes because it's Origin, it's game three and it's a decider as well. 'He's such a good player. I feel like he's been playing his best footy the past couple of weeks leading into his Origin selection. 'There is going to be a lot of talk around it, but I feel like the Origin arena brings out the best in everyone regardless of whether you haven't played a game because you're always going to turn up and play your best.' Shibasaki has scored more tries this season than he has in the rest of his NRL career combined, with the powerful centre no stranger to the Maroons jersey having worn it several times in the junior ranks. He played three matches for the Queensland under-20 team, while he also lined up alongside Zac Lomax in the centres for the Junior Kangaroos back in 2018. He has been the constant on the left edge for a Broncos team that has made several changes to the backline, but teammate Payne Haas will switch his respect for animosity when they square off next week. 'I'm super proud of him,' the Blues prop said. 'He came in (to the Broncos) on a train and trial (deal) and worked his backside off to get to where he is now. 'I'm really proud of him, but I will hate him next Wednesday.'
