&w=3840&q=100)
‘If he fails again, it's the end for him': Fans divided as India recall Karun Nair for fifth Test vs England
Fans are saying Karun Nair's comeback is his third and final chance. Image: PTI
Just when you thought Karun Nair's international career was over, the 33-year-old made a comeback to the Indian Test team on Thursday as he was included in the against England at The Oval. Nair made a return to international cricket after a gap of eight years in the first Test of the series at Leeds as he scored a duck in the first innings, followed by 20 in the second essay.
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
After batting at No.6 at Headingley, he was tried out at No.3 at Edgbaston and Lord's, scoring 31, 26, 40 and 14 in four innings. His failure to convert the starts into big scores as India went 2-1 down led to his exclusion in the fourth Test at Manchester.
However, India captain Shubman Gill as the visitors look to level the series. Probably the absence of Rishabh Pant, who is out of the final Test due to a fractured toe, played a role in Nair's inclusion as India wanted more batting strength. Nonetheless, it's another opportunity for Nair to seal a permanent place in the Indian Test team.
Fans divided as India recall Karun Nair
A failure in the fifth Test at The Oval could potentially lead to his exclusion from the India squad and the end of his international career.
Indian fans were divided on coach Gautam Gambhir and Gill's decision to recall Karun Nair. A few pointed out that The Oval Test could be the final lifeline thrown at Nair.
'Karun Nair is lucky to get another chance but it's his last.. If he fails again, it's the end for him,' a fan wrote on X.
Another wondered why Nair was called back: 'Why inclusion of Prasidh vs Arshdeep? Again Karun Nair? Yashasvi has been failing consistently with his failed technique!'
Why inclusion of Prasidh vs Arshdeep? Again Karun Nair? Yashasvi has been failing consistently with his failed technique! @BCCI @DineshKarthik @bhogleharsha astonished Yadav again excluded! — Arjun (@lososcuros_) July 31, 2025
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
But a few Indian team fans were delighted for the middle-order batter as they hoped he would make big runs in the fifth Test and become a permanent fixture in the team.
'I know nobody is gonna read it, But deep down i want karun nair to play the 5th Test and score Great runs, atleast Min. 150 runs in 2 innings and win it for india He has achieved inhuman numbers in domestic and worked very hard for whole year I hope god is watching,' a fan said.
Another fan pointed out that Nair was included to negate the green top at The Oval.
'Fed up of criticisms around playing too many all-rounders, Gambhir plays one extra specialist batter in Karun Nair. Yes, it covers for a possible first innings batting collapse on a greenish pitch but leaves India with only 3 pacers,' he said.
Fed up of criticisms around playing too many all-rounders, Gambhir plays one extra specialist batter in Karun Nair. Yes, it covers for a possible first innings batting collapse on a greenish pitch but leaves India with only 3 pacers. — Mayank (@mayankreports) July 31, 2025
STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
Besides Nair, India also called up Dhruv Jurel for Pant, Akash Deep for Anshul Kamboj, while Prasidh Krishna replaced Shardul Thakur.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India Today
9 minutes ago
- India Today
Curious case of the heavy roller: How it can affect Day 5 of the Oval Test
The Oval Test is perfectly poised for a dramatic end on Day 5 on Monday, August 4. Everyone expected the match to be done and dusted on Sunday as India needed nine wickets and England, who were 50 for 1, needed another 324 runs to seal the win and the series. Things started off well for the visitors as they dismissed Ben Duckett right after he got his fifty before Ollie Pope was trapped in front of the stumps by Mohammed Siraj. advertisementIndian fans were almost in raptures when Siraj caught Harry Brook near the boundary line but the Indian pacer accidentally stepped on the line. Brook made India pay with a brilliant 111 and Root followed it up with his 39th Test hundred. England looked all set for the win, but there was a twist in the tale. Prasidh Krishna got the wickets of Jacob Bethell and Root to get India back into the contest. Just when things got interesting, the weather played spoilsport and both teams returned to the pavilion ready to fight it out on Monday. All four results are possible in the match with England needing 35 runs and India looking for four wickets, with the injured Chris Woakes ready to bat. But here is where England has an advantage, with the use of the heavy roller, something that Harsha Bhogle pointed out in his tweet right after the play stopped on Day 4. "I am glad there are people other than me asking why the covers couldn't have come off in time to allow us to witness an extraordinary climax. Now we come back tomorrow but the heavy roller can be used and that can be a game-changer," tweeted Bhogle. The heavy roller was used just before the start of Day 4 by the hosts and their skipper, Pope and the results were evident. The English batters were scoring freely and the Indian bowlers were made to toil and work hard for breakthroughs. What does the heavy roller do?So, according to the ICC, the pitch may be rolled at the request of the captain of the batting side, for a period of not more than 7 minutes, before the start of each innings, other than the first innings of the match, and before the start of each subsequent day's Test, Day 5 Weather reportThe rolling permitted before play on any day shall be started not more than 30 minutes before the time scheduled or rescheduled for play to begin. The captain of the batting side may, however, delay the start of such rolling until not less than 10 minutes before the time scheduled or rescheduled for play to the important thing is that the choice of the roller (heavy or light) is given to the captain of the batting side. In this case, it will be England's Pope. If he is going to opt for the heavy roller, then it will smoothen out any unevenness on the pitch, essentially making it flat and suitable for batting. While this may be only for a brief period, it plays into the hands of the hosts at the Oval given that they need 35 runs to win. Joe Root, during the press conference, said that the rolling has had an effect on the game so far and is hoping things will work out in their favour if the heavy one is used. "In terms of the roller, we'll see. I haven't got a crystal ball unfortunately, but it has made an impact so far throughout this game. Whether that changes on day five, we'll see, but hopefully it works well in our favor in flattening things out," said Root. advertisementIndia's bowling coach Morne Morkel was unfazed by the prospect of the heavy roller being used, and feels that his well-rested bowlers can get in a good warm-up and go out to chase and get the wickets needed. "Tomorrow we can just focus on doing a good warm-up and get the boys ready to hopefully get the ball in the right area and yeah, create a little bit of excitement again," said Morkel. With the match on a knife-edge, things could all come down to the process of rolling just before the start of play. - EndsTune InMust Watch
The Hindu
9 minutes ago
- The Hindu
How a missed chance became motivation: Sujeet Kalkal's rise in wrestling
Whenever Indian wrestler Sujeet Kalkal feels short of motivation, he pulls out his phone and looks at the wallpaper. The 22-year-old has had his share of wrestling highlights recently. In July, Sujeet won India's first gold medal of the year at the UWW (United World Wrestling) Ranking Series in Budapest, defeating Olympic bronze medallist Islam Dudaev of Albania, two-time Olympian Vazgen Tevanyan of Armenia, and four-time European medallist Ali Rahimzade of Azerbaijan in the men's 65kg division. In a strong field, Sujeet scored 33 points while conceding just two across four matches — a result that marks him as a potential medal contender at the World Championships in September. The picture on Sujeet's phone, however, isn't from Budapest. It's from Istanbul, taken during last year's World Wrestling Olympic Qualification Tournament, where he experienced one of the lowest moments of his career. Having won the selection trials in India, Sujeet had hoped to qualify for the Paris Games at the Asian Olympic Qualifiers in Jordan. But in a turn of misfortune, his connecting flight to Amman was delayed due to a record-breaking flood in Dubai. At the World Qualifiers — a much tougher field — Sujeet made it to the semifinals, needing just one more win to book his Olympic ticket. But he fell short. He lost 6-1 to Mongolia's Tulga Tomor-Ochiryn, and then came agonisingly close against World Champion Zain Retherford of the USA, losing 2-2 on criteria. (Sujeet lost because Retherford scored the final takedown) It's a picture of the match against Tulga that Sujeet glances at every time he picks up his phone. While most athletes might have been bitterly disappointed about missing out on making their Olympic debut, Sujeet sees things differently. 'Although I lost, I consider these two defeats to be the most important matches for me. I might have qualified for the Olympics had I somehow won, but I don't think I was mentally ready then. I learned so much from my two losses. The fact that I lost just 2-2 against a world champion gave me a lot of motivation. I realised how much more I had to work on,' he says. But that's not the only thing atypical about India's latest prospect in men's freestyle wrestling. He's a relatively late bloomer in the sport, only seriously pursuing it since the last five years. He once had dreams of being an engineer and routinely peppers his conversation with English. Sujeet might have been expected to take to wrestling as a matter of tradition. He traces his roots to Imlota, a village in Haryana's Bhiwani district with a strong wrestling culture. His father, Dayanand, is a former national wrestling champion and even competed at the 2005 World Championships in the Greco-Roman category. Method wrestler: 'I was always drilled on technique, that's the kind of wrestler I've become,' says Sujeet. | Photo Credit: RV MOORTHY Sujeet, however, wasn't pushed into the sport. Although he started going to the village akhara with his father from the age of six, he, unlike many Indian wrestlers, was expected to give equal importance to his studies. Unable to focus solely on wrestling, Sujeet's career features no major success at the cadet (Under-17) or junior (U-19) levels. 'He scored over 90 per cent in his Class 12 Board Exams. Because he excelled in his studies, I didn't want to push him to wrestle the way he had to if he had to win at the age-group levels. Kushti karwane aur sikhane me farak hai (there's a kind of wrestling you do when you want to learn the sport, and a kind you do when you have to win). While Sujeet was in school, I just wanted him to learn,' says Dayanand. It was only after Sujeet graduated from school that he decided to focus solely on becoming a wrestler. 'I was in the non-medical stream and initially thought about preparing for the JEE (Joint Entrance Exam). I even gave a few mock tests. But after my Class 12 exams, my father said I had to choose which direction I wanted to go. I finally decided I wanted to be a wrestler. I loved the sport. When I was growing up, I'd watch videos of Sushil (Kumar) and Bajrang (Punia). I used to really enjoy those videos. I was good in studies, of course, but I felt I could do more for myself and the country as a wrestler,' says Sujeet. He moved to Sonipat to train with coach Kuldeep Singh, who recalls the youngster standing out particularly because of his intelligence. 'He didn't have any big results at the age-group levels for two reasons. One, of course, was because he was managing his studies alongside his sport. The second was that, unlike a lot of junior athletes, he never changed his age to get an unfair advantage. But his best quality was just how quickly he picked up things. He started training at our academy in 2021, and within four years, he's now one of the best wrestlers in India,' says Kuldeep. Atypical Indian wrestler The unorthodox route Sujeet has taken in his career has influenced the kind of wrestler he is. 'Most of the top Indian wrestlers have a game that is based on tiring out opponents. That's because the training that most of them have is designed to build up stamina. When I watch someone like Bajrang pehelwan, it's really exciting because he wrestles for all six minutes, and when he is competing, you always know that even if he is trailing in the score, he will break the opponent physically and then come back in the last few seconds of the match,' says Sujeet. 'It's fun to watch, but I can't wrestle that way. When I started wrestling, I was always drilled on technique. Even now I'm more of a technical wrestler,' he says. That's what coach Kuldeep identifies as Sujeet's strength too. 'He's not going to tire out an opponent. But he's very sharp and explosive. He doesn't like to give away easy points, and if he can, he will try to finish off matches as early as possible,' says Kuldeep. Making it count: Having fallen short of making it to Paris 2024, Sujeet is determined not to miss out again. | Photo Credit: RV MOORTHY Ever since making his senior national debut in 2022 — where he won silver — Sujeet has made a concerted push to claim the top spot in one of India's marquee weight categories. While he emerged as the national representative in 2024 after winning the selection trials, Sujeet admits that he still has some way to go before cementing his place in the Indian squad. His loss at the Olympic Qualification Tournament only further motivated him. 'That tournament gave me the confidence that I could compete at a very high level, but it also helped me to understand just where I have to improve. I used to do very little strength training before last year. I was mostly just doing mat practice. I've added a lot more strength training to my routine now. If I give myself about 70 out of 100 when it comes to my technique, I think I will give myself about 50 out of 100 when it comes to my strength. 'I went to train in Japan and Russia, and both of those gave me the opportunity to polish my technique,' he says. Double World goal While he had hoped to push his case further at the Asian Championships at the start of the year, an unlucky injury to his right ankle in his second bout forced him to forfeit the remainder of the tournament. The injury, diagnosed as a ligament tear, took nearly two months to heal. The Budapest Ranking Series marked his comeback. It was just one tournament, but the nature of his dominance suggests the injury is firmly behind him. It's also a timely boost as Sujeet gears up for the rest of the season. 'My goal for this season is to medal at both the Senior and U-23 World Championships (in September and October of this year). I know I have the capability of doing both,' he says. There's a long-term goal too. Although he doesn't specify the details, the Los Angeles 2028 poster in his room in Sonipat hints at it. Having fallen short of making it to Paris 2024, he's determined not to miss out again. 'By the next Olympics I want to be confident that I am as ready and well prepared as I can be,' he says. Related Topics Sujeet Kalkal /
News18
18 minutes ago
- News18
Ollie Pope's Vice-Captaincy In Threat, Pressure Mounting To Promote 26-Year-Old
Last Updated: Michael Vaughan wants Harry Brook to replace Ben Stokes as England captain instead of vice-captain Ollie Pope, citing Brook's leadership and secure team position. Former England captain Michael Vaughan has advocated for Harry Brook to be considered the rightful successor to Ben Stokes, rather than the current vice-captain Ollie Pope. Brook, an unconventional batter, revived England's hopes in the ongoing Test by scoring an aggressive 111 off 98 balls, leaving his team just 35 runs away from victory with four wickets remaining on the final day. Vaughan, who won 26 out of 51 Tests as captain, believes that while Ollie Pope is an excellent deputy, Brook is the ideal candidate to lead England when Stokes decides to step down. 'Harry Brook, to me, looks a leader. He looks a born leader," Vaughan stated on the Test Match Special podcast. 'If Ben Stokes is injured in the future, can't Pope remain as vice-captain while Harry Brook assumes the leadership role?" Yorkshire's Brook was named England's white-ball captain earlier this year and secured his first series win against a subpar West Indies team. Vaughan explained his preference for Brook over Pope. He cited his own experience as England captain. 'Marcus Trescothick was a magnificent vice-captain for me, but you wouldn't want to give him the captaincy." Pope, 27, is leading England in a Test for the fifth time, having previously stepped in when Stokes was sidelined with a hamstring injury last year. 'I'm not well-acquainted with the dressing room dynamics, but I want the best leader for the England side. A good vice-captain isn't necessarily a good captain," Vaughan emphasized. On Monday, David Lloyd also supported Vaughan's view. 'Michael Vaughan said he would prefer Harry Brook as vice-captain, and I agree," Lloyd wrote. 'Brook is assured of his place in the team and shows leadership qualities. He would naturally thrive under Stokes. The simple fact is that Ollie Pope's spot in the team is vulnerable. Excluding his runs against Ireland and Zimbabwe, his performance is modest. His average in the fourth innings of a Test is 16.7, which is not sufficient for a number three." (With PTI Inputs) view comments First Published: Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
