logo
Boston trial over Trump's push to deport campus activists concludes

Boston trial over Trump's push to deport campus activists concludes

It is a major First Amendment case with implications across higher education and beyond. It took place one courtroom over from another involving the administration and its federal research funding cuts aimed at Harvard, a case where lawyers also raised key First Amendment issues.
The administration has argued that it can deport visa and green card holders under the Immigration and Nationality Act, which has a provision granting the secretary of state the authority to remove people from the country if they undermine its foreign policy interests.
But the trial in American Association of University Professors v. Rubio, which began on July 7, raised questions about whether the administration was violating the First Amendment by retaliating against people for their political speech.
The lawsuit - filed March 25 on behalf of the association's campus chapters at Harvard, New York and Rutgers universities, along with the Middle East Studies Association - accused the administration of fostering a "climate of repression and fear on university campuses."
The trial came amid the backdrop of a high-profile case involving Mahmoud Khalil, a Columbia University graduate and pro-Palestinian activist. Last month, a federal judge in New Jersey ordered Khalil released from Immigration and Customs Enforcement custody.
That judge had previously ruled that the government's actions were chilling Khalil's right to free speech. The Trump administration has said the basis for its March 8 detention was Khalil's supposed alignment with Hamas, a designated terrorist group.
Trump administration 'systematically violating the First Amendment,' lawyers say
Here in Boston, closing arguments took place before U.S. District Judge William Young, a Harvard Law School graduate.
Knight First Amendment Institute at Columbia University, along with co-counsel Sher Tremonte LLP, represented the association of professors in the case, and Young first asked them what evidence they had to support the notion that an "ideological deportation" policy exists.
Alexandra Conlon, a Sher Tremonte lawyer representing the plaintiffs, said that was proven by the administration revoking visas and green cards based on noncitizens' pro-Palestinian activism. In doing so, she said, the federal government was "systematically violating the First Amendment" and seeking to chill speech it disagrees with.
She said the administration conflates antisemitism with pro-Palestine, anti-Israel or anti-war viewpoints.
Ramya Krishnan, an attorney at the Knight First Amendment Institute , went on to argue that legal precedent affirms noncitizens' right to First Amendment protections. Further, she said, lawyers representing the administration hadn't proven that its actions against noncitizen activists were necessary for national security.
Noncitizens don't have the same First Amendment rights, administration argues
Justice Department attorney Ethan Kanter, representing the Trump administration, argued noncitizens do not have First Amendment rights to the same extent as U.S. citizens. While they may have such rights in some capacity, he said, they are "context dependent and in relation to the compelling government interest at play."
He cited a 6th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals decision in 2024 that allowed the state of Ohio to ban foreign nationals from contributing to political campaigns while litigation continued. The court said the state was likely to succeed on the merits of the case, saying the state's law was narrowly tailored to serve the government's compelling interest in preventing foreign influence on elections.
William Kanellis, another attorney representing the administration, at one point referenced the novel "Don Quixote." He cited a particular story in which Quixote mistakes windmills for giants and tries to fight them, leading to him falling off his horse.
The plaintiffs had similarly "been knocked off their horse" in the trial, he said, adding that the notion of an "ideological deportation policy" was, like Don Quixote's vision, based on the plaintiffs' "imagination and creative conjuring."
If such a broad policy existed, he said, "you'd see many more arrests."
In their complaint, the plaintiffs requested that Young, among other actions, recognize the existence of an "ideological deportation policy" and deem it, along with "threats to arrest, detain and deport noncitizen students and faculty," to be unconstitutional. They asked for the policy to be set aside and for Young to bar the administration from making such threats moving forward.
Closing arguments lasted about 90 minutes. Young said he appreciated the "vigorous advocacy" and "high level of civility" shown by the legal counsel and witnesses throughout the trial. He said he now has the responsibility to consider all arguments and deliver a "fair and just" ruling.
Young previously blocked the administration's termination of National Institutes of Health grants that cut funding for research related to minority communities. In that case, he'd said that the funding cut "represents racial discrimination," the New York Times reported.
BrieAnna Frank is a First Amendment Reporting Fellow at USA TODAY. Reach her at bjfrank@usatoday.com.
USA TODAY's coverage of First Amendment issues is funded through a collaboration between the Freedom Forum and Journalism Funding Partners. Funders do not provide editorial input.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Security operation under way on first full day of Trump's visit to Scotland
Security operation under way on first full day of Trump's visit to Scotland

South Wales Argus

time23 minutes ago

  • South Wales Argus

Security operation under way on first full day of Trump's visit to Scotland

The President is expected to take to the greens on the golf course at the Trump Turnberry resort, which he bought back in 2014. Ahead of that, a large number of police and military personnel have been spotted searching the grounds at the venue in South Ayrshire. Various road closures have been put in place, with limited access for both locals and members of the media. Mr Trump is staying at Turnberry for the start of a five-day private visit to Scotland which will see him have talks with both UK Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and Scottish First Minister John Swinney. A meeting has also been scheduled for him to talk about trade with European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen on Sunday. With no talks apparently scheduled for Saturday, the President – a well-known golf enthusiast – appears to be free to play the famous Turnberry course. A major security operation is under way for US President Donald Trump's five-day private visit to Scotland (Robert Perry/PA) However, protests have been planned, with opponents of Mr Trump expected to gather in both Edinburgh and Aberdeen later on Saturday, with the Stop Trump coalition planning what it has described as being a 'festival of resistance'. As well as visiting Trump Turnberry, Mr Trump will head to Aberdeenshire later in his visit and is expected to open a second course at his golf resort in Balmedie. As he landed in Ayrshire on Friday, the President took questions from journalists, telling Europe to 'get your act together' on immigration, which he said was 'killing' the continent. US President Donald Trump's motorcade on the A77 in Maybole, South Ayrshire (Robert Perry/PA) He also praised Sir Keir, who he described as a 'good man', but added that the UK Prime Minister is 'slightly more liberal than I am'. Saturday will be the first real test of Police Scotland during the visit as it looks to control the demonstrations in Aberdeen and Edinburgh, as well as any which spring up near to the president's course. The force has asked for support from others around the UK to bolster officer numbers, with both organisations representing senior officers and the rank-and-file claiming there is likely to be an impact on policing across the country for the duration of the visit. Before the visit started, Mr Swinney appealed to Scots to protest 'peacefully and within the law'.

At least 25 people killed by Israeli gunshots and strikes in Gaza, some while seeking aid
At least 25 people killed by Israeli gunshots and strikes in Gaza, some while seeking aid

The Independent

time23 minutes ago

  • The Independent

At least 25 people killed by Israeli gunshots and strikes in Gaza, some while seeking aid

At least 25 people were killed by Israeli airstrikes and gunshots overnight, according to health officials and the ambulance service on Saturday, as ceasefire talks appear to have stalled and Palestinians in Gaza face famine. The majority of victims were killed by gunfire as they waited for aid trucks close to the Zikim crossing with Israel, said staff at Shifa hospital, where the bodies were brought. Israel's army didn't respond to request for comments about the latest shootings. Those killed in strikes include four people in an apartment building in Gaza City among others, hospital staff and the ambulance service said. The strikes come as ceasefire talks between Israel and Hamas have hit a standstill after the U.S and Israel recalled their negotiating teams on Thursday, throwing the future of the talks into further uncertainty. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said Friday his government was considering 'alternative options' to ceasefire talks with Hamas. His comments came as a Hamas official said negotiations were expected to resume next week and portrayed the recall of the Israeli and American delegations as a pressure tactic. Egypt and Qatar, which are mediating the talks alongside the United States, said the pause was only temporary and that talks would resume, though they did not say when. For desperate Palestinians a ceasefire can't come soon enough. The United Nations and experts say that Palestinians in Gaza are at risk of famine, with reports of increasing numbers of people dying from causes related to malnutrition. While Israel's army says it's allowing aid into the enclave with no limit on the number of trucks that can enter, the U.N. says it is hampered by Israeli military restrictions on its movements and incidents of criminal looting. The Zikim crossing shootings come days after at least 79 Palestinians were killed trying to reach aid entering through the same crossing. Israel's military said at the time its soldiers shot at a gathering of thousands of Palestinians who posed a threat, and that it was aware of some casualties. Israel is facing increased international pressure to alleviate the catastrophic humanitarian crisis in Gaza. More then two dozen Western-aligned countries and more than 100 charity and human rights groups have called for an end to the war, harshly criticizing Israel's blockade and a new aid delivery model it has rolled out. The charities and rights groups said even their own staff were struggling to get enough food For the first time in months Israel said it is allowing airdrops, requested by Jordan. A Jordanian official said the airdrops will mainly be food and milk formula. British Prime Minister Keir Starmer wrote in a newspaper article on Saturday that the U.K. was 'working urgently' with Jordan to get British aid into Gaza. Aid group the World Central Kitchen said on Friday that it was resuming limited cooking operations in Deir al-Balah after being forced to halt due to a lack of food supplies. It said it's trying to serve 60,000 meals daily through its field kitchen and partner community kitchens, less than half of what it's cooked over the previous month. ————————

Donald Trump security operation underway as cops and military comb grounds at Turnberry
Donald Trump security operation underway as cops and military comb grounds at Turnberry

Daily Record

time24 minutes ago

  • Daily Record

Donald Trump security operation underway as cops and military comb grounds at Turnberry

Police snipers have also been seen on the roof of the Trump Turnberry hotel while officers have been patrolling the waters near the resort. A large number of police and military personnel have been spotted searching the grounds at the Turnberry golf resort where Donald Trump is staying. ‌ The US President drew crowds to Prestwick Airport as Air Force One touched down on Friday evening ahead of a four-day visit that will also take him to the club his family owns in Aberdeenshire. ‌ Trump - a well-known golf enthusiast - appears to be free to play the vaunted Turnberry course on Saturday with a meeting scheduled with European Commission president Ursula von der Leyen on Sunday and Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer understood to be making the trip north on Monday. ‌ A high-profile security operation is in full swing, with police and others searching the area. Police snipers have also been seen on the roof of the Trump Turnberry hotel while officers have been patrolling the waters near the resort. ‌ Road closures are also in place, with limited access for locals and members of the media. Amid the search, a few golfers were also spotted at the course, enjoying an early-morning game, as the President prepares to play at the course. ‌ A number of protests have also been planned on Saturday after the Stop Trump Coalition announced demonstrations in Edinburgh - near the American consulate in the Scottish capital - and another in Aberdeen city centre. Meanwhile, a small group of protestors gathered outside the Turnberry golf resort on Friday night as the US President arrived in Scotland. Around five or six demonstrators lined the roadside near the entrance to the luxury resort, holding placards and shouting as Trump's convoy - including his armoured car known as The Beast - passed by. ‌ As he landed in Ayrshire on Friday evening, the president took questions from journalists, telling Europe to "get your act together" on immigration, which he said was "killing" the continent. He also praised Keir Starmer, who he described as a "good man", who is "slightly more liberal than I am". ‌ Saturday will be the first real test of Police Scotland during the visit as it looks to control the demonstrations in Aberdeen and Edinburgh, as well as any which spring up near to the president's course. The force has asked for support from others around the UK to bolster officer numbers, with both organisations representing senior officers and the rank-and-file claiming there is likely to be an impact on policing across the country for the duration of the visit. First Minister John Swinney - who is also set to meet with the president during his time in Scotland - has urged Scots to protest "peacefully and within the law".

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store