With fear and courage, Hungarians are refusing to let their government beat them down
IN THE BOOKSHOPS of Budapest, books that were easily available only a few years ago can no longer be openly found on the shelves.
In police stations, authorities are preparing to use facial recognition software to identify and imprison organisers of the annual Pride parade.
And in the homes of the city's LGBTQ+ community and their loved ones, people are anxiously watching as their government chips away at hard-fought-for human rights and democracy.
Across the border – west to Romania, or north to Slovakia – more European Union citizens wonder if their country will be the next to ban Pride.
Budapest Pride is marking its 30th anniversary this year. Organised Pride events started out small – a film festival; picnics on a mountain outside of the city – at a time when Hungary was only a few years out of the Soviet Union and most LGBTQ+ people weren't safe to let their identity be publicly known. The first march was in 1997, and the marches have continued each year since then (aside from 2020 on account of the pandemic).
But this year, the Hungarian government wants to imprison its organisers.
The Hungarian parliament buildings along the River Danube
Lauren Boland / The Journal
Lauren Boland / The Journal / The Journal
Prime Minister Viktor Orbán has led the country for almost as long as Pride has existed there, serving from 1998 to 2002 and again from 2010 up to the present day. During that time, his party, Fidesz – which once occupied the same political grouping in the EU as Fine Gael – has moved further and further to the right.
In 2021, the parliament passed legislation to restrict the visibility of LGBTQ+ content, embedding into law that only over-18s should be allowed to engage with information and media that pertains in some way to LGBTQ+ people.
The law has had numerous ramifications. For one, it's meant that bookshops have had to take children's books with LGBTQ+ characters off the shelves or wrap them up in plastic. One of the country's bookshop chains, Líra Könyv, was
fined $34,000 in 2023
for failing to wrap up 'Heartstopper', a popular book-turned-Netflix hit featuring a relationship between two teenage boys.
A legal opinion for the EU Court of Justice said that by enacting the law,
Hungary has violated the EU Charter of Fundamental Rights
by interfering with rights to human dignity, to freedom of expression, and to protection from discrimination. The country has 'significantly deviated from the model of a constitutional democracy'.
On top of the anti-LGBTQ+ law, Hungary passed legislation this year curtailing freedom of assembly and introduced sweeping new powers to prosecute participants and organisers of protests.
The government layered those laws to justify a ban on the Pride parade that's scheduled to take place in Budapest today. Budapest's mayor, a left-wing politician, said he could get around the restrictions by taking over the event to host it on a municipal level. Nonetheless, police intend to enforce the ban, and it's expected that attendees identified as taking part could be fined up to €500, and organisers could face imprisonment of up to a year.
It is a distressing time to be a member of the LGBTQ+ community in Hungary. But the government's mounting attacks, while repressive, have also emboldened many people to stand up for their rights and refuse to be pushed to the sidelines of society.
A community centre in Budapest
Lauren Boland / The Journal
Lauren Boland / The Journal / The Journal
Maja has been an event organiser at a community centre in Budapest for the last two years. The centre collaborates with several human rights campaigns and hosts music gigs, workshops, exhibitions, film nights and more. When
The Journal
visited, there were plenty of locals enjoying a warm summer's evening in the garden, and a poster-painting session inside to create banners for the Pride march.
Advertisement
The centre is due to have a tent at the end point of the Pride parade in what's known as the 'civil village'; a kind of fair where various groups and organisations set up stalls.
'Last year we had little bingo cards in the tent – the goal was to get people to talk to each other and to build community. We also had an exhibition about how it's important that Pride has to be about solidarity, and how it's more than just big corporations going out with the rainbow,' she said, referring to businesses that support Pride when it suits them but shy away when it doesn't.
'This was a big topic this year in Hungary. When they first talked about banning Pride, a lot of big corporations stayed very, very quiet. There were big corporations who went out to march when it was more accepted or 'trendy', but they are now really quiet and not trying to help the community.'
Poster-making for Pride at the community centre
Lauren Boland / The Journal
Lauren Boland / The Journal / The Journal
One of the biggest differences this year compared to others is the level of preparation that's gone in to organising and participating.
'This year we have to do a lot more preparation about what can you do in advance, what can you do there, what can you do after if they fine you for being there,' Maja said.
'There are different groups or blocks that march in the Pride, including a group that's in solidarity with Palestine, and that's also something that here that's banned – just marching with the Palestine flag.
'There's a lot of preparation for how to show what's important to you, how to show what you believe in, and how to march for your rights and your community and not a fine or get taken away by cops.'
Maja expects that people who may not ordinarily attend Pride will turn out this year to support the community.
'My impression is that not just people who already belong to the community will march this year, but also a lot of others. Liberals who normally don't go to Pride because it's not that personal for them, but now, in this kind of political climate, there's a lot more people who will go.'
Simon is from the UK and has lived in Budapest since 2016, where he worked for three years before retiring.
He's always gone to the annual Pride parades but he thinks this one is going to be 'by far' the most important, and that it could be a tipping point for change. He has friends from other countries in Europe who are coming to the Budapest march to show solidarity, and expects, like Maja, that it's going to have a larger attendance than usual because of the volume of additional support.
He said that while Pride in some other countries has become mostly a celebration, in Hungary, it's still fundamentally a protest because of the discrimination that the community faces.
Simon said he's aware of the possibility that taking part could be dangerous and is a little concerned about the facial recognition software. He 'probably won't dress wildly flamboyant' the way he has at other Prides, but at the same time, he's 'not going to hide'.
Simon said Pride in Budapest is still fundamentally a protest
Lauren Boland / The Journal
Lauren Boland / The Journal / The Journal
Even as the government tries to marginalise Hungary's LGBTQ+ community, in Budapest, there are a number of local spots and events that pop up that bring people together.
There's a popular restaurant and bar along the Danube where you can have a spot of brunch while watching a Drag Queen perform, or go along of an evening for a weekly Drag Queen-hosted bingo.
Inside the restaurant one evening this week, a women from South America who moved to Hungary several years ago told
The Journal
that she's attended Pride each year since she arrived in Budapest but that she won't be going this year.
Related Reads
Irish politicians to attend Budapest Pride as Hungary threatens participants with fines
Budapest mayor threatened with imprisonment as he defies police to host Pride parade
It's too dangerous, she said, for people like her and her friends who could risk losing immigrant work visas.
At a conference on Thursday organised by Budapest Pride, speakers warned that what's happening in Hungary is a warning bell for human rights and democracy around Europe.
Asked to give a worst-case scenario forecast of where Europe could be in ten years, former Taoiseach Leo Varadkar said a repeat of the 1930s is not beyond the realm of possibility – though he strongly hopes it won't come to that.
German MEP Terry Reintke, the co-chair of the Greens/EFA political grouping, said during a panel discussion that 'the far-right is growing stronger'.
'They have a very aggressive agenda, and for me, this is about trying to keep the far-right in check – and that depends on how other democratic forces are going to react to this.'
András Léderer of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee, a Budapest-based human rights monitor, said the Hungarian government's aim is to 'discourage individual citizens to dare to behave as individual citizens, to have an opinion, to go and meet with like-minded people and discuss those issues'.
'The political calculation in Hungary was that it can isolate and alienate people who dare to behave as citizens.'
András Léderer of the Hungarian Helsinki Committee speaking at the Budapest Pride conference
Lauren Boland / The Journal
Lauren Boland / The Journal / The Journal
Later that day,
The Journal
visited a Pride event being held by a small film club. It convened in an apartment-turned-community library nestled inside a winding maze of a shared building, with books lining the walls almost from floor to ceiling.
Around sixteen film enthusiasts gathered to watch the items on the night's agenda. The theme was centred around marking two significant advancements internationally for LGBTQ+ rights a decade ago in 2015. One was the US Supreme Court's ruling to allow same-sex marriage; the other was Ireland making that same choice by referendum.
In Hungary, same-sex marriage is prohibited by the country's constitution, which was enacted by Orbán's government in 2012.
A film club in Budapest watched two campaign videos from the Yes side of Ireland's marriage equality referendum
Lauren Boland / The Journal
Lauren Boland / The Journal / The Journal
The organisers gave a short presentation about Ireland, the marriage referendum, and this year's Dublin Pride. With Hungarian subtitles on the screen, they played two of the campaign videos that were shared in the lead-up to the vote by the Yes side.
The first was the 'Can I have Sinead's hand?' ad where a man asks everyone he meets for permission to marry his girlfriend, the message being that no-one should have to ask tens of thousands of others for sign-off to marry whom they choose.
The second was probably the most prominent ad that came out of the Yes campaign – the one where young adults ask their family members to come with them to vote. 'Mam, it's time.' 'Granny, do you need a lift to the polling station?' You know the one.
In a dark library, in a city struggling to stand up for itself, it made for emotional viewing – a reminder of how tirelessly the LGBTQ+ community in Ireland had to fight for equal rights; of how little time, really, has passed since then; of how many people in the world are still fighting that battle, like the Hungarians who were there watching, waiting, wondering when it might be their turn to celebrate equality too.
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
32 minutes ago
- The Journal
Life in Palestine: 'I'd rather they break my arms and legs than take me into detention'
PEOPLE WHO LIVE under military occupation in the West Bank would rather be hospitalised than taken to an Israeli detention centre, Palestinian human rights activist Nasser Nawaj'ah has told The Journal . Nawaj'ah comes from the village of Susiya in the West Bank and has been working with the Israeli human rights NGO B'Tselem for over 16 years. He and his colleague Sarit Michaeli, B'Tselem's head of funding and international advocacy, sat down with The Journal during a visit to Dublin to discuss what happens to people in Israeli detention, and what it's like in the communities where arbitrary arrest is a constant threat. 'Today in the Palestinian community, you hear many people saying that if the army comes into my house in the middle of the night and knocks down the door, I would rather they break my arms and legs and beat me up than take me into detention, because I'd rather go into hospital for a few months rather than going into Israeli detention,' says Nawaj'ah. The conditions in Israeli prisons, Nawaj'ah explains, have been made harsher recently as a way of exacting revenge for the Hamas-led attack against Israel on 7 October 2023. But even before then, basic services in detention were already being deliberately degraded by Itamar Ben-Gvir, Israel's National Security Minister and the leader of the Jewish Power party. 'Prisoners should be shot in the head instead of being given more food,' Ben-Gvir said in response to complaints of overcrowding in Israeli jails in November 2024. A map of Israel and Palestine based on the 1967 borderssSource: Alamy Stock Photo 'Revenge arrests' and 'torture camps' The Hamas attack had reverberations beyond the besieged enclave of Gaza from which it was launched. That attack left almost 1,200 people dead and 251 people were taken hostage. Israel continues to wage war on the population of Gaza, where more than 55,000 Palestinians have been killed, but it has also ramped up assaults on West Bank communities through military raids and settler violence. 'After 7 October, Israeli forces started engaging in revenge arrests and this is ongoing,' Nawaj'ah says. Palestinians, including children, are routinely detained by Israeli occupation forces in the West Bank for minor infractions, such as throwing stones, and sometimes for doing nothing at all. 'If soldiers discover any sort of 'incriminating' photo on a Palestinian phone, like, for example, some sort of documentation of events in Gaza, then they'll immediately use it as an excuse, a pretext, to detain them and in some cases to attack and assault them. 'But I hear again and again from people who are glad that they were only beaten up and not arrested.' Nawaj'ah himself decided not to stay in his home for three months following the October 2023 attack, 'because I was worried about revenge arrests by the army'. One example of the systemic mistreatment of Palestinians in detention is the fact that people might only be fed 'three tablespoons of rice a day', just enough to keep them alive, 'but they would be suffering constantly', Nawaj'ah says. In April, a Palestinian teenager died in Israeli detention. An Israeli doctor who observed his autopsy said the likely cause of death was starvation. Palestinians released earlier this year also showed signs of torture and starvation , as well as suffering from scabies. In July last year, Said Maarouf, a 57-year-old pediatrician taken by Israeli forces in Gaza City in December 2023 told Amnesty International that guards kept him blindfolded and handcuffed for the entirety of his 45 days in detention. He described being starved, repeatedly beaten, and forced to sit on his knees for long periods. 'I think it's really important to remember that over half, or approximately half, of the Palestinians that are currently in Israeli detention have been detained without trial,' explains Sarit Michaeli. CNN / YouTube Palestinians taken from the West Bank without charge or trial are termed 'administrative detainees'. If they come from Gaza, they are detained under Israel's Unlawful Combatants law. In both cases, people are not informed of the charges against them and are held incommunicado, without access to a lawyer or the chance to speak to their families. 'It's mind bogglingly shocking,' she says, adding that it's not just about the lack of due process, 'it's the fact that they're subjected to a hellish torture system.' The Israeli prison system functions like a network of torture camps. The Israeli detention facilities have been shown in multiple investigations to be the scenes of abuse, torture and sexual assault. Prisoners or hostages? Since the October 2023 attack, media outlets and governments have come under scrutiny for the terms used to describe the people held captive in Gaza and the Palestinians held captive in Israel. Israeli forces have been rounding up people in Gaza and transferring them to detention centres since they invaded the territory. While those taken captive by Hamas during the October 2023 attack are clearly hostages under international law, the same designation can be given to many Palestinians in Israeli detention. Advertisement The International Convention against the Taking of Hostages defines the offence as the seizure or detention of a person, combined with a threat to kill, injure or to continue to detain that person, in order to compel a third party to do – or to abstain from doing – something as an explicit or implicit condition for the hostage's release. As of March 2025, Israel was holding captive 3,405 administrative and 1,555 Palestinians as 'unlawful combatants', all without trial, according to the Israeli human rights NGO Hamoked . Legal experts, including the UN Special Rapporteur for the Occupied Palestinian Territories Francesca Albanese, have previously told The Journal that Palestinians arrested and held without trial can be seen as hostages , especially those taken since October 2023. This is because they were abducted without cause and held without trial in the expectation that they might be exchanged for people in Hamas captivity. Michaeli tends to agree. 'We're talking about thousands of people who, over the last 20 months, have been detained either because they are political activists or because the Israeli authorities suspect them of doing something that they are not willing to put (forward) any evidence to prove. 'Or in some cases, and they're not a few cases, there's a very large number of them, by virtue of being in Gaza at a certain moment and basically being rounded up and taken.' Footage emerged early on in the conflict of Israeli soldiers corralling men stripped to their underwear, blindfolded and sitting cross-legged on the ground in Gaza. 'That is shocking,' she says. Micheali mentions a recent illustrative example, the final round of captive exchanges during the last ceasefire in Gaza in March this year, when Israel released a number of women and children. 'Essentially, there was a clear admission by the Israeli authorities that these people had been kept in detention as bargaining chips, in order to then be able to have this cadre of people to release for Israeli hostages.' In Arabic, Palestinians use the term prisoners for the people in Hamas captivity and those held in Israeli detention, according to Nawaj'ah and Michaeli. In Israel, the majority of people call Palestinian detainees 'terrorists', regardless of whether or not they have committed, or even been charged with, a crime, Michaeli says. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo At the same time, Michaeil stresses, Hamas has also mistreated hostages. She herself is involved in campaigning with some families to get their loved ones – or at least their bodies – released. Israelis who were taken hostage have described being tortured and sexually assaulted while in Hamas captivity. Others described being held in appalling conditions and suffering starvation , as well as being used in Hamas propaganda videos. Taking and holding hostages, she notes, is a war crime. 'It's immoral, it's shocking'. 'The conditions that Israeli hostages have had to deal with are absolutely horrific.' Still, she does believe that 'there is a real gap and a sort of double standard in the way the international community is treating the concept'. Hamas fighters escort Israeli hostage Or Levy on a stage before handing him over to a Red Cross team in Deir el-Balah Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo 'I'm not saying it's an identical situation,' she says while pointing to Hamas parading hostages as one example of a difference. Expressing frustration at her government's apparent lack of sincerity when it comes to prioritising the return of the hostages, Michaeli says the Israeli violation of the last ceasefire gave people reason to see the government's stated war aim as 'disingenuous'. 'All of this leads one to the unfortunate conclusion that the Israeli government is currently not interested in releasing the remaining hostages.' Obviously, she says, responsibility for capturing them lies with Hamas, but 'one has to admit that the current impediment to their release is the Israeli government. And that is a shocking admission'. 'It's recognised, and I think it's very blatant, that the 'price' of a full hostage deal is ending our war on Gaza, and this means if we (Israel) end our war on Gaza, we can't reoccupy it and resettle it.' Need more information on what is happening in Israel and Palestine? Check out our FactCheck Knowledge Bank for essential reads and guides to navigating the news online. Visit Knowledge Bank Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Independent
5 hours ago
- Irish Independent
The Sunday Independent's View: Ireland can take Pride in progress on gay rights
The idea that the international community is waiting on the lead of a small island in the north Atlantic is easy to mock. Ireland was certainly unable to find many allies when leaders met in Brussels last Thursday to discuss the fate of EU-Israel economic ties in light of the Gaza war. The watered-down statement that eventually emerged deplored the 'catastrophic humanitarian situation' and called again for a ceasefire. But with hundreds of Palestinians now being killed as they seek aid, Taoiseach Micheál Martin lamented that more was not being done to put pressure on Benjamin Netanyahu's government. There is, however, one issue on which Ireland has undoubtedly led the way. When he took his place on O'Connell Street at the head of yesterday's Dublin Pride march, Micheál Martin did so as the leader of the first country in the world to legalise same-sex marriage by popular vote. The 2015 referendum was carried by 62pc of voters. Ten years on, the likelihood is that the Yes vote would be even more emphatic. Ireland is a far more progressive place to live than it has ever been Irish society in past decades was always more complex and diverse than the caricature of an oppressed Catholic theocracy that persists in popular myth. What is beyond question is that the country today, while by no means perfect, is a far more open and progressive place in which to live than it has ever been. Dublin's first Pride march in 1983 took place when homosexuality was still illegal. The numbers taking part could be counted in the dozens. Yesterday saw more than 12,000 participants and up to 100,000 people line the streets to show support. Other events were held around the country, including for the first time in Kilkenny, the last county to join the party. There is no downside to these changes. Whatever else is wrong with Ireland in 2025, a tolerance of who others chose to love is not one of them. ADVERTISEMENT These advances must not be taken for granted. In his message to Dublin Pride, President Michael D Higgins paid tribute to all who 'paved the way for progress when marching was not safe, who gave voice to truths that were long silenced and who set the foundations for the inclusive Ireland that we continue to strive towards today'. He urged parade-goers to remember them 'with gratitude'. There was a grim reminder this year that many countries have still not won such freedoms. The right-wing populist government led by Viktor Orban in Hungary, a fellow member of the European Union for more than two decades, passed legislation this year banning yesterday's Budapest Pride march and has even threatened to jail organisers and use facial recognition software to identify and fine marchers. That the right to peaceful assembly is under threat again in the heart of the EU is profoundly shocking. Pride marches are a threat to no one. Irish politicians can take justifiable pride, pun intended, in the part they played in moving this country beyond such ugly battles. If only they could put the same collective energy into solving more intractable challenges to inequality — such as housing, our crumbling infrastructure and health — there would be even more to celebrate.
The Journal
14 hours ago
- The Journal
Dublin awash with colour as thousands take part in Pride parade
THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE have taken to the streets of Dublin to mark this year's Pride parade. Organisers said there were more than 12,000 people marching in the annual parade. This year's event also celebrated a milestone 10 years of marriage equality. The capital's streets were filled with an array of colour, music and dance as the parade made its way to Merrion Square's Pride Village for speeches and entertainment. Among those taking part was Taoiseach Micheál Martin, Tánaiste Simon Harris, Labour leader Ivana Bacik, People Before Profit TD Paul Murphy and Minister for Public Expenditure Jack Chambers. Citing the previous work of the Government to address gay rights and equality, Martin told the crowd at Merrion Square that he is aware 'our work is far from done'. Martin was forced to raise his voice as a small number of protesters shouted for better trans rights and health care access during his speech. Taoiseach and Fianna Fáil leader Micheál Martin with Lord Mayor Emma Blain at the Pride parade in Dublin City centre today. Justin Farrelly / © Justin Farrelly / © / © The Fianna Fáil leader said: 'LGBTIQ+ people in Ireland today still face a myriad of challenges, and the Government is committed to bolstering our efforts to address these challenges and delivering for our LGBTIQ+ citizens. 'There are global trends of increased harassment and persecution of LGBTIQ+ people across the world, which make many of our LGBTIQ+ citizens feel deeply concerned and unsafe. 'This is not the vision for Ireland that we are striving to build.' Martin continued: 'Our goal is to build a society in which LGBTIQ+ people can live safe, inclusive, healthy and fulfilling lives in an accepting and compassionate Ireland. 'The new LGBTIQ+ Inclusion Strategy will promote and respect the right of LGBTIQ+ people to live their lives safely, free of harassment and violence. 'It will advance health and wellbeing outcomes through improved investment and access to a range of health services. 'It will build on initiatives already undertaken within the business community and by employers so that LGBTIQ+ people are enabled to participate fully within the workplace. 'This new strategy will seek to deliver a fairer and more inclusive Ireland, and Government departments and state agencies are determined to work together to that end.' The grand marshal of Dublin Pride, Ruadhán Ó Criodáin, who has long advocated for LGBT+ rights, told the crowd in Merrion Square: 'We all want better futures for the next generation of queer people, but without education or health care, trans people can't see those futures for ourselves. 'I know you won't let our community die for the want of a future. I know that each of you will stand with trans people, I know that you will stand up and fight back. 'I know that you won't give in to the transphobe you've seen take hold in the UK, because we are stronger than that. 'The far right and the TERF (Trans-Exclusionary Radical Feminism) movement want to divide the LGBT community.' 'They want to isolate your trans siblings, because then it'll be easier to tear us all apart. Advertisement 'If they come for us first, they will come for all of you next. But I won't let that happen to my community, and I know you'll promise me the same. 'There is no LGBT without the T.' Dublin Mayor Emma Blaine said: 'Today, we march through the heart of our capital, a city that celebrates diversity, embraces inclusion and champions equality. 'Pride is more than a parade. It's a powerful statement of love, of visibility and of resilience. 'It's a celebration of how far we have come and a reminder of the work still ahead. 'Dublin has a proud history of standing up for the rights of its citizens. 'We remember today, the trailblazers, the activists and the everyday people who fought and continue to fight for dignity, respect and justice.' She added: 'To our LGBTQ+ young people, know that you are valued, you are seen, and you belong, this city stands with you. 'To all the allies here today, thank you for walking beside us, not just today, but every day.' Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo The parade started at O'Connell Street at 12.30pm, and travelled along Eden Quay and Custom House Quay before crossing the Talbot Memorial Bridge, up Lombard Street and Westland Row before finishing at Merrion Square. The non-ticketed festival at the Pride Village included music, food stalls, acts and speeches on the main stage. In his last year as president, Michael D Higgins offered his warmest greetings ahead of the Pride parade. He said: 'This annual celebration is a vital affirmation of the rights, dignity, and joy of our LGBT+ communities. 'It is a time, too, to remember with gratitude the courage of those who paved the way for progress when marching was not safe, who gave voice to truths that were long silenced, and who set the foundations for the inclusive Ireland that we continue to strive towards today. 'In recent years, great strides have been made in advancing the rights and recognition of LGBT+ people in Ireland. 'In celebrating Pride this year, we are also marking the 10th anniversary of the Marriage Equality referendum, a moment that spoke of the kind of Ireland we aspire to be: inclusive, generous, an Ireland that is unafraid to affirm the equal worth of all of our citizens. 'Yet, we must also acknowledge that the journey is not complete. 'A truly inclusive society is one where all can live authentically and creatively, regardless of sexual orientation, gender identity, or expression, where all can participate fully, and where all voices are not only heard but valued, in all their richness and diversity. 'Pride remains a vital expression of that vision in challenging us to deepen our commitment to human rights, to solidarity, and to the kind of republic that cherishes all of its people equally. 'In a time when hard-won rights are being questioned in many parts of the world, such vigilance and unity are more vital than ever.' There were road closures in the city centre.
