‘Writing is thinking': Do students who use ChatGPT learn less?
A recent study suggests students who use ChatGPT to write essays engage in less critical thinking.
PARIS - When Professor Jocelyn Leitzinger had her university students write about times in their lives they had witnessed discrimination, she noticed that a woman named Sally was the victim in many of the stories.
'It was very clear that ChatGPT had decided this is a common woman's name,' said Prof Leitzinger, who teaches an undergraduate class on business and society at the University of Illinois in Chicago.
'They weren't even coming up with their own anecdotal stories about their own lives,' she told AFP.
Prof Leitzinger estimated that around half of her 180 students used ChatGPT inappropriately at some point last semester – including when writing about the ethics of artificial intelligence (AI), which she called both 'ironic' and 'mind-boggling'.
So she was not surprised by recent research which suggested that students who use ChatGPT to write essays engage in less critical thinking.
The preprint study, which has not been peer-reviewed, was shared widely online and clearly struck a chord with some frustrated educators.
The team of MIT researchers behind the paper have received more than 3,000 emails from teachers of all stripes since it was published online in June, lead author Nataliya Kosmyna told AFP.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore 3 out of 4 in Singapore cannot identify deepfake content: Cyber Security Agency survey
Singapore GrabCab, Singapore's newest taxi operator, hits the roads with over 40 cabs to be rolled out in July
Life Star Awards 2025: Xiang Yun and Chen Hanwei are the most decorated actors in show's 30-year history
Business Cathay Cineplexes gets demand for $3.4 million in arrears from Jem landlord
Asia Dalai Lama says he will have successor after his death
Sport FAS introduces 'enhancements' to SPL, with increase in prize money and foreign player quota
Singapore 3,800 private candidates in Singapore to take O- and A-level exams in 2025
Singapore Teen admits assaulting cop, fracturing officer's nose
'Soulless' AI essays
For the small study, 54 adult students from the greater Boston area were split into three groups. One group used ChatGPT to write 20-minute essays, one used a search engine, and the final group had to make do with only their brains.
The researchers used EEG devices to measure the brain activity of the students, and two teachers marked the essays.
The ChatGPT users scored significantly worse than the brain-only group on all levels. The EEG showed that different areas of their brains connected to each other less often.
And more than 80 per cent of the ChatGPT group could not quote anything from the essay they had just written, compared to around 10 per cent of the other two groups.
By the third session, the ChatGPT group appeared to be mostly focused on copying and pasting.
The teachers said they could easily spot the 'soulless' ChatGPT essays because they had good grammar and structure but lacked creativity, personality and insight.
However Dr Kosmyna pushed back against media reports claiming the paper showed that using ChatGPT made people lazier or more stupid.
She pointed to the fourth session, when the brain-only group used ChatGPT to write their essay and displayed even higher levels of neural connectivity.
Dr Kosmyna emphasised it was too early to draw conclusions from the study's small sample size but called for more research into how AI tools could be used more carefully to help learning.
Dr Ashley Juavinett, a neuroscientist at the University of California San Diego who was not involved in the research, criticised some 'offbase' headlines that wrongly extrapolated from the preprint.
'This paper does not contain enough evidence nor the methodological rigour to make any claims about the neural impact of using LLMs (large language models such as ChatGPT) on our brains,' she told AFP.
Thinking outside the bot
Prof Leitzinger said the research reflected how she had seen student essays change since ChatGPT was released in 2022, as both spelling errors and authentic insight became less common.
Sometimes students do not even change the font when they copy and paste from ChatGPT, she said.
But Prof Leitzinger called for empathy for students, saying they can get confused when the use of AI is being encouraged by universities in some classes but is banned in others.
The usefulness of new AI tools is sometimes compared to the introduction of calculators, which required educators to change their ways.
But Prof Leitzinger worried that students do not need to know anything about a subject before pasting their essay question into ChatGPT, skipping several important steps in the process of learning.
A student at a British university in his early 20s who wanted to remain anonymous told AFP he found ChatGPT was a useful tool for compiling lecture notes, searching the internet and generating ideas.
'I think that using ChatGPT to write your work for you is not right because it's not what you're supposed to be at university for,' he said.
The problem goes beyond high school and university students.
Academic journals are struggling to cope with a massive influx of AI-generated scientific papers. Book publishing is also not immune, with one startup planning to pump out 8,000 AI-written books a year.
'Writing is thinking, thinking is writing, and when we eliminate that process, what does that mean for thinking?' Prof Leitzinger asked. AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
3 hours ago
- Straits Times
How Apple gave ‘the gift of fire' to Chinese electronics firms
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox A new book explains how Apple's obsession with sleek design and efficiency supercharged China's electronics sector – and why decoupling may be impossible. It was Christmas 1998, and a secret commercial experiment was under way in an Apple facility in Ang Mo Kio. A team of over 20 employees had just flown in. Over the next few months, they would toil six days a week, sometimes up to 15 hours a day, to master a single task: learning how to assemble Apple's brightly coloured iMac, which came with a chunky cathode ray tube monitor imported from LG in South Korea.
Straits Times
3 hours ago
- Straits Times
Micron sees new Singapore plant as key in plan to meet rising demand for AI-enabling chips
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Production at the plant will start in 2026. SINGAPORE – A new US$7 billion (S$8.9 billion) plant being built in Singapore will underpin Micron Technology's plans to produce advanced semiconductors needed for artificial intelligence (AI) applications. The facility, which is adjacent to Micron's existing plant in Woodlands, was announced earlier in 2025 and will initially create 1,400 jobs, with that increasing to around 3,000. Production at the plant will start in 2026, allowing the American chipmaking giant to increase its output of what are known as AI-enabling high-bandwidth memory (HBM) chips, according to Mr Sumit Sadana, its executive vice-president and chief business officer. The chips contain several layers that make a cube able to store and process large amounts of data faster while consuming a lot less power than conventional chips. They enable graphics processing units and other accelerators made by companies such as Nvidia and AMD to process generative AI workloads at data centres. The HBM market is worth about US$35 billion, but Micron expects that it will approach US$100 billion by 2030. 'That's a massive amount of growth in the HBM market, and in order to meet the growth expectations that we have, we have been making plans for HBM capacity expansion,' Mr Sadana told an online briefing on July 2. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Singapore and Cambodia to expand collaboration in renewable energy, carbon markets and agri-trade World Trump announces Vietnam trade deal with 20% import tariff Singapore From camping to mentorship, Singapore Scouts mark 115th anniversary of the youth movement Singapore Ong Beng Seng's court hearing rescheduled one day before he was expected to plead guilty World Sean 'Diddy' Combs convicted on prostitution counts but cleared of more serious charges Singapore Teen, 17, to be charged with allegedly trespassing on MRT tracks Singapore Granddaughter of Hin Leong founder O.K. Lim fails to keep 3 insurance policies from creditors' reach Singapore Man on trial for raping drunken woman after offering to drive her and her friend home Micron is expanding its existing HBM output in Taiwan, but that capacity is likely to be used up quite quickly, so it will need more facilities to meet the expected demand in the coming years. 'We are rapidly going to run out of space in our facility in Taiwan. So, the Singapore facility will be very important to continue our HBM growth,' said Mr Sadana. 'We are super excited about the AI opportunity, and Singapore will certainly have a strong role to play in a lot of the AI-based innovation that we're doing.' Micron has also announced plans to start producing HBM chips in the United States; however, the Singapore plant will be up and running by the time production there kicks off. The firm – the top memory-chip maker in the US – unveiled a 'strategic reorganisation' of its business units in April designed to capitalise on the growth driven by AI, from data centres to devices such as computers and mobile phones. The reorganisation will make the company structure more market-focused rather than product-focused. The new four business units will include a cloud memory business unit focused on large hyperscale cloud customers and HBMs for data centre customers. There will be a separate mobile and client business unit, and one for automotive, industrial and consumer segments. 'This new structure will increase our resources towards data centres and allow us to have the end-to-end capability to serve AI in all segments,' said Mr Sadana. He said Singapore will continue to be the company's main production base of Nand flash memory chips used in solid-state drives, USB drives and mobile phones. Nand constituted 22 per cent of Micron's total revenue of US$9.3 billion in the third quarter of 2025, with turnover from data centres more than doubling year on year to hit a quarterly record. Mr Sadana said revenue from Singapore would keep increasing, especially when HBM output starts, noting: 'That's going to be a very big positive for us to be able to leverage Singapore for HBM sales that are, you know, very high-value sales that are growing rapidly.'
Straits Times
6 hours ago
- Straits Times
Ancient Egyptian man's genome reveals his society's cross-cultural ties
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox DNA obtained from the remains of a man who lived in ancient Egypt around the time the first pyramids were built is providing evidence of the ties between two great cultures of the period, with a fifth of his genetic ancestry traced to Mesopotamia. Although based on a single genome, the findings offer unique insight into the genetic history of ancient Egyptians - a difficult task considering that Egypt's hot climate is not conducive to DNA preservation. The researchers extracted DNA from the roots of two teeth, part of the man's skeletal remains that had been interred for millennia inside a large sealed ceramic vessel within a rock-cut tomb. They then managed to sequence his whole genome, a first for any person who lived in ancient Egypt. The man lived roughly 4,500-4,800 years ago, the researchers said, around the beginning of a period of prosperity and stability called the Old Kingdom, known for the construction of immense pyramids as monumental pharaonic tombs. The ceramic vessel was excavated in 1902 at a site called Nuwayrat near the village of Beni Hassan, approximately 170 miles (270 km) south of Cairo. The researchers said the man was about 60 years old when he died, and that aspects of his skeletal remains hinted at the possibility that he had worked as a potter. The DNA showed that the man descended mostly from local populations, with about 80% of his ancestry traced to Egypt or adjacent parts of North Africa. But about 20% of his ancestry was traced to a region of the ancient Near East called the Fertile Crescent that included Mesopotamia. "This suggests substantial genetic connections between ancient Egypt and the eastern Fertile Crescent," said population geneticist Adeline Morez Jacobs of Liverpool John Moores University in England and the Francis Crick Institute in London, lead author of the study published on Wednesday in the journal Nature. The findings build on the archaeological evidence of trade and cultural exchanges between ancient Egypt and Mesopotamia, a region spanning modern-day Iraq and parts of Iran and Syria. During the third millennium BC, Egypt and Mesopotamia were at the vanguard of human civilization, with achievements in writing, architecture, art, religion and technology. Egypt showed cultural connections with Mesopotamia, based on some shared artistic motifs, architecture and imports like lapis lazuli, the blue semiprecious stone, the researchers said. The pottery wheel from Mesopotamia first appeared in Egypt at about the time the man lived, a period when the earliest pyramids began to spring up near modern-day Cairo, starting with the Step Pyramid of the pharaoh Djoser at Saqqara and later the Great Pyramid of the pharaoh Khufu at Giza. About 90% of the man's skeleton was preserved. He stood about 5-foot-3 (1.59 meters) tall, with a slender build. He also had conditions consistent with older age such as osteoporosis and osteoarthritis, as well as a large unhealed abscess from tooth infection. "Ancient DNA recovery from Egyptian remains has been exceptionally challenging due to Egypt's hot climate that accelerates DNA degradation, with high temperatures breaking down genetic material over time compared to cooler, more stable environments," Francis Crick Institute population geneticist and study co-author Pontus Skoglund said. "In this case, the individual's burial in a ceramic pot vessel within a rock-cut tomb likely contributed to the unusual DNA preservation for the region," Skoglund added. The fact that his burial occurred before mummification became standard practice in Egypt may have helped avoid DNA degradation because his remains were spared elaborate preservation techniques. Scientists have struggled to recover ancient Egyptian genomes, according to paleogeneticist and study co-author Linus Girdland Flink of the University of Aberdeen in Scotland. One previous effort yielded partial genome sequencing of three individuals who lived some 1,500 years after the Nuwayrat man. Given the track record, the researchers were surprised with their success in sequencing the man's genome. "Yeah, it was a long shot," Skoglund said. The man may have worked as a potter or in a trade with similar movements because his bones had muscle markings from sitting for long periods with outstretched limbs. "All indicators are consistent with movements and positions of a potter, as indicated in ancient Egyptian imagery," said bioarcheologist and study co-author Joel Irish. "He would have been of high status to have been buried in a rock-cut tomb. This conflicts with his hard physical life and conjecture that he was a potter, which would ordinarily have been working class. Perhaps he was an excellent potter." REUTERS
