Mashaba ‘played': Where to now for ActionSA after being kicked into the political wilderness in Joburg?
ActionSA leader Herman Mashaba says his party's relationship with the ANC has completely broken down, with those close to the situation believing he was outsmarted.
ActionSA played a significant role in Dada Morero's election as mayor of Johannesburg last year. In turn, the ANC supported the election of ActionSA Speaker of Council, Nobuhle Mthembu.
But the relationship soon soured, leading to ActionSA abstaining from a no-confidence vote on Wednesday in protest against Morero, and the ANC retaliating by voting to boot out Mthembu.
Speaking to The Citizen on Thursday, Mashaba said it is clear that the working relationship between the two parties is 'non-existent', but ActionSA will not pull out of the partnership in Tshwane.
'From day one, the relationship was very difficult, and it was even affecting us in public. We do not want any association at all with Dada Morero's administration,' he said.
He said ActionSA was not consulted on issues such as the State of the City address, the 2025 budget, and the controversial bomb squad that was announced earlier this month.
'We tried to get them to do the right thing, but it was not really working, so we decided that we cannot support this man,' he said.
Mashaba said he had engaged with the leadership of the ANC regarding some of these issues, including concerns about ethical governance in the City of Johannesburg.
Back to the benches
Mashaba said his party will now go back to the opposition benches, where it plans to hold the ANC accountable.
'They thought that they are punishing us by taking the speaker's position, but I can tell you now that we are relieved. No one can hold a gun to our head when Johannesburg is busy collapsing.
'We will operate as an effective opposition with no strings attached,' he said.
What about the speaker?
The City of Johannesburg is currently without a speaker of Council and councillors will now have two weeks to select a new one. That process will be presided over by the current acting city manager, Tshepo Makola.
Earlier this year, Morero said he would reshuffle his mayoral committee to ensure that people with the right skills are in the right positions.
However, The Citizen understands that the smaller parties in the government of local unity (GLU) led by Morero are likely to take the position.
The 'return of Gwamanda'
Another reason some believe Mashaba was outsmarted is due to an alleged meeting he had with Al Jama-ah councillors.
He claimed former mayors Thapelo Amad and Kabelo Gwamanda said they had been sent by the DA to convince ActionSA to vote for the return of Gwamanda as Joburg Mayor.
'On the 6th of June, they came to my office asking for my support to remove Dada and vote for the election of Kabelo Gwamanda. I said to them, 'What nonsense are you talking about?',' he said.
Both Al Jama-ah and the DA have denied this claim.
DA Johannesburg caucus leader Belinda Kayser-Echeozonjoku said the party 'did not make any promises' about the vote.
'Fortunately, we can speak for ourselves. Our motion to remove the speaker was inadmissible, and our caucus' decision to support her removal was tabled on record in council.
'It is unfortunate that the ANC didn't keep their promise to Mashaba that if he [ActionSA] abstains and keeps their mayor, they will abstain and keep the speaker.
'It must be frustrating working with people who can't keep their word.'
This belief that Mashaba had been 'played' was supported by several other sources in the council who spoke to The Citizen.
ALSO READ: Joburg speaker removed in vote of no confidence
Morero 'the right man for the job'
Meanwhile, ANC Gauteng spokesperson Mzi Khumalo said Morero's survival of a motion of no confidence vote on Wednesday was a sign that he was the right person for the job.
'Under the leadership of Dada Morero, the City of Johannesburg is making visible and meaningful inroads to stabilise governance, restore service delivery, and respond to resident concerns,' said Khumalo.
It remains unclear who will become the next speaker of the City of Johannesburg.
NOW READ: Joburg mayor Dada Morero survives motion of no confidence
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
32 minutes ago
- IOL News
ANC orders KwaDukuza mayor to repay taxpayers' money
KwaDukuza mayor Ali Ngidi and his deputy Njabulo Cele have been ordered to pay back municipal funds they splurged on luxury vehicles hire which was not approved by the council. Image: Facebook Opposition parties in the embattled KwaDukuza Local Municipality north of KwaZulu-Natal have welcomed the removal of the mayor and his deputy as well as the instruction to pay back all the taxpayers' money that the pair abused while in office. On Wednesday evening, ANC provincial task team coordinator Mike Mabuyakhulu summoned the party caucus, where he presented the report and the recommendations of the team that the party had appointed in April to investigate the reported abuse of privileges by both the mayor, Ali Ngidi and his deputy Njabulo Cele. Besides removing the pair from their positions, the ANC also ordered them to pay back the money they splurged on luxury vehicles since assuming office in November without council approval. The report that was presented to council in April showed that from November to February the mayor had spent R497,180,10 while his deputy had spent R527,720,13 which meant the municipality was paying R17,590 on the vehicle hire. Furthermore, the ANC ordered Ngidi to pay for fuel use of the mayoral car which was used to transport his family, particularly his children to school. Ngidi will also have to pay for the security firm that guarded his home- this was also not approved by the council. It was reported that the Durban-based security company was billing the municipality R173,000 for eight guards that were stationed at the mayor's house day and night. It is not clear for how long the company had guarded his home. Reacting to the ANC's announcement on Wednesday, the DA's caucus leader Privi Makhan said her party welcomed the decision, describing it as long overdue. 'The DA in KwaDukuza welcomes the long-overdue removal of former Mayor Ali Ngidi, whose time in office was marked by scandal, arrogance, and a blatant disregard for the people he was elected to serve. Over the last eight months, Mayor Ngidi brought the Office of the Mayor into utter disrepute. Under his watch, service delivery collapsed and basic municipal functions deteriorated while he embarked on a relentless pursuit to support events and vanities designed to boost his personal image,' said Makhan Also weighing in, ActionSA councillor Halalisani Ndlovu said his party was vindicated by the ANC decision that the mayor and his deputy must pay back the money they used illegally. He said his party had been calling for the docking of the mayor and his deputy's salaries because the hiring of luxury vehicles was never approved by the council. 'For now we know they have to pay just over a million for care hire costs and we are still waiting for a full report on the security company costs and mayoral car fuel costs that was used by the mayor's family. I think the mayor alone will pay more than a million,' said Ndlovu. ANC spokesperson Fanle Sibisi said the total costs to be paid by the mayor and his deputy will be determined by the council after proper consolidation.
IOL News
43 minutes ago
- IOL News
IRR warns Parliament against expropriating SARB
So extreme is the Bill's threat of expropriation without compensation that even the government and members of the ANC have voiced public opposition to it. The Institute of Race Relations has made written and oral submissions to Parliament in opposition to the South African Reserve Bank (SARB) Amendment Bill. The Bill, tabled by Economic Freedom Fighters leader Julius Malema in 2018, is moving forward to a committee vote on 'desirability'. The IRR warned that it is undesirable, uneconomical, unfunded, unconsidered, and unconstitutional. To start, the Bill expropriates the shareholders of the SARB without compensation, which is a direct violation of constitutionally protected property rights. The shares are worth an estimated R20 million, so no one can seriously claim that the Bill would expropriate these shares without compensation to save the fisc money. Rather, the real purpose of such an exercise is to try to set a precedent that any shares in the country can be expropriated without compensation, including trillions of rands worth of stock and bond securities that depend on SARB's prudent monetary management. So extreme is the Bill's threat of expropriation without compensation that even the government and members of the ANC have voiced public opposition to it. Treasury official Christopher Axelson, representing the government, spoke out at length in opposition to this danger and other dangerous aspects of the Bill before Parliament. Says IRR Fellow Gabriel Crouse: 'The effort to expropriate rural landowners in the hinterland is death to property rights by a thousand cuts. Expropriating SARB shareholders without compensation poses the same threat, only faster, like an atom bomb.' SARB's 802 shareholders make very little money from those shares, with dividends limited to R1,000 per annum, but do get to elect seven of the SARB's 15 directors. This decentralised, minority input provides a public-private engagement mechanism that has helped implement the 'primary object' of the SARB, which is 'to protect the value of the currency', according to the Constitution. SARB is arguably the most successful government institution at hitting its target. Over the last quarter of a century, it has largely succeeded in maintaining inflation within the 3% - 6% target range that was nominated for it by the then-minister of finance back in 2000. Most of South Africa's thousands of other organs of state have, by stark contrast, been riddled with ongoing state capture, often taking them well beyond the point of bankruptcy. Most organisations where the state is the 'sole shareholder' are so badly off that President Cyril Ramaphosa's first, second, and third presidential terms have included repeated calls for 'reform' through 'public-private partnerships' that increase the role of the private sector. So why, in this local environment, would anyone want to make the same overburdened state the 'sole shareholder' of one of the only bastions of excellence, namely SARB? Malema, the Bill's sponsor, leaves no room for mystery about it. Malema openly calls for total nationalisation of the land, banks, and mines, which would be significantly easier if the SARB were captured, and forced to abandon its mandate temporarily by stocking rampant inflation. That sudden loosening of monetary policy would produce what luminary SARB Governor Lesetja Kganyago has warned would be a 'deep depression'. It would also create enough chaos to facilitate a deeper round of state capture. Crouse concludes: 'This is a test for the GNU. The MK, EFF, and Action SA signalled support for the Bill in Parliament. If the ANC joins those parties in keeping the Bill alive to spite its investment-friendly GNU partners, this will damage government unity. More importantly, it dangles a threat over everyone's prospects, and the lifesavings of those who have any.' Institute of Race Relations I Joburg
Mail & Guardian
2 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
MK party officials to discuss errant behaviour of Duduzile Zuma-Sambudla and Nhlamulo Ndhlela
Duduzile Zuma-Sambudla. (Delwyn Verasamy/M&G) uMkhonto weSizwe ( Zuma-Sambudla's father, party president Mail & Guardian . They said Sambudla‑Zuma and Ndhela had approached Zuma, attempting to influence him and to disparage parliamentary caucus leader Colleen Makhubele and parliamentary leader and deputy president On Tuesday, eNCA reported that it had seen a letter addressed to Zuma, in which the party's caucus in parliament called for Makhubele to be removed from her position, saying her pro-Israel stance betrayed the party's values. According to the news channel, the MPs also said Makkhubele posed a threat to party unity and had demonstrated poor leadership and conduct that alienated members. In another leaked letter, dated 23 June, addressed to Ndhela and copied to Zuma, Hlophe said he wanted to formally inform the party spokesperson that he had been removed from the whippery team in parliament, effective immediately. The source said Ndhlela and Zuma-Sambudla had tried to use the alleged letter against Makhubele to deflect from 'the storm' brewing against Ndhlela. 'They saw the letter from the deputy president (copied) to the president. The plan was basically: 'How do we destabilise this storm that's coming?' So they decided to run with some fake stories. All the caucus members said they didn't know anything about a letter [against Makhubele] … No one has signed any letter,' the source said. 'Remember when the caucus leader was with the In his letter to Ndhela, Hlophe charged him with: Disrespectful communication: Repeated instances of rude, arrogant and dismissive communication toward parliamentary members, including senior leadership, undermining the dignity and collaborative spirit needed in the whippery team. Obstruction of parliamentary communications: Hindering the communications team's work with parliamentary members in press briefings and statement releases, causing delays and damaging the party's public image. Undermining unity and collaboration: Creating divisions among parliamentary members through perceived factional and counterproductive behaviour, contrary to the party's principles of unity and collective action. Hlophe gave Ndhela 21 days to appeal the decision. The behaviour of Sambudla-Zuma has also been slammed by the party's former secretary general, Folyd Shivambu and expelled MK party founder Jabulani Khumalo. In February, Zuma-Sambudla had to apologise to Shivambu after insulting him on social media platform X while Khumalo accused her of influencing Zuma into making decisions which were not good for the party. Asked by the M&G last month — after her appointment as chief whip — how long she expected to remain in the position given the party's reputation for frequently removing officials, Makhubele said she was unperturbed, insisting that for a new party such as the MK, changes were normal and people needed to adapt. 'At whatever point the leadership feels they need a new skill to stabilise the caucus, to take the caucus in a new direction, they will make those decisions,' she said. This week, another source said Ndhela and Sambudla‑Zuma generally ignored party structures and resisted being told what to do. 'Manyi was just trying to nurse their egos. Whoever comes and tries to run things organisationally, they do not like it — they want to be in charge,' the source said, referring to former parliamentary chief whip Mzwanele Manyi who was removed in May and replaced by Makhubele. They accused Ndhlela and Zuma-Sambudla of behaving as if they were founding members of the MK party and who believed they could not be told what to do. The second source also said no letter calling for Makhubele's removal had ever been signed by the party's MPs. 'Where is this letter? People were asked if they signed it, but no one said they did. There's nothing signed by members of parliament. We are having a meeting tomorrow and no one has signed any letter.' The MK party's head of presidency, 'I don't preempt the agenda. I'm part of the committee that drafts it. I'm not panicking about what's in it or not. Tomorrow [Thursday] the agenda will be finalised. If the matter must be on the agenda, it will be — but it can't be a meeting just for that item,' he said. Mzobe said he didn't understand why party members were creating a non-existent urgency about the meeting, saying officials' meetings happen regularly 'every fortnight night' in the party. 'It's a standard meeting — these meetings always include reports from parliament. A parliamentary report is a regular item. In the governance report, always delivered by the deputy president, he updates the meeting on what's happening in parliament,' he said, adding that this particular one had been originally set for this week but was postponed because of a bereavement in the Zuma family. 'The agenda isn't decided until Thursday, when all issues are brought forward. I don't know where this assumption came from that one specific thing will be discussed when there is no agenda yet,' Mzobe added. 'I don't know why people are anxious about the agenda. People are told there's a meeting and everyone brings their items. I'm meeting the president today or tomorrow. I don't know why people think we'll discuss that issue in a standard meeting and not an urgent meeting.' Asked whether the party would address the alleged theft of R7 million raised by In the media briefing, Shivambu said Zuma was surrounded by 'political scoundrels' who exploited his vulnerability in old age to create false intelligence reports and mislead him with the aim of embezzling money from MK. 'They are withdrawing not less than R7 million from the organisation's coffers. We are addressing this internally, warning them: stop what you are doing because you're going to get the party deregistered as a political party,' he said. This week Mzobe told the M&G: 'I can't say we are sitting to look at the R7 million specifically. There is a financial report that must give us what we need to know, and there's a governance report that must tell us what's happening in parliament. We're not panicking just because something's trending as a headline — it doesn't require an urgent meeting.' Makhubele and Hlophe were due to brief the media on Thursday on the latest developments in parliament, including ongoing budget votes.
