Do international carbon credits fight climate change?
FILE PHOTO: A coal-fired power station scheduled to shut down is seen in As Pontes, Spain, February 8, 2022. Picture taken February 8, 2022. REUTERS/Miguel Vidal/File Photo
BRUSSELS - The European Commission has proposed an EU climate target for 2040 that allows countries to count carbon credits bought from developing nations towards the EU goal for the first time.
Here's what that means, and why the EU move on Wednesday faced criticism from campaigners and some scientists.
WHAT ARE CARBON CREDITS?
Carbon credits, or offsets, involve funding projects that reduce CO2 emissions abroad in place of cuts to your own greenhouse gas emissions.
Examples include forest restoration in Brazil, or converting a city's petrol buses to electric. The buyer counts "credits" for those emission reductions towards its climate goal, and the seller gets finance for their green project.
Proponents say the system generates much-needed funding for CO2-cutting efforts in developing nations and lets countries work together to cut emissions around the world.
However, the reputation of CO2 credits has been dented by a string of scandals in which credit-generating projects failed to deliver the climate benefits they claimed.
Top stories
Swipe. Select. Stay informed.
Singapore 193ha of land off Changi to be reclaimed for aviation park; area reduced to save seagrass meadow
Business More Singapore residents met CPF Required Retirement Sum when they turned 55 in 2024
Singapore PAP questions Pritam's interview with Malaysian podcast, WP says PAP opposing for the sake of opposing
Singapore 1 in 4 appeals to waive HDB wait-out period for private home owners approved since Sept 2022
Sport A true fans' player – Liverpool fans in Singapore pay tribute to the late Diogo Jota
Singapore Healthcare facility planned for site of Ang Mo Kio Public Library after it moves to AMK Hub
Singapore $500 in Child LifeSG credits, Edusave, Post-Sec Education Account top-ups to be disbursed in July
Business 60 S'pore firms to get AI boost from Tata Consultancy as it launches new innovation centre here
WHY IS THE EU BUYING THEM?
The European Commission proposed allowing up to 3 percentage points of the EU's 2040 target - to cut net emissions by 90% from 1990 levels - to be covered by carbon credits bought from other countries.
The EU's existing climate targets require countries to meet the goals entirely by cutting emissions at home.
The bloc's executive Commission said last year it hoped the EU could agree a 90% emissions-cutting target for 2040, with no mention of carbon credits.
Tumultuous geopolitics and the economic woes of European industries have since stoked political pushback, with governments from Germany to Poland demanding a softer target.
In response, the Commission said it would add flexibilities, and landed on carbon credits as a way to retain a 90% emissions-cutting goal while reducing the domestic steps needed to reach it.
EU countries and the European Parliament must negotiate and approve the goal.
WHAT ARE THE RISKS?
The EU plan was welcomed by countries including Germany, which had pushed to include carbon credits in the goal, and by carbon credit project developers as a boost for climate finance.
But environmental campaigners said the EU was shirking domestic CO2-cutting efforts and warned against relying on cheap, low-value credits.
The EU's climate science advisers had also opposed buying credits under the 2040 target, which they said would divert money from investments in local clean industries.
The EU banned international credits from its own carbon market after a flood of cheap credits with weak environmental benefits contributed to a carbon price crash.
To try to address the risks, the Commission said it would buy credits in line with a global market and rules for trading carbon credits which the U.N. is developing. These include quality standards aimed at avoiding the problems that unregulated credit trading has faced in recent years.
Brussels will also propose rules next year on specific quality standards for the carbon credits the EU buys.
HOW MUCH WILL IT COST?
The EU doesn't yet know. Carbon credit prices today can be as low as a few dollars per tonne of CO2, up to more than $100, depending on the project.
EU emissions records suggest the bloc would need to buy at least 140 million tonnes of CO2 emissions to cover 3% of the 2040 target, roughly equivalent to the Netherlands' total emissions last year.
One senior Commission official said the bloc was determined not to hoover up cheap junk credits.
"I don't think that would have any additional value. The credits we see currently on voluntary carbon markets are very, very cheap, and that probably reflects a lack of high environmental integrity," the senior official said. REUTERS
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Trump says countries to start paying tariffs on Aug 1, floats range of 10% to 70%
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Many major trading partners, such as Japan, South Korea and the European Union, are still working to finalise deals. WASHINGTON – US President Donald Trump said that his administration will start sending out letters to trading partners on July 4 setting unilateral tariff rates, which he said countries would have to begin paying on Aug 1. Mr Trump told reporters that about '10 or 12' letters would go out on July 4, with additional letters coming 'over the next few days'. 'I think by the ninth they'll be fully covered,' Mr Trump added, referring to a July 9 deadline he initially set for countries to reach deals with the US to avoid higher import duties he has threatened. 'They'll range in value from maybe 60 or 70 per cent tariffs to 10 and 20 per cent tariffs,' he added. The top tier of that range, if formalised, would be higher than any tariffs the president initially outlined during his 'Liberation Day' rollout in early April. Those ranged from a 10 per cent baseline tariff on most economies up to a maximum of 50 per cent. Mr Trump did not elaborate on which countries would get the tariffs or whether that meant certain goods would be taxed at a higher rate than others. He said that countries would 'start to pay on Aug 1. The money will start going to come into the United States on Aug 1'. Mr Trump has long threatened that if countries fail to reach deals with the US before next week's deadline, he would simply impose rates on them, raising the stakes for trading partners who have rushed to secure agreements with his administration. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Seller's stamp duty rates for private homes raised; holding period increased from 3 years to 4 Singapore Sengkang murder: Man accused of killing elderly mother escorted back to crime scene Singapore Multiple charges for man accused of damaging PAP campaign materials on GE2025 Polling Day Singapore Jail for man who recruited 2 Japanese women for prostitution at MBS Asia Japan urges evacuation of small island as 1,000 quakes hit region Asia Indonesian rescuers widen search for missing after ferry sinks World Trump's sweeping tax-cut and spending Bill wins congressional approval The US President initially announced his higher so-called 'reciprocal' tariffs on April 2, but paused those for 90 days to allow countries time to negotiate, putting in place a 10 per cent rate during that interval. So far, the Trump administration has announced deals with the UK and Vietnam and agreed to a truce with China that saw the world's two largest economies ease tit-for-tat tariffs. Asked on July 3 if more deals were on the way, Mr Trump responded that 'we have a couple of other deals, but you know, my inclination is to send a letter out and say what tariffs they are going to be paying'. 'It's much easier,' he said. Mr Trump announced the Vietnam deal on July 2, saying that the US would place a 20 per cent tariff on Vietnamese exports to the US and a 40 per cent rate on goods deemed transshipped through the nation – a reference to the practice whereby components from China and possibly other nations are routed through third countries on their way to the US. While the rates are lower than the 46 per cent duty Mr Trump imposed on Vietnam initially, they are higher than the universal 10 per cent level. And many of the particulars of the deal are still unclear, with the White House yet to release a term sheet or publish any proclamation codifying the agreement. Still, investors who have eagerly anticipated any deals between the US and trading partners were buoyed on July 2 by the Vietnam announcement, which saw share prices of American manufacturers with facilities in the country rise. Many major trading partners, however, such as Japan, South Korea and the European Union, are still working to finalise deals. Mr Trump has expressed optimism about reaching an agreement with India but has spoken harshly about the prospects of an accord with Japan, casting Tokyo as a difficult negotiating partner. He intensified his criticism this week, saying that Japan should be forced to 'pay 30 per cent, 35 per cent or whatever the number is that we determine'. The President on July 2 also said he was not considering delaying next week's deadline. Asked about any potential extension of talks, US Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said earlier that Mr Trump would make the final call. 'We're going to do what the president wants, and he'll be the one to determine whether they're negotiating in good faith,' Mr Bessent said on CNBC when asked whether the deadline might be lengthened. BLOOMBERG
Business Times
2 hours ago
- Business Times
Time to raise bets on Malaysia semiconductor stocks on expected ‘market-friendly' trade deal: UOBKH
[SINGAPORE] Malaysian stocks could score near-term wins as the US' 'softening stance' on tariffs is expected to bring about market-friendly trade deals between the two countries, said UOB Kay Hian (UOBKH). In a Wednesday (Jul 2) report, the brokerage said it was time to raise bets on Malaysia with the expectations of favourable trade deals with the US. 'In anticipation of market-friendly US trade deals being struck and Malaysia retaining its onshoring destination status, our July 2025 picks raise the bet on semiconductor-related stocks, while still maintaining our emphasis on domestic infrastructure plays,' said UOB analysts. Maybank on Jul 1 also predicted that Malaysia could shine in the next phase of global trade, with US tariffs on the country likely to stay at a lower band relative to other nations. UOB's top picks for July 2025 included engineering solutions provider Coraza, pharmaceutical company Duopharma Biotech, property player Eco World Development, Gamuda, Hume Cement Industries, semiconductor services provider IJM and digital services provider MY EG Services – all of which were assigned a 'buy' rating. Semiconductor-related stocks to succeed in short-run A 'softening stance' on the US' tariff demands should culminate in market-friendly US-Malaysia trade deals, UOBKH analysts said. BT in your inbox Start and end each day with the latest news stories and analyses delivered straight to your inbox. Sign Up Sign Up 'This expectation, together with strong anecdotal evidence of Malaysian electrical and electronics companies significantly clinching orders and order enquiries since the US' 90-day tariff pause in April, should trigger further near-term upside especially for semiconductor-related stocks,' UOBKH analysts said. These semiconductor-related players should get near-term wins before potential profit taking and ahead of forex-related challenges in the upcoming quarterly results season in June and July, they added. One new addition to the brokerage's list of top picks, semiconductor-related laggard Coraza, logged consistent year-on-year revenue improvements across the past four quarters, said UOBKH analyst Desmond Chong. He highlighted the company's 'solid' order momentum, as its current outstanding orderbook is at RM80 million (S$24.1 million) – 10 per cent above the previous quarter's quantum, with the bulk of orders coming from the semiconductor industry. The company is investing in higher and more sophisticated equipment to cater to the needs of its customers, Chong said. Upgrades for a newly acquired plant opposite its existing Nibong Tebal plant are on track, while another new factory adjacent to the plant is set to become operational in the fourth quarter of 2025. The timeline given for Coraza was six to nine months with a target price of RM0.66. Inari, a company involved in semiconductor assembly, is another new addition to UOBKH's top picks. The brokerage lifted its target price upwards to RM2.36 from RM1.90, and assigned it a six to nine-month timeline. While the group's share price dropped 34 per cent in the year to date, Chong noted that its radio frequency segment sustained a 'relatively healthy' utilisation rate of 65 to 70 per cent. Inari is poised to commercialise on new product pipelines in upcoming quarters, with its 2025 growth to be driven largely by its flagship radio frequency business. The group has also made recent forays into advanced packaging platforms such as flip-chip chip-scale packages and flip-chip ball grid arrays, Chong said. 'These technologies offer ultra-high performance, high memory bandwidth, and heterogeneous integration capabilities to cater to the increasing demand for cutting-edge semiconductor solutions in artificial intelligence, server, networking, smart devices and industrial applications,' he added.
Straits Times
2 hours ago
- Straits Times
Indonesia resumes search for 30 missing ferry passengers
Sign up now: Get ST's newsletters delivered to your inbox Indonesia rescue team members sail on dinghies during a search operation for missing passengers, after the KMP Tunu Pratama Jaya ferry carrying 65 people sank near the Indonesian island of Bali, in Bali, Indonesia, July 3, 2025. REUTERS/Johannes P. Christo GILIMANUK, Indonesia - Indonesian rescuers are battling strong currents on Friday as they resume the search for 30 people still missing at sea about 35 hours after a ferry sank killing at least six people, officials said. The ferry named KMP Tunu Pratama Jaya was carrying 65 people, all Indonesians, when it sank about 30 minutes after setting sail from East Java bound for the holiday island of Bali on Wednesday night, said search and rescue agency official Ribut Eko Suyatno. Twenty-nine survivors were rescued on Thursday before the search was called off due to poor visibility. Dayu Made Silawati, 55, said her husband, Dewa Gede Adyana Putra Usia, was travelling on the ferry to pick up supplies in Bali for his job as a truck driver. Waiting for news at a rescue centre in Bali, she said the last time she spoke to him was on Wednesday night. "'I just got on the ship,'" she recalled him saying. "I said to him, 'be careful', dear." At 4 a.m. on Thursday, Silawati said she called him again, and again. There was no answer. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Seller's stamp duty rates for private homes raised; holding period increased from 3 years to 4 Asia Japan urges evacuation of small island as 1,000 quakes hit region Singapore Multiple charges for man accused of damaging PAP campaign materials on GE2025 Polling Day Singapore Jail for man who recruited 2 Japanese women for prostitution at MBS World Trump eyes simple tariff rates over complex talks, says letters will start going out on July 4 World Trump's sweeping tax-cut and spending Bill wins congressional approval Asia Indonesian rescuers widen search for missing after ferry sinks Business More Singapore residents met CPF Required Retirement Sum when they turned 55 in 2024 Rescue operations resumed on Friday in the waters of Bali Strait involving ships, helicopters, and hundreds of rescuers, Eko said. Strong currents and rain are expected. Transportation safety investigators would probe the cause of the sinking when the search is over, officials said. The ferry was not overloaded when it went down, officials said on Thursday. Ferries are a common mode of transportation in Indonesia, a nation of over 17,000 islands, and lax safety standards allow vessels to be overcrowded with inadequate life-saving equipment. REUTERS
