logo
No need to re-conduct NEET-UG 2025, affirms Division Bench of Madras High Court

No need to re-conduct NEET-UG 2025, affirms Division Bench of Madras High Court

The Hindu04-07-2025
A Division Bench of the Madras High Court, on Thursday (July 3, 2025), affirmed a single judge's order against the re-conduct of National Eligibility-cum-Entrance Test - Undergraduate (NEET-UG) 2025 for the students who appeared at centres which suffered power disruption due to heavy rains on May 4.
The Division Bench comprising Justices J. Nisha Banu and M. Jothiraman dismissed a writ appeal filed jointly by a group of candidates by concurring with the submissions of Additional Solicitor General AR.L. Sundaresan that the power disruption had no significant impact in the performance of the petitioners in the test.
The Bench upheld Justice C. Kumarappan's June 6 decision to not order re-conduct of NEET-UG 2025 and said, the single judge had rightly concluded that any court order for conduct of re-examination would severely affect the prospects of more than two million candidates.
While challenging the single judge's order, the appellants had contended that there was complete breakdown of exam conditions at the centres where there was power outage due to heavy rainfall and therefore, the candidates in those centres had lost the advantage of writing the exams in conditions on a par with those in other centres.
However, Mr. Sundaresan produced CCTV footage from the examination centres before the Division Bench to show that the examination halls had large windows with glass panes which allowed ambient daylight to enter the rooms and that there was highly negligible disruption due to the rains and power outage.
He also pointed out one of the candidates in the examination centre in question had answered 179 out of 180 questions and five other candidates had answered 140 out of 180 questions. He said, there was no difference in the performance of candidates who suffered power outage at their centres and others.
He further stated the NTA had constituted an independent expert committee for conducting an on-ground assessment to find out if there was any impact on candidates' performance due to the power outage at some centres and that the committee had conducted a statistical analysis before giving a categorical finding that there was no such impact.
Finding force in his submissions, the Division Bench wrote: 'This court is of the opinion that it is crucial to uphold the integrity of the educational assessments in conducting examinations and this court cannot sit in an appellate jurisdiction against the considered decision of the speaking order passed by the NTA, after field verification of examination centres and statistical analysis by an independent expert committee with no affiliation to the NTA, unless such decision is demonstrated to be manifestly arbitrary, mala fide or illegal.'
Taking note that as many as 22 lakh candidates had appeared for NEET-UG 2025 and that the entire rank list would get disrupted if a re-examination was ordered for select candidates, the Bench said: 'Therefore, we do not find any reason to interfere with the order impugned (under challenge) and the writ appeal lacks merit and the same is liable to be dismissed.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Supreme Court slams Telangana's domicile rule for NEET state quota seats
Supreme Court slams Telangana's domicile rule for NEET state quota seats

India Today

timean hour ago

  • India Today

Supreme Court slams Telangana's domicile rule for NEET state quota seats

The Supreme Court on Wednesday faulted the Telangana government's domicile policy, which mandates a student to have pursued Classes 9 to 12 in the state to be eligible for admission to state quota medical seats through NEET, and said it was far removed from the ground Supreme Court said many students move to places like Kota for better coaching in Classes 11 and 12, and they should not be denied Telangana state quota medical seats just because they studied outside the state. The bench added that students whose parents are residents of Telangana should be allowed to apply under the state quota, no matter where they completed their schooling. The court also warned the government to fix the issue, or it would step for students facing the domicile bar despite their parents being born in Telangana and continuously residing in the state, advocate Raghenth Basant told the bench that it had created a piquant situation. He pointed out that a child of someone from Kerala, who has lived in Telangana for just four years and studied Classes 9 to 12 there, would qualify for state quota medical seats. However, students whose parents are long-time residents of Telangana but who studied outside the state would be denied the same urged the court to modify the domicile criteria by allowing children of every resident of Telangana, irrespective of where they completed their schooling, to get admitted to medical colleges under state quota seats. The SC posted the matter for further hearing on July 29, by when the Telangana government will have to come up with an answer to the court's query.- EndsMust Watch

Domicile rule of T'gana for med seats flawed: SC
Domicile rule of T'gana for med seats flawed: SC

Time of India

time2 hours ago

  • Time of India

Domicile rule of T'gana for med seats flawed: SC

New Delhi: Supreme Court on Wednesday faulted the Telangana govt's domicile policy, which mandates a student to have pursued Classes 9 to 12 in the state to be eligible for admissions to state quota medical seats through NEET and said it was far removed from the ground reality, reports Dhananjay Mahapatra. "These days, many students, to avail of better coaching facilities for competing in medical and engineering entrance examinations, pursue their Class 11 and 12 at places like Kota. Should they be barred from getting admitted on the ground that they are not domiciles of Telangana?" a bench of CJI B R Gavai and Justices K Vinod Chandran and Joymalya Bagchi asked. "You must have a humane approach." We do not want such students to be harassed. All students whose parents are domiciled in Telangana would be eligible for state quota seats irrespective of the place from where they passed Class 11 and 12," the CJI said, with a warning, "Either you (the govt) resolve the issue, or we will set it right." Appearing for students facing the domicile bar despite their parents being born in Telangana and continuously residing in the state, advocate Raghenth Basant told the bench that it has created a piquant situation. "Children of a person from Kerala, who is posted in Telangana for the last four years, on completing Class 9-12 in Telangana would be eligible for admissions to medical seats under state quota. But students who study outside, despite their parents being natural residents of Telangana, would not be eligible to avail these state quota medical seats," he said. He urged the court to modify the domicile criteria by allowing children of every resident of Telangana, irrespective of where they completed their schooling, to get admitted to medical colleges under state quota seats. The SC posted the matter for further hearing on July 29, by when the Telangana govt will have to come with an answer to the court's query.

SC turns down plea to stay NEET counselling
SC turns down plea to stay NEET counselling

Time of India

time8 hours ago

  • Time of India

SC turns down plea to stay NEET counselling

Supreme Court NEW DELHI: Supreme Court on Wednesday turned down plea of two students to stay counselling for undergraduate medical admission on the basis of NEET-UG 2025 but agreed to hear their grievances. The petitioners approached the court after allegedly suffering a power outage during the exam at a test centre in Madhya Pradesh. Agreeing to hear their plea, the Supreme Court bench of Justices P S Narasimha and A S Chandurkar, made it clear that there would be no stay on the counselling and listed the petition for Friday. The candidates approached the Supreme Court against the July 14 order of the Madhya Pradesh high court refusing to order a re-test for them. TNN

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store