Mango airline's business rescue plan faces setback as court ruling is challenged
Image: File
The business rescue practitioner (BRP) of grounded low-cost airline Mango is challenging the Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg, judgment declaring the plan to save the state-owned company unimplementable.
BRP Sipho Sono has filed an application for leave to appeal Judge Denise Fisher's ruling handed down last month.
Judge Fisher found that the plan, stripped of its complexity, amounts to nothing more than the confiscation of creditors' claims to be transferred by Sono to an investor who pays no value for them or the shares.
She ordered: 'The compulsory cession contained in clause 6.2.6 of the business rescue plan is declared to be invalid and of no force and effect. It is declared that the business rescue plan cannot be implemented'.
Judge Fisher said Sono's opposition to Aviation Co-ordination Services' (ACS's) application was unmeritorious.
ACS, which provided security-related services such as baggage and cargo screening services, baggage reconciliation and check-in services, hauled Mango and Sono to court over the plan to save the subsidiary of South African Airways.
The company is one of the creditors owed about R2.91 billion by Mango before it was placed under business rescue in July 2021 and is owed over R23.3 million.
ACS complained that its estimated settlement would translate roughly to R44,300 per R1m, a return which it described as negligible, if not nominal.
Sono has indicated that there are sufficient funds to pay a dividend of more than the 4.43 cents to each rand owed, as estimated in the business rescue plan.
In the challenge to Judge Fisher's judgment, Sono stated that the court's findings that a business rescue plan cannot provide for an involuntary cession against non-acceding creditors was made as a principle that is far-reaching and has implications that extend beyond the present dispute and constitute a compelling reason why leave to appeal should be granted.
'The decision involves a question of law which is important, as the decision is of general application, affecting all business rescue plans that entail an involuntary cession, including against non-acceding creditors, which is a common feature of business rescue plans,' he explained.
Mango and Sono want to be granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Appeal and believe there are reasonable prospects of success.
Sono defended the appeal, asserting his right to pursue litigation if he reasonably believes that a favourable outcome for Mango will benefit all affected parties.
'The BRP will continue to act and take such steps as he reasonably believes are in the best interests of all affected persons, notwithstanding the various threats made by ACS and its legal representatives, which are regrettable, inflammatory, and achieve no legitimate purpose,' he added.
According to Sono, ACS's intentions remain unclear but on the face of it, it would seem that the company prefers a situation where the potential investor withdraws and Mango is wound up.
'It is not clear why such an outcome would be favourable to ACS, who during the height of Mango's operations generated approximately R70m per annum in revenue,' he added.
[email protected]
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
6 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
Is Bitcoin useful yet? The question explored in ‘Decrypting Crypto: the utility conversation'
Forget speculation – can you buy bread with Bitcoin? Daily Maverick's second Decrypting Crypto webinar tackled whether crypto's promise of real-world use is finally growing roots from South Africa's (SA's) townships and suburbs to shops and remittances. Bitcoin's rocket ride is well known – a single coin, worth around R3,300 at the end of 2014, then called the worst investment of that year, is now worth more than R2-million. While exchanges do exist to turn Bitcoin into fiat currency, the question remains: is Bitcoin gaining real practical utility for ordinary South Africans? The answer is that while it's still early days, cryptocurrency is becoming more practical to use in everyday life, thanks to growing adoption and an expanding range of real-world applications. In this second edition of Business Maverick's Decrypting Crypto webinar series held on 10 July 2025, crypto journalist Lindsey Schutters looked to unpack the issue beyond the hype of the marketplace, in conversation with Larry Cooke, head of legal for Binance Africa, and Hermann Vivier, founder of Bitcoin Ekasi and Chairman of The Surfer Kids. It's about simplicity For Vivier, Bitcoin's usefulness isn't just about whether it works as a payment system. It's about what it represents. 'Bitcoin was created specifically as a response against central banking,' he said. 'Satoshi Nakamoto recognised that the basic problem is the centralisation of control. So the answer to that is decentralisation.' Vivier's motivation isn't profit, but principle. 'Utility is a second-layer conversation. The first layer is ideology,' he explained. 'If my utility application of this thing loses sight of that core question, then I'm not doing it right.''I want to be able to do everything I do with normal money. I want to be able to do that with Bitcoin – in the simplest, most straightforward way possible,' he continued. Building Bitcoin Ekasi But ideals are tested in the real world – which is exactly why he helped launch Bitcoin Ekasi in Mossel Bay. Inspired by El Salvador's Bitcoin Beach, the project is building a circular economy around Bitcoin. Salaries are paid in crypto, and spaza shops are encouraged to accept it. 'We've onboarded about 50 businesses in the community,' Vivier said. 'We currently pay 22 staff salaries entirely in Bitcoin. The coaches at Surfer Kids use that money to buy essentials like groceries and electricity. Where Bitcoin isn't accepted, I sometimes convert to rand – but the goal is for crypto to be used as is.' It's not an overnight transformation, though. 'Adoption is slow. It's gradual. And that's normal,' Vivier said. 'Money changes very slowly. Just look at how long it took to go from gold to fiat, or for credit cards to become mainstream.' Everyday use, and a grocery pocket While Vivier is building grassroots use cases, Cooke sees crypto utility growing both personally and institutionally. At Binance Africa, he focuses on legal frameworks, consumer protection and enabling everyday use. Cooke uses his Binance wallet to pay for groceries at Pick n Pay via the Lightning Network, a fast and cheap transaction layer built on top of Bitcoin. 'Freedom of money – that's our slogan,' he said. 'It's about giving consumers control over their assets and allowing them to choose the tools that work best for them.' He distinguishes between personal utility – how individuals make their money more efficient – and general utility, where a broader ecosystem enables spending and saving with crypto. 'What you're trying to solve for is efficiencies,' he explained. 'How do I get the most out of my money? How do I make it simpler, better, faster?' Taxes, scams and the chain that doesn't lie Crypto may be borderless, but Sars treats it as an asset – every disposal triggers a tax event. 'We do enable tax regimes because we are global… we've created a tax tool that allows individuals to reconcile buying and selling and basically calculate their own tax,' said Cooke. 'It's not a certificate per se, but it's one of the closest things you'll find at this point in time.' And while scams are a persistent risk, the blockchain never forgets: 'Once the crypto transaction takes place, you can't undo it. You can't remove it off the blockchain… Eventually you will get caught.' The conversation repeatedly returned to the need for education and inclusion. 'A lot of people have burnt their fingers in past hype cycles,' Vivier admitted. That's why responsible onboarding and community-building matter. For Cooke, the future isn't about crypto versus banks, but about co-existence. 'We're not here to compete with banks or M-Pesa,' he said. 'It's about interoperability. All technologies are embraced. All systems function together.' He points to mobile money's success in Kenya and explains why SA – with its robust banking infrastructure – hasn't seen the same adoption pattern. 'South Africans weren't desperate for a mobile solution like M-Pesa. But crypto can still be valuable in a strong financial system – especially when it offers new ways to move money or store value.' Volatility bites Of course, Bitcoin's volatility remains a sticking point. But Vivier argued that fiat currencies aren't much better – especially across Africa. 'The value of Bitcoin comes from its decentralised network and its rules. It's run without fail for 16 years.' Cooke agreed, adding: 'Fiat is just as volatile in some African countries. What we offer with crypto is transparency and immutability.' That transparency is also a double-edged sword. While the blockchain can expose fraud, it's also why CBDCs (central bank digital currencies) are raising red flags. 'CBDCs are a surveillance tool,' Vivier warned. 'They represent the final merger of money and state. With that control, governments can switch off protestors' bank accounts. That's dangerous.' 'This is why we're doing this series,' Schutters explained to viewers. 'Crypto isn't just a currency play – it's a community education project too.' 'Even I fall victim to concentrating too much on the investment asset side of Bitcoin, and forget to talk about the everyday-use case,' he confessed. One (big) question at a time 'Is crypto useful yet?' asks Schutters in conclusion. In short: yes, but it's still early days. Crypto is being used in Mossel Bay townships, at retail tills in Pick n Pay, and increasingly in online services and cross-border remittances. But broader adoption hinges on community education, smarter regulation and practical use cases. Both DM guests had advice for crypto newcomers. 'Ask questions,' Vivier urged. 'Don't feel stupid. This is a paradigm shift. Every person you onboard brings us closer.'
IOL News
3 days ago
- IOL News
Mango airline's business rescue plan faces setback as court ruling is challenged
Mango's business rescue practitioner is challenging the Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg, ruling declaring the plan to save the state-owned low-cost airline unimplementable. Image: File The business rescue practitioner (BRP) of grounded low-cost airline Mango is challenging the Gauteng High Court, Johannesburg, judgment declaring the plan to save the state-owned company unimplementable. BRP Sipho Sono has filed an application for leave to appeal Judge Denise Fisher's ruling handed down last month. Judge Fisher found that the plan, stripped of its complexity, amounts to nothing more than the confiscation of creditors' claims to be transferred by Sono to an investor who pays no value for them or the shares. She ordered: 'The compulsory cession contained in clause 6.2.6 of the business rescue plan is declared to be invalid and of no force and effect. It is declared that the business rescue plan cannot be implemented'. Judge Fisher said Sono's opposition to Aviation Co-ordination Services' (ACS's) application was unmeritorious. ACS, which provided security-related services such as baggage and cargo screening services, baggage reconciliation and check-in services, hauled Mango and Sono to court over the plan to save the subsidiary of South African Airways. The company is one of the creditors owed about R2.91 billion by Mango before it was placed under business rescue in July 2021 and is owed over R23.3 million. ACS complained that its estimated settlement would translate roughly to R44,300 per R1m, a return which it described as negligible, if not nominal. Sono has indicated that there are sufficient funds to pay a dividend of more than the 4.43 cents to each rand owed, as estimated in the business rescue plan. In the challenge to Judge Fisher's judgment, Sono stated that the court's findings that a business rescue plan cannot provide for an involuntary cession against non-acceding creditors was made as a principle that is far-reaching and has implications that extend beyond the present dispute and constitute a compelling reason why leave to appeal should be granted. 'The decision involves a question of law which is important, as the decision is of general application, affecting all business rescue plans that entail an involuntary cession, including against non-acceding creditors, which is a common feature of business rescue plans,' he explained. Mango and Sono want to be granted leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of Appeal and believe there are reasonable prospects of success. Sono defended the appeal, asserting his right to pursue litigation if he reasonably believes that a favourable outcome for Mango will benefit all affected parties. 'The BRP will continue to act and take such steps as he reasonably believes are in the best interests of all affected persons, notwithstanding the various threats made by ACS and its legal representatives, which are regrettable, inflammatory, and achieve no legitimate purpose,' he added. According to Sono, ACS's intentions remain unclear but on the face of it, it would seem that the company prefers a situation where the potential investor withdraws and Mango is wound up. 'It is not clear why such an outcome would be favourable to ACS, who during the height of Mango's operations generated approximately R70m per annum in revenue,' he added. [email protected]
eNCA
5 days ago
- eNCA
Court orders Meta to shutdown channels publishing sexual content involving SA children
JOHANNESBURG - All WhatsApp and Instagram channels publishing sexual content involving South African children must be shut down immediately. The Gauteng High Court issued the urgent order on Monday night, compelling Meta the parent company of both platforms to investigate and identify the individuals behind these accounts. The application was spearheaded by media law expert Emma Sadleir, founder of the Digital Law Company.
