Wall St Journal may challenge Hong Kong gov't decision to not intervene in press union head's unlawful dismissal suit
Cheng, who previously reported on the Chinese electric vehicle industry for the WSJ, accused the US newspaper of firing her unlawfully last July, weeks after she was elected chair of the Hong Kong Journalists Association (HKJA). She launched a private prosecution against the company last December, after the government decided not to press charges in her case.
Defence lawyer Vinci Lam, representing the Asia branch of Dow Jones Publishing – the publisher of the WSJ – asked the court on Wednesday for a further three-week adjournment. It comes after the court postponed proceedings for 10 weeks in April for the Department of Justice (DoJ) to consider whether it would intervene.
In Hong Kong, the DoJ can intervene in a private prosecution, either taking over the proceedings to continue the prosecution or shut the case down.
The defence requested that the DoJ provide reasons for its decision not to intervene, and may consider launching a judicial review against it, Lam told Acting Principal Magistrate David Cheung.
A judicial review is considered by the Court of First Instance and examines the decision-making processes of administrative bodies. Issues under review must be shown to affect the wider public interest.
Cheng's lawyer revealed on social media last week that the DoJ had decided not to intervene, saying that the DoJ's decision allowed 'our pursuit of justice to proceed unimpeded.'
Plea expected on July 23
Lam also said on Wednesday the DoJ's reply could affect the defence's plea in the case. 'None of us here can say for certain' whether the company will plead guilty or not guilty, she told the court.
Judge Cheung granted a three-week adjournment and scheduled the next hearing for July 23, but it also ordered the defence to be ready for indicating a plea by then.
Senior Counsel Nigel Kat, for Cheng, told the court that his client will testify as a prosecution witness if a trial is needed.
Under Hong Kong's employment law, an employer found guilty of terminating an employee's contract because of their participation in trade union could be fined up to HK$100,000.
Cheng was re-elected as chair of the HKJA unopposed last month.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTHK
7 hours ago
- RTHK
France praises China over thaw in brandy trade row
France praises China over thaw in brandy trade row Beijing said 34 European brandy makers, including several French cognac producers, had signed an accord to avoid tariffs. Photo: AFP France on Friday praised China's steps to settle a trade dispute over European brandy imports but warned that "major issues" remained unresolved. The signs of a thaw in the row over the alcohol came as Foreign Minister Wang Yi met French President Emmanuel Macron and French Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot in Paris. In recent months China and the European Union have butted heads over Beijing's generous subsidies for its domestic industries. Beijing launched an investigation last year into EU brandy, months after the bloc undertook a probe into Chinese electric vehicle (EV) subsidies. In the latest salvo, China will from Saturday require European brandy exporters to raise prices or risk anti-dumping taxes of up to 34.9 percent. Beijing said 34 European brandy makers, including several French cognac producers, had signed an accord to avoid tariffs as long as they stick to an agreed minimum price. France's cognac makers' association BNIC, which includes key producers Hennessy, Remy Cointreau and Martell, confirmed that some companies had agreed to price increases in China to avoid anti-dumping taxes. Macron and Barrot praised China's steps to resolve the dispute but stressed they would discuss the outstanding differences with Wang. "This is a positive step towards resolving this dispute, which was threatening our exports," Macron said on X. "I will continue to raise these issues with the Chinese authorities this afternoon." In a statement to AFP, Barrot said: "Several major issues remain unresolved, in particular the exclusion of certain players from the scope of the exemptions." "We remain fully committed to reaching a definitive solution based on the conditions that existed prior to the investigation," he said. Wang has held fraught meetings in several European countries this week. After meeting Macron and Barrot, Wang told a press conference: "The two sides had in-depth, active and sincere exchanges on Sino-French and European relations." No mention was made of the brandy dispute. Almost all EU brandy is cognac produced in France, whose exports to China are worth 1.4 billion euros (US$1.6 billion) per year. French liquor giant Jas Hennessy said it would face levies of 34.9 percent if it did not stick to the deal. Remy Martin will be hit with 34.3 percent and Martell 27.7 percent. (AFP)
HKFP
13 hours ago
- HKFP
China to require major EU brandy exporters to raise prices
China will require major European brandy exporters to raise prices or risk anti-dumping taxes of up to 34.9 percent from Saturday, the latest salvo in its long-running trade spat with the bloc. Almost all EU brandy is cognac produced in France, exports of which to China are worth 1.4 billion euros (US$1.6 billion) per year. Beijing launched an investigation last year into EU brandy, months after the bloc undertook a probe into Chinese electric vehicle (EV) subsidies. It said it had determined in a preliminary ruling that dumping had occurred and imposed 'temporary anti-dumping measures' on imports of the alcoholic beverage — moves now costing the industry 50 million euros per month. Beijing's commerce ministry said on Friday that China's tariff commission had 'decided to impose anti-dumping duties on imports of relevant brandy originating in the EU' from Saturday. But Beijing said in an explanatory note that several major French cognac producers had signed onto a price commitment to avoid the tariffs — as long as they sell at or above an agreed minimum price. French liquor giant Jas Hennessy would be hit with levies of 34.9 percent if it reneges on the deal, it said. Remy Martin will be hit with 34.3 percent and Martell 27.7 percent. 'The decision to accept the price commitment once again demonstrates China's sincerity in resolving trade frictions through dialogue and consultation,' a commerce ministry spokesperson said in a statement. France's umbrella cognac producers association BNIC — which covers key producers from Hennessy to Remy Cointreau and Martell — confirmed the deal to avoid levies by hiking prices, calling it a 'less unfavourable' outcome. Still, the European Commission said Friday after the announcement that it 'regrets China's decision'. 'We believe that China's measures are unfair. We believe they are unjustified. We believe they are inconsistent with the applicable international rules and are thus unfounded,' said the commission's trade spokesman, Olof Gill. China has sought to improve relations with the European Union as a counterweight to superpower rival the United States. But deep frictions remain over their economic relationship — including a yawning trade deficit of US$357.1 billion between China and the EU, as well as Beijing's close ties with Russia despite Moscow's war in Ukraine. Bitter taste The new levy threats come as Chinese top diplomat Wang Yi has held fraught meetings with his counterparts during a tour of Europe this week. They will likely be high on the agenda when he meets French President Emmanuel Macron and Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot on Friday afternoon in Paris. A trade row between Beijing and the bloc erupted last summer when the EU moved towards imposing hefty tariffs on electric vehicles imported from China, arguing that Beijing's subsidies were unfairly undercutting European competitors. Beijing denied that claim and announced what were widely seen as retaliatory probes into imported European pork, brandy and dairy products. The bloc imposed extra import taxes of up to 35 percent on Chinese EV imports in October. Beijing later lodged a complaint with the World Trade Organization, which said in April that it would set up an expert panel to assess the EU's decision. China and the EU are scheduled to hold a summit this month to mark the 50th anniversary of the establishment of diplomatic ties. Bloomberg News reported on Friday, citing unnamed sources, that Beijing intends to cancel the second day of the summit.
HKFP
20 hours ago
- HKFP
China says US lifted some export curbs, warns against ‘blackmail'
China said Friday that the United States has eased certain export restrictions in line with a 'hard-won' framework reached at talks last month, warning against 'blackmail and coercion' as the countries attempt to de-escalate a ruinous trade war. 'Currently, both teams are working quickly to implement the results outlined in the London framework', China's commerce ministry said in a statement, referring to the June meetings. Beijing is now 'reviewing applications for export licences of controlled items that meet the requirements', it said. 'The US side is also taking corresponding actions and has lifted a series of restrictive measures against China, the details of which have been communicated to the Chinese side,' it added. The world's two top economies agreed to an outline of a deal to walk back from the brink of staggering tariffs at last month's meetings in London, with concessions including Beijing's resumption of key rare earth exports. Washington has also recently lifted rules for certain exports to China, including by removing licence requirements for shipping ethane to the country, according to a Bloomberg report this week. China's commerce ministry statement added that 'the London framework was hard-won' — and warned that 'blackmail and coercion will lead nowhere'. 'We hope the United States will… continue to work in the same direction as China (and) further correct its erroneous practices.' Prior to the London talks, Beijing and Washington had agreed to temporarily lower steep tit-for-tat tariffs on each other's products. But US officials later accused Beijing of violating the pact and slow-walking its approvals of export licences for rare earths — the global production of which is dominated by China. President Donald Trump said Sunday that the United States was 'getting along well with China'.
