Signs of life on rebuild
Diggers are back on the site, working on the foundations, and billboards have gone up proclaiming the involvement of Australian construction giant CPB which is expected to get the contract for the new inpatient building.
All of these things suggest action at last on the beleaguered project.
Questions remain about whether the hospital, in its scaled-back state, can possibly come in within its $1.88 billion budget and be sufficient to serve the population when it is hopefully completed in 2031.
Former head of the new hospital's governance group Pete Hodgson estimates inflation alone would have added an extra $40 million in costs since the government stalled the project last September citing cost concerns.
There has been much airy talk of changed models of care affecting the demand for various services at the new hospital when it opens in 2031, without any detail of what this involves and how it will be achieved.
The whole of the health system still faces workforce shortages.
If changes mean moving to more care in the community, it is hard to understand how when basic issues such as boosting the pay of nurses working there to match their Te Whatu Ora Health New Zealand counterparts remains unresolved. (The government seems to have conveniently forgotten Prime Minister Christopher Luxon, in the televised pre-election leaders' debate, promised he would ensure they would be paid the same if he won the election.)
Mixed messaging from the government about the project continues.
In the New Zealand Gazette notice of the appointment which will bring back Evan Davies to the project, but this time in the supremo role of Crown manager, Health Minister Simeon Brown blamed delays and extra costs on HNZ, ignoring the role the government has played in that.
He said HNZ had struggled to maintain momentum on the project and identify a path forward following consistent cost pressure and extensions to the estimated delivery time for the project.
That seemed at odds with his on-site comment last week that HNZ staff had been "playing a critically important role in getting us to where we are here today".
During his visit Mr Brown announced the establishment of the Southern Engagement Group, to help ensure the local community was kept well informed as the project progresses.
The group will involve HNZ leaders and a variety of other representatives including local government, infrastructure partners and tertiary institutions to provide regular updates and support ongoing engagement throughout the project.
It will meet quarterly to consider "a broad range of matters relevant to the successful delivery of the hospital" but will not provide advice on the building's design scope, clinical models of care or procurement decisions.
Although Mr Brown said he was making this announcement alongside Dunedin Mayor Jules Radich, basic questions posed to Mr Radich's office about whether the meetings would be held in public, whether members would be free to speak about hospital matters outside the group and if the group's terms of reference were finalised, were directed to HNZ.
At the time of writing no answers had been received. Not a great start to make such an announcement on a group supposedly designed to improve communication and then not have relevant details promptly available. Making hay while the drizzle dries
There's nothing quite like a closer-than-expected All Blacks game to take much of the nation's minds momentarily off more important matters such as the fallout from the foul weather which has ravaged much of the country in recent days.
The sold-out All Blacks/France match would also have been a welcome midwinter fillip to Dunedin's hospitality sector at a time when the cost of living continues to affect domestic spending.
It is an uneasy time for the local sector, as it awaits the impact of the competition from the new, bigger, covered Christchurch stadium expected to be completed next year and while Forsyth Barr Stadium continues to struggle financially and to attract major events.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
9 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Opinion: Youth vaping is a problem, let's look at the evidence
It risks reinforcing a narrative implied by e-cigarette companies, including some owned by Big Tobacco: that New Zealand should never clamp down on e-cigarettes or smoking rates may rise again. Let's re-examine the evidence. Beaglehole claims: 'So far, there is no evidence that teen vaping leads to smoking.' This is incorrect. I was an investigator on the only New Zealand study to date to directly compare adolescent smoking trends before and after e-cigarettes became available. We found that the decline in 14– and 15-year-olds initiating smoking – and smoking regularly – significantly slowed after the emergence and rise of vaping in New Zealand. Had pre-vaping trends in adolescent smoking continued, the smoking initiation rate in 2023 would have been around 6.6%, rather than the 12.6% it ultimately reached. Also, our new study – published today in The Medical Journal of Australia – adds to the evidence, albeit from the other side of the Tasman. As in New Zealand, we found that Australia's progress in reducing adolescent smoking significantly slowed after the emergence and rise of vaping. In both countries, the pattern is similar in a manner that seems unlikely to be a coincidence. While youth vaping may be less of a problem in Australia than in New Zealand, it is still a serious problem. But it's not just our New Zealand and Australian studies. There is also a large body of evidence from international cohort studies – the strongest type of observational study for understanding cause-and-effect relationships. These studies track individuals over time and have consistently found that adolescents who vape are more likely to go on to smoke. None have yet been conducted in New Zealand, but their findings are so consistent across countries and cultures that it seems likely a New Zealand cohort study would show the same. To suggest all of these studies provide 'no evidence that teen vaping leads to smoking' is simply inaccurate. What about adult smoking? Beaglehole's claim that vaping has significantly contributed to its decline in New Zealand also deserves a closer look. It is true that adult daily smoking in New Zealand declined more sharply than expected between 2020 and 2023 – from 11.9% to 6.8%, a period when daily vaping rose rapidly from 3.5% to 9.7%. This four-year window is what many e-cigarette advocates rely heavily on when declaring victory on behalf of e-cigarettes. But the most recent New Zealand data diverge from that narrative. Despite daily vaping continuing to increase from 9.7% in 2023 to 11.1% in 2024, the rate of daily smoking failed to decrease for the first time in a decade. Other countries offer further reason for caution. In England, although smoking rates declined between 2016 and 2023, there was no acceleration in that decline among adults aged 18-24 and 25-44, despite a sharp rise in e-cigarette use from 2021. Among those aged 45 and over, the decline in smoking not only failed to accelerate – it actually slowed. Smoking rates in New Zealand were already falling before e-cigarettes emerged – and they continued to fall afterwards. This progress is at least partly due to the impact of strong tobacco control policies accumulating over many years – policies that continue to influence smoking patterns today. These include smokefree bars and restaurants, regular increases in tobacco excise taxes, graphic health warnings on packaging, point-of-sale display bans, plain packaging and legislation prohibiting smoking in cars carrying children. At best, vaping may have slightly sped up the decline in adult smoking. At worst, it may have made no difference – or even slowed progress – while embedding a commercial nicotine industry that will be hard to wind back. The risk of overstating the evidence is that it fuels the idea that New Zealand now needs a thriving vaping industry. That if it's reined in, smoking will inevitably rise. It's a convenient narrative. Especially for companies that profit from it. Vaping may have a role to play in quitting smoking. But that doesn't mean efforts to limit access to young people who have never smoked should be dismissed. Now more than ever, New Zealand should double down on a progressive, evidence-based approach to tobacco control. Decades of hard-won progress shouldn't now be handed to an industry eager to claim the credit.
Otago Daily Times
3 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
Less than half of recent nursing graduates employed by Heath NZ
Nursing students and recent graduates say they are being "failed" by Health NZ, which has employed just 45% of mid-year graduates. Health NZ figures show just 323 of 722 applicants have got jobs in hospitals through its Advanced Choice of Employment Mid-Year matching process. Co-president of the Nurses Organisation student unit, Bianca Grimmer - who is set to graduate at the end of the year - said it was "really discouraging". "It's certainly affecting all of our cohorts from year one to year three, lot of uncertainty and students wondering if they continue with their degree or look at finding a job somewhere else. "Te Whatu Ora used to hire 80-90% of all graduates. We were blindsided this time last year when only three in every five mid-year graduates were hired. This year is even worse." Health NZ said for the mid-year matching process, there were 173 applications from graduates who were still looking for jobs after graduating at the end of last year. National Chief Nurse Nadine Gray said those who did not get hospital jobs were placed in the talent pool, which was open to all registered employers across the health sector. In recent years, the majority of initially unmatched applicants had successfully secured positions from the talent pool with about 84% of nurses eventually finding roles in both 2023 and 2024. "Graduate RNs [registered nurses] often look to hospitals for their first role, and while we are working to employ as many graduate RNs as possible, I want to encourage students to look right across the health system when looking for their first job." The government was investing in expanding and strengthening the nursing workforce in primary and community care, Gray said. The investment includes: $30 million over five years to fund 400 graduate nurses into primary and community care each year, with providers receiving $15,000 for employing a nurse in an urban setting and $20,000 in a rural setting. $34.2 million over five years to fund 120 nurse practitioner training places in primary care each year from 2026. An additional $21.6 million over four years to accelerate advanced tertiary education for up to 120 primary care registered nurses annually. The Nurses Organisation said a recent survey of 1246 nursing students found 62% would consider seeking a nursing job overseas if they were unable to get a new graduate job in Aotearoa New Zealand. This increased to 73% for Māori students. Bianca Grimmer said nursing students recently attended a jobs expo where Australian recruiters were offering graduates better wages and conditions. "We have a health system in crisis and desperately need more homegrown nurses. With 30,000 Kiwis leaving for Australia in the past year, this short-sighted decision by Te Whatu Ora will see more graduate nurses packing their bags." About 36,000 of NZNO's Te Whatu Ora members are preparing for a 24-hour national strike on July 30 after Collective Agreement negotiations stalled. The union said Health NZ's "refusal to commit to its obligation to employ new graduates" was one of the sticking points.
RNZ News
3 days ago
- RNZ News
Nursing students, graduates say they are being 'failed' by Health NZ
National Chief Nurse Nadine Gray says those who do not get hospital jobs are placed in the talent pool. Photo: 123RF Nursing students and recent graduates say they are being "failed" by Health NZ, which has employed just 45 percent of mid-year graduates. Health NZ figures show just 323 of 722 applicants have got jobs in hospitals through its Advanced Choice of Employment Mid-Year matching process. Co-president of the Nurses Organisation student unit, Bianca Grimmer - who is set to graduate at the end of the year - said it was "really discouraging". "It's certainly affecting all of our cohorts from year one to year three, lot of uncertainty and students wondering if they continue with their degree or look at finding a job somewhere else. "Te Whatu Ora used to hire 80-90 percent of all graduates. We were blindsided this time last year when only three in every five mid-year graduates were hired. This year is even worse." Health NZ said for the mid-year matching process, there were 173 applications from graduates who were still looking for jobs after graduating at the end of last year. National Chief Nurse Nadine Gray said those who did not get hospital jobs were placed in the talent pool, which was open to all registered employers across the health sector. In recent years, the majority of initially unmatched applicants had successfully secured positions from the talent pool with about 84 percent of nurses eventually finding roles in both 2023 and 2024. "Graduate RNs [registered nurses] often look to hospitals for their first role, and while we are working to employ as many graduate RNs as possible, I want to encourage students to look right across the health system when looking for their first job." The government was investing in expanding and strengthening the nursing workforce in primary and community care, Gray said. The Nurses Organisation said a recent survey of 1246 nursing students found 62 percent would consider seeking a nursing job overseas if they were unable to get a new graduate job in Aotearoa New Zealand. This increased to 73 percent for Māori students. Bianca Grimmer said nursing students recently attended a jobs expo where Australian recruiters were offering graduates better wages and conditions. "We have a health system in crisis and desperately need more homegrown nurses. With 30,000 Kiwis leaving for Australia in the past year, this short-sighted decision by Te Whatu Ora will see more graduate nurses packing their bags." About 36,000 of NZNO's Te Whatu Ora members are preparing for a 24-hour national strike on 30 July after Collective Agreement negotiations stalled. The union said Health NZ's "refusal to commit to its obligation to employ new graduates" was one of the sticking points. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
