In 30 years at The Age, I never wrote on Israel-Palestine. Now, I must
That is partly because the conflict is not primarily religious. But more importantly, as a wise philosopher advised me, when it comes to such controversial and deeply divisive issues, unless you can include every necessary nuance it is better not to write at all. You are more likely to inflame.
So I begin this article with a trigger warning: it is certain to offend almost everyone who is wedded to one side or the other.
If for years I thought, 'how can I write about Israel/Palestine', today I think, 'how can I not?' On October 8, 2023, after the bestial Hamas attack on Israelis, I and millions of others believed Israel had a right to defend itself. Israel's increasingly callous response is steadily eroding that support.
How do we cope with the realisation that the nation that we long saw as a beacon of hope in the Middle East has carried out calculated and unconscionable cruelty? What do we do when our side are the bad guys (or as bad as the other side)?
For decades, Israel was the David facing the Goliath of the Arab world, fighting wars simply to survive in 1948, 1967 and 1973. Today Israel is the Goliath, mercilessly hammering a people who simply cannot resist.
I am half-Jewish (my father's side). Our wider Dutch family was virtually extinguished in World War II: our family book has scores of entries that end 'died: Auschwitz' or Treblinka or Sobibor. I do not claim this gives me an atom of extra moral authority, but it exacerbates my horror.
I ardently support Israel's right to exist. If that makes me a Zionist, then I suggest every decent human being should be. But I simply cannot equate that with today's Israeli government.
Both Israel and Hamas are firing out propaganda as fast as they can, and one has to be wary about accepting claims. Yet the systematic destruction of Gaza and its starving children are clearly not invented, while it is simply unfathomable that Israeli troops are shooting desperate Palestinians as they line up for scarce aid or endorsing awful settler violence on the West Bank. There are claims and counter-claims on these issues, but it is the fact the violence exists that matters.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Age
2 hours ago
- The Age
Why people like me are taking to the streets
To submit a letter to The Age, email letters@ Please include your home address and telephone number below your letter. No attachments. See here for our rules and tips on getting your letter published. PROTESTS There have been questions raised about why people take part in peaceful mass demonstrations (Letters, 5/8). I believe I can give the prime reason. We live large distances away from many of the world's humanitarian problems, but we feel an emotional connection to the people who are suffering in those places. We can't personally express our feelings to them and their rulers, or undertake any meaningful action to help the victims, but we can join together and share our feelings with other concerned, like-minded people here. It is beneficial to us to know that we are not alone in our feelings, whether of anger or grief or anything else, and in so doing feel a sense of solidarity with the far-away victims. Many people will not or cannot write letters to, or phone, our politicians asking them to take action on our behalf, but large gatherings of people are a visible sign to them of how widespread our feelings are. I remember how uplifting an anti-Vietnam march was in helping me feel that there were many others who wanted the pointless killing and destruction to stop. It was a comfort to me. That's reason enough to encourage demonstrations rather than try and forbid them or meet them with police force. That's not what our police should be doing. Don Jordan, Mt Waverley Who will rescue the children? Who is to judge the so-called 'self-righteous anger of Melbourne keffiyeh-wearing performative protesters' (Letters, 4/8)? I was there at Sunday's protest, as I have been before. My feeling was not self-righteous anger, nor righteous anger. It was not anger at all, but sorrow. For the first time I wore a keffiyeh. It was not performance. It was an expression of sympathy with suffering Palestinians. As a Quaker and a pacifist, I would much prefer the protest was in silence for that would reflect the profound sorrow I feel for the lives being lost in Gaza due to starvation, and people being slaughtered as they desperately seek food. In 1939 British Quakers were instrumental in rescuing 10,000 German and Austrian Jewish children in the 'kindertransport' trains that took them to the UK. Who will rescue the Palestinian children now? Dorothy Scott, Macclesfield Symbol of a nation insulted After the burning of the Australian flag at a pro-Palestinian rally it is about time that protests that are disrespectful and disruptive to our citizens be required to meet standards – or else be stopped. Media condemnation is not adequate as a control and deterrent, it probably fuels their actions. This has nothing to do with the freedom to protest – this is about the fabric of and wellbeing of our society. There are laws that restrict what we can say and can do in a social context, added to these are a wide range of subjects that have established standards/norms of acceptable behaviour in Australia. For example, defamation is illegal and we are developing a stronger attitude and community response to domestic violence. Burning our national flag is an abhorrent action. Will they now burn the flag of our Indigenous Australians and Torres Strait Islanders? How do our war veterans and servicemen and women feel when the flag they fought for and stand for is desecrated? Ross Kroger, Barwon Heads Act of shame Unsurprisingly, the cowards burning the Australian flag on the King St Bridge wore masks to hide their identities. They should go live in maybe Iran, Iraq or Syria and see if they feel more comfortable with those countries' flags. Geoff Lipton, Caulfield North Widen support for action Noting the worldwide impetus to urgently end the Gaza war and to establish a Palestinian state, could the pro-Palestine demonstrators consider tweaking the chant from 'Free free Palestine' to maybe 'Two state solution now.' This may assist in increasing more widespread support. And help disarm opposition that now is not the time to recognise a Palestinian state. Carlo Ursida, Kensington THE FORUM Shift the spending Australia is currently looking at investing more than $368 billion into AUKUS to join forces with the US and UK against a prospective battle with China that we do not seek. At the same time we are facing an existential climate crisis, and yet the US has defunded much of its climate forecasting infrastructure (' Trump cuts cast a cloud over Australian forecasting ', 5/8). Surely now is the time for Australia to withdraw from AUKUS, and use the funds saved to provide ourselves (and the world) with detailed, reliable weather information that will identify and track our growing climate risks, and enable us to foresee and protect against the floods, cyclones and droughts which will inevitably intensify over coming years? Chris Young, Surrey Hills
Sky News AU
2 hours ago
- Sky News AU
Albanese snubbed by Netanyahu amid push to recognise Palestinian state
Shadow Assistant Education Minister for Zoe McKenzie says it's concerning Prime Minister Anthony Albanese has been unable to secure a meeting with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. 'It's no doubt of some concern to the prime minister as it is to many Australians that his calls are going unanswered with the important allies,' Ms McKenzie said. 'He's clearly positioning to recognize a Palestinian state … but he must discuss that with the Israeli leadership. 'He needs to have that conversation and discuss what the impact might be in relation to what we need … a community of international pressure on Hamas.'
Herald Sun
2 hours ago
- Herald Sun
Israel poised to order new Gaza war plan
Don't miss out on the headlines from Breaking News. Followed categories will be added to My News. Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu prepared Tuesday to unveil an updated Gaza war plan designed to destroy Hamas and secure the release of dozens of hostages, with Israeli media reporting he would order the total occupation of the Palestinian territory. Netanyahu was expected to meet security chiefs in Jerusalem to issue new orders, even as Israel's diplomats convened a UN Security Council meeting in New York to highlight the plight of Israelis held in Gaza. The timing of the security meeting has not been officially confirmed. Netanyahu said Monday that it would be "in the coming days". Israeli broadcaster Channel 12 said Netanyahu would meet the army chief of staff, and the defence and army ministers. Unnamed senior officials told Israeli media he intends to order the re-occupation of Gaza. "Netanyahu wants the Israeli army to conquer the entire Gaza Strip," said a report on public broadcaster Kan. "Several cabinet members who spoke with the prime minister confirmed that he has decided to extend the fight to areas where hostages might be held." The private daily Maariv declared: "The die is cast. We're en route for the total conquest of Gaza." While the reconquest plan has not been officially confirmed, it has already drawn an angry response from the Palestinian Authority and Gaza's Hamas-run government, which insisted it will not shift its position on ceasefire talks. "We want to reach an agreement that ends the war. The ball is now in the hands of Israel and the Americans, who support Israeli positions and delay the conclusion of an agreement," senior Hamas official Husam Badran told broadcaster Al Jazeera. - Desperate families - After 22 months of combat sparked by the October 7, 2023 cross-border attacks by Hamas that killed 1,219 people and saw hundreds kidnapped, the Israeli army has devastated large parts of the Palestinian territory. More than 60,933 Palestinians have been killed, according to figures from Hams-run Gaza's health ministry, and humanitarian agencies have warned that the territory's 2.4 million people are slipping into a catastrophic famine. But Netanyahu is under pressure on several fronts. Domestically, the desperate and vocal families of the 49 remaining hostages are demanding a ceasefire to bring their loved ones home. Around the world, humanitarians are pushing for a truce to allow in food to the starving, and several European capitals have announced plans to recognise Palestinian statehood, despite fierce US and Israeli opposition. Meanwhile, Netanyahu's far-right allies in his ruling coalition want to seize the opportunity of the war to reoccupy Gaza and tighten control of the occupied West Bank. Foreign Minister Gideon Saar was in New York, where Israel's US ally was helping organise a Security Council meeting to focus world attention on the fate of the hostages rather than the looming famine -- which Israeli spokespeople insist is an exaggerated threat. The defence ministry civil affairs agency for the Palestinian territories, COGAT, said Tuesday that Israel will partially reopen private sector trade with Gaza to reduce its reliance on UN and aid agency convoys and international military airdrops. "As part of formulating the mechanism, a limited number of local merchants were approved by the defence establishment, subject to several criteria and strict security screening," COGAT said. Israel has been fighting Palestinian militant group Hamas in Gaza for 22 months and imposed a total blockade on March 2, partially lifted in May to allow a US-backed private agency to open food distribution centres. Aid convoys and airdrops by Arab and European militaries resumed last month, as UN-mandated expert reports warned famine was unfolding in the war-torn territory. The COGAT statement said private sector deliveries would be paid for by monitored bank transfers and be subject to inspections by the Israeli military before entering Gaza, "to prevent the involvement of the Hamas terrorist organisation." - Staple foods - Permitted goods under the new mechanism will include food staples, fruit, vegetables, baby formula and hygiene products, COGAT said. On Monday. Netanyahu insisted Israel's war goals remained "the defeat of the enemy, the release of our hostages and the promise that Gaza will no longer pose a threat to Israel". His statement came after hundreds of retired Israeli security chiefs wrote to US President Donald Trump to urge him to convince Netanyahu to end the war, arguing that Israel has already scored a military victory and should seek to negotiate the hostages' release. The families of the hostages are also horrified by talk of escalation, accusing the government of putting their relatives in renewed danger, even as Palestinian groups Hamas and Islamic Jihad release propaganda videos showing emaciated captives. dc-hba/ser Originally published as Israel poised to order new Gaza war plan
