‘Picked off' or ‘not that bad'? The hit dividing football - and why it will decide the game's future
May later suffered a concussion of his own when Tom De Koning accidentally kneed him in the head during a last-quarter marking contest, so he will miss Sunday's match against St Kilda anyway.
Comparable recent cases
In May, the tribunal cleared Fremantle captain Alex Pearce after the Dockers successfully argued against Christian's careless classification for his collision with Port Adelaide's Darcy Byrne-Jones.
Pearce's case differed from May's in that it was an aerial collision in a marking contest, but there were similarities in how Pearce arrived second to the ball and took his eyes off it at the last second to brace for contact.
Pearce's legal team did not challenge the classifications of severe impact and high contact.
They argued Pearce's actions were reasonable, with the veteran defender stressing he was making a genuine attempt to complete a chest mark at the point of collision.
However, the case involving North Melbourne's Jackson Archer in March could also be relevant.
Archer's three-game ban for his role in a collision that concussed Western Bulldog Luke Cleary was upheld at the tribunal, after the match review officer graded the Roo's actions as careless, severe impact and high contact.
North's defence focused on Cleary's decision to go to ground to collect the ball, rather than stay on his feet.
Tribunal chairman Jeff Gleeson acknowledged that rules encouraged players to keep their feet, but said that did not always happen and 'players need to be aware', saying Archer had 'slowed too little and too late'.
What others are saying
Former Hawk Isaac Smith's take on May's actions contrasts greatly with King.
Speaking on Nine's Sunday Footy Show, Smith argued that May should not be suspended and that Evans' injuries were an unfortunate consequence of playing a contact sport.
'The only thing I can see the MRO picking up is that he didn't stay low, and he came up a couple of steps before he got to the contest – and that's what caused the impact,' Smith said.
'It's a line-ball one, and it's going to be fascinating to see where it ends up. I feel for Steven May here because I feel like he was contesting the ball and obviously, Evans is a smaller player to what he is.
'I think you can see him getting no weeks, or you can see him getting four weeks. The more I look at it, I think no weeks ... you look at the Alex Pearce one, [and] May has not done anything to initiate that contact.'
Triple M's breakfast crew, including ex-St Kilda champion Nick Riewoldt, grilled Gawn on the May case on Monday.
Gawn was adamant that May did not bump Evans, but that he was 'never going to take a backward step'.
'Whatever happens, will be the precedent. I understand you've got to look after the head, but it's going to be an interesting tribunal case. I might actually watch it,' Gawn said.
'I came in to defend [May] a little bit when it first happened, and the Carlton boys weren't really remonstrating, and then we all had a look at the ground and the guy's tooth was missing, so it was, 'OK, maybe I can't defend 'Maysy' '.
'Then we watched the replay, and we were like, 'Actually, it's not that bad', and the Carlton boys still didn't remonstrate, really, so it's a tough one.'
Riewoldt, who did not believe May's actions were 'malicious', added that the Blues' eventual reaction was 'almost like out of obligation'.
'If he does get rubbed out, then essentially what we're saying is ... players have to be able to calculate from 20 metres away; the speed the other player is going, the speed you're going to be going, and the fact you're going to arrive a microsecond late,' Riewoldt said.
Carlton forward Harry McKay said Nova that it was a 'nasty incident' but that no player would intentionally hit an opponent in the head.
Former greats James Hird and Jimmy Bartel had sympathy for May but expect him to receive a suspension.
Loading
'This is a really difficult one,' Hird said.
'If he had have stayed a little bit lower and kept his eye totally on the ball, he would be OK. But at the last split-second, he comes up, and his eyes go off the ball, which is why I think it will be three weeks.
'I don't think he has gone out on purpose to hurt anybody. Five years ago, it wouldn't have got weeks. But the rules have changed and unfortunately, for him, his shoulder gets him in the head.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Telegraph
9 hours ago
- Daily Telegraph
Hawks respond to Harley Reid rumour as fresh details emerge
Don't miss out on the headlines from AFL. Followed categories will be added to My News. Hawthorn coach Sam Mitchell has provided some insight on whether the Hawks really are 'obsessed' with Harley Reid. Reports earlier this week stated the Hawks were 'obsessed' with Reid and now the Hawks coach has had his say. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer. 'I saw the word obsessed and I went in the next day and I said to a couple of list guys, 'Are we obsessed with Harley Reid?' and then I saw some of the numbers that were getting thrown up and I said 'What is happening here?' And they're like 'just don't even read the papers',' Mitchell said on SEN's Fireball this morning. 'He's obviously a good player but he's contracted to West Coast and he's having a pretty good year. A bit like 'Daysy' getting sat on in his first game back, it's a bit like, 'oh', I mean this 20-year-old is getting sat on most weeks now. He's a good player.' Harley Reid's future remains up in the air. (Photo by) Earlier this week, AFL Media's Cal Twomey reported that the Eagles have put what would be 'the biggest deal in AFL history' to the star youngster, keeping him at West Coast through to the end of 2037 with its value totalling over $20 million. Channel 7's Ryan Daniels said the deal was far more eye-watering with Reid potentially set to pocket $2.2m per season for 11 years. 'The proposed deal would be for two years initially, with an option for Harley to extend that to 11 years, until the end of 2037, and be worth around $2.2 million per season. The total number would likely be north of $24 million,' Daniels said. Reid's manager, Nick Gieschen, has recently arrived in WA and attempted to downplay the reported offer. 'I don't think anyone is ready to be the highest-paid player in the comp,' Gieschen said. 'But nah, we're working through it. Nothing's finalised. We're in negotiations but we'll take every day as it comes. 'Harley is enjoying his time here and like I said before, we're talking about what the future looks like. We're having discussions with West Coast and we'll go from there. 'Nothing in concrete, we're just talking at the moment and we'll see where we get to.' With easily the biggest deal ever seen in AFL history reportedly on the table, it's tough bidding for any Victorian clubs to swoop in and lure him away. 'If I'm really honest I actually don't know. I don't have anything to do with the financial stuff. It doesn't seem right for us. At some point that's going to happen isn't it? Whether it's in this CBA or the next one, but the money in the game continues to go up,' Mitchell said. Harley Reid could be set to sign the biggest contract in AFL history. (Photo by) 'The average salary continues to be higher and higher and higher and as they should be. Everyone wants to play the game and the spectacle of what we're putting on at the moment is pretty good. I think the players deserve what they're getting, it's just how you attribute that. 'With our midfield as an example, being pretty workman-like and making sure that we're consistent across the board. If you're putting $2 million into one player, that makes it a little bit more difficult of course.' As rumours surrounding Reid's future continue to swirl, Eagles skipper Liam Duggan believes the young star will stick with the club. 'I'm really eager for Harley to sign. I mean, he's going to be paid very well regardless of where it is, and he's going to get a long-term deal regardless of where it is,' he said on Triple M. 'But all I can speak of at the moment is that his investment in what we're going after at the moment is second to none. 'He has been so dialled into what we're going after as a footy club at the moment, he's been very vocal in that amongst the group, the way he's playing, you can see that in the way that he's playing, and I think our supporters would be able to see that in the way that he's going about his footy right now.' Originally published as Hawks respond to Harley Reid rumour as fresh details emerge
West Australian
10 hours ago
- West Australian
Fremantle Dockers defender Brennan Cox is flying blind after never playing on West Coast's young key forwards
Fremantle defender Brennan Cox's derby preparations have gone down an unconventional path with the experienced backman having to thoroughly research all of West Coast's key forwards due to the changes at the Eagles this season. The Eagles have named Jobe Shanahan and Archer Reid as their main key forwards to take on the Dockers, which is vastly different to what Cox has usually experienced in derbies when Oscar Allen, Jake Waterman, Jack Darling and Josh Kennedy were the club's obvious focal points. Shanahan is making his derby debut in his fifth AFL game while Reid has come back into the team for the first time since round 13 and will be playing his 12th match. Cox usually has detailed knowledge of his opponent which has been built up through repeated clashes. He said Saturday would pose a totally different type of challenge. 'I haven't played on any of their tall forwards so I'll watch a bit of vision and see what their little tricks are and what they like to do. It'll be interesting,' he said. 'You obviously do learn a bit (during games). Whoever you play on you always keep a little memory of how they went about it, what they didn't like and what they tried to do. It'll be new but it'll be exciting. I'm looking forward to it.' Cox has already had to make plenty of adjustments this season after moving to full-back when captain Alex Pearce's leg injury forced him out of the team. The South Australian has been influential as an intercept marker during his career, but assistant coach Jade Rawlings asked Cox to switch his focus to locking down on the opposition's most damaging key forward. 'It can be a bit nerve-racking playing closer to goal but I enjoy the challenge of coming up on the best forwards in the game and playing deeper. You hope there's heaps of pressure on the ball and they don't get too many looks,' Cox said. 'I'm happy with how I've played. It's been a bit different to other years where we've had Pearcey playing and i was on the second key forward. With him going down and since Twig (Rawlings) came in, he's trusted me with those key roles. 'I wasn't playing with a whole lot of body but since he's come in I've tried to play with more body and make it a really hard day for the forward. Now that I've adjusted to that I'm trying to find the balance between running, jumping and spoiling.'
The Advertiser
11 hours ago
- The Advertiser
Eagles back $20-million man Reid to handle the hype
The numbers are eye-watering, but West Coast coach Andrew McQualter is confident Harley Reid won't feel a burden upon becoming the highest-paid player in the AFL. Reid's contract status has hit the headlines again this week after his manager Nick Gieschen flew to Perth to have further talks with the Eagles. They have tabled a number of different-length deals to Reid, whose current contract runs out at the end of 2026. One is reportedly worth in the vicinity of $24 million over 11 years, with Victorian clubs also willing to offer long-term deals in excess of $2 million a season. Reid is already one of the most talked about players in the league, but can the 20-year-old Victorian handle being the highest paid? When the $20 million-plus figure was put to McQualter, the first-year coach was quick to compare it to how much he himself was paid during his final season as a player in 2012. "My 45,000 on the Gold Coast," McQualter quipped with a laugh. When asked about the burden of Reid becoming the highest-paid player in the league, McQualter said the pressure came from being the best, rather than the money being earned. "For me, I'll take the contract out of it, because I think it's irrelevant," McQualter said. "It's when you're one of the best players in the competition - there's a burden that comes with it, and that's for anyone. "That's what comes with being a great player in our competition, and it's the skill of being able to cope with that. "We train that from a mental perspective. It's challenging, but the best players embrace it, and they go about their business, which I'm sure Harley will be one of those." Reid will be the centre of attention yet again when he lines up in Saturday's western derby against Fremantle. The star midfielder has hit top form in recent weeks, and his performance in the round six derby last year will still be front of mind for Fremantle fans. Reid tallied 19 disposals, seven clearances and three goals to lead the Eagles to an upset 37-point win, and Dockers coach Justin Longmuir said he's well aware of the "threat". "He's a good player. He's one of the most exciting, promising young players in the comp," Longmuir said. Given it's a Fremantle home game, Reid is set to cop plenty of boos. Reid has a tendency to get caught up in battles with rival players or the crowd, but he showed a great deal of restraint and maturity during last week's 49-point loss to Richmond. "I think he certainly embraces it," McQualter said of the booing. "It's a lot for a young man to have that attention, but he seems to cope with it pretty well, and he's getting better. "Last week, when he got thrown into a security guard, he just went and gave a fist bump to the security guard and moved on, which was pleasing to see." The numbers are eye-watering, but West Coast coach Andrew McQualter is confident Harley Reid won't feel a burden upon becoming the highest-paid player in the AFL. Reid's contract status has hit the headlines again this week after his manager Nick Gieschen flew to Perth to have further talks with the Eagles. They have tabled a number of different-length deals to Reid, whose current contract runs out at the end of 2026. One is reportedly worth in the vicinity of $24 million over 11 years, with Victorian clubs also willing to offer long-term deals in excess of $2 million a season. Reid is already one of the most talked about players in the league, but can the 20-year-old Victorian handle being the highest paid? When the $20 million-plus figure was put to McQualter, the first-year coach was quick to compare it to how much he himself was paid during his final season as a player in 2012. "My 45,000 on the Gold Coast," McQualter quipped with a laugh. When asked about the burden of Reid becoming the highest-paid player in the league, McQualter said the pressure came from being the best, rather than the money being earned. "For me, I'll take the contract out of it, because I think it's irrelevant," McQualter said. "It's when you're one of the best players in the competition - there's a burden that comes with it, and that's for anyone. "That's what comes with being a great player in our competition, and it's the skill of being able to cope with that. "We train that from a mental perspective. It's challenging, but the best players embrace it, and they go about their business, which I'm sure Harley will be one of those." Reid will be the centre of attention yet again when he lines up in Saturday's western derby against Fremantle. The star midfielder has hit top form in recent weeks, and his performance in the round six derby last year will still be front of mind for Fremantle fans. Reid tallied 19 disposals, seven clearances and three goals to lead the Eagles to an upset 37-point win, and Dockers coach Justin Longmuir said he's well aware of the "threat". "He's a good player. He's one of the most exciting, promising young players in the comp," Longmuir said. Given it's a Fremantle home game, Reid is set to cop plenty of boos. Reid has a tendency to get caught up in battles with rival players or the crowd, but he showed a great deal of restraint and maturity during last week's 49-point loss to Richmond. "I think he certainly embraces it," McQualter said of the booing. "It's a lot for a young man to have that attention, but he seems to cope with it pretty well, and he's getting better. "Last week, when he got thrown into a security guard, he just went and gave a fist bump to the security guard and moved on, which was pleasing to see." The numbers are eye-watering, but West Coast coach Andrew McQualter is confident Harley Reid won't feel a burden upon becoming the highest-paid player in the AFL. Reid's contract status has hit the headlines again this week after his manager Nick Gieschen flew to Perth to have further talks with the Eagles. They have tabled a number of different-length deals to Reid, whose current contract runs out at the end of 2026. One is reportedly worth in the vicinity of $24 million over 11 years, with Victorian clubs also willing to offer long-term deals in excess of $2 million a season. Reid is already one of the most talked about players in the league, but can the 20-year-old Victorian handle being the highest paid? When the $20 million-plus figure was put to McQualter, the first-year coach was quick to compare it to how much he himself was paid during his final season as a player in 2012. "My 45,000 on the Gold Coast," McQualter quipped with a laugh. When asked about the burden of Reid becoming the highest-paid player in the league, McQualter said the pressure came from being the best, rather than the money being earned. "For me, I'll take the contract out of it, because I think it's irrelevant," McQualter said. "It's when you're one of the best players in the competition - there's a burden that comes with it, and that's for anyone. "That's what comes with being a great player in our competition, and it's the skill of being able to cope with that. "We train that from a mental perspective. It's challenging, but the best players embrace it, and they go about their business, which I'm sure Harley will be one of those." Reid will be the centre of attention yet again when he lines up in Saturday's western derby against Fremantle. The star midfielder has hit top form in recent weeks, and his performance in the round six derby last year will still be front of mind for Fremantle fans. Reid tallied 19 disposals, seven clearances and three goals to lead the Eagles to an upset 37-point win, and Dockers coach Justin Longmuir said he's well aware of the "threat". "He's a good player. He's one of the most exciting, promising young players in the comp," Longmuir said. Given it's a Fremantle home game, Reid is set to cop plenty of boos. Reid has a tendency to get caught up in battles with rival players or the crowd, but he showed a great deal of restraint and maturity during last week's 49-point loss to Richmond. "I think he certainly embraces it," McQualter said of the booing. "It's a lot for a young man to have that attention, but he seems to cope with it pretty well, and he's getting better. "Last week, when he got thrown into a security guard, he just went and gave a fist bump to the security guard and moved on, which was pleasing to see."
