logo
‘Picked off' or ‘not that bad'? The hit dividing football - and why it will decide the game's future

‘Picked off' or ‘not that bad'? The hit dividing football - and why it will decide the game's future

The Age2 days ago
King said on Fox Footy that he believed May 'picked off' Evans in an incident from a 'bygone era', and his hit warranted a six-week suspension.
May later suffered a concussion of his own when Tom De Koning accidentally kneed him in the head during a last-quarter marking contest, so he will miss Sunday's match against St Kilda anyway.
Comparable recent cases
In May, the tribunal cleared Fremantle captain Alex Pearce after the Dockers successfully argued against Christian's careless classification for his collision with Port Adelaide's Darcy Byrne-Jones.
Pearce's case differed from May's in that it was an aerial collision in a marking contest, but there were similarities in how Pearce arrived second to the ball and took his eyes off it at the last second to brace for contact.
Pearce's legal team did not challenge the classifications of severe impact and high contact.
They argued Pearce's actions were reasonable, with the veteran defender stressing he was making a genuine attempt to complete a chest mark at the point of collision.
However, the case involving North Melbourne's Jackson Archer in March could also be relevant.
Archer's three-game ban for his role in a collision that concussed Western Bulldog Luke Cleary was upheld at the tribunal, after the match review officer graded the Roo's actions as careless, severe impact and high contact.
North's defence focused on Cleary's decision to go to ground to collect the ball, rather than stay on his feet.
Tribunal chairman Jeff Gleeson acknowledged that rules encouraged players to keep their feet, but said that did not always happen and 'players need to be aware', saying Archer had 'slowed too little and too late'.
What others are saying
Former Hawk Isaac Smith's take on May's actions contrasts greatly with King.
Speaking on Nine's Sunday Footy Show, Smith argued that May should not be suspended and that Evans' injuries were an unfortunate consequence of playing a contact sport.
'The only thing I can see the MRO picking up is that he didn't stay low, and he came up a couple of steps before he got to the contest – and that's what caused the impact,' Smith said.
'It's a line-ball one, and it's going to be fascinating to see where it ends up. I feel for Steven May here because I feel like he was contesting the ball and obviously, Evans is a smaller player to what he is.
'I think you can see him getting no weeks, or you can see him getting four weeks. The more I look at it, I think no weeks ... you look at the Alex Pearce one, [and] May has not done anything to initiate that contact.'
Triple M's breakfast crew, including ex-St Kilda champion Nick Riewoldt, grilled Gawn on the May case on Monday.
Gawn was adamant that May did not bump Evans, but that he was 'never going to take a backward step'.
'Whatever happens, will be the precedent. I understand you've got to look after the head, but it's going to be an interesting tribunal case. I might actually watch it,' Gawn said.
'I came in to defend [May] a little bit when it first happened, and the Carlton boys weren't really remonstrating, and then we all had a look at the ground and the guy's tooth was missing, so it was, 'OK, maybe I can't defend 'Maysy' '.
'Then we watched the replay, and we were like, 'Actually, it's not that bad', and the Carlton boys still didn't remonstrate, really, so it's a tough one.'
Riewoldt, who did not believe May's actions were 'malicious', added that the Blues' eventual reaction was 'almost like out of obligation'.
'If he does get rubbed out, then essentially what we're saying is ... players have to be able to calculate from 20 metres away; the speed the other player is going, the speed you're going to be going, and the fact you're going to arrive a microsecond late,' Riewoldt said.
Carlton forward Harry McKay said Nova that it was a 'nasty incident' but that no player would intentionally hit an opponent in the head.
Former greats James Hird and Jimmy Bartel had sympathy for May but expect him to receive a suspension.
Loading
'This is a really difficult one,' Hird said.
'If he had have stayed a little bit lower and kept his eye totally on the ball, he would be OK. But at the last split-second, he comes up, and his eyes go off the ball, which is why I think it will be three weeks.
'I don't think he has gone out on purpose to hurt anybody. Five years ago, it wouldn't have got weeks. But the rules have changed and unfortunately, for him, his shoulder gets him in the head.'
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Western Bulldogs watching Fremantle Dockers midfielder Neil Erasmus ahead of trade period
Western Bulldogs watching Fremantle Dockers midfielder Neil Erasmus ahead of trade period

West Australian

time21 minutes ago

  • West Australian

Western Bulldogs watching Fremantle Dockers midfielder Neil Erasmus ahead of trade period

The Western Bulldogs are the latest club keeping a close eye on out-of-favour Fremantle midfielder Neil Erasmus. According to a report, the Bulldogs have interest in the fourth-year midfielder, who has played 10 times for the Dockers this season. Channel 7's Ryan Daniels revealed last month West Coast are watching the Subiaco product's progress. He has played 33 matches for the Dockers since debuting in 2022 but has slipped down in the pecking order behind draft mate Matt Johnson and other midfielders, including Jaeger O'Meara and Nathan O'Driscoll in recent weeks. The 21-year-old is out of contract at the end of this season. According to the Dockers are working to have the midfielder extend his time at the club, but it is understood Erasmus will weigh up opportunity as a major factor in his decision. The Bulldogs this week announced star Marcus Bontempelli has inked a four-year extension, but ageing midfielders Tom Liberatore and Adam Treloar could be close to the end of their careers. Erasmus is a chance to return to the side for Saturday afternoon's western derby clash with the Eagles. Fremantle will weigh him up as a replacement for Johnson, who injured his ankle in Sunday's dramatic win over Collingwood. Fremantle football boss Joe Brierty confirmed he was in the mix after collecting 21 disposals in Peel Thunder's loss to East Fremantle on Saturday. 'There's obviously a number of ways we can structure up the midfield team and allocate some flexibility,' he told SEN. 'Whether that's a Neil Erasmus coming in or Jeremy Sharp, Isaiah Dudley had a strong game. 'He can look to go forward and that can free up some of our forwards to spend some time around the ball. 'There's just a number of ways we can look to have some flexibility in our team.' Erasmus has not played in either of the Dockers' two wins over Hawthorn at Optus Stadium or Collingwood at the MCG. The Subiaco product made the intriguing move to sell a range of his match-worn Fremantle and Thunder merchandise, including the jumper he wore during his Simpson Medal-winning performance in last year's WAFL grand final.

Kosta Barbarouses happy with move to Western Sydney
Kosta Barbarouses happy with move to Western Sydney

Sky News AU

time2 hours ago

  • Sky News AU

Kosta Barbarouses happy with move to Western Sydney

New Western Sydney signing Kosta Barbarouses says there are 'promising signs' for the Wanderers after a successful start to their 2025-26 campaign. Despite a limited preparation, the Wanderers were far too good for NPL Queensland outfit Peninsula Power in Tuesday night's Australia Cup battle at AJ Kelly Park, winning 3-0 to progress to the competition's round-of-16. Veteran attacker Barbarouses scored in his Wanderers debut after joining the club in the off-season from Wellington Phoenix. 'I think we showed a lot of promise in our combinations,' said the 35-year-old New Zealand international after embarking on his stint with a fifth A-League club. 'At times, you could see how dangerous we can be, especially considering most of us have only been working together for a couple of weeks. 'There's plenty of room for improvement, but there were really promising signs. I'm pretty pleased with the performance tonight.' Barbarouses was part of a new look Wanderers forward line alongside fellow off-season signing, ex-Central Coast Mariners striker Alou Kuol, following the departures of Nicolas Milanovic (Aberdeen, Scotland), Zac Sapsford (Dundee United) and Marcus Antonsson (IFK Varnamo, Sweden). The Wanderers squad also includes Socceroos forward Brandon Borrello, who didn't play in Tuesday night's win, which also included a brace from Bulgarian international Bozhidar Kraev. Spanish star Juan Mata, whose Wanderers contract expired at the end of last season, remains in Europe and is still deciding whether to accept Western Sydney's offer of a new deal. Originally published as Kosta Barbarouses has high hopes for Western Sydney Wanderers after winning debut

Prestigious MCC members asked to consider ‘generational change'
Prestigious MCC members asked to consider ‘generational change'

AU Financial Review

time3 hours ago

  • AU Financial Review

Prestigious MCC members asked to consider ‘generational change'

The highly prestigious Melbourne Cricket Club committee is chaired by ex-Transurban and UBS operative Fred Oldfield and totally stacked with luminaries like Goldman Sachs investment banking head Christian Johnston, former Victorian Treasurer Ted Baillieu and ex-EY Oceania chief (now Bupa chairman) Tony Johnson. They oversee an institution to which full membership gets you guaranteed access to Melbourne's most hallowed grounds on its most holy feast days (like the AFL Grand Final), as well as the chance to vote at annual general meetings. Still, there are members and there are members, and knowing how to nominate to the committee used to be a bit tricky. Before the pandemic, to even know an election was coming in time to put one's hat in the ring, you had to walk past just the right poster at the right time. Or just be told, as we're sure was usually the case.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store