logo
Why is a Russian ‘shadow fleet' using Irish waters?

Why is a Russian ‘shadow fleet' using Irish waters?

Irish Times3 days ago
Earlier this month, the Sierra tanker set off from a
Russian
port on the Baltic Sea laden with thousands of tonnes of crude oil and set a course for India.
There was nothing unusual about that – Russia has continued to export vast amounts of fossil fuels despite the international sanctions imposed following its
full-scale invasion of Ukraine
in 2022.
However, when the Sierra, a 250 metre tanker, reached Dutch waters, it did something which left maritime and naval experts scratching their heads. Instead of taking the safest and most economically efficient route through the English Channel and down the coast of France, the ship abruptly turned north.
It sailed all the way around the British Isles into the North Atlantic before coming down the Irish west coast on July 10th. It skirted down the very edge of the Irish Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ) before continuing south to India.
READ MORE
Two weeks previously, the Marathon, another sanctioned vessel carrying Russian oil, made the exact same journey.
The Sierra and Marathon are part of what has become known as Russia's shadow fleet and are just two of an increasing number of vessels which have been engaging in suspicious and sometimes bizarre behaviour around Irish waters in recent months.
This has raised both environmental and national security concerns among Irish officials, especially given Ireland's extremely limited ability to monitor such vessels.
An Irish Times investigation has identified 19 shadow fleet vessels sailing in, or just outside, the Irish EEZ since May.
Five of these ships appeared more than once. All are subject to US or UK sanctions, while 11 are subject to EU sanctions.
[
New €60m sonar system aims to protect transatlantic cables, gas pipelines in Irish waters
Opens in new window
]
The most recent sailing occurred on Saturday when the Matari, a crude oil tanker flagged in Sierra Leone, sailed north through the EEZ on its way to the Gulf of Kola in the Russian Arctic.
There are various definitions of a shadow fleet vessel, but most involve a ship engaging in deceptive practices to transport sanctioned oil or other cargos.
In the majority of cases, these ships fly the flag of a small country with a poor reputation for maritime regulations. Sometimes, as is the case with the Sierra which claims it is flagged in the landlocked African nation of Malawi, the registration is fraudulent (it previously flew the flags of Sao Tome and Principe, Liberia, Gabon and Barbados).
The tally of 19 ships observed around Ireland recently is likely an undercount. The vessels were tracked using tools from Starboard Maritime Intelligence, a New Zealand-based marine software firm, and open source marine tracking platforms. Their location was based on the signals from their automatic identification systems (AIS).
A defining feature of shadow vessels is that they often sail with AIS turned off, which makes them all but impossible to track.
The figure of 19 shadow fleet vessels does not include the Shtandart, a replica of a historic Russian navy ship,
which visited a Co Louth port earlier this month
despite being under EU sanctions.
[
State needs to invest in Navy and Air Corps to beef up our ability to protect vital undersea connections
Opens in new window
]
Many of the recent incidents in Irish waters involved ships engaging in unusual and economically inefficient practices, including sailing outside of recognised shipping lanes and taking the long way around Ireland on the way to the Baltic Sea.
'Vessels don't take longer routes, especially those that include the North Atlantic, unless there's a reason,' said Mark Douglas, a maritime domain analyst with Starboard Maritime Intelligence and a former New Zealand Royal Navy officer.
'The important thing about all of this is, I don't know why this is happening and no one else does either,' he said.
One possible explanation for the growing number of sanctioned ships sailing up the Irish west coast is increased monitoring of traffic in the English Channel by UK authorities.
UK officials are now challenging by radio an average of 40 shadow vessels every month off the British coast as part of a joint campaign with a group of EU countries to tackle Russian sanction busting.
Christian Panton, an expert in maritime open source intelligence, said European countries are increasingly concerned about the presence of unflagged or fraudulently flagged vessels in their waters.
The Russian oil tanker Sierra. Photograph: Marinetraffic/Hannes van Rijn
The Shtandart, a replica of a historic Russian navy ship, in Dublin. Photograph: Nick Bradshaw
He pointed to a recent joint communication from the NB8++, a group of 12 northern European countries, stating that 'if vessels fail to fly a valid flag in the Baltic Sea and the North Sea, we will take appropriate action within international law'.
Ireland is not a member of this group, meaning vessels may feel more comfortable sailing off its west coast than going through the English Channel.
Evidence suggests shadow fleet ships may also be attempting to avoid areas which impose specific environmental conditions on oil tankers.
Since 2005, the Western European Tanker Reporting System (Wetrep) has required oil tankers to provide details of their crews, cargo and seaworthiness when sailing through a designated area.
Ireland is a member of Wetrep and much of its EEZ is classified as a designated reporting area. Several of the shadow vessel ships tracked through the EEZ in recent weeks appeared to be just skirting the Wetrep area, meaning they did not have to provide details on their operations to authorities.
The increased presence of the shadow fleet off Ireland has raised concern among national security officials. During one recent voyage through the English Channel, the Sierra was escorted by a Russian warship which had disguised itself as a fishing vessel.
[
Ireland cannot protect its waters alone, UN expert says
Opens in new window
]
There is concern Russia intends to start regularly providing military escorts for shadow vessels to deter western intervention. This raises the chances of military escalation.
Secondly, there is concern about the activity of shadow fleet vessels around Irish undersea cables. In a small number of cases, vessels have been observed by the
Irish Air Corps
or
Naval Service
loitering in the areas of these cables.
Last March, the Arne, a shadow fleet tanker previously boarded by German federal police over suspicions of sabotage, was spotted by the Naval Service near undersea cables off Cork.
The main risks to undersea infrastructure may come not from deliberate action but from the poor condition of shadow fleet vessels. Douglas points out accidents account for 90 per cent of incidents of damage to undersea cables globally.
Many shadow fleet vessels are in poor condition and are crewed by inexperienced sailors. The countries they are flagged in take little interest in enforcing safety standards or crew working conditions.
All of this raises the danger of an anchor being accidentally dropped and dredged across some cables, said Douglas.
The biggest concern for Irish officials is that the poor condition of these ships could result in an ecological disaster. Eleven of the 19 ships identified in recent weeks were carrying full loads of crude oil when sailing off Ireland.
The clean-up costs for an oil spill from a single shadow fleet tanker could be nearly €750 million, according to recent estimates from the Centre for Research on Energy and Clean Air. Such an incident would be devastating to Irish waters, even if the ship was sailing just outside the EEZ, as was the case with the Sierra and Marathon.
'That is the thing would keep me up at night, more than anything with cables,' said an Irish maritime official. 'There are redundancies built into the cable system. There's no redundancy for an oil spill.'
It is not an entirely hypothetical scenario. In January, the sanctioned tanker Eventin lost control while at anchor off Germany.
The Blue, a sanctioned oil tanker heading for the Baltic, took an unusual route around Ireland. Photograph: Marinetraffic/Hans Rosenkranz
Last week, the Pushpa, a shadow fleet oil tanker, reported losing control about 50 nautical miles off Malta. 'Imagine that on Ireland's Atlantic coast,' said Douglas.
The right of Ireland to do anything about these ships is up for debate. Maritime law is ambiguous about the rights of countries to board or seize shadow fleet vessels.
In April, the Estonian Naval Service boarded an unflagged shadow fleet vessel off its coast, but no other country has taking similar action.
Ireland largely lacks the ability to conduct such operations, but some action is being taken. The
Defence Forces
and
Coast Guard
monitor many of these vessels as they pass through.
The newly acquired Airbus C295 maritime patrol aircraft,
which has extended range and more advanced sensors
than its predecessors, has proven invaluable.
Just last Friday, an Air Corps C295 set a course for the Mayo coast where it monitored the Blue, a sanctioned oil tanker heading for the Baltic and taking an unusual route around Ireland.
It is understood the Defence Forces received prior intelligence about the ship, which has since left Irish waters.
Earlier in the week, it intercepted the Belgorod, another sanctioned tanker sailing north through the EEZ.
A Defence Forces spokesman declined to comment on the operations but said it 'maintains a continuous presence and vigilance within Ireland's maritime domain.
'We monitor all activity within our Exclusive Economic Zone as part of our routine operations to ensure the security and integrity of our waters.'
The Department of Transport, which regulates maritime traffic, said the Irish Coast Guard 'has instituted specific measures to monitor the presence of these vessels and passage through and out of Irish EEZ'.
It said the Coast Guard is specifically concerned about the increased possibility of maritime casualty incidents 'from such vessels'.
A spokesman also pointed to several measures being taken to crack down on shadow fleet vessels operating without maritime insurance. Ireland is taking part in a one-month 'focused inspection campaign' to check the insurance documents of oil tankers calling to ports. It has also signed up to a new EU system to monitor shadow fleet vessels.
Nevertheless, recent events suggest shadow fleet traffic is only likely to increase. Last week, the EU agreed an additional sanctions package for Russia which will further limit the legitimate market for its oil exports and increase Moscow's reliance on its shadow fleet.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Coulson nears $300m deal to walk away from debt-laden Ardagh
Coulson nears $300m deal to walk away from debt-laden Ardagh

Irish Times

time11 minutes ago

  • Irish Times

Coulson nears $300m deal to walk away from debt-laden Ardagh

Businessman Paul Coulson is nearing a deal to walk away from Ardagh Group , the packaging empire he built over the past 25 years, as debt restructuring talks with bondholders reach a pivotal point. Mr Coulson is willing to accept $300 million (€255.6 million), which he would likely have to share with other shareholders in the Ardagh Group, to exit the business, according to sources. This would see Mr Coulson cede control of the glass and metal containers giant, which has a total of about $12.5 billion of borrowings, and abandon previous notions of retaining control of its prized Ardagh Metal Packaging (AMP) arm. A spokesman for Ardagh Group, whose customers range from Coca-Cola and Heineken to Nestlé, declined to comment. Bloomberg first reported that Mr Coulson is close to a compromise. READ MORE The Dublin native controls the parent of the group – ARD Holdings – through a 18.8 per cent direct stake and 52.4 per cent interest in a vehicle that owns 33.9 per cent of ARD Holdings. Ardagh Group has acknowledged for more than a year that it needs to reduce its unsustainable liabilities, after both its glass and beverage cans businesses had been hit since the Covid-19 pandemic by inflation, soaring interest rates, and soft consumer demand on both sides of the Atlantic. [ Meet Paul 'the Cooler' Coulson: One of the godfathers of leveraged finance Opens in new window ] The heavily-indebted business proposed in March that a group of senior unsecured bondholders write off much of the $2.32 billion they are owed in exchange for taking full ownership of the glass containers part of the business. Mr Coulson had planned at the time to give the unsecured creditors just 20 per cent of AMP, which has ring-fenced borrowings and has seen its earnings improve significantly in recent quarters even as the glass business remains under pressure. That proposal failed to progress. Talks are now centred around Mr Coulson exiting entirely, albeit with a pay-off to avoid a likely protracted legal battle over AMP. The drinks unit is listed on the New York Stock Exchange, but remains 76 per cent owned by Ardagh Group. How will the updated National Development Plan shape Ireland in years to come? Listen | 35:59 The market value of AMP has jumped by as much as 60 per cent so far this year to $2.86 billion, driven by a spike in April when its chief, Oliver Graham, signalled that the business had 'turned a corner', helped by a rebound in demand for energy drinks, sparkling water and health segments. AMP reported on Thursday that its earnings before interest, tax, depreciation and amortisation (Ebitda) rose 18 per cent in the second quarter to $210 million. The company upgraded its full-year earnings forecast for a second time and now sees Ebitda rising to $705 million-$725 million from $672 million for 2024. It had started out the year predicting that earnings would fall between $675 million and $695 million. [ Ardagh in talks to hand control of glass business to bondholders Opens in new window ] AMP's global beverage can shipments grew by 5 per cent in the quarter driven by growth of over 8 per cent in the Americas, driven by energy drinks, and expansion of 1 per cent in Europe. 'Our performance is also testament to the resilience of our business, despite macroeconomic uncertainties, with shipments growth reported across each of our markets,' said Mr Graham . 'Global beverage can growth continues to benefit from innovation and share gains in our customers' packaging mix, and we still anticipate only a minimal impact to our business arising from tariff measures announced.' Ardagh Group typically reports results on the same day as AMP. However, it has held off on publishing its figures amid the ongoing debt restructuring talks.

EU pushing to cap future tariffs on pharma in US deal
EU pushing to cap future tariffs on pharma in US deal

Irish Times

time11 minutes ago

  • Irish Times

EU pushing to cap future tariffs on pharma in US deal

The European Union is pushing for any future tariffs on pharmaceutical products sold to the United States to be capped at a blanket 15 per cent rate, in ongoing trade negotiations with US President Donald Trump's administration. Pharmaceutical products have emerged as one potential sticking point in intense EU-US negotiations to land a tariff agreement in the next eight days. The latest outline of a possible deal – the shape of which has changed several times over recent weeks – would see the EU agree to accept tariffs of 15 per cent being charged on most goods sold to the US. The European Commission, the EU's executive arm negotiating for the 27-state bloc, is pushing to have tariffs on pharmaceutical products and cars capped at that level. READ MORE Negotiators for the Trump administration want possible trade levies on pharmaceuticals to be dealt with separately, leaving the door open to the sector facing significantly higher import duties. The fate of pharmaceuticals in any tariff deal has been a key concern of the Government. The industry accounts for the vast majority of the Republic's huge flow of trade across the Atlantic, due to the large number of US pharma giants with manufacturing plants in Ireland. [ Pharma companies unprepared for production shift amid US tariffs Opens in new window ] To date the sector has not been hit with any tariffs, which are effectively taxes on imports. Though Mr Trump has repeatedly said hefty levies are coming, as a way to force drugmakers to relocate manufacturing capacity and jobs to the US. There is some optimism inside the commission that a EU-US deal could be done in the coming days. However, sources in both Dublin and Brussels stressed the unpredictable nature of the talks, which could equally run right up to an August 1st deadline set by Mr Trump, or beyond. Most European businesses have faced US tariffs of 10 per cent since early April, with Mr Trump levelling higher rates of 25 per cent on imports of cars, and a 50 per cent levy on steel and aluminium. How will the updated National Development Plan shape Ireland in years to come? Listen | 35:59 The outline of a potential deal being hammered out could see tariffs on EU-made cars brought down to 15 per cent, in what would be a bit of a reprieve for Germany's large automobile industry. It is understood existing tariffs on steel may be dealt with separately, possibly through some workaround such as a quota system, to lessen the impact of the US import duties. Several sources briefed on the ongoing negotiations said a 15 per cent tariff on most EU products sold to the US appeared largely settled between the two sides. [ EU backs potential counter-tariffs on €93bn of US goods if no deal Opens in new window ] Much of the recent focus of talks between officials has been on specific sectors, such as pharmaceuticals, cars, steel, and semiconductors. Any negotiated agreement would be subject to a final sign off by Mr Trump. Some European industries would be exempt from US tariffs, with aircraft, spirits and some medical devices believed to be in the frame to be spared, according to several sources. Both sides were close to a deal earlier this month, before Mr Trump instead threatened to triple existing tariffs charged on EU trade to 30 per cent from August 1st. European governments have been keen to agree some type of bare bones trade agreement with the US, to avoid the prospect of those higher tariffs kicking in.

Government unveils plan to tackle insurance costs
Government unveils plan to tackle insurance costs

Irish Times

time41 minutes ago

  • Irish Times

Government unveils plan to tackle insurance costs

A new plan from the Government is aiming to tackle rising insurance premiums, with plans for a transparency code and measures to boost competitiveness. The Action Plan for Insurance Reform contains 26 actions across the Departments of Finance , Justice, and Enterprise, and has identified 10 priorities that will have the biggest impact on insurance affordability, transparency and availability. It builds on the measures announced in 2020, and will cover up to 2029. Amont the six key themes of the plan are transparency, competitiveness, fraud and innovation. The Department of Finance is set to work with the insurance sector to bring in a Transparency Code, while there are also plans to strengthen the powers and remit of the Injuries Resolution Board. Tougher penalties for insurance fraud are also being considered, and measures to reduce the number of uninsured drivers are being examined. READ MORE The plan comes barely a fortnight after Minister for Justice Jim O'Callaghan has bowed to pressure on a plan by the Judicial Council to hike personal injury award guidelines by almost 17 per cent, confirming that he will not ask the Oireachtas to rubber stamp the judiciary's proposed tweak to payouts. 'In a rapidly changing global environment, we must place an unrelenting focus on enhancing our competitiveness and controlling the controllables. This means ensuring the cost of doing business is not prohibitive for our SMEs,' said Tánaiste Simon Harris. 'It is vital that Ireland does what it can to support businesses to thrive. This new Action Plan builds on the strong insurance reforms to-date which have led to improvements in transparency and have seen personal injury awards reduce. By Government working together, we can deliver tangible progress in this next phase of insurance reform so that the benefits are felt by both businesses and consumers.' The insurance industry broadly welcomed the plan, with Brokers Ireland calling it 'a meaningful opportunity to build a more affordable, transparent, and competitive insurance market in Ireland.' 'The IRB has a critical role to play in lowering the cost of insurance and improving the speed and fairness of outcomes,' said Hazel Rock, head of insurance services at the group. 'Making its awards binding in more cases and encouraging default mediation would represent a step change in how injury claims are managed in Ireland,' she added. The Alliance for Insurance Reform meanwhile urged immediate reductions in premiums across the board. 'Policyholders should not have to wait a day longer to see meaningful and sustained reductions in their premiums and any attempt to use today's action plan as reason not to pass on existing savings, must be pushed back strongly against by government,' it said in a statement.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store