Donegal landlord must pay €15,000 in damages after ending tenancy
A Residential Tenancies Board tribunal described as 'profound' the consequences suffered by Claire Friel and her family who resorted to living in two separate mobile homes after their tenancy was terminated.
Ms Friel, who lived at the house in Termon, Letterkenny, with her partner, David McLaughlin, and their five children since 2015, received a notice of termination in October 2022 from their landlord, Declan Breslin, who claimed he required the property for his daughter.
Ms Friel claimed Mr Breslin subsequently began to engage in 'intimidating behaviour' after her partner requested more time to find alternative accommodation before the May 2023 vacate date.
READ MORE
This, she claimed, included blocking her car on the road with his car, calling her on the phone 'without saying anything' and threatening them with legal action.
Ms Friel also alleged that Mr Breslin told locals the tenancy was being terminated due to rent arrears, which was 'completely untrue'.
After vacating the house in November 2023, the family of seven purchased and moved into two mobile homes located on land belonging to a relative, at a cost of about €35,000.
She told the tribunal she had been in 'constant contact' with Donegal County Council about accommodation, adding 'there simply were not any suitable houses to rent'.
The cost of the 'cold and damp' mobile homes, she said, 'drained' the couple's savings, adding that they, and her mother, also took out loans.
Ms Friel also claimed her mother and former neighbours described no signs of anyone living in the house after the family vacated.
She added that her former landlord retained the deposit of €500, which Eimer Taylor, a solicitor representing Mr Breslin, attributed to 'confusion' surrounding Housing Assistance Payments.
Ms Taylor claimed Bredagh Breslin, Mr Breslin's daughter, was in the house from December 2023 until December 2024.
She added that Ms Breslin 'works all over' and was in Florida in the United States at the time of the hearing and could not attend to give direct evidence.
Mr Breslin, who said his daughter now lived in Athlone with her husband when not travelling, claimed she moved in before Christmas 2023, stayed for about a week, 'and was then away again, travelling'.
He said his daughter had not stayed full-time in the house but 'went for weekends regularly'.
Mr Breslin argued he had been 'very fair' to Ms Friel in giving an extra period from May until November, but that it was not his responsibility to house his former tenant's family.
Noting the reason for the termination being that his daughter required the house, expecting to occupy it indefinitely, which would be a valid ground for termination, the tribunal said it was 'not convinced by the bona fides of the landlord's intentions' and deemed the notice of termination to be invalid and unlawful.
Noting Mr Breslin's evidence that his daughter 'spent weekends on and off in the dwelling', the tribunal said: 'He gave no evidence and none was provided that Ms Breslin required it for her occupation on an indefinite basis.'
Describing the consequences of the termination for Ms Friel's family as 'profound,' it noted the costs incurred in establishing new living arrangements, which were 'entirely inappropriate living conditions for a family of seven people with young children'.
The tribunal ordered Mr Breslin to pay his former tenant €15,000 in damages for unlawfully terminating the tenancy, alongside the €500 deposit and a further €500 for unlawfully retaining the deposit.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
a minute ago
- Irish Times
Cyclist seriously injured following collision with car in west Dublin
Gardaí are investigating an incident in which a cyclist was seriously injured after being hit by a car in Clondalkin, west Dublin on Sunday night. The cyclist, who is in his late teens, was struck by the car on Fonthill Road South at about 11.40pm. He was taken to Beaumont Hospital where he is said to be in a critical condition. No other injuries were reported. READ MORE The road was closed for forensic examination, and local traffic diversions were put in place on Fonthill Road South, between the junctions with Cherrywood Avenue and St John's Road. Gardaí are appealing for any witnesses to come forward. Road users who may have relevant camera footage, including dashcam footage, are asked to make it available to gardaí. Anyone with information is asked to contact Clondalkin Garda station at 01 666 7600, the Garda Confidential Line at 1800 666 111, or any Garda station.
Extra.ie
an hour ago
- Extra.ie
GAA pay tribute to mother and children killed in Fermanagh shooting
A heart-wrenching tribute was paid at Croke Park for the mother and two children killed in Co Fermanagh last week. It took place ahead of the All Ireland Senior Football final in memory of Vanessa Whyte and her children, James and Sara who were fatally injured following a shooting at their home on Wednesday. The trio's names appeared on a screen alongside their picture while a minute's applause took place before Kerry faced off Donegal. It took place ahead of the All Ireland Senior Football final in memory of Vanessa Whyte and her children, James and Sara who were fatally injured following a shooting at their home on Wednesday. Pic: Facebook Veterinary surgeon Ms Whyte was in her 40s and originally from Co Clare. A man remains in hospital following gunshot wounds with the Police Service of Northern Ireland (PSNI) believing the horror incident was an attempted murder-suicide. The popular matriarch had played camogie for the local club, St Joseph's Doora Barefield, with locals telling of her love of hurling and Clare GAA. Vanessa, James & Sara remembered in @CrokePark today at the @officialgaa All Ireland. 💚🤍 — Fermanagh GAA (@FermanaghGAA) July 27, 2025 St Josephs' Doora Barefield GAA club said it was 'shocked and saddened to hear of the tragic passing yesterday of Barefield native Vanessa Whyte and her two beautiful children James and Sara in Fermanagh'. After relocating to the North, Vanessa joined St Patrick's Lisbellaw Hurling Club, where her children were also members. No funeral details have been released for the family as of yet, though it is expected it will take place in Vanessa's native of Clare. After relocating to the North, Vanessa joined St Patrick's Lisbellaw Hurling Club, where her children were also members. Pic: PSNI/PA Wire Fr Tom Fitzpatrick, parish priest in Barefield, Co. Clare, told Clare FM last week that though no details have been finalised, it's the family's wish that the funeral be held in Clare. Clare FM reported that Ms Whyte 'was a frequent visitor to friends and family in Barefield and was a keen Clare GAA supporter, even attending last year's All-Ireland hurling final with Sara and James'. A vigil took place over the weekend at Maguiresbridge Primary School, where James and Sara had both previously attended. School principal Honor Irvine described the two sporty kids as popular, noting she had taught them both for two years. 'James was full of fun, always laughing, loved to get a laugh, loved to be outdoors. Sara was the same. Sara loved outdoors, bit of a tomboy, and the two of them got on very well, [had] lots of friends and were very popular in school' she said.
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
Halt in decline of Garda resignations sparks concern
A decline in the number of resignations from An Garda Síochána recorded last year has halted, dashing hopes that the high level of early departures from the force was part of a short-term trend during the Covid pandemic years. For decades, the number of gardaí leaving the force before being eligible to retire on full pensions was low. However, it jumped from 69 in 2020 to 171 in 2023, a near-250 per cent increase. Last year, resignations declined by about 20 per cent, to 138, though that decline has not continued in the first six months of this year, when there were 68 resignations. If that pace continued for the remainder of the year, the total would be the same as last year's. Shortages of personnel continue to hamper police work across the State, from responding to emergencies to investigating crimes. READ MORE However, the Garda has insisted the level of resignations is much lower than in other sectors and far below that in other police forces. 'Despite the extensive commentary and public narrative on a crisis on resignations in An Garda Síochána, the resignation rate remains at approximately 1 per cent,' Garda Headquarters said in reply to queries. It said this is far below the rate in other police services, citing a figure of up to 10 per cent in the UK, and the private sector, where it said the rate was 10 to 20 per cent. The force said some of those who had left were subject to internal discipline and opted to resign from the organisation rather than be dismissed. Twelve gardaí who had previously resigned were reattested in recent months and applications from others seeking to rejoin are under consideration. [ Garda resignations surge to record high in 2023 Opens in new window ] The Association of Garda Sergeants and Inspectors (AGSI) said the Government is already set to miss its recruitment targets less than a year into office. The Garda Representative Association (GRA) said the next Garda commissioner, due to be appointed on Tuesday, must address 'high levels' of resignations. Recruitment has begun to increase the strength of the Garda over the past 12 months, to 14,300 at present. However, that remains below the target of 15,000 minimum, with the long-term aim of growing to 18,000. The number of resignations is a concern because recruitment to the force has been sluggish since the Garda College in Templemore, Co Tipperary, reopened after being forced to close during the pandemic. Though there is capacity at the college to take in four 200-strong classes of recruits per year, classes have been smaller, with 630 recruits starting training last year. [ Garda numbers set for significant decline, sergeants and inspectors warn Opens in new window ] Some of those offered places have moved on to take other jobs, or have emigrated, by the time their applications to join the Garda have been approved and their start date for Templemore is set. Garda Headquarters has vowed to streamline that process; other ideas to bolster recruitment include satellite garda training centres, home study, and directly hiring specialists with the required skills. The trainee allowance is now €354 per week, almost double the rate in 2023. The maximum age for new recruits has increased from 35 to 50.
