Sydney hospital's plan to increase mental health beds stymied by psychiatrist shortage, court hears
Dr Brett Oliver, director of medical services for the South Western Sydney Local Health District, appeared on Wednesday as a witness for NSW Health on day three of its arbitration with the doctors' union in Sydney's industrial relations commission (IRC) court.
The Australian Salaried Medical Officers' Federation (Asmof) is seeking a special levy to increase its psychiatrist members' pay by 25% to stem the flow of specialist doctors leaving the public system.
In January, 206 psychiatrists in New South Wales threatened to resign: at least 62 have resigned, while others await the IRC outcome.
Under cross-examination by Asmof's barrister, Thomas Dixon, Oliver confirmed that Campbelltown hospital had a plan to increase its 66 beds for psychiatric patients to over 100.
Sign up for Guardian Australia's breaking news email
The expansion was meant to accomodate increased mental health presentations due to the district's expanded population but could not go ahead due to shortages of psychiatrist staff, Oliver said.
The hospital had also been unable to use extra adolescent mental health beds while an old age mental health unit's opening was delayed due to staff shortages, he said.
Oliver confirmed the district had been using visiting medical officers (VMO) to cover shortages of permanent staff specialists.
The district's clinical director for old age psychiatry was previously a staff specialist employed full time, but since transitioning to a VMO contract, had worked 0.8 or 0.6 full-time equivalent (FTE), Oliver said. He agreed that fractional appointment of a VMO was 'fairly typical'.
VMOs are senior doctors who provide services on a contractual basis. Asmof's case has repeatedly emphasised the difference between VMOs' duties – focused on clinical care – and permanent staff specialists who the union says for a lower hourly rate of pay also contribute to a hospital's leadership, safety and quality of work, and the education and training of junior doctors.
But Dr Justine Harris, NSW Health's chief medical workforce advisor, also appearing as a witness for NSW Health on Wednesday, disagreed under cross-examination by Dixon that there were differences in the type and quality of work undertaken by staff specialists compared with locums and VMOs.
Since January, 72 permanent staff specialist psychiatrists had transitioned to VMO roles across NSW. Alfa D'Amato, NSW Health's chief financial officer, said the government had not yet costed the replacement of permanent staff specialists by VMOs.
Sign up to Breaking News Australia
Get the most important news as it breaks
after newsletter promotion
Dixon put to D'Amato that NSW Health spent $97.4m to fund 196.4 FTE VMO positions in 2023-24, working out at close to $500,000 per FTE doctor, as opposed to paying $119m for 300 FTE permanent staff specialists, or $396,000 per doctor.
Asked if VMOs were more expensive, D'Amato said it 'seems the case', but said it was necessary to account for additional costs, such as staff specialists being paid annual leave.
Dixon highlighted that in 2023-24, NSW Health additionally spent $37m on commission fees paid to locum agencies, which a parliamentary inquiry had revealed was a $20m increase on the prior year.
D'Amato said VMOs took on 'additional work', but when pressed by Dixon, agreed he had no knowledge of whether VMOs provided additional work above and beyond that of staff specialists.
Dixon put to another witness for NSW Health, industrial relations director Melissa Collins, that VMO hours logged in the system were overinflated, citing evidence of a VMO being paid for 10 hours when they had only worked eight.
Collins said any uplift in hours could have been to meet a rate set in a verbal agreement between a district and a doctor within an individual contract.
The hearing, which is scheduled to run until Friday, continues.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
2 days ago
- Daily Mail
Urgent warning over triple virus threat striking the country - as experts reveal how you can avoid getting sick
A growing number of Aussie households are falling victim to a trifecta of nasty viruses as cases of influenza, Covid and RSV skyrocket across the country. More than 50,000 flu cases were detected in the first two weeks of July, with cases the highest in NSW (17,112), followed by Victoria (9,991) and Queensland (6,620). Covid and RSV cases were sitting at around 13,000 cases for the same period. The latest Australian Respiratory Surveillance report also found a 50 per cent increase in hospital admissions for the flu, with the majority of cases influenza A, and a worrying increase in patients requiring ventilators to help them breathe. Deakin University epidemiologist Catherine Bennett said that since April, more people have been hospitalised for the flu than RSV or Covid. 'It is worrying regarding the number of influenza hospitalisations and deaths,' she said. 'Influenza vaccine data shows vaccine uptake is still at the lower end of that seen over the past few years, including the most at risk group over 65 years of age.' NSW Health reports influenza activity has increased 42 per cent for the week ending on June 28, while in Queensland, influenza hospitalisations have skyrocketed. 'Since the start of the year, nearly 3,600 people have been hospitalised with flu – with 90 per cent of patients not vaccinated. This year's flu hospitalisations are nearly 16 per cent higher than the same period last year,' a spokesman said. Currently, national coverage is sitting at 28.9 per cent for the 2025 flu season and only 13.7 per cent of children aged five to 14 years old are vaccinated. Professor Bennett said influenza and Covid has peaked in NSW, but not in Victoria. While there is no surveillance data to examine correlations between illness severity and vaccination status, studies continue to show Covid booster doses reduced the risk of severe disease against the current dominant variants. RACGP vice president Dr Ramya Raman said from May to June 2025, monthly influenza cases have more than doubled in most states off the back of one of the worst flu seasons on record in the Northern Hemisphere. She said so far this July more than 16,000 Covid cases, 57,000 flu cases and 18,600 RSV notified cases had been lab-confirmed. She said the data is trending in a worrying direction. 'I've been in clinic for the last few weeks and certainly during the July school holidays I've seen a significant number of patients who have been unwell with respiratory symptoms and have tested positive to the flu or Covid,' she said. Dr Raman recommended people wear a mask in public to reduce the risk of transmission and talk to their GP about vaccination. 'Flu immunisation coverage is down, so if [patients] haven't had a flu shot this year, now is the time. We can't be complacent,' she said. 'We can keep everyone safer, including those too young to get a vaccine, by reducing the severity and caseload of influenza in the community. 'That means fewer hospitalisations, fewer deaths, and easier recovery.' There were 581 Covid-related deaths in the first four months of 2025, down 52 per cent from January to April 2024. There have been 180 deaths due to influenza in the first four months of 2025, a 73 per cent increase on the same period last year. There have been 19 deaths due to RSV published in the first four months of 2025.
The Sun
5 days ago
- The Sun
My little boy came home from school trip with 2nd degree BURNS after he was left to fry in 30C heat with no suncream
A FURIOUS dad has slammed teachers for allowing his child to 'fry in 30-degree heat without sun cream' on a school trip. Simon Oakley claims his 12-year-old son Oliver came home from Barcelona with agonising second degree burns. 4 4 4 4 The Parklands High School pupil set off for Spain from Chorley, Lancashire, for a week-long holiday with classmates and spent nearly 24 hours travelling to the country via coach. But fuming dad Simon says the nightmare happened on the final day when the school trip took them to a water park. Simon, a self-employed furniture maker, said: "When I saw how bad the burns were, I was extremely upset. 'I feel incredibly let down and disappointed with the school. 'Oliver told me that the sunburn happened on the final day. The kids spent the full day at a water park. 'We later learned from Oliver that he hadn't had any sun cream on all day and wasn't wearing a T-shirt or a hat." Simon continued: 'This left him fully exposed to the 30-degree sun and heat. 'We found out about his sunburn on Thursday evening while he was travelling back. 'He sent us a few messages saying his shoulders and back were really sore, and even did a short video so his mum and I could see how red and blistered his skin was. 'Over the next 48 hours, the blisters got much worse and new ones kept developing.' I laid on the beach for just ONE hour but the sunburn was brutal and left me looking like a wasp-stung dog - don't make my mistake Simon claims Oliver was given paracetamol and heavy-duty plasters were applied to his burns but the youngster was in 'agony' by the time he got home. Oliver's parents rushed him to Preston Royal Hospital for treatment. Nurses allegedly confirmed that the burns were of a second degree nature and popped his blisters before peeling away the damaged skin. Simon said: 'They headed home straight from the water park at around tea time. 'It was only on the bus journey back, which took over 24 hours, that the burns and blisters started to develop and he was in agony for the majority of the journey back. 'He did let the teachers know towards the end of the journey, and they stuck some plasters on his blisters and gave him a paracetamol.' The family have since lodged a formal complaint with the school. 'SCREAMING IN AGONY' Simon was left unimpressed with the school's response to the situation, he claimed: 'They gave him some paracetamol and then applied heavy-duty plasters to the blisters. 'The plasters had to be peeled off the next day at hospital, which left Oliver screaming in agony and in tears on the floor. 'I submitted a formal complaint to the school. The headteacher phoned me back but I was essentially told there was nothing more that could have been done for my son - even though seven teachers were on the trip.' Parklands High School were contacted for comment on multiple occasions but a reporter was told over the phone by a receptionist that 'no one was available' to comment. Oliver went on the school trip on May 24 to May 30. But his dad says it has taken the child's skin 'about a month' to 'get back to normal' and he has some very faint scars from the burns. Simon added: 'He's okay now but is a little wary about going out in the sun because of what happened. "I just want other parents to know this can happen and schools need to take sun safety seriously. 'No child should come home in that kind of pain after what's meant to be a fun trip."
The Independent
6 days ago
- The Independent
Pensioner accidentally pepper sprays entire spa, injuring 13 people
An 80-year-old woman is being investigated by police after accidentally letting off pepper spray in a spa in Germany. At around 9.50am on Wednesday, the pensioner began rummaging through her handbag in the entrance of the Keidel Thermal Baths in Freiburg, a city in southwest Germany's Black Forest region. According to local media, she wanted to show the spray to a friend. Instead, she accidentally activated the spray, releasing the toxic substance throughout the foyer. The irritant then reportedly spread throughout the building through the ventilation system. Thirteen visitors to the thermal baths were affected by the incident and complained of eye irritation. Emergency services, including police and fire personnel, attended the scene and treated the injured. According to BILD, the pensioner was one of those injured. The entire pool was evacuated for around 30 minutes for safety reasons, while the entrance area was mechanically ventilated by emergency services, before guests were allowed to return. The 80-year-old is reportedly being investigated for negligent bodily harm. In a statement to The Independent, Oliver Heintz, director of Keidel Mineral-Thermalbad, said:'We regret the incident and the inconvenience caused to our guests. 'The situation was handled quickly and professionally by our team and the emergency services. 'We are in close contact with the authorities and will take the necessary steps to support a thorough clarification.' The Independent has contacted local police for further comment. Pepper spray is a non-lethal self-defence tool made from oleoresin capsicum (OC), a chemical derived from hot chilli peppers. It causes a severe burning sensation in the eyes, skin, and respiratory system, leading to temporary blindness, coughing, difficulty breathing and intense pain. Pepper spray is illegal to buy, sell or carry in the UK and is classed as an offensive weapon. In Germany, however, pepper spray is legal for use against animals and people 'in self-defence situations' and can be purchased by people as young as 14 years old. In 2023, an American Airlines flight was forced to land more than 800 miles from its destination after a passenger released pepper spray into the cabin. The incident was described by one passenger as 'incredibly scary not being able to breathe'. According to the US Transportation Security Administration, pepper spray is not allowed in carry-on bags.
