Murder through monologue
It is the outwardly and sometimes inwardly charming Joe we are concerned with today with You Season 5 having crawled to an end. For as long as we have known him, Joe (Penn Badgley) has been spreading murder and mayhem wherever he goes, be it a bookstore in New York, a suburb in Los Angeles, or within the affluent confines of South Kensington in London.
In his latest and most ludicrous outing yet, Joe relocates to New York from his brief but characteristically violent spell in London, having persuaded his otherwise intelligent love interest (Kate Lockwood, played by Charlotte Ritchie) from the previous season to marry him. Will their wedded bliss continue to bloom? As you may have already surmised, it does not.
A rocky road
We enter season 5 three years into Joe and Kate's marriage. Joe's son Henry – whom he had abandoned for the previous season – now lives with them. For viewers who have forgotten, Joe had disposed of Henry's mother during an earlier encounter in season 3. Kate, who is in the dark about all this, is startled to learn that Joe is not quite the easily led white knight she had originally hoped for.
Whilst Kate is perfectly happy for Joe to kill on command when the situation demands it, she cannot understand why he is not racked with insomniac guilt like other normal people (i.e. herself). In other words, she wants to have her cake and eat it too.
On the other side of the equation, a hurt and bewildered Joe cannot for the life of him fathom Kate's opposition to murder for what they have both agreed is for (their) greater good. In Joe's eyes, his past actions have proved a more heroically blameless man has never existed. (Relatedly, he remains convinced he is also father of the year despite the niggling issue of having killed his son's mother that one time.) Kate's inhibitions vis a vis murder irk Joe to no end and pave his backslide as he encounters his most boring love interest yet: Bronte (Madeline Brewer).
If you are open to being emotionally manipulated as a viewer, unlike the denizens of Reddit and IMDb, you may be willing to overlook Bronte's objective dullness. Bronte swans into Joe's life via his largely empty bookstore and successfully woos him over with talk of literature. (This may be one of the most unbelievable aspects of You: stumbling upon a man interested in literary fiction.)
Unless you are a very gullible Joe busy handing over your heart, Bronte's true motivations remain a question mark throughout her time on the show. However, since the new love of Joe's life remains as interesting as a bowl of soggy bran flakes, you lack any emotional capacity to care why she does any of the things she does.
To compensate for Bronte's boring interlude, however, faithful viewers will be rewarded cameo appearances from all the people Joe has wronged over the years, much in the same way the Seinfeld series finale brought back Babu and the Bubble Boy for that one glorious day in court. All is not lost.
Insanely absurd
Kate has bigger problems than just a wayward husband (or so she thinks). For example, her sister Raegan, who is acting very strangely indeed, appears to be engaging in all sorts of shady nonsense in the family business. Due to not being privy to Joe's inner monologue, Kate has no way of realising that Joe is not entirely blameless in this Raegan situation. Unbeknownst to her (her husband is not in a sharing mood after Kate's reservations regarding violence), Joe cannot resist meddling in his wife's affairs and dealing with Raegan in his own special way.
Unfortunately for both him and us, things unravel as if plotted by a fourteen-year-old writing fan fiction. That is the thing to be said for You: it never shies away from the insanely absurd. Instead, it goes the other way and embraces it like a long lost brother. Just when you think you know where you are headed, along comes a mad plot twist to wrench you off course and bait you into the next episode to tentatively check if common sense will ever make a comeback.
Great news for common-sense haters: it doesn't. And why should it? Rationality has no place in a show about a well-read good-looking serial killer with an alluring baritone, and you will be relieved to learn that as the seasons progress, You liberates itself entirely from the shackles of cold hard logic. Mistaken identities, a twin switcheroo (Sherlock from Sherlock would be appalled), a heavy reliance on pop culture knowledge, girl-fixes-boy tropes, suspiciously clean glass cages with not a fingerprint in sight, a UK Home office that grants visas with the scantest of background checks, a rich woman who can click her fingers and make murder charges poof into thin air – this is not a short list. You invites you to not only suspend your disbelief, but to shred it to pieces.
Is this the end?
Who knows? When it comes to television, you can never be too sure if producers and writers will stick to their word after promising they have finished. For example, we all thought we had seen the last of Dexter after his questionable lumberjack era in Dexter: New Blood, and look at us now.
Poring over Dexter's troubled youth in Dexter: Original Sin to see what started his serial killing journey. On TV, the dead can be revived in a manipulative 'haha, fooled you' moment, and the imprisoned can dig their way out of jail, if they are dedicated enough. Throughout this roller coaster of a journey, however, one question, however, remains unanswered. How on earth does Joe keep his glass cage so sparkly? Out of all the things he shares with us, Joe never does let us in on that particular secret.
But do not despair. Despite Netflix swearing this is the last of You, we may hear from Joe again one day. As the saying goes, anyone can be a murderer if they have a good reason and a bad day – and as Joe's fans and wives come to know exceedingly well, here is a man who often finds good reasons on as many bad days. All he needs is one more wretched day and an excellent reason, and he may be back to murder and maim once more. And this time, let us know about that glass cage.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Express Tribune
20 hours ago
- Express Tribune
'Demon Slayer Infinity Castle' sets new box office record in Japan with highest opening weekend
Demon Slayer: Infinity Castle has achieved a record-breaking debut at the Japanese box office, setting the highest opening weekend earnings in the country's history. According to Crunchyroll, the film earned ¥7.31 billion (approximately USD 49.55 million) within four days of release, with over 5.16 million tickets sold. Its three-day opening total reached ¥5.52 billion (USD 37.42 million). The film, which begins the climactic arc of the Demon Slayer series, follows the Hashira Training arc and is the first in a trilogy set to conclude the main story. Infinity Castle has received a 9.3/10 rating on IMDb, with fans praising its animation quality, emotional depth, and large-scale production. Premium formats contributed to the film's total, with Deadline reporting $3.5 million from IMAX screenings. While the film has surpassed the opening weekend record previously held by Demon Slayer: Mugen Train, it has not yet approached Mugen Train's lifetime box office figure. Demon Slayer: Mugen Train remains the highest-grossing anime film in Japan, with a total of ¥40.4 billion (around USD 507 million) worldwide. Infinity Castle will continue its rollout internationally, premiering in Southeast Asia on August 12, followed by Latin America, Australia, and the Middle East on September 11, and in the US, UK, Canada, and India on September 12. European markets will follow, with France on September 17 and Germany on September 18.
Express Tribune
3 days ago
- Express Tribune
Russo brothers direct post-credits scene in Fantastic Four First Steps to set up Avengers Doomsday
The Fantastic Four: First Steps director Matt Shakman has confirmed that Joe and Anthony Russo helmed one of the film's post-credits scenes, setting up the upcoming Avengers: Doomsday. In a conversation with Shakman explained that he was happy to pass the baton to the Russo Brothers, praising them as 'amazing' and 'generous' collaborators. He noted they were present during filming, eager to understand the new interpretations of Reed, Sue, Johnny, and Ben to ensure continuity and character integrity in future MCU entries. 'They're really good protectors of these characters as well,' Shakman said. 'I often think of working at Marvel like running a relay race… I passed it on to Joe and Anthony and they're off and running.' The moment mirrors Thunderbolts, where director Jake Schreier also handed off characters to future Marvel projects. The Russo Brothers' return to post-credit scene direction brings a sense of significance back to the tradition, reminiscent of the Infinity Saga's impactful stingers. Some recent Multiverse Saga teases have lacked narrative weight by comparison. New fan screenings of The Fantastic Four: First Steps continue to generate glowing reactions online. Set in a 1960s-inspired retro-futuristic world, the film reintroduces Marvel's First Family—Reed Richards (Pedro Pascal), Sue Storm (Vanessa Kirby), Johnny Storm (Joseph Quinn), and Ben Grimm (Ebon Moss-Bachrach)—as they battle Galactus (Ralph Ineson) and his mysterious Herald, Silver Surfer (Julia Garner). They must also navigate the tension between their superhero duties and family dynamics. The ensemble cast includes Paul Walter Hauser, John Malkovich, Natasha Lyonne, and Sarah Niles in undisclosed roles. Robert Downey Jr. is rumored to appear as Doctor Doom, especially with Avengers: Doomsday approaching. The film, written by Josh Friedman, Cam Squires, and Eric Pearson, hits theaters on July 25, 2025.
Express Tribune
3 days ago
- Express Tribune
Fake Moosewala heads for stage
When Sidhu Moosewala was shot dead in May 2022, it felt like time stopped for millions. He was more than just a singer. He was a movement, a voice that cut through the noise with raw honesty, rooted pride, and political grit. His death left a void in Punjabi music that felt impossible to fill. Now, three years later, that silence has been cracked open again by an announcement no one expected: Sidhu Moosewala is going on a world tour. Embracing technology Titled Signed to God, the tour is set to kick off in 2026 with shows lined up in Indian Punjab, Toronto, London, and Los Angeles. Except this time, Moosewala will not walk onto the stage in person. Instead, audiences will see a digital version of him created through AI and hologram technology. His team promises an immersive experience that feels just like watching him live, maybe even more lifelike than we are ready for. This kind of digital resurrection is not entirely new. Back in 2012, Tupac Shakur's hologram stunned Coachella audiences. Michael Jackson's likeness has toured the world, from Cirque du Soleil's Immortal World Tour to a hologram performance at the Billboard Music Awards 2014. Over the years, we have seen actors, singers, and public figures digitally reanimated, blurring the line between tribute and spectacle. But Signed to God marks the first posthumous world tour of its kind for a South Asian artist. And at a time when artificial intelligence is increasingly being used to replicate voices, faces, and entire performances, this tour feels both groundbreaking but unsettling. Reactions to the announcement reflect the same. Some fans are overjoyed, calling it the tribute they had been waiting for. One X user wrote, "I was never a Sidhu fan but the way his legacy is being managed deserves serious credit. Keeping his momentum alive more than a year after his death isn't easy, it's something worth studying." Another user wrote, "With the technology we have, they can literally cook with this. It will be too sick, with all the guest appearances, especially. Hope they execute it well, because if done so, it will be one for the books." 'Late stage capitalism' Others, however, are not so sure. There is a growing discomfort around the idea of turning someone into a digital avatar without their explicit consent. Some have pointed out that Moosewala was known for maintaining creative control. He launched his own label, handpicked his visuals, and crafted every move with intention. For fans who admired his independence, this tour is bringing to question the sanctity of his legacy. As a user on Reddit expressed, "How much milking is left? This is too much. And people are going to buy these tickets, if this is not late stage capitalism, then I don't know what is." Others echoed the sentiment. "Such artists lived, created and passed," wrote a fan. "They deserve to rest in peace, not be mocked after their passing for the entertainment of people who never knew them personally or the profit of executives who likely never cared. A machine can't capture the soul, intent or spontaneity of a human being, it just mimics. At some point, it stops being art and starts being mockery." There is no doubt that Signed to God will be technically impressive. The use of AI, holograms, and immersive soundscapes will likely make for a visually stunning performance. It will draw in fans from all over the world who never got to see him live. But beneath the glitter of innovation, there is a deeper question. Who is this really for? For some, it will be closure. For others, it will feel like a line has been crossed. Moosewala was not just known for his voice or stage presence. His music was layered with the pain of displacement, the rage of the working class, and the vulnerability of a man who knew what it meant to live with a target on his back. Those things are not programmable and they certainly cannot be coded into an algorithm. So, this tour may bring Moosewala's image back to life, but what it cannot replicate is his soul. And maybe that is what fans are wrestling with most. Whether we call it a tribute or a spectacle, one thing is clear. Moosewala is gone. But what does remain is how we choose to remember him.
