David Lammy calls Israel Gaza concentration camp plan 'sticking point'
The Israeli politician called the camp a 'humanitarian city', in comments reported by the Haaretz newspaper.
Lammy was asked about Katz's comments at a meeting of the Foreign Affairs Committee on Tuesday by chair Emily Thornberry.
The Foreign Secretary said: 'The statements that you've just described from defence minister [Israel Katz] relate very much to where the IDF are located and you'll understand that if they're, if what you describe is true then I think that would be a big sticking point for getting that ceasefire.'
Describing the issue as one of Israel's 'location' in Gaza, he added: 'I suspect the statement from defence minister Katz is in relation to that and I suspect if indeed he is insistent of that position then it would be very hard to see how we get that ceasefire because there is an acute discussion about the degree to which the IDF withdraws from Gaza.'
READ MORE: Top BBC journalist fumes as Gaza spy planes media blackout revealed
Plans briefed to the Israeli media say that some 600,000 Palestinians would be forced to undergo "security screening" before entering the camp. They would be banned from leaving.
Israeli soldiers would control the camp, which would eventually house the entire population of Gaza.
Katz was quoted as saying that the plan is part of an overarching scheme to ethnically cleanse Palestinians from their land, which he referred to as the "the emigration plan, which will happen".
Netanyahu, who is wanted by the International Criminal Court for alleged war crimes in Gaza, was asked about the plans during a visit to the White House this week.
(Image: Archive)
"It's called free choice," said the Israeli prime minister. "You know, if people want to stay, they can stay, but if they want to leave, they should be able to leave."
Netanyahu revealed he would nominate US president Donald Trump for the Nobel Peace Prize, after brokering a ceasefire between Israel and Iran following a brief war between the two countries earlier this year.
The embattled Israeli prime minister is facing corruption charges at home but has been emboldened by American support for his plans to ethnically cleanse the Gaza Strip.
Trump sparked outrage when he suggested that Palestinians should be removed from the territory, which would be remade into the "Riviera of the Middle East".
It later emerged that Tony Blair's think tank worked with a project looking to give life to the suggestion, which also included a manufacturing zone named after Elon Musk.
Elsewhere in the committee session, Lammy refused to say when the UK Government would recognise a Palestinian state, saying: "I'm not going to set it to a set timeframe, because I've explained that this is a moving, live situation. There are delicate ceasefire negotiations under way."
He has faced calls to recognise Palestine in conjunction with France at an upcoming conference in a symbolic move as the two previous colonial powers in the Middle East.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Metro
43 minutes ago
- Metro
Trump shocked by Liberian president's English though it's the official language
To view this video please enable JavaScript, and consider upgrading to a web browser that supports HTML5 video Donald Trump went on about the president of Liberia's 'beautiful English' – despite it being the African nation's official language. The US president seemed completely unaware about the national language while delivering what he intended to be an extended compliment to Liberian President Joseph Boakai. Trump made his surprising remark after Boakai said during a meeting with other African leaders at the White House: 'We want to work with the United States in peace and security within the region and we are committed to that, and we just want to thank you so much for your support.' 'Well thank you, and such good English, that's beautiful,' Trump said, prompting laughs around the conference table. 'Where did you learn to speak so beautifully? Where were you educated? Where? In Liberia?' Boakai replied: 'Yes.' 'That's very interesting. It's beautiful English,' Trump continued. 'I have people at this table who can't speak nearly as well.' Liberia was established in 1847 and many descendants of freed American slaves were sent to live there. Though more than 20 indigenous languages are spoken in the West African country, its capital was named after America's fifth president, James Monroe, who supported making it a state for freed slaves. Boakai refrained from informing Trump about the official language during the lunch meeting with leaders from Gabon, Guinea-Bissau, Mauritania and Senega, on Wednesday afternoon. It was not the first time that Trump has made a controversial comment about an African leader or country. In May, Trump ambushed South African President Cyril Ramaphosa with false claims that white Afrikaner farmers were genocide victims in a tense Oval Office meeting. Trump even told his staff to play a video of what he incorrectly said were the grave sites of more than 1,000 murdered white farmers. Ramaphosa squirmed and calmly contested Trump's baseless claims, but avoided a heated argument and said he was there 'to reset the relationship between the United States and South Africa'. Trump during his first term in 2018 also infamously called African nations and Haiti 's***hole countries' in a meeting with senators. On Wednesday, Trump told leaders from the five African countries that the US's approach to the continent is 'shifting from aid to trade'. More Trending 'We're working tirelessly to forge new economic opportunities involving both the United States and many African nations,' Trump said. 'There's great economic potential in Africa, like few other places.' Trump has cut aid to African nations and left them staggering. American aid to Liberia made up 2.6% of its gross national income, which was the highest percentage for any country in the world, the Center for Global Development found. The US president also urged his African counterparts to help crack down on immigrants overstaying their visas in America. Get in touch with our news team by emailing us at webnews@ For more stories like this, check our news page. MORE: Baby girl mauled to death by family pit bull despite mum's desperate effort to stop attack MORE: Leaked audio of Trump boasting he would 'bomb the s*** out of Moscow' if Putin invaded Ukraine MORE: 'Anything to make Trump's ego grow', reader's discuss the US President and the Nobel Peace Prize
ITV News
an hour ago
- ITV News
Hostage families fear ‘Russian roulette' offered by ceasefire talks
For almost two years, the families of hostages held in Gaza have been desperately hoping that their loved ones will be released. So one might imagine that growing rumours of a ceasefire and hostage exchange between Hamas and Israel would be welcome news. But at an event in London calling for more international action to free those captured, the response from families is more trepidation than celebration. The Israeli government believes that there are 20 living hostages still in Gaza but sources indicate that only 10 would likely be released as part of any ceasefire agreement. 'You know, it's like a game' sais Galia David, whose son Evyatar is in captivity. 'Like a lottery?' I ask her. 'Like Russian Roulette' is her response. Evyatar was 22-years-old when he was abducted from the Nova music festival during the October 7 attacks. In home videos and photos, he looks his age: healthy, happy and with a full head of curly hair. It's a far cry from the most recent video his family has seen of him. Released earlier this year, it shows Evyatar, looking gaunt with a shaven head, being taken to the handover ceremony of another hostage. In an act of psychological torture, he is forced to beg for his own release. Four months on and he is still being held captive. Despite the chance that her son could be amongst the 10 potentially being released, she - as with all the other families - is insistent that all the hostages need to be released at the same time. Otherwise, they fear that a handful could remain as collateral for years on end. Bipin Joshi's family worry that he may be far down the list when it comes to an exchange. He is a Nepalese citizen, with no family in Israel. His country has little international clout. Joshi had only arrived in Israel three weeks before he was kidnapped, as part of an international program providing agricultural training to young people from rural Nepal. Adi Radai has been helping to advocate on his behalf because his family don't speak English or Hebrew. 'They don't understand the conflict and it's heartbreaking,' said Adi. 'They just want their son back.' The timing of this event in London is co-incidental. It was delayed because all flights in and out of Israel were cancelled as a result of missile strikes from Iran. The families want to make clear that they aren't politicians - all they are interested in is the return of their loved ones. But they believe that will only happen when there is a permanent end to the fighting and a proper peace agreement, rather than a ceasefire. And even that is uncertain.
NBC News
2 hours ago
- NBC News
After Texas floods, questions about FEMA's future loom large
The devastating Texas flooding that has killed nearly 120 people is the first high-profile disaster the Federal Emergency Management Agency has faced under the current Trump administration. But while the loss of life has been catastrophic, former and current FEMA officials told NBC News that the relatively small geographic area affected means it's not a true test of what the agency, whose full-time staff has been shrunk by a third, is capable of doing in the wake of a disaster. The real tryout could come later this summer, they say, when there is always the threat that a hurricane could hit several states. As the agency's future is debated — President Donald Trump has talked about possibly 'getting rid of' it — Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, who oversees it, has tightened her grip. Noem now requires that all agency spending over $100,000 be personally approved by her, according to current and former FEMA officials. To prevent delays on the ground, on Monday FEMA officials created a task force to speed up the process of getting Noem's approval, according to two people familiar with that unit. While Noem has been exercising more direct control over the agency, there is a void created by the largely voluntary exodus of FEMA leaders. In May, the agency announced in an internal email the departures of 16 senior officials who took with them a combined disaster expertise of more than 200 years. 'DHS and its components have taken an all-hands-on-desk approach to respond to recovery efforts in Kerrville,' a DHS spokesperson said in a statement to NBC News. 'Under Secretary Noem and Acting Administrator [David] Richardson, FEMA is shifting from bloated, DC-centric dead weight to a lean, deployable disaster force that empowers state actors to provide relief for their citizens. The old processes are being replaced because they failed Americans in real emergencies for decades. … Secretary Noem is delivering accountability to the U.S. taxpayer, which Washington bureaucrats have ignored for decades at the expense of American citizens.' On Wednesday afternoon, officials gathered for the second meeting of the FEMA Review Council, which the president has set up to determine the agency's future role. Trump told reporters in early June, 'We want to wean off of FEMA, and we want to bring it down to the state level.' As of now FEMA still has the same mandate and is managing more than 700 open disasters, according to Chris Currie, who tracks and audits the agency for the Government Accountability Office. 'They are not doing anything different. They are just doing it with less people,' he said in an interview. While the push to get states to do more has some supporters, even at FEMA, some Republican members of Congress have taken care to defend the agency in light of the disastrous floods. 'The role of FEMA is critically important,' Sen. Ted Cruz of Texas told reporters on Capitol Hill this week. 'I think everyone also agrees reforms that make FEMA more nimble, able to respond more quickly to a disaster, those reforms are beneficial, but regardless of the precise structure, the role is critical.' Red tape A key theme of the first FEMA Review Council meeting was how the federal government could reduce red tape. But current and former FEMA officials say Noem's demand to personally sign off on expenditures is creating a layer of bureaucracy that could delay assistance on the ground in Texas and during future hurricanes. A current FEMA official said the new requirement runs counter to the idea of reducing red tape and costs. 'They're adding bureaucracy … and they're adding cost,' the official said. One former senior FEMA official said the agency frequently needs to buy supplies and services in disaster zones and routinely signs contracts that exceed $100,000 to do that. 'FEMA doesn't sneeze without spending that amount of money,' the former official, who requested anonymity because they are working in a related industry, told NBC News. Beyond the rule about Noem approving certain spending, current and former officials said staff are confused about who is in charge of FEMA on a day-to-day basis: Noem or Richardson, who has been acting administrator since early May. One of the former officials said the agency's culture has shifted from being proactive to being more cautious because people are afraid of losing their jobs. DHS spokeswoman Tricia McLaughlin told NBC News that any questions about who is in charge are 'silly,' saying, 'Kristi Noem is the secretary of Homeland Security, which oversees federal emergency management — everyone knows that.' More changes are afoot. Last week the agency officially ended its practice of sending staff to knock on doors in disaster zones as a way to connect victims to services. The change came after FEMA canvassers came under scrutiny last fall when an agency employee told a survivor assistance team to avoid homes with Trump signs. The acting administrator at the time called the FEMA staffer's actions 'reprehensible.' The staffer, who was fired, has since told NewsNation that she was following orders from a supervisor and that the move was intended to help employees avoid 'hostile encounters.' While many people access FEMA services through other means, including its website and hotline, two former senior officials said door knocking is still an essential way that disaster victims get connected to services. It's unclear if the agency is sending or will send staff to knock on doors in Texas. This week a Democratic senator also complained that he has not yet seen the 2025 hurricane plan that Noem said at a May hearing she would share. Sen. Andy Kim of New Jersey, the top Democrat on the Subcommittee on Disaster Management, will send a letter Wednesday to Noem asking for the plan again. 'The reports of FEMA's incomplete 2025 hurricane season plan on the cusp of the start of hurricane season and DHS' slowness in providing the plan to this Committee are equally unsettling,' Kim wrote in the letter. FEMA or states? The key question going forward for FEMA remains what role, if any, it will play in disaster recovery, and what part of its previous mission will be delegated to the states to handle on their own. Experts who spoke with NBC News say it's clear the federal agency should still have a role in managing large-scale multistate disasters. What is less clear is whether states should be encouraged to do more to manage smaller disasters instead of relying on the federal government to bail them out. 'We need to incentivize states to spend more before requiring federal assistance,' said Jeff Schlegelmilch, director of the National Center for Disaster Preparedness at Columbia University. Natalie Simpson, a professor at the University of Buffalo who is an expert in emergency services and disaster response, said larger states can handle more responsibility when disaster strikes. 'I think big states like California, New York and Florida have enough economies of scale so they can set up a mini-FEMA, but I think other states it won't be as effective,' she said in an interview. Current and former FEMA officials pointed to comments Texas Gov. Greg Abbott made at the first FEMA Review Council meeting, in which he called FEMA 'clunky and 'slow' and that 'states have proven that we can move more nimbly, more swiftly and more effectively.' They noted that the governor had asked for a FEMA disaster declaration within days of the floods. On Sunday the president dodged a question about whether he would still eliminate the agency, telling reporters: 'Well FEMA is something we can talk about later. But right now, they're busy working, so we'll leave it at that.' By Monday, White House spokesperson Karoline Leavitt said talks around the broader purpose of the agency were ongoing. 'The president wants to ensure American citizens always have what they need during times of need. Whether that assistance comes from states or the federal government, that's a policy discussion that will continue,' Leavitt said.
