Trial challenging Japan's 'hostage justice' opens
TOKYO: A trial challenging Japan's lengthy and gruelling detention of criminal suspects opened in Tokyo Wednesday (July 9), with plaintiffs decrying "subhuman" treatment they say ignores the presumption of innocence.
Campaigners argue that lengthy pre-trial detention is meted out too easily in Japan, especially if suspects remain silent or refuse to confess.
The lawsuit is challenging the constitutionality of the system of "hostage justice" in which confessions become a de-facto condition for their release.
The term was globally popularised by ex-Nissan chief Carlos Ghosn's 2018 arrest and months-long detention, with international rights groups having also repeatedly criticised it in the past.
The new lawsuit challenges Japanese judges' ability to "rubber-stamp" detentions, and to reject bail without demonstrating "probable cause" that evidence will be destroyed, according to lead lawyer Takashi Takano.
Detained 24/7, those who maintain their innocence are often "deprived of their freedom, assets and lives ahead" even before trial starts or guilty verdicts are issued, Takano told a gathering after the first hearing Wednesday.
Pre-indictment detention can last up to 23 days, extendable by multiple rearrests.
Only after indictment does bail become possible, but the option is often dismissed if the accused denies the charges, campaigners say.
One of the plaintiffs is Tomoya Asanuma, who last year was held in police custody for nearly four months over charges he was ultimately acquitted of.
"It was like I was in a zoo cage, being fed food through a small window", Asanuma said after the hearing, recalling life "with no privacy".
"They treated me like I was subhuman."
There are "many of those who succumbed (to detention) and falsely confessed in favour of immediate release, with their names forever soiled as former criminals," Takano said.
This, critics say, partly helps explain why Japan has long maintained astonishingly high conviction rates of more than 99 percent.
Proponents, meanwhile, attribute the nearly perfect conviction rates to "precision justice", where prosecutors only pursue airtight cases they are confident about winning.
The justice ministry declined to comment on Takano's lawsuit when contacted by AFP ahead of the opening of the trial.
It however said the confinement of suspects and defendants, as well as the denial of bail, were ordered "based on the law and evidence, and in a fair manner". - AFP
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
an hour ago
- The Star
Cambodia genocide survivors 'thrilled' at new Unesco status
FILE PHOTO: Cambodian students of Royal University of Fine Arts reenact torture and execution by the Khmer Rouge during their reign of terror in the 1970s, in an event hosted by the ruling Cambodian People's Party to mark the annual Day of Anger at Choeung Ek, a former Khmer Rouge "killing field," on the outskirt of Phnom Penh, Cambodia Wednesday, May 20, 2015. This is one of three notorious Cambodian torture and execution sites used by the Khmer Rouge regime to perpetrate genocide 50 years ago, which were inscribed on Unesco's World Heritage List. - AP PHNOM PENH: Survivors of Cambodia's four-year genocide on Saturday (July 12) told AFP they were "thrilled" that the site of their lives' biggest horror has gained Unesco recognition. Three notorious Cambodian torture and execution sites used by the Khmer Rouge regime to perpetrate genocide 50 years ago were inscribed on Unesco's World Heritage List on Friday. One of the sites, Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum in the capital, is a former high school which was converted into a notorious prison known as S-21, where an estimated 15,000 people were imprisoned and tortured. "I am so thrilled," said Chum Mey, one of just a handful of S-21 survivors who now sells his memoirs in the prison compound where he says he was beaten, electrocuted and starved. "The listing by Unesco reminds me of the torture against me," he said. The two other sites are Choeung Ek Genocide Centre, also in the capital, and another site known as M-13 in a rural area in central Kampong Chhnang province. "I am so happy and excited that Unesco recognises Tuol Sleng museum, Choeung Ek, and M-13," Chum Mey said. "This is for the next generations." Around two million people died of starvation, forced labour or torture or were slaughtered in mass killings between 1975 and 1979. On Saturday, students and tourists walked through the black-and-white mugshots of Tuol Sleng's many victims and the preserved equipment used by Khmer Rouge tormentors. Khuon Sovann lost more than ten relatives to the genocide. The 82-year-old and her older sister prayed for her late brother-in-law with offerings of food and water in front of an inscription of victims' names. She said the Unesco listing was "good" and would help preserve the site. "I am happy that what we Cambodians suffered is now recognised by the international community," she told AFP. The Cambodian culture ministry on Friday issued a statement saying the inscription acknowledged the kingdom's efforts at "transforming a land once ravaged by war and genocide... into a place of peace and dignity". Norng Chanphal, 55, survived S-21 as a child and returns to the site every day to sell his memoirs and feel close to his mother who died there. He said he was "so glad" and "excited" that Tuol Sleng - a place of bitter memories where many lost everything - had earned Unesco recognition. Norng Chanphal hoped the recognition would allow Tuol Sleng to exist forever and serve as a reminder "to prevent such a regime from happening in Cambodia again". He said the site was "a lesson of life for people around the world to clearly understand the regime", adding Unesco recognition offered some justice to the souls of his mother and other victims of Tuol Sleng. - AFP
The Sun
2 hours ago
- The Sun
Indonesia's new history books spark fears of whitewashing past events
JAKARTA: The Indonesian government's plan to release updated history books has raised concerns among scholars and activists, who fear key events like the 1998 riots targeting ethnic Chinese may be erased. The 10-volume project, commissioned under President Prabowo Subianto, has drawn criticism for potentially glossing over past abuses. Draft summaries seen by AFP show no dedicated section on the 1998 violence, which saw widespread riots, looting, and allegations of mass rape. A brief mention of Suharto's resignation cites student protests as a factor, omitting deeper context. Historian Andi Achdian called the draft 'flawed' and accused it of whitewashing history. Culture Minister Fadli Zon defended the project, telling lawmakers the May 1998 events were 'small' and did not require detailed coverage. However, project editor Jajat Burhanudin contradicted this, stating the final version would include the riots, with the draft serving as a discussion starter. The controversy deepened after Fadli questioned whether mass rapes occurred during the unrest, despite a 1998 fact-finding report documenting at least 52 cases. Amnesty International Indonesia's Usman Hamid warned the project risks 'erasing uncomfortable truths.' Critics argue the government should not dictate historical narratives. Former attorney general Marzuki Darusman cautioned that ignoring past abuses acknowledged by previous administrations undermines accountability. Activist Maria Catarina Sumarsih, whose son died in post-Suharto violence, accused officials of deceiving younger generations. At least one scholar, archaeologist Harry Truman Simanjuntak, resigned over political interference, citing disputes over terminology. Opposition lawmakers and civil groups are calling for the project's suspension, urging historians—not the government—to lead historical documentation. Fadli confirmed the project will proceed, calling it an 'updated version of history' with public debates expected this month. - AFP
Malay Mail
5 hours ago
- Malay Mail
France probes Corbas prison escape after inmate hides in cellmate's luggage to slip out near Lyon
LYON, July 13 — France's prison service said yesterday it had launched an investigation after a man escaped by smuggling himself into his cellmate's bag as he left jail, having served his sentence. The 20-year-old prisoner escaped from Corbas prison, near Lyon, southeast France, on Friday, broadcaster BFMTV reported. The inmate was serving several sentences, the prison service said in a statement to AFP. He "took advantage of the liberation of his fellow inmate to hide himself in his luggage and get out", the statement said. The escaped prisoner was also under investigation in a case linked to organised crime, a source close to the affair told AFP. An internal investigation is underway and Lyon prosecutors had opened their own investigations, the prison service added. — AFP
