Letters to the Editor: Simon Harris backed us but he has U-turned on alcohol warning labels
Our views were that it was too cheap, too available, and the country was saturated with advertisements. We gave our support to the passing of the Public Health Alcohol Act.
When the bill was passed, the then health minister Simon Harris thanked my wife and I publicly for our input into getting the bill passed.
At the time, I had great respect for Mr Harris and his unwavering determination to take on the alcohol industry.
In the past few weeks, something really strange happened: first, finance minister Paschal Donohoe called for health warning labels on alcohol, which were due to become law in May 2026, to be shelved.
His reason was that with the tariffs on alcohol the labelling would be detrimental to the alcohol industry — which I might add is absolute nonsense.
Shortly afterwards, Simon Harris backed him on his stance.
To say we are disappointed is an understatement. I find it hard to understand why a man who fought such a sterling battle against the alcohol industry has now become a traitor to what we fought for.
Some might think that these are harsh words, but when you consider the time and effort that so many people and organisations put into the passage of the Public Health Alcohol Act and the unrelenting concentrated efforts by the alcohol industry to derail the passage of the bill, I think these words are justified.
To try to reverse something that he was instrumental in passing is beyond belief.
Mr Harris' words of praise for us are now meaningless, and I'm sure those in the alcohol industry are clapping their hands with glee at his about-turn.
John Higgins, Ballina, Co Mayo
Jesus in 2025 would welcome women priests
I really enjoyed TP O'Mahony's article — 'Scaled-down papacy with women given greater influence in Catholic Church's future' (Irish Examiner, May 5) to be a most compelling read.
Mr O'Mahony examines the possibility about a future female Pope. He then poses the question: Is this notion fanciful or fantasy?
Canon Law (Canon 1024) states: 'Only a baptised man can validly receive sacred ordination.'
The Catholic Church teaches that Jesus chose only men as apostles, a tradition reinforced by Pope John Paul II in 1994. Since the early Catholic Church, no woman has been ordained a priest.
I would like to point out the theological difference in the Pontifical Biblical Commission in 1976 where it found nothing in scripture that ruled out women from becoming priests.
I believe that it's always important to remember that the early Catholic Church had women in leadership positions.
It's a cause of great concern to me that women who espouse their faith today are part of an institution that does not recognise them as equal. We have to remind ourselves that women make up half of the world's population and yet it was patently clear at Pope Francis's funeral, that 50% of the global population was not represented at the pope's obsequies.
We seem stuck on the notion of Jesus having chosen 12 men as being the model of selection that we must emulate. It's my contention that the avant-garde Jesus in 2025 would welcome women priests. The Church's fundamental focus is on the Eucharist which is buttressed and undergirded by the consecration, which is the changing of water into wine. It's my humble opinion that it would be within the gift of women priests to perform this sacred ritual.
It might not be such a chimeric notion to think that in 30 years from now the presence of women as priests, bishops, and cardinals could well be commonplace. The logical, rational part of me believes the male priesthood is going to stay for now.
However with the paucity of clergy, the Church will have to take a serious look at how it will minister to its flock, considering the dwindling number of priests within the Church's ranks.
John O'Brien, Clonmel, Co Tipperary
What's your view on this issue?
You can tell us here
Reasons why women cannot be ordained
The recent passing of Pope Francis has occasioned the usual comment from the usual quarters about the Catholic Church 'needing to ordain women priests'; views coming from lapsed Catholics or avowed secularists.
That being the case, they may be unfamiliar with the reasons why women are not ordained.
It is not merely a question of tradition, though 'tradition' comes into it, begun by the founder of the Church, one Jesus Christ. Jesus — as he himself explained, and St Paul and others confirmed — came to Earth to be 'the new Adam' who would undo the disobedience of Genesis Adam, by 'obedience to God, even unto death on the cross' (Philippians 2:8).
The Catholic Church believes the priesthood is a continuation of this role, when the Catholic priest celebrates Mass, he does not merely perform a series of ceremonial actions or words, but becomes 'in persona Christi', saying 'this is my body, my blood'. The Catholic Church is thus not free to alter this fact unless God does so — see the Catholic Catechism para 1577.
A woman aiming to enter the Catholic priesthood is putting herself forward to take on the role of Jesus, the new Adam, and high priest, in contradiction of the plan of salvation as devised by God.
She would therefore be embarking on a career path saying 'no' to the very God she would claim to be serving — hardly an auspicious start to any career.
Nick Folley, Carrigaline, Co Cork
Conclave countermeasure to zealotry of Trump
I am hopeful that the 132 'other' cardinals in conclave were guided by divine intervention of the global need for a homemade countermeasure to the zealotry of Donald Trump.
Michael Gannon, Saint Thomas Sq, Kilkenny City
What's your view on this issue?
You can tell us here
Pope Leo will follow in footsteps of Pope Francis
America, and the world, has a new Pope, but not the one Donald Trump hoped for himself. Although he was an unexpected choice, he appears to be a very good choice.
From what is being reported, Pope Leo XIV will follow in the footsteps of Pope Francis. The Church needs to be all encompassing as its members are more diverse than they used to be.
My own Catholic childhood, in the 1960s, of old Irish priests with accents so broad I had trouble following what they were saying, are so long gone. Now we have priests from any country — although in my parish, not from America yet.
There are also old tweets from Pope Leo XIV commenting on Trump and Vance, which will make their first meeting interesting. Maybe there will need to be some divine intervention there.
In welcoming the Pope to the job and wishing him good luck, I just hope that he will be aware of the truth of the people he meets, as not all great people are good people.
Dennis Fitzgerald, Melbourne, Australia
Catastrophic genocide in Gaza must be ended
The genocide in Gaza is now becoming catastrophic. The warnings by Dr Michael Ryan (WHO), Peter Power (Unicef), and the UN Secretary General António Guterres are being ignored by the Irish Government and by the so-called international community, who have abandoned the Palestinian people, and ignored their responsibilities towards the proper rule of international and humanitarian laws.
Too many of these organisations and their leaders are actively assisting or being complicit in the genocide. The UN has been rendered powerless by abuses of the powers of veto. The Irish Government is failing to take all necessary measures to prevent or punish breaches of the Genocide Convention.
By allowing the US military to use Shannon Airport, Ireland may be in breach of Article III (e) Complicity in Genocide.
Ireland has failed to effectively use its membership of the UN and EU to advocate on behalf of the Palestinian people, and to uphold international humanitarian laws.
Its plans to remove the triple lock undermines the role of the UN, and it is failing to process the Occupied Territories Bill in a timely manner.
It is too late to save the Palestinian people who have already been killed, or to undo the physical and mental trauma suffered by millions of Palestinians.
Up to 100 Palestinians are now dying daily, by Israeli bombs and bullets, and by starvation and diseases due to the Israeli blockade and destruction of medical facilities.
Israel plans to expand its military offensive, and to capture and hold the territory of Gaza. Israel prime minister Benjamin Netanyahu said the cabinet had decided that Gaza's 2.1m population 'will be moved, to protect it'.
This expanded military offensive, and ethnic cleansing, is likely to cost the lives of many more Palestinians.
This genocide must be ended, and all those responsible for it, or complicit in it, must be held to account as soon as possible, otherwise all of humanity is in danger, as the rule of brute force replaces the proper rule of law.
Edward Horgan, Castletroy, Limerick
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
an hour ago
- The Journal
Tánaiste says any gardaí showing 'brazen' disregard for roads policing 'letting colleagues down'
ANY GARDAÍ WHO have shown a 'brazen' disregard for roads policing are 'seriously letting their colleagues down', Tánaiste Simon Harris has said. The Fine Gael leader was responding to comments by Garda Commissioner Drew Harris, about a report that found some gardaí showed a 'blatant disregard' for roads policing duties while they knew their actions were being reviewed. The Journal / YouTube It comes amid a focus on road safety in Ireland, with the Government introducing new speed laws and after the Garda Commissioner mandated that frontline gardaí dedicate 30 minutes of road policing duties per shift. Simon Harris said he did not want to 'tar any one group with one brush', and said he has the utmost respect for gardaí. 'Indeed, it's not that long since we were at a funeral of a member of An Garda Síochána killed while on road traffic policing duties,' he said at Government Buildings. 'Having said that, I am concerned with what I've heard, and I'd like to be in a position to read it. So I think it's important that what the commissioner said he intends to do does happen, that he publishes the report so that we can actually see this and analyse it directly. 'Because any member of An Garda Siochana who is acting in the way that the commissioner outlined is seriously letting their colleagues down in the first instance, colleagues who work every day to keep us safe and would absolutely be undermining our road safety efforts in this country. 'There are far too many empty seats at far too many kitchen tables in Ireland. We've worked extremely hard as a country, I don't just mean as a government, as a country, to improve road safety over many years. 'That progress had stalled in recent years and indeed we'd seen a negative trend, and this is disappointing and concerning. 'But I think it's important that we have the opportunity to see the report, rather than to comment on a comment about the report.' Advertisement Asked if he was surprised that a member of government had not seen the report, considering the policing authority had seen the report in June, he said: 'I am somewhat, but I haven't had an opportunity to discuss this with colleagues in government yet, and I'd obviously like to discuss it in the first instance with the Minister of Justice.' Sean Canney, a junior minister with responsibility for road safety, said the reported findings were 'shocking' and 'serious'. 'There's no point in us bringing in laws, reducing speed limits, doing all of this kind of thing, if we don't have a functional enforcement section within the Gardaí,' he said on RTE Radio. Canney said his thoughts were with the families of the 95 people who had died on Irish roads so far this year. He said he had not read the report from consultancy firm Crowe, which has carried out investigations on behalf of An Garda Síochána previously, but planned to meet Justice Minister Jim O'Callaghan and both the outgoing and incoming Garda commissioners. 'I'll be talking to the commissioners to express my deep concern with what is in this report,' he said. He said the independent Crowe report was conducted while the reviewer was 'sitting in the car with a garda that wasn't doing his duty and didn't seem to have a problem with that'. 'So I think there is definitely a serious case to be answered here as quickly as possible.' Harris said he commissioned the examination after he received an anonymous report from a whistleblower. The chairwoman of the Policing and Community Safety Authority, Elaine Byrne, said the report was 'shocking' and found some gardaí showed a 'blatant disregard' for road policing while they knew their actions were being reviewed. 'They were openly hostile to doing their job,' she said, in what she described as a 'wake-up call' for An Garda Siochana. She also described an issue with fear among Garda managers of carrying out poor performance management, which she said Harris agreed was an issue.
Irish Examiner
4 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Kamala Harris says she doesn't plan to return to ‘broken' system of US politics
Kamala Harris has said that she currently has no desire to re-enter 'the system' of American politics because it is 'broken'. On Thursday night the Democratic party's defeated presidential nominee, who replaced Joe Biden late in the 2024 campaign after he dropped his re-election bid, gave her first interview since losing the election to Donald Trump, talking to Stephen Colbert on The Late Show. After she announced she will not run for the governorship of California just a day earlier, Harris told the TV show that it was about something more 'basic' than whether she wanted to run for something else instead — with the subtext being whether she will attempt a White House run again in 2028. 'Recently I made the decision that I just — for now — I don't want to go back in the system. I think it's broken,' she said, provoking a collective groan from the studio audience. Colbert later returned to the subject, saying that her remark was harrowing. 'Well, but it's also evident, isn't it?' she said. Describing herself as a 'devout public servant', the former vice-president added: 'I always believed, that as fragile as our democracy is, our systems would be strong enough to defend our most fundamental principles. And I think right now that they're not as strong as they need to be. And for now I don't want to go back into that system.' Harris's choice of The Late Show as the channel for her first post-election defeat interview was pointed. The most-watched talkshow was cancelled last month by the CBS network, which pleaded financial stress, though the decision was widely denounced as being politically motivated. The cancellation was announced after Colbert had criticized CBS and its parent company Paramount Global for reaching a $16m settlement with Trump. The president had sued CBS News over an interview on the 60 Minutes show with Harris at the height of last year's presidential campaign, which Trump claimed had been manipulated in her favour. None of this febrile back story was mentioned by either Colbert or Harris on Thursday. But she did delivery a passionate lament for the numbers of people who she said had 'capitulated' to the aggressive second Trump administration. When Colbert invited her to say 'I told you so' after she had predicted many of Trump's most contentious moves — including Medicaid cuts, ignoring court orders, and 'massive tax cuts to the rich' — she replied: 'But Stephen, what I did not predict was the capitulation.' She went on: 'Perhaps it's naive of me … there should be many who consider themselves to be guardians of our system and our democracy who just capitulated, and I didn't see that coming.' The timing of the interview was also poignant, as she was considered to be the automatic frontrunner if she had decided to run to become the next governor of California. Her wider remarks on 'the system' help explain that decision, though they still notably left room for another possible presidential run. In the meantime, Harris has a book to sell, 107 Days, which she name-checked copiously on the Late Show in advance of its publication next month. The book, as its title suggests, relates the story of the shortest presidential run of all time. She said it would give a 'behind-the-scenes sharing' of those intense days. Whether it is to sell the book or to lay the foundations for another presidential bid remains a moot point, but Harris said she wanted to use the next period to 'travel the country and listen to people. I don't want it to be transactional, where I'm asking for their vote.' Harris admitted that it had taken her months following her defeat before she had the strength to tune into the news again. 'You know, I'm just not into self-mutilation,' she said. Instead there had been 'lots of cooking shows', her top choice being The Kitchen. — The Guardian
Irish Times
6 hours ago
- Irish Times
Garda staff body doubts damaging allegations about roads policing will be substantiated
The biggest staff body in An Garda Síochána has questioned the accuracy of claims made about the performance of roads policing gardaí . The Garda Representative Association (GRA) accused Garda Commissioner Drew Harris and the Policing and Community Safety Authority (PCSA) of 'drip-feeding' damaging allegations to the media about gardaí which it doubted would ever be substantiated. The GRA, which represents more than 11,000 rank and file members in the 14,300-strong force, attacked Mr Harris's management style, claiming it has 'dramatically impacted on the morale and motivation' of all gardaí. It accused Mr Harris, who is due to retire in less than a month , of being 'disrespectful' to gardaí, abdicating his responsibilities as commissioner, valuing the input of consultants more than Garda supervisors and lacking confidence in his own managers. READ MORE The Association of Garda Sergeants and Inspectors (AGSI), which represents Garda middle management, said it was 'deeply concerned' at the conclusions reached about the standard of roads policing in the new report by Crowe consultants. It said it remained 'resolutely committed' to its 'core mission of keeping people safe' and improving policing performance. However, AGSI added that it was 'disappointed' at the manner in which elements of the Crowe report emerged in the public domain at a public meeting of the PCSA. It pointed out it had not yet been provided with the report, reflecting a 'broader dysfunctionality' around consultation in the Garda force. [ Garda roads policing numbers hit historic low Opens in new window ] Outgoing Garda Commissioner Drew Harris spoke to the media ahead of his retirement and last meeting at the PCSA on Thursday. Photograph: Sam Boal/ Collins Photos AGSI, which has enjoyed better relations with Mr Harris than the GRA, addressed the core findings of the Crowe report, expressing its concern and saying it had confidence that improvements could be made to roads policing performance. However, the GRA referenced the report's damning findings about roads policing only in the context of doubting them. GRA general secretary Ronan Slevin said by commissioning consultants to review roads policing, Mr Harris was guilty of 'inaction' and using a management style that sabotaged morale. He also questioned claims made by Mr Harris and Ms Byrne at Thursday's PCSA meeting about the contents of the Crowe report. 'The initial feedback from our members who interacted with Crowe is at odds with the drip fed comments from the (PCSA) and the commissioner,' he said. He added that gardaí 'now anxiously await' the Crowe report's publication 'and question whether any findings will substantiate the damaging allegations made against our members'. AGSI said the report appeared to be 'highly critical' of how the Garda 'under Commissioner Harris' leadership, has overseen and supported' personnel in roads policing. However, it recognised that such reports could become 'valuable tools' and believed progress would be made once the report was published and fully understood. Crowe, a consultancy firm, was commissioned by Garda headquarters to carry an independent review of roads policing. That occurred after anonymous correspondence, apparently from a Garda member, was sent to Garda management expressing concern about roads policing. The report would be published once it was checked to ensure nobody referenced could be identified, the commissioner said. Photograph: Artur Widak/ NurPhoto via Getty Images PCSA chair Elaine Byrne said Mr Harris had 'acted on' the whistleblower claims by commissioning the Crowe report. She said that action 'very much reflects a cultural change' in the Garda where 'uncomfortable truths' had been 'confronted' rather than hidden. She hoped that approach would continue after Mr Harris retired next month. Ms Byrne said the Crowe report was 'shocking' because 'there are members in roads policing who seem very much disinterested in their job'. Some gardaí displayed a 'blatant disregard' for their jobs and were 'openly hostile' about doing their work, she said. The report, she added, also showed some Garda managers were too fearful to intervene when they identified poor performance, which was very concerning. Mr Harris also said he was 'shocked' by the report, describing it as 'sobering to say the least'. He said some gardaí were 'brazen' about their disinterest in their jobs, even while their work was being reviewed by examiners who travelled with them in Garda cars. The report would be published once it was checked to ensure nobody referenced could be identified, the commissioner added.
