Mark Brown Slams New Zealand For Its 'Patronising Approach' Over China Deal
Caleb Fotheringham, RNZ Pacific Journalist
Pausing nearly $20 million in development assistance is "patronising" and "inconsistent with modern partnership", Prime Minister Mark Brown has told the Cook Islands parliament.
New Zealand Foreign Minister Winston Peters has paused $18.2 million in development assistance to the Cook Islands, due to a lack of consultation regarding a partnership agreement and other deals signed with Beijing earlier this year.
The pause includes $10 million in core sector support, which represents four percent of the country's budget. On Wednesday local time, Brown said the money would have been used for health, education and tourism marketing.
"The relationship between the Cook Islands and New Zealand is defined by partnership, not paternalism," he told his parliament on Thursday. "Decisions to unilaterally pause core sector support reflect a patronising approach, inconsistent with modern partnership."
The 2001 Joint Centenary Declaration signed between the two nations requires them to consult each other on defence and security, which Peters said had not been lived up to, but Brown said the declaration was "explicitly clear" that the Cook Islands could enter international agreements in its own right.
"Where we are finding our divergence of views is in the provision relating to the consultation obligations and rights of both parties to the declaration.
"We are committed to addressing this urgently. That is why we agreed to New Zealand's proposal to establish a formal dialogue mechanism to discuss the agreements and their implementation."
Brown said there had been two meetings so far - one in April and May.
"It is disappointing that political commentary from within New Zealand has come at a time when official dialogue continues," he said. "Such commentary undermines genuine and concerted efforts by our senior officials to mend the erosion of trust and confidence that, to be clear, has been experienced on both sides."
RNZ Pacific reached out to Peters' office for a response on Brown's comments. A spokesperson for Peters said they would make no further comment and stood by the statements issued Thursday.
In parliament, Brown suggested a double standard from New Zealand and said he was "not privy to or consulted on" agreements New Zealand may enter into with China.
Brown said he was surprised by the timing of the announcement.
"Especially, Mr Speaker, in light of the fact our officials have been in discussions with New Zealand officials to address the areas of concern that they have over our engagements in the agreements that we signed with China."
Peters previously said the Cook Islands government was informed of the funding pause on 4 June. He also said it had nothing to do with Prime Minister Christopher Luxon visiting China.
Brown said he was sure Luxon would ensure good outcomes for the people of the realm of New Zealand on the back of the Cook Islands state visit and "the goodwill that we've generated with the People's Republic of China".
"I have full trust that Prime Minister Luxon has entered into agreements with China that will pose no security threats to the people of the Cook Islands.
"Of course, not being privy to or not being consulted on any agreements that New Zealand may enter into with China."
The Cook Islands is in free association with New Zealand and governs its own affairs, but New Zealand provides assistance with foreign affairs (upon request), disaster relief and defence.
Former Cook Islands Deputy Prime Minister and prominent lawyer Norman George said Brown "should go on his knees and beg for forgiveness, because you can't rely on China".
"[The aid pause] is absolutely a fair thing to do, because our Prime Minister betrayed New Zealand, and let the government and people of New Zealand down."
Not everyone agrees. Rarotongan artist Tim Buchanan said Peters was being a bully.
"It's like he's taken a page out of Donald Trump's playbook, using money to coerce his friends," Buchanan said.
"What is it exactly do you want from us, Winston? What do you expect us to be doing to appease you?"
Buchanan said it had been a long road for the Cook Islands to get where it was now and New Zealand seemed to want to knock the country back down.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
4 hours ago
- Scoop
New Zealand Government Refuses To Condemn Illegal US Bombing Of Iran
New Zealand's right-wing coalition government is refusing to condemn the illegal US bombing of nuclear facilities in Iran and the continuing war being waged by Israel in collaboration with US imperialism. A few hours before US President Donald Trump announced the attack, New Zealand Prime Minister Christopher Luxon—who was in Europe to attend the NATO war summit—called for 'diplomacy' to end the Israel-Iran war, stating: 'more military action [is] going to make the region more destabilised and cause more catastrophe and more human suffering.' Afterwards, however, on June 23, Luxon echoed the fraudulent pretext for the US-Israeli bombardment. He told a media conference, 'We do not want to see a nuclear armed Iran. But now there is an opportunity, as we look forward from these strikes, to actually get around and use diplomacy and dialogue and negotiation to actually get a political solution in place.' Luxon did not explain how unprovoked acts of war by the US—in addition to Israel's murderous bombardment of Iran and assassinations of top officials and scientists—created an 'opportunity' for peace. The opposite is the case. The prime minister's statements are an endorsement of the gangster-like methods of the Trump administration, which is working with Israel to topple Iran's regime and to control all the resources of the Middle East. This is seen as a stepping stone to war against China, which US imperialism considers the main threat to its global domination. Conscious of widespread and deeply-ingrained anti-war sentiment, and outrage over the ongoing US-Israeli genocide in Gaza, the New Zealand government is continuing to feign neutrality and non-involvement in the war with Iran. Acting Prime Minister David Seymour, from the far-right ACT Party, told the media that he would not 'rush to judgement on the rights and wrongs of the situation.' On June 24, Foreign Minister Winston Peters informed parliament that the United States had made a 'statement to the UN Security Council that it was acting in collective self-defence consistent with the UN Charter.' Asked whether the New Zealand government agreed with the US position, Peters replied: 'we [will] wait till we get the evidence' about how close Iran was to being able to build a nuclear weapon. It is well-known that Iran does not have a nuclear weapon or any ability to build one in the near future. Israel is estimated to have 90 nuclear weapons and the US has thousands. The fact is that the Luxon administration is firmly aligned with Washington. New Zealand military personnel are stationed in the Middle East, where they are assisting in the US-led bombing of Yemen in defence of supply lines for Israel's military as it carries out genocide in Gaza. Peters has refused to say whether New Zealand personnel have been involved in US-Israeli operations against Iran or had prior knowledge of them. As a member of the US-led Five Eyes network, New Zealand's spy agencies routinely share intelligence with their counterparts in the US, UK, Australia and Canada. The opposition Labour Party and its allies, the Greens and Te Pāti Māori, have declared that the US attack on Iran violated international law and called on the government to condemn it. Labour leader Chris Hipkins told parliament: 'There is no clear justification, there is no credible claim of imminent threat, and there is no UN mandate. … New Zealand should not drift from our values simply because the actions come from one of our traditional allies. We do not believe in a world where might makes right, and where power justifies impunity.' The opposition parties are seeking to channel rising public anger and ensure that it does not develop into a mass anti-war movement, independent from and opposed to all the capitalist parties. In reality, Labour's 'values' are no different to those of the National Party and its allies: they are both parties of big business and imperialism. The last Labour government—which included the Greens—strengthened the alliance with US imperialism and sent troops to Britain to help train Ukrainian soldiers to fight in the NATO proxy war against Russia. The Labour Party has pledged its support for the government's plan to vastly increase military spending and integrate New Zealand into the build-up to war against China. Hipkins falsely claimed that in 2003 the then Labour government led by Helen Clark 'took a principled and courageous stand by opposing the illegal invasion of Iraq… We were told then that it was in our economic interests to look the other way. We didn't, because we knew that legality matters, principle matters, and international rules matter.' This is a complete rewriting of history. The Clark government postured as opponents of the initial invasion of Iraq, while strengthening ties with US imperialism, including by sending troops to take part in the illegal invasion and occupation of Afghanistan. In 2003, 61 New Zealand army engineers were deployed to Iraq to assist in the occupation of that country. According to US embassy cables released by WikiLeaks in 2010, the troops were sent after it was made clear that New Zealand dairy giant Fonterra risked missing out on lucrative supply contracts in Iraq. In other words, the 'economic interests' of big business convinced the Labour government that it had to join the war. There is no doubt that if Labour was in government today it would act no differently from the National Party-led government. Notably, the Labour government in Britain and the Albanese Labor government in Australia have both given full-throated support to the US bombing of Iran. It should also be recalled that when Hipkins was still prime minister in October and November 2023, he and the Labour Party government supported Israel's genocidal onslaught against the population of Gaza. Asked what he thought about Israel bombing hospitals, schools and refugee camps, Hipkins told the media he was 'not going to make a judgement' about whether this breached international law—using the same language now being used by the Luxon government to avoid any condemnation of the war crimes against Iran. The genocide in Gaza and the escalating war against Iran are part of a developing world war, which includes the US-NATO war against Russia and the military build-up against China. New Zealand, a minor imperialist power in the Pacific, is supporting US imperialism on all these fronts, so that the NZ ruling class can share in the division of the spoils. The fight against war requires a struggle against the capitalist system and all its political parties, including Labour and its allies. It must be based on the fight to unify the working class internationally in a struggle for the socialist reorganisation of society. By Tom Peters, Socialist Equality Group 28 June 2025
Scoop
3 days ago
- Scoop
New Caledonian Delegates To Learn About NZ Economy
Rt Hon Winston Peters Minister of Foreign Affairs A New Caledonian delegation will tour New Zealand next week to learn about aspects of our economic development, Foreign Minister Winston Peters says. 'As New Caledonia seeks to recover economically from a challenging period in its history, New Zealand is pleased to be sharing our own lessons and experiences. 'When visiting New Caledonia twice in the past year, we heard from businesses, including Kanak entrepreneurs, significant interest in New Zealand's economic development – including the Māori economy. 'We are therefore delighted to welcome this high-level delegation, which will be introduced to all aspects of our economic development – including the Māori economy and how Māori operate in key sectors like youth training, economic development, and technology. 'This study tour is an important element of New Zealand's commitment to New Caledonia's development through ongoing and constructive exchanges.' The programme includes a meeting with Māori policymakers and engagement with a range of iwi on areas such as youth, tourism, services and private sector partnerships. The study tour follows Mr Peters' visits over the last six months to Paris, Nice and Nouméa, where he has met France's President Emmanuel Macron, Foreign Minister Jean-Noël Barrot, and Overseas Territories Minister Manuel Valls, as well as the new President of the Government of New Caledonia, Alcide Ponga. The 20-person study tour includes visits to Wellington, Hamilton, Tauranga, and Auckland. 'We have a shared interest in promoting economic development, good governance and regional security,' Mr Peters says. The delegation arrives in New Zealand on Sunday 29 June, will meet Mr Peters on Friday 4 July, before returning to Nouméa the following day.
Scoop
4 days ago
- Scoop
Tonga's Government Mum On Health Cyber Breach
, RNZ Pacific Senior Journalist The Tongan government has yet to reveal more details about a cyber breach of its health records that occured 10 days ago. The breach by hackers and their subsequent demand for payment were revealed in parliament four days after the event. A cyber expert from Australia has been in the country for nearly a week, and local media report that more personnel are being brought in. Meanwhile, concern about illegal access to health records is mounting, amid a requirement that patients bring any medical records they have into the country's hospitals as staff are now relying on manual data. Former Prime Minister Siaosi Sovaleni wants a full explanation from the government, but most of the country's leaders are in Ha'apai this week for the annual conference of the Wesleyan Church. Police have said that the hackers have demanded a payment in "the millions". A media conference scheduled for later on Thursday is expected to shed more light on the issue.
