Sugababes in Dublin review: A steamroller of peerless pop and sisterhood

Irish Times

21-04-2025

Sugababes
3Arena, Dublin
★★★★☆
Like a cross between Destiny's Child and the cast of Grange Hill,
Sugababes
' streak of early 21st-century hits applied a gritty British teenage twist to classic girl group pop. The only missing ingredient was the ability to get along. From the start, their quicksilver pop was clouded by melodrama and the occasional backstage bust-up.
But a quarter of a century later, the band's founding members – Mutya Buena, Keisha Buchanan and Siobhán Donaghy – have tied a ribbon around their tumultuous history and replaced conflict with collective joy.
Rolling into
Dublin 3Arena
for the latest leg of a greatest hits tour, they delightfully blend nostalgia with the message that even in the cut-throat music industry, time heals all.
There was a lot of healing to do. Donaghy left Sugababes in acrimony after just one album in the middle of a run of dates in Japan. Three years later, in March 2004, a concert in Dublin was cancelled ten minutes after it was due to start amid rumours of a dressingroom face-off between Buchanan and Donaghy's replacement, Heidi Range.
READ MORE
If ever a comeback was destined to be bumpy, then it was surely that of Sugababes, who are back in Ireland and the scene of the most notorious flashpoint (it was later reported that the cause of the Buchanan-Range dust-up was the perpetually controversial subject of Britney Spears's Toxic).
The Sugababes in Dublin: delightfully blending nostalgia with the message that time heals all. Photograph: Alice Backham
The twist is that instead of tears and tension, the original Sugababes have returned wiser and more appreciative of their audience.
To that end, their Easter Sunday concert at 3Arena is a treat as delicious as an artisanal chocolate egg. It helps that, unlike some of their contemporaries (cough, Spice Girls, cough), their music has held up. That point is demonstrated as they kick off with the doomy, slo-mo stomp of their September 2000 debut single Overload, performed on stools that are revealed as a giant curtain falls to the ground.
The atmosphere is half early 2000s pop revival and half heavenly school disco. Backed by a no-frills video display and a pub rock-y band, they rip through Red Dress and Ugly, a one-two that doubles as post-girl power feminist anthemia ('unzip your bias', declares the video screen during the former).
Sadly, the mid portion of the set lags by comparison. The problem is that Sugababes don't have quite enough hits to deliver end-to-end bangers. A medley of their early recordings is, for instance, received with polite applause rather than any great enthusiasm. But they get things back on track with an epic new tune, Weeds, a trip-hop thumper that suggests a cross between Girls Aloud and Radiohead.
From there, it's into top gear with Round Round: the sort of effortlessly effervescent pop many of their early 2000s contemporaries attempted but could never pull off. The encore is even better as they rip through their Tubeway Army-sampling cover of Adina Howard's Freak Like Me and the bittersweet barnstormer About You Now.
The latter is a heartfelt chugger, which the trio, having changed into tracksuits, turns into a divine singalong. With old tensions smoothed over, Sugababes' Easter return to Dublin is a steamroller of peerless pop and sisterhood rekindled.
Sugababes at 3Arena. Photograph: Alice Backham