‘Don't agree to be party to foeticide': Delhi HC stays termination of 27-week pregnancy of minor rape survivor after AIIMS cautions
The 16-year-old girl approached the Delhi High Court through her mother last month, seeking permission to terminate an approximately 26-week pregnancy. In response to the court's request for a medical opinion on the termination, the AIIMS New Delhi medical board recommended against the procedure.
The medical board noted that the fetus is viable and 'at this gestational age, medical termination of pregnancy, if undertaken, entails significant risks, including a higher likelihood of caesarean section, which could adversely affect her future reproductive health'.
'The medical board feels that continuation of the pregnancy for at least 8 more week is expected to offer a more favourable neonatal outcome,' the board opined in its report on June 28.
It also said that if the court considers permitting termination of pregnancy at this stage, 'clear guidance would be necessary on the management of the live fetus/neonate, particularly with respect to decisions on feticide (if permissible under law) or adoption post-delivery, given the viability of the fetus at this gestational age'.
On June 30, Justice Manoj Jain, taking into consideration 'the grave mental injury and trauma inflicted upon the mind of minor, on account of sexual assault in question', permitted the termination. For management of the fetus, if born alive, the single judge had further directed, 'If the child is born alive, Medical Superintendent, AIIMS in conjunction with the State Authorities would ensure that every possible and feasible assistance is offered to such child.'
Appealing against the order, AIIMS New Delhi, told the Delhi High Court that having regard to totality of circumstances, the direction issued by the single judge for making arrangements for medical termination of pregnancy of a minor and a victim of crime of rape is in derogation of provisions of MTP Act 1971. It also says the orders areuns contrary the to medical opinion expressed by the medical bo,ard comprising medical experts from AIIMS, which included a psychiatrist as well.
A division bench of Chief Justice D K Upadhyaya and Justice Anish Dayal Thursday requested assistance from the members of the medical board. In the second half of the court session, Dr K Aparna Sharma and Dr Jyoti Meena, two members of the medical board who are professors in the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology at AIIMS New Delhi, appeared before the court.
The doctors informed the court that 'termination of pregnancy is safer at 34 weeks, than now', as inducing labour towards the end of the pregnancy makes it easier for the uterus to respond. The experts also made it clear that in such a case, foeticide will have to be performed to ensure that the baby born is not alive.
Following the opinion by the AIIMS experts, CJ Upadhyaya, addressing the counsel for the minor survivor, orally remarked, 'Termination of pregnancy here would mean delivery of a child… it is is not an induced abortion, it is foeticide… unless medically required, it is a criminal offence… Asking us to be party to foeticide, which is permissible for medical requirements only, that I do not agree to.'
The bench suggested that the counsel for the minor survivor convince them to carry out the pregnancy while assuring free medical services for both the survivor and the to-be-born child for the next five years, free of charge, at the AIIMS. The bench also offered that they may further issue directions to the Delhi government to ensure the education of the survivor free of cost until Class 10, as well as assisting the survivor in giving up the child for adoption if she so decides ultimately.
The counsel, after consulting with the survivor's mother, informed the bench that they are currently open to the option of carrying the pregnancy to full term. However, they are unable to make any decisions regarding adoption at this time and will need the survivor's consent. It was also mentioned that the survivor has only completed education up to Class 2.
The bench directed that the survivor should remain admitted in AIIMS for the entire gestation period of 34 weeks or even more if required, till she delivers the child, and should be permitted to stay in the hospital in AIIMS until she becomes medically fit after delivery.
Noting that the 'facts and circumstances of this case are very unfortunate, unpleasant and precarious situation where the court has to ensure the welfare of both the minor rape victim as also the child to be born', the court also sought an affidavit within two weeks from the Delhi government's department of women and child development. The affidavit must detail all the assistance it can provide to the survivor and the baby to be born, including facilities for education, skill development, and vocational training.
The court kept the appeal pending and posted it for consideration next on October 15.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
From Luck to Protocol: India's Emergency Care Gets Structure and the Golden Hour Its Due
New Delhi: Emergency care in India is no longer a waiting game. It's transforming into a fast, tech-enabled, and protocol-driven system that puts the patient at the center. From trained ER doctors managing critical trauma independently to AI-assisted triage and ambulance alerts triggering in-hospital prep, the change is sweeping. What once relied on luck and specialist availability is now structured, timely, and increasingly seamless even in tier 2 and 3 cities. The golden hour is finally getting the urgency it deserves, informed top experts in emergency medicine . Speaking at ETHealthworld's inaugural FutureMedX Summit during a compelling panel discussion titled 'Revolutionizing Emergency Care: Patient-Centric Approaches in Trauma and Critical Care', experts addressed how emergency care in India is evolving from a fragmented, protocol-driven system to a more integrated, tech-enabled, and patient-centric approach. The session saw participation from Dr. Deepak Agrawal , Professor, Neurosurgery , AIIMS New Delhi; Dr. (Prof) Ajay Bahl, Chairperson and HOD, Emergency Medicine, Sir Ganga Ram Hospital; Dr. Sushant Chhabra , Cluster Head, Emergency Medicine, Manipal Hospitals North-West Region; and Dr. Sachin Chaudhry from the Armed Forces Medical Services shared their views. Moderated by Vikas Dandekar , Editor (Pharma & Healthcare), The Economic Times. Opening the session by highlighting the radical transformation in India's emergency care landscape over the past decade , Dr Agrawal said, 'Earlier, emergency departments across India were staffed by Casualty Medical Officers (CMOs) who were not specifically trained in emergency medicine. They could be orthopedic surgeons, trauma surgeons, or anesthetists. The most significant shift has been the emergence of dedicated emergency medicine departments staffed by trained professionals." According to Dr Agrawal, emergency care has evolved from mere triage-based systems to more holistic, protocol-based interventions. 'Today, emergency physicians manage the ABCs—airway, breathing, circulation—and initiate diagnostics like CT scans, with specialists arriving later in the care chain. This has made emergency care more consistent and less dependent on chance,' he explained. Underlining the increasing use of AI and machine learning in emergency settings, he said, 'We've installed cameras that use object detection to track critical steps—like when intubation is done or when pulse oximetry is applied. This data generates key performance indicators on how long each life-saving step took, helping us refine our processes." Dr Chhabra elaborated on the structured emergency response system adopted by Manipal Hospitals. 'Our model is built on strong clinical leadership, integrated systems, and seamless transitions of care. We follow a 'closed ER and closed ICU' model, where patients are continuously managed by trained emergency medicine doctors from triage to discharge,' he said. He added that protocols like Code Stroke and Code STEMI—standardised across their network—enable quicker diagnoses and timely interventions. 'If a chest pain patient presents, we perform an ECG within five minutes and activate Code STEMI if necessary. This has drastically reduced door-to-balloon times and improved outcomes.' Manipal has also invested in robust pre-hospital care through the Manipal Ambulance Response Service (MARS). 'If our field paramedic suspects a stroke, the hospital is alerted in advance, enabling faster triage and imaging the moment the patient arrives,' he added. On the technology front, Dr Chhabra noted the adoption of AI-based triage in global emergency departments. 'In Canada, AI-driven systems now categorise patients into red, yellow, or green zones automatically. AI is also being used in history-taking to ensure no critical questions are missed, especially when physicians are cognitively overloaded.' Dr Chaudhry, speaking from his experience at military and civilian hospitals, emphasized triage as the cornerstone of emergency care. 'It begins not just at the hospital but also in ambulances. Integration between departments is crucial. Once myocardial infarction is ruled in, the patient is directly moved to cardiology,' he explained. He stressed that trained emergency staff—certified in ATLS, ALS, and BLS—manage patients from initial assessment through to transfer. 'With the Ayushman Bharat Digital Mission, we can access past patient data immediately. This cuts down delays in treatment, which in emergency medicine, could mean the difference between life and death,' he said. Backing up his points with concrete statistics, Dr. Chhabra said, 'In the Manipal network, we manage around 1,200 STEMI cases annually. Our Code STEMI protocol has helped reduce mortality by 30 per cent. We have also brought down door-to-balloon time by 20 to 30 minutes well below the international standard of 90 minutes even in tier 2 and tier 3 cities,' he noted. Dr Agrawal shared insights on neurotrauma care and how the system has evolved. 'Ten years ago, we were operating on two to three severe head injury cases daily. Today, that number has dropped to one. Better infrastructure, safer vehicles, and emergency awareness have helped,' he said. However, he pointed out that Delhi still lacks a world-class ambulance system. 'Interestingly, 50 per cent of our emergency neurotrauma cases are brought in by Delhi Police, who have a scoop-and-run directive. While they're not medically trained, they get patients to us in under 10 minutes, often faster than ambulances,' he noted. He recounted how AIIMS was once accused of shunting patients to smaller hospitals, leading to a Supreme Court petition by Safdarjung Hospital. 'We took a call that any patient requiring intubation or ventilation would not be referred out. We would treat them regardless of bed capacity. That's when we built a dedicated trauma center with half of our 250 beds reserved for neurotrauma,' he said. 'Someone has to take responsibility and we did," Dr Agrawal mentioned. The Regulatory Setback Toward the end, Dr. Chhabra raised a serious concern on the fluctuating recognition of emergency medicine as a specialty. 'In 2009, the specialty was recognised. In 2022, NMC mandated every medical college to have an Emergency Medicine department. But in 2023, emergency medicine was shockingly removed as an essential specialty. That's a huge setback,' he said. He advocated for national protocols from the Ministry of Health or NABH, especially for golden hour conditions like STEMI and head injuries. 'If doctors across India follow standardized treatment protocols—even if they eventually refer to the case—they could still stabilise the patient and save lives,' he emphasised. In closing, moderator Vikas Dandekar reflected on the international context. 'In Canada, a student with a fractured finger waited 12 hours in the ER without even a painkiller—because he was low priority. Compare that to India, where doctors operate under immense pressure but still manage to deliver care with empathy and speed. That's our strength,' he said. Dr. Agrawal echoed the sentiment. 'We're lucky here. In India, if you need an MRI, you can get it done immediately. In many Western countries, you'd need to go through multiple referrals. While that system has its merits, our accessibility—despite resource constraints—is a huge advantage.' The session concluded with a unanimous call to institutionalise emergency medicine, invest in smart technologies, and uphold patient-centered values that make India's evolving emergency care ecosystem not only efficient but also humane.
Time of India
4 hours ago
- Time of India
Dhami govt marks 4 Years with healthcare push: Hospitals begin operations in Pithoragarh & Rudrapur; two new medical colleges in pipeline
NEW DELHI: As the Pushkar Singh Dhami-led government marks four years in office, Uttarakhand is poised to receive two new government medical colleges, in Pithoragarh and Rudrapur. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Ahead of the launch, hospital operations have already begun at both sites, setting the groundwork for future academic and healthcare services. Since taking office on July 4, 2021, chief minister Pushkar Singh Dhami has focused heavily on strengthening the state's medical infrastructure. During his tenure, two government medical colleges have already been made operational, Almora Medical College in 2021 and Haridwar Medical College in 2024. These institutions have added 200 MBBS seats, raising the total number of first-year medical seats in the state to 625. Prior to these additions, government medical colleges were already functioning in Srinagar, Dehradun, and Haldwani. The government now aims to expedite the construction of the upcoming colleges in Pithoragarh and Rudrapur. According to Dr. Ashutosh Sayana, director of medical education, hospitals at both locations are already operational, and work is underway to ensure adequate staffing and infrastructure to support the upcoming medical colleges. Progress on AIIMS Satellite and Cancer Hospital In a major boost to tertiary healthcare, an AIIMS satellite center in Kichha was also approved during Dhami's tenure and work on it is progressing rapidly. The state has also launched its first air ambulance service through AIIMS Rishikesh, catering to emergency medical needs. Additionally, a 300-bed cancer hospital in Harrawala, Dehradun, has been completed. Ayushman Scheme a Lifeline for Patients The Atal Ayushman Uttarakhand Yojana has emerged as a crucial support system for underprivileged families. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Under the scheme, eligible cardholders receive free treatment up to ₹5 lakh per year for critical illnesses like heart disease, kidney disorders, cancer, and diabetes. So far, around 60 lakh Ayushman cards have been issued in the state. Beneficiaries can avail of treatment in over 30,000 reputed government and private hospitals across India. Highlighting the government's commitment, chief minister Dhami said, 'In hilly areas, people had to travel to big cities even for minor ailments. Our aim is to create a strong healthcare network at the district and tehsil levels. New medical colleges will ensure better treatment for people and open new career opportunities for youth in the medical field.' With a clear focus on decentralizing healthcare and expanding medical education, the Dhami government is making notable strides in transforming Uttarakhand's health landscape.
Hindustan Times
6 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
AIIMS gastroenterologist explains why you must soak chia seeds before eating them: ‘People have ended up in hospitals'
From smoothies to puddings, chia seeds have become a staple in health-conscious diets. But if you're eating them dry, you could be putting your digestive health at risk. Dr. Saurabh Sethi, a gastroenterologist trained at AIIMS, Harvard, and Stanford universities, shared in his July 3 Instagram post that chia seeds absorb many times their weight in liquid. Chia seeds absorb 27 times their weight in water, making dry consumption risky.(Pixabay) This means that if consumed dry, they can expand in your throat or stomach, potentially causing discomfort, bloating, or even digestive blockages. (Also read: Gastroenterologist shares how modern work culture fuels silent liver crisis: 'Even those with normal weight are at risk' ) Can eating dry chia seeds be dangerous Dr Seth explains in the post, "People have ended up in the hospital after eating dry chia seeds and then drinking water," he warned. 'The seeds expanded and got stuck in their oesophagus, and it had to be removed endoscopically. While this is rare, it has happened, especially in individuals with pre-existing swallowing difficulties or gastrointestinal conditions.' How to safely consume chia seeds for better digestion Dr Sethi shares that chia seeds have the remarkable ability to absorb up to 27 times their weight in water, which is why eating them dry can pose a risk. "Always soak them before consumption, ideally for at least 30 minutes, if not overnight. They'll form a gel-like texture that's not only easier to swallow but also great for digestion," he advises. He also recommends starting small: "Begin with just one teaspoon a day and gradually work your way up as your body adjusts." By soaking chia seeds, you're not just making them safer to eat, you're also unlocking their full nutritional potential, including fibre, omega-3 fatty acids, and gut-friendly benefits. Note to readers: This article is for informational purposes only and not a substitute for professional medical advice. Always seek the advice of your doctor with any questions about a medical condition.
