Divided over Saipan…again our writers debate footie film & whether Ireland needs reminding of sporting ‘civil war'
A 76-second teaser trailer for the upcoming
5
Republic of Ireland captain Roy Keane walks past manager Mick McCarthy during squad training
Credit: Sportsfile
5
Eanna Hardwicke has been cast as Roy Keane
Credit: Wildcard
5
Mick McCarthy during a press conference to announce the departure from the squad of captain Roy Keane
Credit: Sportsfile
The trailer showcases the remote island in the Pacific Ocean that went down in Irish
The film is described as 'the definitive account of one of the most fractious fallings-out in the history of
Here, Associate Sports Editor Vincent Whelan and Senior Reporter Michael Doyle give their take on whether Ireland needed to be reminded about our sporting 'civil war'.
FOR - VINCENT WHELAN
5
Vincent Whelan said that Saipan film brings a chance for fans to be part of footie history
Credit: Collect image through journalist
SORRY if this offends you, reader . . . but a lot of us weren't even alive in 2002.
The 23-year gap between the real thing and it being committed to the big screen means most people under 30 have barely any recollection of
To paraphrase Tommie Gorman's interview with
We never got to witness the frenzied debates taking over current affairs
We never got to argue around the water cooler about whether we were 'Team Roy' or 'Team Mick'.
This summer's release will finally give us a chance to feel a part of the most infamous episode in Irish footballing history . . . and also a World Cup!
Jason McAteer jokes only time he ever voted was in Saipan and reveals how many Ireland teammates wanted Roy Keane back
Frankly, as a young(ish) Irish sports fanatic I'd be happy handing over the price of a cinema ticket to witness any kind of
But on top of that desperation to have some experience of it, there are legitimate grounds for optimism around it actually turning out to be good.
For starters, you've got
Anyone who'd be dubious about a largely comic actor taking on a weighty role clearly hasn't seen him in the likes of Philomena or Stan & Ollie.
It's a chance for fans to be part of footie history".
Vincent Whelan
Both parts earned him Bafta nominations in the Best Actor category.
And while Eanna Hardwicke is not as much of a household name, the 28-year-old is a star on the rise.
He's been in
And he was named a Screen International Rising Star in the film magazine's first Irish edition.
For all of those legitimate acting chops, perhaps most crucially of all is he's Irish and he's from
So that immediately reduces the risk of a Christopher Walken in Wild Mountain Thyme or Julia Roberts in Michael Collins level of accent butchering.
And finally, Saipan's production company, Fine Point Films, were behind the globally-acclaimed Kneecap movie.
AGAINST - MICHAEL DOYLE
5
Michael Doyle said that the main issue with the Saipan trailer is the tone
Credit: Marc O'Sullivan - The Sun Dublin
AH Saipan — will we ever stop talking about it?
It's been the subject of books, a musical, thousands of
I have no doubt the man behind Alan Partridge will do a fantastic job playing Mick McCarthy.
But my main issue with the trailer for Saipan is the tone.
It looks like the makers are about to recreate the most divisive moment in the history of Irish sport as some kind of psychological thriller — when in reality it just couldn't have been more farcical.
Now, if Coogan was to play Mick being portrayed by his much-loved alter-ego, then we'd all be dying to watch it.
Arthur Matthews probably got it right with his spoof musical I Keano, which saw the Irish manager and
It was hilarious, capturing the mood of the fiasco perfectly for everyone to just laugh at how bonkers it all really was. So how can a dark, serious tale of footie egos squaring off on a remote Pacific island just weeks before a World Cup do justice to what really went on?
Impossible to get excited if you lived through it".
Michael Doyle
I've been working in the media long enough to remember the chaos in newsrooms when Keane walked out. And the satire it created weeks later.
Everything from the skipper walking his dog Triggs in the glare of a hundred flashing bulbs to Tommie Gorman's iconic interview
with the midfield icon to a 'tired and emotional' Eamon Dunphy ranting on
Apres Match couldn't stop licking their lips.
In hindsight, it was comedy and us journalists lapped it up.
Maybe a new generation of football and movie fans will get excited by seeing this version of McCarthy v Keane.
But for those of us who lived it, it's impossible to get excited by this new film — and the trailer is genuinely hard to watch.
Maybe they should have let
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
25 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Katie Taylor aims most brutal dig yet at Chantelle Cameron as she claims ‘I made her more money than she deserves'
KATIE TAYLOR stepped up her trash-talking game after beating Amanda Serrano for the third time - with Chantelle Cameron the victim. Advertisement 2 Katie Taylor once again beat Chantelle Cameron Credit: Stephen McCarthy/Sportsfile 2 She aimed a brutal dig at Chantelle Cameron in the press conference Credit: Stephen McCarthy/Sportsfile Earlier on the night, Cameron famously beat Taylor in her homecoming bout at the 3Arena before the Bray woman avenged that defeat in November 2023 to However, a trilogy does not appear to be on KT's mind, as she illustrated with her most direct instance of trash-talking to date. In the post-fight press conference, she remarked: "I think Chantelle has to see if she can sell-out a 1,000-seater arena first. Advertisement Read More on Katie Taylor "I don't think she can sell out any stadium at all. "I think I made her more money than she deserves, to be quite honest." Cameron has long since been lobbying for a threequel against the Irishwoman. Back in March, she accused Taylor of "running away scared" after hopes of a trilogy fight between the two fell through. Advertisement Most read in Boxing The 34-year-old told TNT Sport: "It's very frustrating. "A trilogy is meant to be 1-1 and there is only one person who is 1-1 with Katie Taylor vs Amanda Serrano trilogy punch stats revealed with numbers proving how close epic fight was "It is what it is but, at the end of the day, I have a win over Katie and Katie has a win over me and now she is running scared." It is not a case of who KT will fight next, but if she will fight at all, as the Bray Bomber admitted herself. Advertisement As she has been after every fight in recent times, Taylor was asked if she was going to keep going or retire. And the Bray woman responded: "I don't know". However, she did rule out a fourth clash against her biggest rival, adding: "I just don't want to fight Amanda Serrano again. While their first two bouts were white-knuckle brawls, Taylor largely dictated the threequel at her own pace, with Advertisement That was Taylor landed the same number but from 231 thrown. The Both judges who scored it 97-93 in her favour gave her four of the last five rounds. Advertisement While even the judge that scored it a draw gave her three of the last five rounds as her stamina, intelligence and skill paid dividends. After tasting defeat for the third time, She said: "I tried something different. It was all about working smarter, not harder. "I tried to keep my distance, try not go in there and fight with her because, apparently, it didn't work the first two fights so tried to stick with the low punches, the 1-2s and I guess it wasn't enough. Advertisement "One judge saw it even. I got a couple of rounds. I don't know. I have to go back and see it. My team said I won. "Obviously I am going to go with what my team tells me. They were telling me what to do and I was trying to apply it in the ring."
The Irish Sun
25 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Douglas James-Taylor bags first Bohemians goal in cruise over Galway United – though concern over injured ace
BOHEMIANS climbed to second thanks to their biggest home win in 20 months. Douglas James-Taylor's first goal for the club - on Although they had twice won 3-0 on the road since, it was their largest margin of victory in Phibsborough since defeating Cork City 4-0 on the final day of the 2023 season. They are now eight points behind leaders Shamrock Rovers, with a game in hand, although Derry City can leapfrog them if they beat Sligo Rovers. The next league game for Alan Reynolds' side is away to the Candystripes on Friday week with both sides looking to establish their credentials as the Hoops' main challengers. For Galway, it is about trying to stop the rot. They have won just two of their last 12 games. Read More On Irish Football They had taken three points here in March but that was thanks to two goals by Moses Dyer who had since left. His effective replacement Malcom Shaw was handful here but is not as clinical. This was his fifth appearance and he has yet to score. He went close with a bicycle kick from Jeannot Esua's cross. And his physical presence did give Galway an outlet in the first half at least. Esua was involved in Galway's only real other opportunity of the first half when his path deflected nicely into the path of Ed McCarthy. Most read in Football Kacper Chorazka was alert to the danger and raced off his line to block. The ball came to David Hurley but his chipped effort went wide. But Bohs had the bulk of the ball and more chances. From Chorazka's goal kick following Hurley's shot, Greg Cunningham misdirected a defensive header. Inside Lamine Yamal's epic summer including holiday to Sicily with model 11 years his senior & meeting Neymar in Brazil That allowed James Clarke to nick the ball, he shifted the ball on to his left, and then back on to his right and tried to curl one into the far corner but Evan Watts made a good save. There was nothing he could do when James-Taylor stroked the ball across his goal but a deflection off Esua helped it onto the post and the danger passed. Earlier, Rob Slevin had headed behind when Dayle Rooney thumped the ball into the ground from Adam McDonnell's cross when he would have hoped to have made a cleaner connection. But perhaps a bigger concern than not getting a goal in the opening 45 minutes was the departure of Rob Cornwall - who missed the rest of last season after tearing his ACL on the opening night - through injury. 1 It was a comfortable 3-0 win for the home side His replacement Leigh Kavanagh was the unlikely source of an assist for the opening goal in the 47th minute. After Walsh had failed to trouble Chorazka, Kavanagh was allowed to carry the ball over the halfway line without anyone making an effort to dispossess him. The centre-half played it into James-Taylor who had his back to goal. Again, Galway stood off, giving the striker the time and space to swivel and rifle the ball into the bottom corner. He almost turned provider in the 55th minute when he won the ball ahead of Galway debutant Aaron Bolger. He prodded the ball forward with Clarke getting ahead of Cunningham whom he left trailing in his wake. The shot which followed was good but, again, Watts thwarted the Meath man. Clarke then teed up McDonnell in front of goal but, as he moved to pull the trigger, Slevin made a block. But Bohs doubled their advantage in the 62nd minute when it was a case of third time lucky for Clarke who scored with a tap-in after good work by McDonnell and Dawson Devoy. It was 3-0 10 minutes later. Devoy carried the ball forward before slipping in Clarke who cut inside one of the substitutes Garry Buckley before letting fly into the far corner. Cillian Tollett went close to a consolation goal after coming on but his header struck the bar. SUN STAR MAN: James Clarke (Bohs) BOHEMIANS: Chorazka 7; Byrne 7, Cornwall 6 (Kavanagh 39, 7), Flores 7; Rooney 7 (Mountney 85, 5), Devoy 8, Morahan 7; McDonnell 7 (Buckley 76, 6); Tierney 7 (Whelan 76, 6), Clarke 9; James-Taylor 8 (Parson 85, 5). GALWAY UNITED: Watts 7; Esua 7, Slevin 6, Cunningham 5 (Piesold 67, 5), Burns 5; Hurley 5 (Brouder 67, 4), Borden 5 (Buckley 67, 4), Bolger 5 (Thiam 77, 5), McCarthy 5 (Tollett 85, 5); Walsh 5; Shaw 7. REFEREE: R Harvey (Dublin) 6
Irish Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Katie Taylor retirement hint as she discusses what's next after trilogy win
Katie Taylor hinted that a fight at Croke Park would be the perfect way to end her career after beating Amanda Serrano for a third time. The Bray Bomber produced one of the best performances of her career as she beat the Puerto Rican by majority decision at Madison Square Garden to retain her super-lightweight world titles. Taylor's amateur skills and pedigree came to the fore in what was arguably her most dominant win over Serrano, despite one one judge scoring the bout a 95-95 draw. The other two had it 97-93 in her favour. There surely aren't many better ways to end a career than by having your hand raised in victory at a sold-out MSG, but Taylor, who turned 39 last week, says she will enjoy the win first before making a decision on retirement. "I'm just going to enjoy this victory right now and sit back, reflect, and then I'll make a decision about that soon," she said after the bout. "But I'm very, very happy with tonight's performance and just the amount of work that we put in over the last few months, myself and Ross [Enamait, coach] , it was a gruelling few months of preparation we did for these kind of fights and I'm so glad I was able to showcase what I could do tonight." Taylor was then asked if she could promise her fans back in Ireland that she would fight again on home soil. "Maybe in Croke Park," the 2012 Olympic gold medallist immediately said in response. "That would be unbelievable. I said it in the ring earlier on, just these people are spending their hard-earned money to go over and support me. It just means the world. Honestly, I can't believe that this is my life. "I'm headlining a show in Madison Square Garden, all-female card. Looking back on the whole journey, what an amazing life. "These are nights that I dreamed of as a kid and to be sitting here again as a winner, I'm so happy, so grateful." Unfortunately, the chances of a Croke Park fight realistically taking place are slim at best. Taylor's promoters Matchroom have explored the idea a number of times in recent years, but the cost of renting the stadium and the security costs that go with it have been massive stumbling blocks. Without some sort of financial help from the Irish government, it seems very unlikely that an event at GAA Headquarters will take place.
