Divided over Saipan…again our writers debate footie film & whether Ireland needs reminding of sporting ‘civil war'
A 76-second teaser trailer for the upcoming
5
Republic of Ireland captain Roy Keane walks past manager Mick McCarthy during squad training
Credit: Sportsfile
5
Eanna Hardwicke has been cast as Roy Keane
Credit: Wildcard
5
Mick McCarthy during a press conference to announce the departure from the squad of captain Roy Keane
Credit: Sportsfile
The trailer showcases the remote island in the Pacific Ocean that went down in Irish
The film is described as 'the definitive account of one of the most fractious fallings-out in the history of
Here, Associate Sports Editor Vincent Whelan and Senior Reporter Michael Doyle give their take on whether Ireland needed to be reminded about our sporting 'civil war'.
FOR - VINCENT WHELAN
5
Vincent Whelan said that Saipan film brings a chance for fans to be part of footie history
Credit: Collect image through journalist
SORRY if this offends you, reader . . . but a lot of us weren't even alive in 2002.
The 23-year gap between the real thing and it being committed to the big screen means most people under 30 have barely any recollection of
To paraphrase Tommie Gorman's interview with
We never got to witness the frenzied debates taking over current affairs
We never got to argue around the water cooler about whether we were 'Team Roy' or 'Team Mick'.
This summer's release will finally give us a chance to feel a part of the most infamous episode in Irish footballing history . . . and also a World Cup!
Jason McAteer jokes only time he ever voted was in Saipan and reveals how many Ireland teammates wanted Roy Keane back
Frankly, as a young(ish) Irish sports fanatic I'd be happy handing over the price of a cinema ticket to witness any kind of
But on top of that desperation to have some experience of it, there are legitimate grounds for optimism around it actually turning out to be good.
For starters, you've got
Anyone who'd be dubious about a largely comic actor taking on a weighty role clearly hasn't seen him in the likes of Philomena or Stan & Ollie.
It's a chance for fans to be part of footie history".
Vincent Whelan
Both parts earned him Bafta nominations in the Best Actor category.
And while Eanna Hardwicke is not as much of a household name, the 28-year-old is a star on the rise.
He's been in
And he was named a Screen International Rising Star in the film magazine's first Irish edition.
For all of those legitimate acting chops, perhaps most crucially of all is he's Irish and he's from
So that immediately reduces the risk of a Christopher Walken in Wild Mountain Thyme or Julia Roberts in Michael Collins level of accent butchering.
And finally, Saipan's production company, Fine Point Films, were behind the globally-acclaimed Kneecap movie.
AGAINST - MICHAEL DOYLE
5
Michael Doyle said that the main issue with the Saipan trailer is the tone
Credit: Marc O'Sullivan - The Sun Dublin
AH Saipan — will we ever stop talking about it?
It's been the subject of books, a musical, thousands of
I have no doubt the man behind Alan Partridge will do a fantastic job playing Mick McCarthy.
But my main issue with the trailer for Saipan is the tone.
It looks like the makers are about to recreate the most divisive moment in the history of Irish sport as some kind of psychological thriller — when in reality it just couldn't have been more farcical.
Now, if Coogan was to play Mick being portrayed by his much-loved alter-ego, then we'd all be dying to watch it.
Arthur Matthews probably got it right with his spoof musical I Keano, which saw the Irish manager and
It was hilarious, capturing the mood of the fiasco perfectly for everyone to just laugh at how bonkers it all really was. So how can a dark, serious tale of footie egos squaring off on a remote Pacific island just weeks before a World Cup do justice to what really went on?
Impossible to get excited if you lived through it".
Michael Doyle
I've been working in the media long enough to remember the chaos in newsrooms when Keane walked out. And the satire it created weeks later.
Everything from the skipper walking his dog Triggs in the glare of a hundred flashing bulbs to Tommie Gorman's iconic interview
with the midfield icon to a 'tired and emotional' Eamon Dunphy ranting on
Apres Match couldn't stop licking their lips.
In hindsight, it was comedy and us journalists lapped it up.
Maybe a new generation of football and movie fans will get excited by seeing this version of McCarthy v Keane.
But for those of us who lived it, it's impossible to get excited by this new film — and the trailer is genuinely hard to watch.
Maybe they should have let
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
an hour ago
- Extra.ie
FILM REVIEW OF THE WEEK: Beat The Lotto
Beat the Lotto , the latest offering from director Ross Whitaker, is a charming and light documentary that spins the tale of a group of amateur gamblers, hustlers, and dreamers who, in 1992, decided they could outsmart the Irish National Lottery. What unfolds is part caper, part cultural time capsule, and part portrait of the particularly Irish love of cheekily bending the rules and rooting for the underdog though who the underdog in this story is less obvious than it seems. With his trademark curiosity and affection for character-driven stories, Whitaker introduces us to Stefan Klincewicz, a moustachioed accountant with a head for numbers and a twinkle in his eye, who assembled a ragtag syndicate determined to buy every possible ticket combination and win the jackpot. Their plan was bold, audacious, and grounded in cold, hard mathematics, and the documentary walks viewers through the scheme with enough clarity and humour to keep even the most math-averse of us engaged. The true joy of Beat the Lotto is in its cast of real-life characters, many of whom are interviewed on screen. These men, older but no less spirited, bring a warmth and wit that lights up the film, and their mix of nostalgia, mischief, and sheer cheekiness is deeply endearing. Theres a sense that what they were really after wasnt just money, but fun, adventure, and the thrill of beating the odds or at least of giving it a good go. (Its interesting to note that no women appear to be in the syndicate though there was rumoured to be one woman involved, and members mention not telling their wives what they were up to, so there is like many films about finance a deeply embedded boys club mentality throughout.) Whitaker makes full use of grainy 90s TV clips, old chat show appearances, and golden-hued footage from the era, which gives the film a kind of dusty, familiar texture, and viewers who remember the early years of the Lotto will find much here to delight in. The clothes, the graphics, the music, the very tone of that time in Ireland its all there, and it makes for oddly comforting viewing, even when the subject is a potential multi-million pound scheme that was legal, but felt unfair to the average punter hoping their weekly lotto ticket could change their life. A testy interview between Pat Kenny and Stefan Klincewicz is spicily entertaining, and clips of Lotto representative Ray Bates are fantastic, as he passionately argues for fairness and equality in the Lotto. News cameras following syndicate members trying to offload hundreds of tickets in local shops feel like a wildly entertaining live episode of Crimecall , and watching the syndicate deftly turn the media narrative in another direction is a fun lesson in P.R. In this David V. Goliath story, the roles constantly change – and of course, for those unfamiliar with the story, the suspense of whether the scheme will pay off and pay out is well built. That said, the film isnt without its flaws. The pacing occasionally drags, with some interviews returning to the same points a few too many time. The dramatic reenactments dont feel necessary, and there are moments when you wish the film would stretch further beyond the mechanics of the plan and explore the broader political and cultural context of the time. It hints at a wider national mood one shaped by emigration, economic precarity and a desire to believe in something better but never quite digs in. A deeper exploration of what it meant for Irish people to put their faith in a government-backed game of chance, or how that faith sat alongside growing disillusionment in other state institutions, would have made the film deeper and stronger. Still, Beat the Lotto succeeds where it counts. It tells an Irish story that is funny, weird, and true, and does so with a lightness of touch. Ultimately, this is a film about belief in luck, in numbers, in collective effort, and in a system that might, just might, be beatable. Its about risk and reward, trust and trickery, and the uniquely Irish art of taking the craic seriously. In cinemas now. Watch the trailer below:
RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
On This Week: Ryanair launches its first ever route
This Week In Irish News Ryanair launched its first scheduled service with a flight from Waterford to London Gatwick Airport. It was the first route launched by the company and was a daily service. It also marked the first international scheduled air service from Waterford, making it Ireland's fourth international airport. 2010: The case of the kidnapped penguin from Dublin Zoo A penguin was stolen from Dublin Zoo and was later found at Rutland Street. Kelli, a 10-year-old female penguin, was captured at 8:30am before the zoo opened. She was later found and returned by Gardai from Store Street. Kelli was returned to the penguin habitat after a vet inspection found she had no injuries. This Week In Irish Sports The first two stages of the iconic cycling race, the Tour de France, took place in Ireland. The 85th edition saw the first stage held in counties Wicklow and Dublin, where it finished in Phoenix Park. The stage winner was Tom Steels from Belgium. The second stage began in Enniscorthy, County Wexford, and ended in Cork, with Svorada Ján from the Czech Republic crossing the finish line first. 2022: Westmeath win the inaugural Tailteann Cup A late goal from Kieran Martin capped a dramatic comeback that helped Westmeath secure the inaugural Tailteann Cup title. Three points down when approaching the hour mark, Westmeath scored 1-04 to beat the tournament favourites Cavan and secure the title. The final score was Cavan 1-13 Westmeath 2-14. This Week In Irish Entertainment 2005: 'The Wind That Shakes The Barley' begins shooting in Cork Bandon in Co Cork was transformed for Ken Loach's film 'The Wind that Shakes the Barley'. The movie, which starred Cillian Murphy, Pádraic Delaney, Liam Cunningham, and Orla Fitzgerald, was set during the Irish War of Independence and the Irish Civil War. Loach, known for his realistic portrayal of working-class heroes, said the movie tackled the thorny subject of Irish nationalism. 2015: Coláiste Lurgan release as Gaeilge cover of Cheerleader Coláiste Lurgan released another as Gaeilge cover over the summer, OMI's chart-topping hit, Cheerleader, which received over 2.7 million views. The summer school, based in the Connemara Gaeltacht village of Inverin, had released cover versions of hit songs as Gaeilge; its first one was a cover of Avicii's Wake Me Up in 2013. The school has given other famous hits an Irish spin, such as Adele's 'Hello' and Hozier's 'Take Me to Church.' This Week In Irish Culture 1998: Carnival marks Dublin's 1,000th birthday Dublin city marked its 1,000th birthday with a weekend-long street carnival. Lord Mayor of Dublin Ben Briscoe launched the massive Dublin Street Carnival, which began with a parade of over 200 performers in full costume, led by the New Jersey Emerald Pipe Band. Over the weekend, hundreds of events took place, featuring entertainers, musicians, clowns, and jugglers performing around Dublin city centre. What was Number 1 in Ireland This Week? 1970: 'In The Summertime' by Mungo Jerry The British rock band sold 30 million copies of the song, which celebrates the carefree days of summer. 1991: '(Everything I Do) I Do It for You' by Bryan Adams Written for the film 'Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves', the power ballet reached number one in over 19 countries. 2001: 'Lady Marmalade' by Christina Aguilera, Lil' Kim, Mýa & Pink Originally a hit in 1974 from US funk rock group LaBelle, Lady Marmalade hit number one again as a cover for the musical film 'Moulin Rouge'. Irish Celebrities Celebrating Birthdays This Week Eve Hewson (34) Actor best known for Bad Sisters, and The Perfect Couple Robbie Keane (45) Former footballer who is the record scorer for The Republic of Ireland Imelda May (51) Signer, songwriter and TV presenter who has released six albums over her career Other Irish Trivia From This Week 1989: When the Harlem Globetrotters visited Dublin The Harlem Globetrotters, a US exhibition basketball team, came to Ireland to showcase their skills. The team was playing against arch-rivals The Washington Generals at Neptune Stadium in Cork. Before they arrived, members of the team - Quentin Jones, Memphis Douglas and Tyrone 'Hollywood' Brown - took the time to meet and greet children who were part of the Aer Lingus Sports Club at Dublin Airport. They demonstrated their skills for the young Irish players and taught them a few tricks in the process. Looking Ahead Each Monday, On This Week will bring you a mix of stories from the last 75 years, to celebrate Volkswagen's 75 year anniversary, featuring the big news stories, sporting highlights and major pop culture moments. Volkswagen has been part of those unforgettable moments - driving families to milestones, memories, and moments that matter. Join us every week as we look back at the moments of yesteryear.
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Roy Keane returns to Cork ahead of three nights of conversation at LATM
Fans of Roy Keane will be in for a treat over the next week or so, as the Corkman returns home for a stint at Live at the Marquee. The ex-footballer-turned-pundit will be speaking with Roddy Doyle in the iconic tent on Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday evening. Tickets sold out well in advance for the conversation. ★ ★ 𝗘𝗫𝗧𝗥𝗔 𝗗𝗔𝗧𝗘 𝗔𝗗𝗗𝗘𝗗 ★ ★ 📢 Due to demand, an extra date has been added for Roy Keane in conversation with Roddy Doyle on 8 July 2025 ⚽️ 🎫 Tickets on sale This Friday at 9AM — LATMofficial (@LATMofficial) November 6, 2024 The former Manchester United star has been a frequent visitor to his home county in recent years. He has done plenty of charity work, be it for Marymount Hospice or Cork Penny Dinners, or surprising a die-hard Manchester United fan in the Mercy Hospital in May. A topic that is likely to be visited at the Marquee tent is the upcoming Saipan film. It will see Éanna Hardwicke star as the Mayfield man in the dramatic recreation of perhaps Keane's most infamous moment at the 2002 World Cup. A row with then-Ireland manager Mick McCarthy (played by Steve Coogan in the film) led to Keane leaving the World Cup squad. It won't be the first time that Doyle has been involved with Keane either, having collaborated on the footballer's second autobiography, The Second Half, in 2014. Speaking to the Irish Examiner last year about that process, Doyle reflected: 'My father loved Roy. I remember Roy telling me about the early days when he was managing Sunderland, and the kit man was in charge of the music — he put on Abba's Greatest Hits and he said Roy just watched his team running out on the pitch while listening to 'Dancing Queen'. 'The way Roy told it, I was listening to it again and again, tears were coming out of me, it was just so funny."
