Council's risk aversion cause of eye-watering consultants' bill, mayor says
Nobby Clark. PHOTOS: ODT FILES
Invercargill Mayor Nobby Clark has hit out at his own council, saying its aversion to risk has resulted in an "eye-watering" consultants' bill.
His comments follow the organisation revealing it spent more than $7.3 million on consultants in less than three years between July 2022 and December 2024.
Mr Clark said the council's low tolerance for risk meant elected members did not "run against" advice from management, and management used consultants to "justify" the advice they gave elected members.
"For me, personally, I think the risk should be higher. We should take more risk," Mr Clark said.
"Because at the end of the day, you've got to balance it out against the cost of these consultants, which are eye-watering amounts."
Mr Clark said the only way to change the situation was to tell staff not to spend large amounts on advice, and for councillors to accept the risk.
"And if we get it wrong, we get it wrong."
Invercargill City Council was approached for comment but did not respond in time for publication.
The numbers were made public on the back of a Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act request from the Taxpayers' Union.
The data showed $2.58m was spent on consultants for the 12 months to June 2023, $3.23m was spent for the 12 months to June 2024, and $1.52m was spent for the six months to December 2024.
The document showed more than 160 companies were used during the two and a half-year period.
Deloitte topped the spending with more than $424,000 for work on reviewing rates, contract compliance, internal audit support and risk and assurance support.
Stantec was next with a figure of more than $396,000 for support with the Bluff wastewater consent.
— Matthew Rosenberg, Local Democracy Reporter
— LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
4 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
'We can't sustain these numbers': Wānaka rates rise questioned
Queenstown Lakes District deputy mayor Quentin Smith questioned why the Wānaka rates were significantly higher when many of the council's projects were focused on Queenstown. Photo: ODT Files Double-figure rates rises across most of the Queenstown Lakes were defended yesterday. The district council set rates at its meeting in Wānaka yesterday. Wānaka had the highest rates in the region for the upcoming year. Councillors were presented with the 2025-26 final rates for the whole region compared with the rates that were estimated in the draft 2024-34 long-term plan adopted last year. A report said the district recently had its three-yearly revaluation. New valuations on September 1 last year had been used for the assessment of rates for this year's rates. Although the total capital value had grown by 20.6%, the impact of the revaluation on rates was more pronounced for some types of property, the report said. In simple terms, if a property experienced a capital change of significantly more or less than the 20.6% average, rates payable would change up or down according to the degree of difference. The impact of the rates increases for 2025-26 would not be even across all property types and locations. This was largely because of the impact of targeted rates which were often ward or scheme-based and the availability of reticulated services, the report said. Most final rates had increased from the proposed rates in the long-term plan — Wānaka and the Upper Clutha had higher rates. The median residential rates increase for median value residential homes went from 18.7% for Wānaka, 17.6% for Luggate, 15.3% for Hāwea and 13.2% for Queenstown. The lowest median residential rate for the region was Arrowtown with a rate of 10.6%. Wānaka surpassed rates for most other property types, including median commercial rates which were set to be 14.4% compared with Queenstown's 9%. Accommodation property rates rose 22.4% in Wānaka compared with 11.4% in Queenstown. Queenstown Lakes District deputy mayor Quentin Smith questioned why the Wānaka rates were significantly higher when many of the council's projects were focused on Queenstown. The main justification given was the planned upgrades for the Upper Clutha wastewater conveyance scheme and more specifically to the Project Pure treatment plant. The purpose of the project was to ensure the resilience of Hāwea's wastewater needs as well as strengthen the wider Wānaka and Albert Town wastewater network. The project was one of the largest in the region and was costing several million dollars. "We cannot sustain these numbers," Mr Smith said, referencing Wānaka's rates. "We will need to find other ways to generate revenue." Queenstown Lakes District Mayor Glyn Lewers said during the meeting that 85% of operating expenses had gone towards core services such as building consents, recourse planning, transport, wastewater, stormwater, water supply and waste management. "This idea that we are frivolous in spending is completely and utterly erroneous."
Otago Daily Times
a day ago
- Otago Daily Times
Council's risk aversion cause of eye-watering consultants' bill, mayor says
Nobby Clark. PHOTOS: ODT FILES Invercargill Mayor Nobby Clark has hit out at his own council, saying its aversion to risk has resulted in an "eye-watering" consultants' bill. His comments follow the organisation revealing it spent more than $7.3 million on consultants in less than three years between July 2022 and December 2024. Mr Clark said the council's low tolerance for risk meant elected members did not "run against" advice from management, and management used consultants to "justify" the advice they gave elected members. "For me, personally, I think the risk should be higher. We should take more risk," Mr Clark said. "Because at the end of the day, you've got to balance it out against the cost of these consultants, which are eye-watering amounts." Mr Clark said the only way to change the situation was to tell staff not to spend large amounts on advice, and for councillors to accept the risk. "And if we get it wrong, we get it wrong." Invercargill City Council was approached for comment but did not respond in time for publication. The numbers were made public on the back of a Local Government Official Information and Meetings Act request from the Taxpayers' Union. The data showed $2.58m was spent on consultants for the 12 months to June 2023, $3.23m was spent for the 12 months to June 2024, and $1.52m was spent for the six months to December 2024. The document showed more than 160 companies were used during the two and a half-year period. Deloitte topped the spending with more than $424,000 for work on reviewing rates, contract compliance, internal audit support and risk and assurance support. Stantec was next with a figure of more than $396,000 for support with the Bluff wastewater consent. — Matthew Rosenberg, Local Democracy Reporter — LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air
Otago Daily Times
a day ago
- Otago Daily Times
Signing of build contract edges closer
After years of delay, the government is finally edging closer to a contract with an Australian construction giant to build the new Dunedin hospital, the ODT understands. Te Whatu Ora Health New Zealand (HNZ) is expected to send CPB Contractors a letter saying it plans to hire the firm to construct the inpatient building. Crown manager Evan Davies' role for the government requires him to negotiate a draft contract and present it to ministers for signing by mid-September. However, there are hurdles that mean the process could take longer, including getting an implementation business case through legally required Treasury approval. The re-employment of former programme director Tony Lloyd in Mr Davies' team raises the likelihood that the proposed contract will have fine print that shares at least some of any overspend risk between government and CPB, rather than HNZ paying a fixed price set in advance. Mr Davies, Mr Lloyd and senior CPB executives are known to have all favoured a shared-risk deal when discussing possible contracts three years ago. Responding on social media to a post by a CPB legal adviser about the problems of fixed-price contracts, Mr Lloyd said he "fully agreed". Fixed-price contracts are usually priced higher to protect the contractor against any rising costs but, depending on construction prices and other variables, are no guarantee that a project's costs will be contained. One independent construction expert — who did not wish to be named — said the type of contract would make little difference to the job's price compared with the cost of the lengthy delays to date. "It will be six of one and half a dozen of the other," they said. However, a shared-risk arrangement could prevent pricey legal pain down the track. CPB and the government have had various scuffles, including time in the High Court over escalating costs of a sports centre build in Christchurch. Meanwhile, the foundations of the inpatient building are likely to get under way. Health Minister Simeon Brown told the ODT that capping of the 324 piles already on the site would start soon, followed by work on the perimeter of the basement to form the base for the substructure. "The third part of the process will be installing the base isolators and then the frame of the main construction," he said. HNZ did not answer a question about the letter of intent to CPB but said that "commercial and delivery arrangements for the inpatient building are continuing to progress.'
