logo
Phones cannot be tapped as part of covert operations aimed at detecting crime, says Madras HC

Phones cannot be tapped as part of covert operations aimed at detecting crime, says Madras HC

Scroll.in3 days ago
The Madras High Court on Wednesday held that the law does not allow for telephonic conversations or messages to be tapped for the purposes of covert operations aimed at crime detection.
The law permits phone tapping only in public emergencies or in the interest of public safety, the court said.
Justice N Anand Venkatesh was hearing a petition by P Kishore, the managing director of a company in Chennai named Everonn Education. The Central Bureau of Investigation had in 2011 filed a corruption case against three persons, including Kishore and an Income Tax official named Andasu Ravinder.
The agency alleged that the official demanded a bribe from the company to help it evade taxes, after which Kishore paid him Rs 50 lakh.
The Union home ministry had in August 2011 passed an order allowing Kishore's mobile phone to be tapped. Kishore challenged the order before the High Court.
The court on Tuesday quashed the home ministry's order, holding that phone tapping would violate the right to privacy unless it was authorised under a procedure established by law.
The home ministry had authorised the tapping of Kishore under Section 5(2) of the Indian Telegraph Act.
However, the court noted that the provision only allows for the interception of telephones in public emergencies or in the interest of public safety.
When such a situation exists, the authorities may pass an order directing interception of messages 'after recording satisfaction if it is necessary or expedient to do so in the interest of sovereignty or integrity of India, security of the state, friendly relations with foreign states, public order or for preventing incitement to the commission of an offence', the court said.
The judge noted that the case at hand was one involving a covert operation for detecting a crime.
'As the law presently stands, a situation of this nature does not fall within the four corners of Section 5(2) of the Act…' the court said.
The judge referred to a 1996 Supreme Court judgement on a petition filed by the People's Union for Civil Liberties, in which the court laid down guidelines for telephone tapping. It also noted that these principles had been approved by the court in its 2017 judgement in the Puttaswamy versus Union of India case, in which it held that the right to privacy was a protected fundamental right under the Constitution.
The High Court on Wednesday also held that the authorities had contravened Rule 419A of the Indian Telegraph Rules by not placing the intercepted material before a review committee in time.
'As a consequence... the impugned order dated August 12, 2011, must necessarily be set aside as unconstitutional and one without jurisdiction,' Justice Venkatesh said.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Mumbai businessman accused in bank fraud and money laundering case denied bail
Mumbai businessman accused in bank fraud and money laundering case denied bail

Time of India

time25 minutes ago

  • Time of India

Mumbai businessman accused in bank fraud and money laundering case denied bail

Mumbai: Observing that the Enforcement Directorate (ED) collected sufficient material to prima facie conclude that the applicant was actively involved in the offence of money laundering, a special PMLA court on Friday rejected the bail plea of businessman Vijay Gupta. He is accused in a Rs 764.44 crore fraud involving the State Bank of India (SBI). Gupta, founder of the Vindhyavasini Group of Companies, which operates in steel manufacturing, real estate development, and infrastructure services, remains in judicial custody. The ED strongly opposed the bail, submitting that Gupta is a "habitual economic offender" actively involved in money laundering. Given the gravity and seriousness of the offences, the court concluded that Gupta is not entitled to bail. While the defence claimed that the accused was in jail for over 12 months, the court noted that he was arrested in the money laundering case only in March this year. The court said that the period of custody in the predicate offence cannot be considered since the offence under section PMLA is a different and distinct offence. The ED's case stems from six FIRs registered by the CBI and EOW, Mumbai, against six companies of the Vindhyavasini Group. It is submitted that these companies, promoted and managed by Gupta, are accused of defrauding the SBI's Eastern Express Highway Branch in Thane of approximately Rs 764.44 crores. According to the ED, the accused used 57 shell entities and 117 bank accounts for the placement, integration, and layering of the proceeds of crime. The ED detailed a systematic scheme of fraud, including the submission of fabricated and inflated Memorandums of Understanding (MOUs), Technical Economic Viability (TEV) reports, and highly inflated valuation reports of mortgaged properties to secure maximum loan sanctions from SBI. It was further alleged that the accused colluded with Vishwas Kadam, a then relationship manager for Medium Enterprises (RMME) at SBI, Thane branch, and loan consultant Vijay Patil, to process and approve loans based on these forged documents. The ED claims Gupta paid a bribe of Rs 59 lakh to Vishwas Kadam. It was further submitted that there was a diversion of approximately Rs 164 crore from cash credit limit accounts of group companies to Gupta's personal accounts and shell entities owned by him and his brothers, Ajay Gupta and Sanjay Gupta. These funds were allegedly routed multiple times for unauthorised purposes. You Can Also Check: Mumbai AQI | Weather in Mumbai | Bank Holidays in Mumbai | Public Holidays in Mumbai The ED also submitted that around Rs 42.77 crore were withdrawn in cash from August 2010 to July 2013 from the bank accounts of the Vindhyavasini Group, shell entities, and personal accounts of family members. Allegations include the purchase of flats in Borivali and Kandivali using illicit funds, with one flat reportedly purchased in the name of his children's caretaker. It was also alleged that Gupta siphoned off a significant portion of Rs 13.20 crore received as compensation from NHAI for land acquisition, some of which was already mortgaged with SBI. Gupta's lawyer argued that he was falsely implicated and that the case was lodged with ulterior motives. It was also contended that the transactions are civil in nature, with recovery proceedings already initiated by SBI pending before civil courts. It was also submitted that sufficient collateral was provided to the bank, and the remaining dues of Rs 321 crores (out of a total loan of Rs 805 crores, with Rs 486 crores already recovered) could be covered by auctioning mortgaged properties, including the Solaris Building at Powai, valued at approximately Rs 400 crore in 2013. The defence highlighted Gupta's incarceration of over 12 months and the unlikelihood of a speedy trial given hundreds of witnesses and over fifty thousand pages of documentary evidence.

Posing as sub-inspector, woman trained at Rajasthan Police Academy for 2 years
Posing as sub-inspector, woman trained at Rajasthan Police Academy for 2 years

Indian Express

time36 minutes ago

  • Indian Express

Posing as sub-inspector, woman trained at Rajasthan Police Academy for 2 years

For nearly two years she participated in outdoor drills with trainee sub-inspectors on the campus of Rajasthan Police Academy (RPA) in Jaipur, posed with senior officers and posted photos in official uniform on social media, claiming to be a serving officer in the state police force. On Friday, the Rajasthan police finally arrested the woman, Mona Bugaliya (33), on charges of impersonating a police officer, forgery and cheating. Mona, who had been on the run since 2023 following a complaint by an RPA officer, was arrested from a rented accomodation in Sikar and brought to Jaipur for further questioning. According to police officers, Mona created fake documents to gain access to the premier training institute. She frequented the RPA campus from 2021 to 2023, claiming to be a trainee S-I and participating in outdoor activities and ceremonies, trying to blend in with new recruits and senior officers. She avoided indoor training sessions where attendance was recorded, said sources at the police academy. In September 2023, an RPA officer questioned Mona about her batch affiliation and she said she was an Intelligence Bureau (IB) recruit. The officer filed a complaint against her after not finding her name in the RPA records. This prompted an official inquiry. An FIR was registered against Mona on September 29, 2023, following which the Jaipur police raided her house in Nagaur district and recovered Rs 7 lakh and a police uniform from the premises. Mona, however, was absconding. Further investigation revealed that Mona had been preparing for the S-I recruitment exam for years and had sat for it multiple times without any success. In 2021, she posted false claims of being selected in the exam on social media to impress her relatives and friends. The police did not rule out the possibility of Mona using her fake profile to con many people between 2021 and 2023. More information will be revealed after questioning the accused, said the police.

17-yr-old girl sexually assaulted on Pune-Solapur Highway: Police arrest two suspects, to be produced in court today
17-yr-old girl sexually assaulted on Pune-Solapur Highway: Police arrest two suspects, to be produced in court today

Indian Express

timean hour ago

  • Indian Express

17-yr-old girl sexually assaulted on Pune-Solapur Highway: Police arrest two suspects, to be produced in court today

Pune rural police arrested two suspects in the sexual assault of a 17-year-old girl on the Pune-Solapur highway which took place in the early hours of June 30. Three women who had been travelling in a car with the victim were robbed as well. 'We have arrested two suspects in the case from different locations in Pune district. We are investigating their criminal history. The two will be produced before a court tomorrow (June 6) where their custody for further probe will be sought.' said an officer from Pune Rural police. The officer identified the two suspects as Sameer Pathan alias Lucky (25) and Vikas Satpute (28). The incident took place when seven people from three families, incuding the teen and the three other women, were on their way to the temple town of Pandharpur in Solapur district. The seven knew each other as they were all from the same village in Pune District. Two 17-year-old boys and a 70-year-old driver were also part of the group in the van. Ten teams had been formed for the probe. The incident had taken place around 4.15 am on June 30, around 10 kms from Bhigwan town. At the time of the incident, the driver had stopped the vehicle by the roadside to relieve himself. Two unidentified men approached the car. Brandishing sharp weapons, they robbed three women of her gold ornaments worth Rs 1.5 lakh. During this attack, one of the men took the girl away behind the structure of the tea stall and sexually assaulted her, threatening her with a knife. The two men had covered their faces with masks. Investigation had revealed that the assailants blew chilli powder at the occupants of the vehicle as an irritant. When one of the suspects was blowing the chilli powder at them, he had momentarily lowered his mask. Based on the description given by the occupants of the vehicle, a sketch of the suspect was prepared.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store