Review that led me to resign as archbishop was partly ‘wrong', says Welby
The report said Smyth 'could and should have been formally reported to the police in the UK, and to authorities in South Africa (church authorities and potentially the police) by church officers, including a diocesan bishop and Justin Welby in 2013'.
During an interview which took place at the Cambridge Union in May, Mr Welby denied having learned the full extent of Smyth's abuse until 2017.
'Makin is wrong in that,' Mr Welby said during the event.
'Not deliberately, but he didn't see a bit of evidence that subsequently came out after his report and after my resignation.
'The bit of evidence was his emails from Lambeth to Ely and from Ely letters to South Africa, where Smyth was living, and letters to the police in which the reporting was fully given to the police, and the police asked the church not to carry out its own investigations because it would interfere with theirs.
'Now I had checked, and I was told the police had been informed.'
Over five decades between the 1970s until his death, John Smyth is said to have subjected as many as 130 boys and young men in the UK and Africa to traumatic physical, sexual, psychological and spiritual attacks, permanently marking their lives.
Smyth died aged 75 in Cape Town in 2018 while under investigation by Hampshire Police, and was 'never brought to justice for the abuse', the Makin Review said.
Asked at the event why he did not report John Smyth in 2013 when he first heard of allegations made against him, Mr Welby said: 'First of all, I first knew of John Smyth's abuse in 2013 at the beginning of August, when one person in Cambridge disclosed to the diocesan safeguarding advisor that they had been abused.
'A few days later, I had a report through my chaplain who had been rung up from the Diocese of Ely, which Cambridge is in, saying … there was an allegation of abuse by one person.
'I didn't know the full details of the abuse until 2017 – that is clearly in the report …
'And it wasn't until about 2021, in a meeting with Keith Makin, that I discovered there were more than 100 people who had been physically abused.
'I disagree with the report on that … it's not truth.
'Secondly, I certainly didn't know about anything in Zimbabwe for the same period, and that emerged steadily as well.'
Mr Welby added that, in 2013, he only knew of one person alleging they had been abused by Smyth, and that he was in the midst of dealing with other prominent cases of sexual abuse within the Church.
Mr Welby said: 'I was dealing at the time with Peter Ball, the bishop of Gloucester, where we knew there were at least 30 victims, and he was going to prison, obviously, and one of those victims had committed suicide.
'That was among many cases that were coming out, and they were obviously getting my attention.
'I was focusing my attention on making sure it didn't happen again.
'I don't apologise for that.
'The worst of all possible things would have been to say, we're not going to change the system sufficiently to reduce the chances of such appalling events with such lifelong damage to survivors happening again.'
The former archbishop, however, acknowledged he was 'insufficiently persistent' in bringing Smyth to justice while he was still alive – which ultimately compelled him to step down from his role as archbishop of Canterbury.
Mr Welby also said he was seeing a psychotherapist with whom he has been discussing the time of his resignation, which he described as 'one of the loneliest moments I've ever had'.
Asked about what he would have done differently, Mr Welby replied: 'I have thought a great deal about that.
'One must be very careful about making it sound as though it was all about me. It's really not.
'There will be people here who've been abused, who are the victims of abuse, sexual abuse, or physical abuse, emotional abuse, and I've been very open that I'm one of them, so I'm aware of what it means.
'There were two reasons it was right to resign.
'One was, although I thought I had done at the time everything I should have done, I hadn't.
'It had been reported to the police, the first signs of the abuse … and it was reported to Cambridgeshire Police and then to Hampshire Police, where he (Smyth) lived at the time.
'But I was insufficiently persistent and curious to follow up and check and check and check that action was being taken.
'And I felt that that had re-traumatised the survivors.'
Mr Welby added: 'The other point was shame, because in my role, it wasn't only the Smyth case (in) the whole time I've been in post as archbishop for 12 years.
'There were more and more cases (that) emerged, very few from the present day, but going right back to the 60s and the 70s – 50, 60 years.
'And I'm sure we have not uncovered all of them, and I'm sure it goes further back than that.
'And there's one area the psychotherapist I have been seeing has helped me understand better, is: one develops an idealisation of an organisation, particularly the Church, and the sense of its failure made me feel that the only proper thing to do was to take responsibility as the current head of that organisation.
'It's one of the loneliest moments I've ever had, the reverberations of that I still feel.
'But I can persuade myself I could have done other things. I could have taken on the interviewers more strongly.'
The process to replace Mr Welby is under way.
It is expected there could be an announcement on a nomination for the 106th archbishop of Canterbury by autumn – a year after Mr Welby announced he was standing down.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
4 hours ago
- BBC News
Uninsured vehicles seized in South West police operation
A joint road policing operation involving three forces from across the South West has seized more than 10 uninsured vehicles through number plate recognition. Officers from Devon and Cornwall, Avon and Somerset, and Hampshire Police forces took part in the operation on Friday, to coincide with the busiest day of travel into region. Thirteen uninsured vehicles were seized and people were also stopped for other crimes including speeding, mobile phone offences and fuel James Gallienne, from Devon and Cornwall Police, said the operation was important as "at least one person every day" is seriously injured by an uninsured or hit and run driver." He added: "Operations like this aim to educate about and enforce the law in order to reduce the number of uninsured drivers on the road and reduce collisions."Devon and Cornwall remain safe places to live and visit and we will continue to be proactive in keeping our road network safe." 'Linked criminal activities' The three police forces worked alongside the Motor Insurers' Bureau (MIB) using Automatic Number Plate Recognition to monitor interchanges on the A30, A38 and A380 to identify uninsured vehicles."Every 20 minutes, someone is falling victim to an uninsured or hit-and-run driver, with one person so seriously injured that they require life-long care," the MIB said. "Removing uninsured vehicles from the road helps protect all road users from potential harm."Additionally, uninsured drivers are frequently linked to other criminal activities, including drug or drink driving, excessive speeding, and organised crime such as drug running."Roads policing inspector Matt Boiles, from Avon and Somerset Police, added: "We typically see a significant rise in traffic volumes at the start of the summer holidays as people travel to and through our region. "By targeting uninsured vehicles, we're aiming to reduce risk to all road users during one of the busiest times of year."The MIB said many of the drivers of the seized vehicles were knowingly uninsured but urged all drivers to check their insurance status
Scottish Sun
a day ago
- Scottish Sun
Who was Noel Stanton and how did the founder of the Jesus Army die?
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) Charismatic preacher turned cult leader Noel Stanton built a religious empire that hid horrific abuse behind colourful buses and a "Christian community" for nearly four decades. Born on Christmas Day 1926, this ordinary Baptist minister transformed into one of Britain's most controversial religious figures when he founded the Jesus Army in rural Northamptonshire. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 3 Noel Stanton preaching to his community Credit: BBC After his death in 2009, aged 82, shocking allegations emerged of systematic physical, sexual and psychological abuse spanning decades. A new BBC documentary now exposes the disturbing truth behind what one survivor describes as "a British cult hiding in plain sight." Who was Noel Stanton? In the 1970s, this firebrand preacher convinced dozens of idealistic Christians to hand over their homes, possessions, and even their children to create what he claimed would be "heaven on Earth" in rural Northamptonshire. Stanton established the Jesus Fellowship Church – better known as the Jesus Army – which grew from a small congregation at Bugbrooke Baptist Church into a nationwide movement with thousands of followers. Read more on cults 'DEEPLY DECIEVED' Sex cult brainwashed me into being a 'bride' for a rapist The bearded, authoritarian leader demanded total obedience from his flock. Members lived in communal houses, surrendered their savings to the group, and followed his increasingly bizarre rules about everything from diet to relationships. His preaching became increasingly focused on sexual "purity," with shocking footage from a 1993 documentary showing him urging followers to give their "genitals to Jesus". This obsession with controlling members' sexuality would later become central to many abuse allegations. How did the Jesus Army founder die? Noel Stanton died on May 20, 2009, aged 82, after leading his controversial religious movement for nearly four decades. Despite building what appeared to be a thriving Christian community with its distinctive fleet of colourful Jesus Army buses and evangelistic street outreach, Stanton's final years were marked by increasing scrutiny of his leadership methods. Watch moment rape cult leader who told followers he was an alien called Great Shaman is arrested in Argentina By the time of his death, cracks were already appearing in the movement he'd created, though the full extent of the abuse within the Jesus Army wouldn't become public knowledge until years later. Stanton was buried at the fellowship's New Creation Farm in Nether Heyford, a sprawling community site that had been purchased with money donated by his followers. Inside the controversial cult While presenting itself as a legitimate Christian church, the Jesus Army operated with all the classic hallmarks of a cult. Members were encouraged to cut ties with family and friends outside the group. Those living in communal "community houses" had to follow strict rules about everything from clothing to personal relationships. The group's radical "kingdom theology" taught followers that Stanton had special authority from God. This created an environment where questioning the leader was seen as questioning God himself. Ex-members describe an atmosphere of intense control, with decisions about jobs, marriages and even what clothes to wear dictated by "elders" appointed by Stanton. The Jesus Army became known for its distinctive evangelism style, with members in brightly coloured jackets approaching strangers in town centres, offering hugs and inviting them to join community life. What appeared to outsiders as a quirky but harmless Christian group was, behind closed doors, implementing practices that damaged hundreds of lives. 3 Aerial view of Sheepfold Grange, Northampton, Jesus Army Credit: Google Shock abuse claims Following Stanton's death, horrifying accounts of systematic physical, emotional, psychological and sexual abuse began to emerge from former members. Children as young as two were routinely "disciplined" with birch canes in a practice known as "rodding", causing physical and psychological trauma that survivors still deal with today. The group conducted terrifying "exorcisms" on members thought to be possessed by demons, with some subjected to hours of shouting, physical restraint and psychological abuse under the guise of spiritual cleansing. There were also several unexplained deaths within the community that former members claim weren't properly investigated at the time. Perhaps most disturbing were the widespread sexual abuse allegations. Multiple members, many of whom were children when the abuse occurred, have since come forward with accounts of sexual assault perpetrated by senior figures within the organisation. The cult's strict sexual teachings, which demanded celibacy from single members while simultaneously creating an environment where authority figures had unchecked power, created perfect conditions for predators. 3 The Jesus Army commune in Northampton was the site of many abuses Credit: Jesus Fellowship Central Offices/Youtube The Redress Scheme The scale of abuse was so extensive that, following the official disbanding of the Jesus Army in 2019, the Jesus Fellowship Community Trust established a Redress Scheme to compensate victims. The scheme identified numerous abusers within the organisation, with victims ranging from young children to vulnerable adults who had been drawn into the community. By November 2021, when the scheme closed, hundreds of former members had come forward with claims of serious abuse suffered during their time in the Jesus Army. Former members continue to speak out about their experiences, with many featured in the powerful new BBC documentary "Inside the Cult of the Jesus Army," which exposes the shocking truth behind what once appeared to be just an eccentric Christian group. The Jesus Fellowship Community Trust has acknowledged that "serious harm" was caused to many former members, particularly children, and has apologised for the "pain and suffering" experienced by those who lived under Stanton's leadership. What began as a dream of Christian community ended as a nightmare for hundreds of victims – a stark reminder of how easily religious devotion can be twisted into control and abuse when placed in the wrong hands.
Daily Mail
2 days ago
- Daily Mail
Horror of British Christian cult where 'domineering' leader obsessively preached celibacy - but he and other 'elders' sexually abused dozens for decades
Its motto was 'Love, Power & Sacrifice'. Led by the celibacy-obsessed preacher Noel Stanton, the Jesus Army espoused what to its pious members seemed like noble aims. But, as a new two-part BBC documentary reveals, the radical Christian sect that grew to have more than 2,500 followers was far from holy. Over decades, so-called 'elders' abused dozens of defenceless children who grew up in the cult. Inside the Cult of the Jesus Army reveals how Stanton himself, who died in 2009, was an alleged abuser of young boys. In rapturous meetings held in halls around the country, he told his followers that they had to '100 per cent' belong to Jesus. And one of Stanton's biggest bugbears was - ironically as it later turned out - sex. In one bizarre talk given to hundreds of attendees, he decreed: 'Surrender the middle part of you. Many of us here will have to accept that an awful power of sin lurked there. But now, we give our genitals to Jesus.' Stanton himself, who died in 2009, was an alleged abuser of young boys. In rapturous meetings held in halls around the country, he told his followers that they had to '100 per cent' belong to Jesus No music, TV or holidays: Some of he rules imposed by 'dominating' leader of Jesus cult A typed list of rules laid down by Stanton is revealed in the BBC documentary. It reads: We do not listen to secular music, watch secular TV / video or read secular books. We only listen to Christian music, watch Christian videos and read Christian literature recommended by the Church. All tape recorders, Walkmen, video players, etc are kept under central household Church control. We do not have TV's [sic], radios, stereos or CD players in our houses or vehicles. We do not use telephone services to listen to music, sport reports or any other entertainment services. We do not go to cinemas, theatres, sporting events, concerts or other places of entertainment. We do not visit public houses or clubs except for evangelistic purposes. We neither hold nor attend parties, barbeques, buffets, etc except for evangelistic purposes. We do not go swimming for exercise or pleasure, neither do we sunbathe. We do not go on holidays, nor on recreational outings to seaside resorts, zoos, museums etc. Men, women and children who lived in properties owned by the church had to follow strict rules. They included bans on 'secular' music, TV, and films, visiting the cinema or theatre and even going swimming. The BBC documentary features testimony from abuse victims and others who left the cult - which was also known as the Jesus Fellowship Church - after their claims of having witnessed wrongdoing were ignored. One survivor, Sarah, was abused within a year of moving into the church's community. She says: 'At the time I was quite childlike, and emotionally I was probably looking for this father figure. 'He was so obvious about what was going on. Like he would put his hand on my thigh under the table, whilst his wife was opposite. He would intimidate you, and he would belittle you. 'And who is going to believe you if you say it? You know, this is a person of authority. 'He just shut me down and shut me down, until I felt like it was my fault.' Stanton, who had previously been a Baptist preacher, founded the Jesus Fellowship in the village of Bugbrooke in 1969 after undergoing a spiritual experience that one church member described as being 'visited by God'. Meetings quickly attracted attention for being raucous affairs, with attendees speaking 'in tongues' and watching on as Stanton performed immersion baptisms. In the mid 1970s, church members sold their homes and then pooled their wealth to buy up properties in Bugbrooke. At its heart was a rectory that was renamed New Creation Hall. Another church hub was a farmhouse called New Creation Farm. Stanton said in 1973: 'We always had a fairly substantial congregation and on Sunday evenings we might have as many as 50 people here. 'But four years ago there came a tremendous change. I had been baptised in water, of course, but suddenly I felt I was being baptised - really baptised - in the spirit. 'Some members of my congregation completely shared this wonderful experience. 'We realised that so much of the Christian faith was traditional and respectable but it was missing "life."' Another abuse victim, Abigail, recalls being sexually assaulted when she was 14. 'One of the things he used to say was, if he didn't ejaculate, it's not rape. 'And that was, obviously a very hard thing to hear. She adds: 'It kind of got spread what had happened to some of the leaders in the church. 'And you kind of hoped there would be this like kind of welcoming arms and kind of like, "oh my god that's really awful". 'But instead you're kind of met with, "isn't she a Jezebel". By 1984, the Jesus Fellowship was the UK's largest residential Christian community. There were 600 members living across the Midlands. The group had a builder's merchants, plumbing and decorating business and even a doctors' surgery. In 1986, the Baptists Union and Evangelical Alliance - two national church bodies - expelled the Jesus Fellowship from their organisations over concerns about their unusual practices. But Stanton and his fellow leaders were not deterred by the move. They launched the Jesus Fellowship in 1987. At its peak in the early 2000s, the church had grown to have nearly 3,000 members. Another clip in the upcoming documentary shows Stanton telling another meeting: 'We are looking for a new Britain, a new Britain morally. 'We live in a nation where, there's all sorts of sexual permissive problems and the like, every kind of moral problem.' Former member Philippa remembers witnessing her friend being abused at a church outpost called Battlecentre in Acton, West London. By 1984, the Jesus Fellowship was the UK's largest residential Christian community. There were 600 members living across the Midlands But when she reported what she had seen, she was branded a 'traitor'. She says: 'This elder, he didn't seem to mind that I was there. 'He would use me as lookout so I could warn him if anyone in the community house was coming into the room or passing by. 'He took her down into the cellar and he would touch her, try and hug her. I didn't actually try and watch, because I was supposed to be the lookout, but you can't help yourself but watch. 'We were 12 and 13 at the time. One day, my dad approached me and told me that my best friend had tried to commit suicide. 'I felt ashamed. I felt ashamed of what he had done to her, I felt ashamed I hadn't told anybody already. 'So the next day my dad arranged for me to tell the elder of our household. 'They would report back to Noel. Noel was just adamant I was a traitor and I was in collaboration with my best friend.' After Philippa went to the police, the abusive elder was found guilty of the indecent assault of a minor. He was sentenced to three months in prison. Philippa adds: 'I later found out, actually, that most of my peers had been abused. These people thought they were above the law.' Another survivor recalls the exorcisms that regularly took place. She says: 'Exorcisms were quite frequent. 'Noel was one of these people who would quite easily point out a demon in somebody. 'People would throw up, some people would convulse on the floor. 'You don't know what it is. And you are trying to rationalise it as a child.' Two church members were found dead in the 1970s. The first, 26-year-old solicitor's clerk David Hooper, was discovered lying naked in the garden of one of the church's properties in Bugbrooke on a freezing cold day in December 1976. He died from exposure. At an inquest into his death, the coroner said: 'He was found in circumstances which gave the impression of a man who had been sunbathing. This will always remain a mystery.' Eighteen months later, another church member was found dead on a railway track after having an argument with Stanton, who was unhappy that he had been enjoying reading. Children were regularly beaten - 'rodded' - if they were deemed to have been 'defiant'. Another former member, named as John, was ostracised when he chose to leave over his concerns about Stanton's level of control of the church. He says: 'Nobody was allowed to talk to me or have anything to do with me because I had become the enemy.' Abuse victim Noel, who was sexually assaulted by an elder, is seen telling police in a recorded interview: 'I remember him always asking me to sit on his lap. And I could feel he had an erection. He adds: 'He put his hand in my groin area. He would do it discreetly.' The man who abused him was given an 18-month suspended sentence. After Stanton's death, a leadership team that were called the Apostolic Five took over the running of the church. Northamptonshire Police launched a criminal investigation, named Operation Lifeboat, in 2014. However, only a handful of Jesus Army members were convicted, and just two went to jail. Former member Philippa adds: 'Basically it was a sweet shop for paedophiles.' Among alleged abusers who was named in a dossier was Stanton himself. Solicitor Kathleen Hallisey says: 'His kind of victim tended to be mid to late teens. He liked young boys. He sought out young boys and he abused them.' Overall, 33 allegations of abuse were made against Stanton. A compensation scheme for former members of the Jesus Fellowship was launched in 2022. More than 500 alleged perpetrators of physical, sexual and emotional abuse were identified. A statement from the now-defunct church that was given read: 'We continue to hold out an unreserved apology to anyone who has been affected by abuse and failings of any kind in the Jesus Fellowship. 'In 2013 we as the senior leadership of the church initiated a wide-ranging process that invited disclosures of any kind of abuse, both historic and recent, and referred all such reports to the authorities.'
