Plans for 280 apartments on campus of former Bessborough mother and baby home refused
An Coimisiún Pleanála, formerly An Bord Pleanála, gave two key reasons, linked to concerns about housing mix and its design, for rejecting Estuary View's The Meadows scheme – one of two large residential schemes proposed by the company on separate sites it owns at Bessborough.
The buy-to-sell Meadows scheme was earmarked for a landbank on the eastern side of the site, and included four buildings ranging in height from one to 10 storeys.
It was submitted to the former Bord Pleanála in 2021 under the since-discontinued strategic housing development (SHD) process.
It also proposed a new pedestrian and cycle way bridge connection with the Blackrock to Passage West greenway, which flanks the site's eastern boundary. The zoning in the area permits residential, but it is an area designated as high landscape value.
However, in its ruling An Coimisiún Pleanála said the mix of units did not meet the target levels set out in the city development plan.
It also said no "statement of housing mix" was submitted, and therefore no justification had been provided in relation to the proposed mix of units.
Secondly, it said it considered its 'excessive and sustained scale, bulk and mass in combination with height, and the consequent plot ratio" would be visually obtrusive from several viewpoints within and adjoining the site.
Burial ground
The commission also noted a third recommended reason for refusal from its inspector – the presence of a potential burial ground immediately in front of the folly – which was among the reasons for its decision to refuse permission for a previous SHD application and another housing proposal on Bessborough.
But it said it believes the Meadows site, could, subject to careful forensic monitoring of ground works, be more amenable to residential development, and it decided not to include this as a reason for refusal.
Labour Cllr Peter Horgan said: "Given that this entire site is fraught with emotion and history, we need to put an end to the constant retrenching of concern that is brought whenever an application is provided here."
Estuary View declined to comment.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
2 days ago
- Irish Times
Planning ruling on Dublin Airport ramps sends wrong message
The planning authorities have their hands full with Dublin Airport . Between passenger caps and night flights, they have enough to be getting on with, but added to the mix is a Dublin Airport Authority (DAA) plan to knock down the now unused spiral ramps for cars next to Terminal 1. On Wednesday An Coimisiún Pleanála turned down DAA's appeal to demolish the ramps . Doing so 'would diminish the visual amenity on approach to T1 and expose the crude architectural detailing of the existing structures to the rear of the spirals, including the prominent architectural elements of the energy centre screened by the spiral car park ramps and as such would erode the character of the area', the commission said. Please. READ MORE This is not an application to demolish something like a block of Georgian buildings in the city centre. The character of the area around Terminal 1 has changed dramatically since it was built in 1972. What character it has now is that of a hotchpotch of buildings and walkways built at different times in an effort to keep a rapidly expanding airport fit for purpose. It has little resemblance to what was a beautiful, and not always full, building in the 1970s and 1980s. [ Planners just cannot win at Dublin Airport Opens in new window ] The reality is the airport is a key part of the State's infrastructure. It is bursting at the seams as it is, and has to always be in position to evolve to match the changing demands of air travel. This is a much different issue to the likes of the 32 million passenger cap. The cap has been in place since 2007. It was only in the last 18 months or so that it has become an issue, with DAA and airlines railing against a rule in place for almost two decades. An Coimisiún Pleanála sends a very clear message to any owner or manager of a large development in Ireland with this ruling: don't build anything interesting. Don't seek a memorable design or anything that might be architecturally notable. Build something as boring and generic as possible. Think Hawkins House more than Terminal 1. It might be the only way you will be allowed replace it when it has reached the end of its functional lifespan in a few decades.
Irish Examiner
3 days ago
- Irish Examiner
Plans for 280 apartments on campus of former Bessborough mother and baby home refused
A proposal for 280 apartments on part of the former Bessborough mother and baby home campus in Cork has been shot down. An Coimisiún Pleanála, formerly An Bord Pleanála, gave two key reasons, linked to concerns about housing mix and its design, for rejecting Estuary View's The Meadows scheme – one of two large residential schemes proposed by the company on separate sites it owns at Bessborough. The buy-to-sell Meadows scheme was earmarked for a landbank on the eastern side of the site, and included four buildings ranging in height from one to 10 storeys. It was submitted to the former Bord Pleanála in 2021 under the since-discontinued strategic housing development (SHD) process. It also proposed a new pedestrian and cycle way bridge connection with the Blackrock to Passage West greenway, which flanks the site's eastern boundary. The zoning in the area permits residential, but it is an area designated as high landscape value. However, in its ruling An Coimisiún Pleanála said the mix of units did not meet the target levels set out in the city development plan. It also said no "statement of housing mix" was submitted, and therefore no justification had been provided in relation to the proposed mix of units. Secondly, it said it considered its 'excessive and sustained scale, bulk and mass in combination with height, and the consequent plot ratio" would be visually obtrusive from several viewpoints within and adjoining the site. Burial ground The commission also noted a third recommended reason for refusal from its inspector – the presence of a potential burial ground immediately in front of the folly – which was among the reasons for its decision to refuse permission for a previous SHD application and another housing proposal on Bessborough. But it said it believes the Meadows site, could, subject to careful forensic monitoring of ground works, be more amenable to residential development, and it decided not to include this as a reason for refusal. Labour Cllr Peter Horgan said: "Given that this entire site is fraught with emotion and history, we need to put an end to the constant retrenching of concern that is brought whenever an application is provided here." Estuary View declined to comment.
Irish Independent
5 days ago
- Irish Independent
Galway farmer wins bid to challenge CPO to construct cycleway across his land
A Galway farmer has been granted High Court permission to challenge a compulsory purchase order made by An Coimisiún Pleanála (ACP) to construct a cycleway under the Connemara Greenway Project that he says would run across his land and "split" his farm, making it "unmanageable and land locked".
