Black Caviar and Winx to be elevated to Legend status in Australian Racing Hall of Fame
The mighty mares were both freakish champions and trying to determine who is the best is the subject of robust debate.
There is a school of thought that comparing champions of different eras is a futile exercise but racing – and other sports – is built on comparisons.
We all like to consider how Phar Lap would have gone against today's champions. Or, who is the best racehorse, Secretariat or Frankel?
It's the same in other sports. In cricket, we are forever comparing the records of modern day batters like Steve Smith to the legendary Sir Donald Bradman.
In rugby league, is Wally Lewis better than Andrew Johns? Is Reg Gasnier or John Raper the best of them all?
• PUNT LIKE A PRO: Become a Racenet iQ member and get expert tips – with fully transparent return on investment statistics – from Racenet's team of professional punters at our Pro Tips section. SUBSCRIBE NOW!
It's the same with AFL. There's plenty in Leigh Matthews' corner, Gary Ablett Senior is in the conversation, as are Ted Whitten, John Coleman and Tony Lockett.
There are always comparisons between Michael Jordan or LeBron James as the best basketballer, and does any boxer challenge Muhammad Ali as the greatest of all-time?
In tennis, there is ongoing debate about the best player of the modern era – Roger Federer, Rafael Nadal or Novak Djokovic? And how do they rate against the only man to win the Grand Slam twice, Rod Laver?
The point is comparing champion racehorses is like debating the greats of other sports – it's a fun exercise and we all do it.
But when analysing the race careers of Winx and Black Caviar, how do you split them?
This was the dilemma facing the Australian Racing Hall of Fame selection committee when determining which of these two mares would be elevated to 'Legend' status at the Hall of Fame-Racehorse of the Year awards in Brisbane on August 31.
There are only three racehorses elevated to the Legend category so far – Phar Lap, Carbine and Makybe Diva – and it is the most elite honour in Australian racing.
Winx and Black Caviar are both deserving of 'Legend'' status, it was just a matter of when.
And trying to decide who would go in first was like asking which mare would win if they clashed over 1400m at weight-for-age?
In the end, the selection panel simply couldn't split them and made the unprecedented but sensible call to elevate both Winx and Black Caviar to 'Legend' status the same year.
'It is fitting Black Caviar and Winx are going in as a 'Legend' together,'' said Peter Moody, trainer of Black Caviar.
'They are both great mares and it was only a matter of time, with all due respect, they were both going to get that honour and very deservedly so.''
Perfection! ðŸ'¯
Do yourself a favour & watch Black Caviar's 25 wins from 25 starts �
Which victory was your favourite? pic.twitter.com/ejIuDyuXEj
— Racing.com (@Racing) August 17, 2024
•
Hall of Fame chairman Jason Scott echoed the sentiments of the entire selection panel when he said: 'Debate has raged for years over which of the two champion mares is the greatest we've seen, however what is certain is that their legacies transcend far beyond the boundaries of racing.
'It's deserving that they both be bestowed 'Legend' status in the Australian Racing Hall of Fame together, befitting of their stature as two of the best we have and will ever have the (good) fortune to see'.
Winx won 37 of her 43 races, including her last 33 races in succession, featuring a world record 25 at Group 1 level. She was so good they made a movie about her.
'I always admired Winx's determination and the uncomplicated way she went about her work and racing,'' Waller said. 'She didn't require any extra fuss.
'She was a high performance athlete with an amazing amount of talent, and she captured the imagination.
'When I talk to people about Winx, there's nothing but ultimate respect for her. It is fitting she has been elevated to 'Legend' status.''
"IT'S EQUINE UTOPIA!"
It wouldn't be Cox Plate week without the four-time champion Winx - the most successful Cox Plate horse in history 🙌
If you're looking for more Cox Plate replays, you can head to https://t.co/Ga3GHuaAKJ 's Vault to watch them ðŸ'‰ https://t.co/rnwadynQhP pic.twitter.com/MnNVRdF6zU
— Racing.com (@Racing) October 24, 2024
Black Caviar was simply unbeatable. 25 starts, 25 wins, 15 at Group 1 level. Surely there has never been a better sprinter than this magnificent mare.
She won most of her races effortlessly, running fast times and breaking the hearts of her chasing rivals. Even when she wasn't at her absolute best, like the 2012 Diamond Jubilee Stakes at Royal Ascot, they still couldn't beat her.
'Black Caviar changed my life,'' Moody said. 'Every day, I still think about her and then when Royal Ascot comes each year around you relive those great memories again. She was a once-in-a-lifetime horse.''
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Australian
18 minutes ago
- The Australian
NRL 2025: Cameron Ciraldo ignores criticism of Lachlan Galvin's role
Bulldogs coach Cameron Ciraldo says his plans for Lachlan Galvin won't be influenced by the same people who criticised the club's recruitment strategy as he prepares to avenge his side's heavy loss to Brisbane earlier in the season. Galvin is just three games into his Bulldogs career after he made the mid-season switch from the Wests Tigers, with the young playmaker winning his first two matches before tasting defeat in an instant classic against Penrith last week. The former Tiger has started one match and has come off the bench in the other two games, with plenty of outside noise that Ciraldo should move him into the halves now and drop Toby Sexton to work on combinations ahead of the finals. Cameron Ciraldo won't let outside noise influence his plans for Lachlan Galvin. Picture:'I don't see a whole lot of it. I am told about it at different times, but internally we all understand what we're trying to do here,' Ciraldo said ahead of Friday's showdown with the Broncos where Galvin has again been named on the bench. 'We're all on the same page and I've got a number of good people around me whose opinions I trust inside our four walls, and we'll continue to do that. 'It's probably the same voices who are doubting what we did now who doubted our recruitment strategy, doubted our forward pack and doubted a lot of other things we did along the way. 'At the end of the day, how we play towards the back end of the season – everyone will have an opinion on that – but we're really comfortable with what we're doing now and how our team is evolving. 'It was such a quality game last week and it was like a benchmark game for the season, so I don't think there needs to be too much negativity around how we played last week.' Stephen Crichton's teammates rallied around him after a few late errors last week. Picture:The Bulldogs only trail ladder leaders Canberra on for and against, with the blue and whites looking to bounce back after their narrow loss to Penrith in what was the game of the season. They missed a late chance to win it when skipper Stephen Crichton's pass went into touch, with his teammates quick to pick him up and support him. That's something Crichton would have done when he joined the club, with his traits now rubbing off on his teammates. 'That was great. We're a very connected team and a very connected club at the moment, and that's really important,' Ciraldo said. 'There's a lot of outside noise about disruptions and things like that, but if you look at those key moments in the game last week… the way our team came together makes me really proud as a coach.' Their next challenge is against a Broncos side that thrashed them in round 8 to snap their winning streak to start the season, with Brisbane racing in six first-half tries to ambush their rivals. Both teams will be missing a stack of Origin stars, but Ciraldo is backing his team to learn from what went wrong when they met back in April. Poor discipline hurt the Bulldogs when they met Brisbane earlier this year. Picture:'There are some really good lessons for us there, but there were also some really good parts of our identity where we just fought for the end and never gave up and had a really good second half,' he said. 'There are lessons every week but particularly that week. 'We reviewed it pretty heavily at the time, but it's always good to go back and look at what went well and what didn't. 'I'd like to see us build on what we did last week. We learnt lots of lessons in round 8 against the Broncos, but we learnt plenty of lessons last week as well. I just want to see us put as many of those into action as we can.'
The Australian
22 minutes ago
- The Australian
Wimbledon, Day 8: Alex de Minaur v Novak Djokovic result
Seven-time champion Novak Djokovic endured a nightmare start to his match against Australian 11th seed Alex de Minaur on Centre Court, but eventually battled back to win 1-6, 6-4, 6-4, 6-4. Djokovic survived a scare to reach the Wimbledon quarter-finals with a tense four-set victory over de Minaur on Monday, local time, staying on course for a blockbuster clash with world number one Jannik Sinner. The loss continued a tough pattern of Grand Slam losses for the Aussie. 'It is a tough one. I'm looking right now at my grass season as a whole as a tad disappointing,' he said. 'There are positives [from this loss, but] at the moment, where I am in my career, it doesn't completely fulfil me. I want more. I want to be on the other side of this match and finishing this match coming out on top because I think that's the next step in my career. 'If I'm going to make the next step; these are the types of matches that need to start going my way.' Serbia's Novak Djokovic douses himself in water to cool down during a break in play against Australia's Alex de Minaur. Picture: AP Photo/Kin Cheung Alex De Minaur of Australia reacts against Novak Djokovic of Serbia during the Gentlemen's Singles fourth round match on day eight of The Championships Wimbledon 2025. Picture:Djokovic was broken in the first game and conceded two more breaks as De Minaur ran away with the first set. 'It wasn't a great start for me, it was a great start for Alex de Minaur obviously. I kind of reset myself in the second set,' Djokovic said. The Serb committed 16 unforced errors, including four double faults in the opener. Djokovic broke immediately at the start of the second set but then became bogged down in a game lasting nearly 19 minutes, which De Minaur won on his sixth break point. De Minaur plays a backhand against Novak Djokovic during the Gentlemen's Singles fourth round match on day eight of The Championships Wimbledon 2025 at All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet Club on July 07, 2025 in London. Picture: Getty Images Novak Djokovic break as he plays against Alex De Minaur as he tried to recover from a rocky start against the Australian. Picture: Adrian Dennis / AFP 'He's playing the tennis of his life. He's definitely knocking on the door of the final stages of Grand Slams,' said Djokovic ahead of the game. 'You're not super excited to play Alex de Minaur on grass, that's for sure, because he's so quick and he's a complete player.' Serbia's Novak Djokovic reacts as he plays against Australia's Alex de Minaur during a fourth round men's singles match at the Wimbledon Tennis Championships in London, Monday, July 7, 2025. Picture: AP Photo/Kin Cheung Both players struggled to hold onto their serve in an attritional battle but Djokovic, pleading for support from the crowd, held his nerve to level the match, letting out a roar as De Minaur went long. Alex de Minaur returns to Serbia's Novak Djokovic during a fourth round men's singles match at the Wimbledon Tennis Championships in London, Monday, July 7, 2025. Picture: AP Photo/Kin Cheung The third set went with serve until the ninth game, when De Minaur skewed a forehand wide to concede the crucial break. De Minaur found new inspiration in the fourth set, surging into a 4-1 lead but crumbled at the pivotal moment as Djokovic fought back, reeling off five games in a row to seal the win in three hours and 18 minutes. 'I was very pleased to hang in tough in the right moments and win this one,' said Djokovic. Alex De Minaur of Australia shakes hands with Novak Djokovic of Serbia at the net following his defeat during the Gentlemen's Singles fourth round match on day eight of The Championships Wimbledon 2025. Picture: Getty Images Fresh from his 100th win at Wimbledon on Saturday - making him the third player to achieve that feat after Martina Navratilova and Roger Federer - Djokovic reached his 16th quarter-final at the tournament. Aged 38, Djokovic is aiming to win a record 25th major title, breaking a tie with the long-retired Margaret Court, and a record-equalling eighth men's crown at the All England Club. That would make him the oldest Grand Slam singles champion in the Open era. Tennis legend Roger Federer waves after Serbia's Novak Djokovic beat Australia's Alex de Minaur during a fourth round men's singles match at the Wimbledon Tennis Championships in London, Monday, July 7, 2025. Picture: AP Photo/Kin Cheung Sixth-seeded Djokovic's 101st victory at Wimbledon came under the gaze of Federer, who was sitting in the front row of the royal box alongside his wife Mirka. 'It's probably the first time he's watching me and I've won the match,' said Djokovic. 'The last couple I lost, so good to break the curse. 'No, it's great, obviously, great to have Roger, a huge champion and someone that I admired and respected a lot. 'We shared the stage for so many years, and it's great to have him back.' Sinner gifted quarter-final spot by Dimitrov injury A heartbroken Grigor Dimitrov left Wimbledon's Centre Court in tears on Monday after being forced to retire injured when two sets up in his last-16 battle against Jannik Sinner, handing the top seed a remarkable reprieve. Sinner himself had suffered a nasty fall in the opening game of the fourth-round clash and appeared to be suffering discomfort in his right elbow. The Italian was unable to cope with Dimitrov's varied style across the opening two sets, and was staring at a shock exit when trailing 3-6, 5-7, 2-2. Yet the 34-year-old Bulgarian, who has now retired in each of his past five Grand Slam appearances, pulled up holding his right pectoral muscle and was unable to continue. 'Honestly I don't know what to say,' said Sinner. 'He is an incredible player, I think we all saw this today. 'He's been so unlucky in the past couple of years. An incredible player, a good friend of mine also. We understand each other very well off the court too. 'Seeing him in this position, honestly, if there would be a chance that he could play the next round, he would deserve it.' Dimitrov, the 19th seed, served an ace out wide to hold serve for 2-2 in the third set but then collapsed in pain. Sinner rushed to his aid before Dimitrov went off court, but he returned just moments later in tears and was unable to continue, barely able to wave to acknowledge the crowd's warm ovation. 'I hope he has a speedy recovery,' said Sinner, 23. 'It's very unlucky from his side. I don't take this as a win at all. This is just a very unfortunate moment to witness for all of us. 'I think already in the last Grand Slams he has struggled a lot with injuries and seeing him now again having this kind of injury is very, very tough. We all saw this with his reaction, how much he cares about the sport.' Jannik Sinner helps Grigor Dimitrov off court after his injury. Picture: AP Photo/Kin Cheung Dimitrov's injury woes began 12 months ago at Wimbledon, where he slipped and damaged his knee in the first set of his fourth-round clash against Daniil Medvedev. He was forced to retire from matches at the US Open, Australian Open and the recent French Open. Sinner, into the quarter-finals at Wimbledon for the fourth consecutive year, will next face world number 10 Ben Shelton, who earlier beat Lorenzo Sonego in four sets. He is on a potential semi-final collision course with seven-time champion Novak Djokovic, but there will be question marks over the Italian's own fitness after his struggles against Dimitrov. Sinner has never reached the Wimbledon final, going as far as the semi-finals in 2023. He has played in the past three Grand Slam finals, taking the title at the US Open and the Australian Open and losing the French Open showpiece in a five-set epic against Carlos Alcaraz in June. Read related topics: Wimbledon
News.com.au
28 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Blues captain Isaah Yeo pays respects to Cameron Munster after passing of his father before Origin 3
NSW Blues captain Isaah Yeo has put state rivalry aside for a brief moment in a touching act towards Cameron Munster. The Maroons captain was all set to lead his side out for the State of Origin decider in Sydney on Wednesday when over the weekend he received news that his father had sadly passed away at the age of 58. Speaking to media ahead of Wednesday's clash, opposing captain Yeo responded to the news of Steven Munster's passing, putting state rivalry to the side for a brief moment. 'I send me condolences out to the Munster family and Cam. I can't imagine what they're going through at the moment,' Yeo said. 'I feel like the NRL, as much as we sometimes hype rivalries and that, there's some things that supersede that. 'When that it the case, I feel like the NRL community rallies behind the people involved. 'Just on behalf of the playing group and the whole Blues staff and organisation we send our condolences to the Munster family.' Just days before his death, Munster and wife Debbie had spoken of his hopes to see their son Cameron captain his state to a victory against all odds. 'He's got to be proud the way he's turned his life around and for where he's come from,' Steven said. Munster is so far still expected to bravely line up and lead his Maroons side out, but since Sunday has been out of the side to remain with his family in Queensland and will rejoin the playing group on Tuesday afternoon. Munster reportedly broke down in tears around his Queensland teammates when he learned of the news at training. Although rivals, Munster has close connections to several of the Blues contingent, including Melbourne's Frank Ponissi and teammate Stefano Utoikamanu, who have set the biff aside in the wake of the news. 'It's a unique scenario where Blues staff members and Blues players are reaching out to Cameron in the middle of an Origin series,' Daily Telegraph journalist David Riccio said on Triple M. 'This hate against hate series, this state against state, but at the end of the day they're mates against mates. 'That's certainly been evident keeping in mind Frank Ponissi, he's the GM of the Blues team, but also the highly respected GM of football for Melbourne Storm of which he is extremely tight with Cameron Munster. 'At the end of the day they're all humans and Cam's going through a really tough time. 'Munster told the team before he left that 'absolutely I will play' and it's now set the scene for what should be and what will be a highly emotional affair for Cameron Munster.' Former Canterbury forward James Graham said tragedy will no doubt bring the Queensland side closer together and can stir them to a resounding victory. 'It's more important than sport and it certainly put things into perspective,' Graham told Triple M. 'When I've been in and around situations not too dissimilar to this, the effect of tragedy on an individual and within the group, it can produce a mental approach to a game which is incredibly different and ignite an emotional response. 'It is just a game, but obviously there's triggers that go into elements of a performance and I think this unfortunate situation brings this Queensland team even closer together.' Should Munster not be available, coach Billy Slater will likely bring in 18th man Reece Walsh who was seen training in the five-eighth role days before the match. But the 30-year-old, who was man of the match in a resilient Game 2 performance and first game as captain, is likely run out onto Accor Stadium for the emotionally-charged decider. 'When you think about it, Cameron Munster captaining Queensland brings so much pride to the whole of his family, and Steve would love to see him out there in the Maroon captaining his state,' Queensland and Melbourne teammate Harry Grant said. 'I think it's very brave the way he's handling the situation, but we have to respect the way he's handling it and respect the way he's doing things and give him the time and space to flick the mind back to the Queensland Maroons and Origin. 'It's a beautiful family and I had plenty of moments with the family over the years. What we can control is our performance, and that's the best way to pay our respects to the family.'
