Mamdani's beyond-cynical ‘defund' flip-flop just shows what a lightweight he truly is
The Democratic mayoral nominee rushed back from his family Ugandan villa to meet with the widow and dad of murdered cop Didarul Islam, then announced that he never really meant all those years of 'Defund the police' statements.
All the anti-police talk was just because he was 'frustrated' over the killing of George Floyd, Mamdani says . . . now.
Plus, the hate mostly came five years back, before he even won his Assembly post.
Never mind that his current agenda doesn't aim to solve the very real problem of too much NYPD overtime by hiring more cops, but rather by burning $1 billion-plus on social workers who'll supposedly pick up the burden.
So his claim that his #Defund posts are now 'out of step with the way' he views police today doesn't even pass the most elementary sniff test.
What do all the lefties who backed him in the primary think of this turnaround?
Do they feel fooled — or are they happy winking at the obvious flim-flammery?
It'd be one thing if Mamdani were maturing to a sincere appreciation for policing and the urgent need for improved public order, but the timing of this turnaround is simply damning.
No: He just can't say he still wants to defund the police if he's about to attend a hero cop's funeral as he tries to win power.
New York City doesn't need a mayor who can't make up his mind about whether having police is a good idea; it needs a mayor fully committed to a strong program of public safety.
That is, one who stood foursquare behind the men and women in blue before a cop got killed.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NBC News
25 minutes ago
- NBC News
Michigan Sen. Elissa Slotkin urges fellow Democrats to 'go nuclear' in redistricting fight
BENTON HARBOR, Mich. — Sen. Elissa Slotkin, a rising Democratic star from Michigan, told NBC News that Democrats should 'go nuclear' to counter Republicans' push in Texas and other red states to redraw the congressional maps in their favor. The first-term senator, who was tapped to deliver the Democratic rebuttal to President Donald Trump's joint address to Congress this year, said Democrats have to fight fire with fire. 'I'm going to urge and encourage blue states like a California or Chicago or Illinois to do the same thing. I don't want to do that. I want the country to have a completely nonpartisan drawing of the lines based on the census. But if they're going to do that and go nuclear, so am I,' she said in an exclusive interview after her first and only town hall of the congressional August recess on Monday night. Slotkin argued that Democrats should go on the 'offensive' against Trump and congressional Republicans' agenda more broadly. If Republicans want her vote on a spending bill to avert a government shutdown at the end of September, for example, Slotkin said they will need to roll back health care cuts signed into law as part of Trump's megabill last month. 'If my vote is wanted, right, then we got to negotiate. And then the thing I'm going to negotiate for is returning some of that health care to the people I represent,' she told NBC News, noting that she voted against a Republican spending bill in March as well. The top Democrat in the Senate, Chuck Schumer of New York, faced intense backlash from the base after he allowed a key procedural vote on that bill to move forward. Slotkin said Democrats are ready for a new generation of leadership, noting that at 49 years old, she's 'like a spring chicken in the Senate.' She referred to older leaders, at one point, as 'warmed over leftovers' and said younger voters relate to members who get 'technology and the changing economy' and don't 'use a flip phone.' Slotkin brought up the issue during the town hall as well. 'Let's be honest, even here tonight, right? It is a very hard thing to bring our young people into the conversation, because they're disillusioned, they feel left out, they feel like these people don't represent me,' she told the crowd, which was overwhelmingly composed of White seniors and older voters, although it was held at a Boys and Girls Club in predominantly-Black Benton Harbor. The club, which is located in Republican Rep. Bill Huizenga's district, has lobbied her to protect its federal funding, Slotkin said. One Democrat who appears to have a grasp on the demographic the rest of the party seems to be struggling with, Slotkin said, is Zohran Mamdani, the Democratic nominee for mayor in New York City. Slotkin said she disagrees with Mamdani on many issues, but that his upset victory over former Gov. Andrew Cuomo was 'like a blinking red light.' 'It's hard to miss the message of that election, which I think was very similar, frankly, to the election we had in November. Cost of living is still the biggest issue for people that I talk to,' she said. 'It's not maybe the internet's biggest issue, Twitter's biggest issue. It is the issue that 80% of my constituents will talk to me about in the street.' Slotkin said it's not about progressive versus moderate. Like Mamdani, Trump defeated Kamala Harris in 2024 after making lowering costs central to his campaign. 'He was going to put more money into your pocket and his yard signs, his digital ads, his TV ads, they were all centered around that,' she said. 'For Democrats, it was hard to know exactly what our priorities were.' 'We had a lot of issues we cared deeply about, but sometimes, when you care about everything, no one knows what your priorities are,' she continued. 'So my strong belief is that our priority has to be the economy.' The Democratic Party is divided on a central question right now, Slotkin said: 'Is Donald Trump an existential threat to democracy in his second term, or is Donald Trump's second term bad, but, like his first term, survivable if we just wait it out? And I just want you to know, from your senator, as someone who sits in that room on your behalf, I am in camp number one, he is an existential threat to democracy.' Asked about Gaza, Slotkin, a former CIA analyst who is pro-Israel, said she would have voted in favor of blocking certain offensive weapons sales to Israel last week. She missed the votes, brought by Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vt., which failed but attracted the support of more than half of Senate Democrats. 'It's a very dangerous thing if we have support for our relationships abroad be completely partisan,' Slotkin said, adding that she 'was glad' that Trump sent his Middle East Envoy Steve Witkoff to Gaza. 'I think that's an important step to, like, see what's on the ground and just bring this thing, all hostages out, end the humanitarian blockade. Like, get it done.'
USA Today
26 minutes ago
- USA Today
Trump says FBI 'may have to' force Democratic lawmakers back to Texas
President Donald Trump said the FBI might help arrest Texas Democratic lawmakers who fled to other states to block a Republican redistricting plan. President Donald Trump said the FBI "may have to" help arrest Texas Democratic lawmakers to their home state after more than 50 fled to block a Republican redistricting plan that could flip five U.S. congressional seats. "A lot of people are demanding they come back. You can't just sit it out. You have to go back," Trump said at an Aug. 5 press event. Trump made the remarks when asked by a reporter about Texas Republican Senator John Cornyn's request earlier in the day for the FBI to "take any appropriate steps to aid in Texas state law enforcement efforts to locate or arrest" the Democratic lawmakers. Texas Republican Governor Greg Abbott ordered the Texas Department of Public Safety Aug. 4 to arrest the Democratic lawmakers. His order was designed to force the absconding legislators to comply with civil arrest warrants that state Republican lawmakers voted to issue earlier in the day. However, it has not been clear how Texas law enforcement would be able to force the Democrats back to Texas when they are in states where local law enforcement might not be willing to execute the warrants. Many of them went to the Chicago area in Illinois, where Democratic Gov. J.B. Pritzker greeted them. Others went to Boston, Massachusetts and Albany, New York. "A lot of people are demanding they come back," Trump said Aug. 5. "You can't just sit it out. You have to go back." Contributing: Savannah Kuchar – USA TODAY
New York Post
26 minutes ago
- New York Post
Adams, Tisch and the NYPD have crime headed firmly down — but Mamdani would send it back up
Props to the NYPD, Police Commissioner Jessica Tisch and Mayor Eric Adams: Shootings so far this year plunged to the lowest level on record. Don't let anyone get away with pretending this just happened: It was the result of Adams' pro-police policies and Tisch's first-rate leadership. Indeed, shooting victims peaked at over 1,000 for the first seven months of 2021 under Mayor Bill de Blasio, after he shifted over $1 billion away from the NYPD and declined to to hire more cops. Advertisement With City Hall supporting New York's Finest, the number of victims has more than halved. Total shooting incidents, which exploded during the pandemic and amid de Blasio's retreat from proper policing, have also more than halved. Overall crime rates are now steadily dropping, too. Advertisement Yes, Adams took far longer than he should've to get his public-safety leadership team straight, but it's clear that bringing in Tisch has fully turned the tide. Heck, overall crime can and should keep going down: Brooklyn is joining Manhattan and The Bronx with full coverage of quality-of-life cops to deal with the daily concerns of New Yorkers; Queens and Staten Island will follow later this month. Get opinions and commentary from our columnists Subscribe to our daily Post Opinion newsletter! Thanks for signing up! Enter your email address Please provide a valid email address. By clicking above you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. Never miss a story. Check out more newsletters The initiative has lowered emergency response times by over 45 minutes and effectively tackled disorder like abandoned vehicles, homeless encampments and open drug use on city streets. Advertisement But the tide can readily turn back if Zohran Mamdani wins in November; even if he's abandoning his years of anti-cop, anti-policing, anti-NYPD rhetoric, he's still pushing extremist policies well to the left of de Blasio's. The ultraprogressive Mamdani, who once mocked a crying officer, doesn't want to expand the force and plans to axe the elite task force that responded to the deadly Midtown attack. He's a longtime ally of the city's most devoted cop-bashers, such as Queens Councilwoman Tiffany Caban; his entire Democratic Socialist crew is deeply committed to a poisonously foolish approach to policing, disorder and crime. Advertisement For Mamdani and his movement, the great tragedy is that cops are arresting people again. Hand him the keys of Gracie Mansion, and he'll put a stop to that.
