From The Hindu, July 3, 1975: 60 p.c. of Foreign Doctors fail in tests by council
Dr. Abdul Sayeed, Chairman of the Overseas Doctors Association, criticised the examinations and said he was not surprised that so many candidates had failed.
Only 27 out of 68 doctors passed the two-day tests held in Edinburgh last week. Dr. Sayeed remarked, 'The question paper was such that many doctors could not understand it.'
The candidates came from 70 countries whose citizens are eligible for the tests.
Doctors from Australia, New Zealand, Canada, and the West Indies are not required to sit for the examinations because their degrees are recognised in the UK. However, this year's graduates from India, Pakistan, and non-Commonwealth nations must undergo the tests.
The two-day assessments evaluated an applicant's ability to understand colloquial expressions that might arise in a doctor's office, in addition to testing their clinical knowledge.
Dr. Sayeed commented, 'On the multiple-choice question, many doctors spent 20 minutes deciphering it because it was very bizarre and badly produced.'
They were asked how they would cope with a pregnant woman with an infectious disease who had been in a road crash, and what they would tell the woman's mother-in-law. 'It is not the sort of situation that a medical practitioner is likely to encounter very often,' Dr. Sayeed said.
'All these put together in one question was a bit too much. The doctors were not expecting that type of question.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
19 hours ago
- Time of India
WHO says Gaza's Nasser hospital 'one massive trauma ward'
Geneva: Nasser hospital in Gaza is operating as "one massive trauma ward" due to an influx of patients wounded at non-United Nations food distribution sites run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation , the World Health Organization said on Friday. The U.S.- and Israeli-backed GHF began distributing food packages in Gaza at the end of May, overseeing a new model of deliveries that the United Nations says is neither impartial nor neutral. It has repeatedly denied that incidents involving people killed or wounded at its sites have occurred. The GHF told Reuters on Friday that "the most deadly attacks on aid sites have been linked to U.N. convoys," and said the U.N. and humanitarian groups should work "collaboratively" with the GHF to "maximise the amount of aid being securely delivered into Gaza". The U.N. in Geneva was immediately available for comment. Referring to medical staff at the Nasser hospital, Rik Peeperkorn, WHO representative in the West Bank and Gaza, told reporters in Geneva: "They've seen already for weeks, daily injuries ... (the) majority coming from the so-called safe non-UN food distribution sites. The hospital is now operating as one massive trauma ward." Israel lifted an 11-week aid blockade on Gaza on May 19. The United Nations human rights office said on Friday that it had recorded at least 613 killings both at aid points run by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation and near humanitarian convoys. "We have recorded 613 killings, both at GHF points and near humanitarian convoys - this is a figure as of June 27. Since then ... there have been further incidents," Ravina Shamdasani, the spokesperson for the U.N. Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, told reporters in Geneva. The OHCHR said 509 of the 613 were killed near GHF distribution points. The GHF dismissed these numbers as coming "directly from the Hamas-controlled Gaza Health Ministry" and were being used to "falsely smear" its effort. The GHF has previously said it has delivered more than 60 million meals to hungry Palestinians in five weeks "safely and without interference", while other humanitarian groups had "nearly all of their aid looted." The U.N. office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs said that there have been some instances of violent looting and attacks on aid truck drivers, which it described as unacceptable. BULLET WOUNDS Hundreds of patients, mainly young boys, were being treated for traumatic injuries, including bullet wounds to the head, chest and knees, according to the WHO. Peeperkorn said health workers at Nasser hospital and testimonies from family members and friends of those wounded confirmed that the victims had been trying to access aid at sites run by the GHF. Peeperkorn recounted the cases of a 13-year-old boy shot in the head, as well as a 21-year-old with a bullet lodged in his neck which rendered him paraplegic. "There is no chance for any reversal or any proper treatment. Young lives are being destroyed forever," Peeperkorn said, urging for the fighting to stop and for more food aid to be allowed into Gaza. The war began when Hamas fighters stormed into Israel on October 7, 2023, killing 1,200 people and taking 251 hostages back to Gaza, according to Israeli tallies. Israel's subsequent military assault has killed more than 57,000 Palestinians, according to the Gaza health ministry, while displacing most of the population of more than 2 million, triggering widespread hunger and leaving much of the territory in ruins.
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
Medical students learn handling cases caused by CBRNE tragedies
Pune: Students of Govt Medical College, Alibaug, attended a first-of-its-kind training programme on handling mass casualties and injuries caused by CBRNE (chemical, biological, radiological, nuclear, and explosive) tragedies. The content for the two-day workshop was developed by the college under the mentorship of Colonel Santosh K Singh, professor of medicine, Armed Forces Medical College (AFMC), Pune, and national coordinator for CBRNE management training. Dr Deodatt Suryawanshi, assistant professor, GMC, said although this is not part of the syllabus, they wanted to make sure that MBBS students are prepared for any untoward incident. "Be it a war or the recent chemical factory blast in Telangana, CBRNE training is a must for doctors. However, at present, it is restricted to specialised personnel in the National Disaster Response Force (NDRF) and the armed forces. Such training is not frequent for medical students, despite their potential frontline role in emergencies, especially in peripheral and rural healthcare systems," he said. You Can Also Check: Pune AQI | Weather in Pune | Bank Holidays in Pune | Public Holidays in Pune At the programme held on July 1 and 2 on RCF Campus, Alibaug, the students were taught the START (simple triage and rapid treatment) method, colour coding for casualties using triage tags to determine severity, assessing respiration rate, checking radial pulse or capillary refill, evaluating mental status using commands, high-quality cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) following AHA guidelines, and use of automated external defibrillator. Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like local network access control Esseps Learn More Undo by Taboola by Taboola They also practised chest compressions (rate, depth, recoil), rescue breathing, hot zone to cold zone transition (zoning in CBRNE), use of PPE suits for first responders, shower decontamination (dry/wet simulated), safe handling of contaminated material, proper donning and doffing of PPE, use of decontamination stretchers and tents (simulated), and tagging post-decontamination for further triage. Dr Purwa Patil, dean of GMC, said there is an urgent need for disaster preparedness and skill-based medical training in the wake of increasing manmade and natural emergencies. "As many as 105 of our MBBS students actively participated in rigorous simulation-based training that covered triage and victim prioritisation in field conditions, standardised decontamination protocols for hazardous exposure, casualty evacuation and scene safety procedures, and CPR and emergency resuscitation in disaster contexts," she said. Dr Devannad Pawar, associate professor, anaesthesia, GMC, conducted hands-on training in basic life support and CPR — foundational skills for all medical first responders. "Medical students are expected to respond effectively to mass casualty situations, yet most lack structured exposure to high-risk disaster scenarios involving hazardous materials. This workshop addressed that gap by introducing them to the essential knowledge and skills for CBRNE casualty management," he said. Such training will help produce a generation of disaster-ready, system-aware, and clinically competent doctors, prepared to protect public health and safety in times of crisis, Dr Patil said. The workshop was organised by the department of community medicine and the medical education unit of GMC, in collaboration with the District Disaster Management Authority (DDMA), Raigad. The training was conducted by Sagar Pathak, head of DDMA, senior PI Jalinder Funde of NDRF, M K Mhatre, retired assistant deputy controller, Civil Defence, and Dr (Colonel) V N Supenekar, consultant in hospital disaster management, YASHADA. Pune: Students of Govt Medical College, Alibaug, attended a first-of-its-kind training programme on handling mass casualties and injuries caused by CBRNE (chemical, biological, radiological, nuclear, and explosive) tragedies. The content for the two-day workshop was developed by the college under the mentorship of Colonel Santosh K Singh, professor of medicine, Armed Forces Medical College (AFMC), Pune, and national coordinator for CBRNE management training. Dr Deodatt Suryawanshi, assistant professor, GMC, said although this is not part of the syllabus, they wanted to make sure that MBBS students are prepared for any untoward incident. "Be it a war or the recent chemical factory blast in Telangana, CBRNE training is a must for doctors. However, at present, it is restricted to specialised personnel in the National Disaster Response Force (NDRF) and the armed forces. Such training is not frequent for medical students, despite their potential frontline role in emergencies, especially in peripheral and rural healthcare systems," he said. At the programme held on July 1 and 2 on RCF Campus, Alibaug, the students were taught the START (simple triage and rapid treatment) method, colour coding for casualties using triage tags to determine severity, assessing respiration rate, checking radial pulse or capillary refill, evaluating mental status using commands, high-quality cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR) following AHA guidelines, and use of automated external defibrillator. They also practised chest compressions (rate, depth, recoil), rescue breathing, hot zone to cold zone transition (zoning in CBRNE), use of PPE suits for first responders, shower decontamination (dry/wet simulated), safe handling of contaminated material, proper donning and doffing of PPE, use of decontamination stretchers and tents (simulated), and tagging post-decontamination for further triage. Dr Purwa Patil, dean of GMC, said there is an urgent need for disaster preparedness and skill-based medical training in the wake of increasing manmade and natural emergencies. "As many as 105 of our MBBS students actively participated in rigorous simulation-based training that covered triage and victim prioritisation in field conditions, standardised decontamination protocols for hazardous exposure, casualty evacuation and scene safety procedures, and CPR and emergency resuscitation in disaster contexts," she said. Dr Devannad Pawar, associate professor, anaesthesia, GMC, conducted hands-on training in basic life support and CPR — foundational skills for all medical first responders. "Medical students are expected to respond effectively to mass casualty situations, yet most lack structured exposure to high-risk disaster scenarios involving hazardous materials. This workshop addressed that gap by introducing them to the essential knowledge and skills for CBRNE casualty management," he said. Such training will help produce a generation of disaster-ready, system-aware, and clinically competent doctors, prepared to protect public health and safety in times of crisis, Dr Patil said. The workshop was organised by the department of community medicine and the medical education unit of GMC, in collaboration with the District Disaster Management Authority (DDMA), Raigad. The training was conducted by Sagar Pathak, head of DDMA, senior PI Jalinder Funde of NDRF, M K Mhatre, retired assistant deputy controller, Civil Defence, and Dr (Colonel) V N Supenekar, consultant in hospital disaster management, YASHADA.
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
New NHS plan will slash foreign recruits from 34% to less than 10% of workforce
UK PM Keir Starmer TOI Correspondent from London: UK PM Keir Starmer has announced plans to cut the number of overseas staff recruited for the NHS from its current level of 34% to under 10% by 2035, according to the 10-year NHS health plan unveiled this week. The largest cohort of foreign doctors and nurses in the NHS are Indian nationals. As of June 2023, there were 60,533 Indian nationals working as staff in the NHS. Of these, 10,865 hospital doctors and 31,992 nurses were Indian. 'While the NHS has always welcomed recruits from abroad, today, the NHS disproportionately relies on international recruitment…We will need to reduce the NHS' dependence on overseas staff from its current level — where 34% of new recruits have a non-UK nationality. It's our ambition to reduce international recruitment to less than 10% by 2035,' the plan states. It also says UK medical graduates will be prioritised above overseas recruits for foundation training, and will be prioritised, alongside those who have worked in the NHS for a significant period, for specialty training. It said that the 2020 decision to open competition for postgraduate medical training to international trainees on equal terms with UK-trained graduates meant the competition ratios for postgraduate places had increased to a level which was 'unacceptable'. Ramesh Mehta, president of BAPIO, which represents Indian-origin doctors and nurses, is opposed to the plan. He said a third of UK-trained medical graduates left the country last year and went to places like New Zealand, Canada and Australia. 'The number of medical staff required will continue to grow and will be impossible to have enough local graduates to fill the roles, especially if they continue to move abroad,' he said. He said the authors of the plan are 'living in dreamland' because unless things in the NHS change, local graduates will continue to emigrate. 'Last year almost 10,000 Indian doctors came to the UK to take the screening exam to work in the NHS. But many have no jobs and some have gone back. There are no jobs in the NHS at a junior level. Many doctors can't get postgraduate training in India so that's why they want to come to the UK,' he said, explaining training posts should be given on merit to those already working in the NHS, not on nationality.
