
Iran missile strikes: Father's anger exposes divide in Israeli society
"They sang about what happened to my family," says Kasem, softly, surrounded by relatives at a vigil.The video - which shows Israelis singing a common anti-Arab chant often sung by ultranationalist Jews - has been widely condemned in Israel, with President Isaac Herzog calling it "appalling and disgraceful".But there are more reasons that Kasem and the wider community in Tamra are angry about what happened.Here - as is the case with many Arab-majority communities in Israel - there are no public bomb shelters for its 38,000 residents.For comparison, the nearby Jewish-majority town Karmiel, population 55,000, has 126 public shelters.Residents of Tamra have long raised the alarm over the disparity. Situated in Israel's north, about 10km (6 miles) east of the city of Haifa and 25km (16 miles) south of the border with Lebanon, the town has been vulnerable to rockets fired by the Iran-backed Lebanese group Hezbollah. In October 2024, a rocket fired by the group seriously injured one woman. Across Israel, about a quarter of the population have no access to a proper shelter. But in non-Jewish local authorities the figure is almost half, according to a 2018 report by Israel's State Comptroller, the most recent data available. "For many decades, Arab local authorities have received lower state funding across various areas, including emergency preparedness," says Lital Piller of the Israel Democracy Institute, a think tank.Where shelters do exist, she says, "they are few, poorly maintained, and often not suited for prolonged stays".The BBC has approached Israel's Ministry of Defense for comment. Israeli Arabs - many of whom prefer to be called Palestinian citizens of Israel - make up a fifth of the country's population. By law, they have equal rights with Jewish citizens, but they routinely complain of state discrimination and being treated as second-class citizens. Following the Gulf War of 1990-91, when Iraqi missiles hit Tel Aviv and Haifa, the Israeli government mandated that all new residential buildings must contain a reinforced safe room, or Mamad, as they are known.
But Arab communities often face tough planning restrictions, which leads to unregulated construction and homes being built without them, activists say.About 40% of Tamra's homes have their own safe room, local authorities say, leaving the majority of residents having to run to neighbours' homes to share. In many cases, due to the short warning period, this is not possible."The gaps are enormous," says Ilan Amit, of the Arab-Jewish Center for Empowerment, Equality, and Cooperation (Ajeec), which works to build shelters in Arab communities. "I live in Jerusalem. Every building has a bomb shelter. Every neighbourhood has a public bomb shelter."As dark falls in Tamra, residents' phones light up simultaneously with a screeching alert: "You must stay near a protected area."Sirens soon follow, and residents - fresh from the trauma of Saturday's strike - panic. Mothers gather their children and people run up the street shouting. Several families cram into the safe room of one house. Some cry, some smile, others twitch nervously. One man closes his eyes and prays. Boom after boom is heard overhead.The shelter issue is even more pronounced in Israel's Arab bedouin communities - many of which live in villages in the Negev Desert that are not recognised by the Israeli government, so do not have shelters built for them. The only victim of the April 2024 escalation in hostilities between Israel and Iran was a young girl from one such community who was seriously injured and spent a year in hospital after fragments from an Iranian missile struck her head.Lack of shelters is also a prevalent issue in some of Israel's poorer Jewish communities in areas like the south of Tel Aviv.
A new survey conducted by Hebrew University found that 82.7% of Jewish Israelis support the attack on Iran - but 67.9% of Arab Israelis oppose it. Further to that, 69.2% of Arab Israelis reported feelings of fear over the strikes - with 25.1% expressing despair."Arab society feels neglected and left behind," says Amit. "There are huge gaps in education and employment. There are huge gaps in shelters, in the existence of shelters."Adel Khatib, a municipal official from Tamra, says: "In the days since this happened, you can feel the anger.""We don't get the basic needs," says Khatib. "Most of the Arab communities, they don't have community centres or buildings for culture, activities."According to official Israeli statistics, in 2023, 42.4% of the Arab population lived below the poverty line - more than double the proportion in Israel's general population.There have been attempts in recent years to close these gaps. In 2021, Israel's previous government brought in a five-year development plan for Arab society. "We were in the middle of a huge leap in social economic development, narrowing gaps in education, higher education, and employment," says Amit.But Israel's current right-wing governing coalition, the most hardline in its history, has slowly reduced funding for that plan - redirecting the money elsewhere.Some of these cuts came as the government adjusted budgets to fight the ongoing war in Gaza, which began in response to the Hamas-led cross-border attack on Israel on 7 October 2023, in which about 1,200 people were killed and 251 others were taken hostage.
"This government has been simply putting, you know, sticks in the wheels of this five-year plan, not making it possible to implement broad parts of it," Amit adds."For the past year and a half, Arab society found itself between a rock and a hard place in the sense that on one hand, they're suffering from the policies of the current government, and on the other hand, they're seeing their brothers and sisters in Gaza and in the West Bank suffering because of the war," he says. Outside the ruins of the family home, Mohamed Osman, 16, a neighbour, says: "Everyone is angry and sad."Speaking of Shada, 20, he says: "She studied her entire life. She wanted to be the best. Her father is a lawyer, and she wanted to be like him. All of those dreams, just disappeared."They were the best picture of a happy family…When I imagine them, I imagine the pieces of them that I saw."At a vigil ahead of the funeral, dozens of community members gather, greeting one another with handshakes, sharing coffee and tea, and mourning quietly."The bombs do not choose between Arabs or Jews," says Kasem. "We must end this war. We must end it now."Photographs by Tom Bennett
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Daily Mail
22 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Trump publicly burns Pete Hegseth with major U-turn on Ukraine weapons stance
President Donald Trump announced a sudden policy change that will once again ship powerful weapons to Ukraine – while sitting next to the the top official credited with unilaterally ordering the pause. The stunning U-turn came at an evening meeting with Israeli PM Benjamin Netanyahu and top members of his security team. It followed a phone call with Russian President Vladimir Putin that drew a rare public rebuke from Trump, and returns the U.S. to the posture of sending lethal weaponry to its beleaguered ally. Trump was seated next to Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth during the event, which came just hours after the White House defended what it called a 'standard pause' to review the state of U.S. stockpiles, even admit Russia's relentless and ongoing attacks. 'We're going to send some more weapons. We have to. They have to be able to defend themselves. They're getting hit very hard. Now, they're getting hit very hard. We're going to have to send more weapons, your defensive weapons, primarily, but they're getting hit very, very hard. So many people are dying in that mess,' Trump said. Hegseth could be seen glancing at Trump and nodding repeatedly while the president spoke about Russia 's ongoing attacks on Ukraine. Also making noticeable gestures was CIA Director John Ratcliffe, who was seated next to Hegseth. Ratcliffe glanced quickly in Trump's direction, raised an eyebrow, then looked upward while taking a large breath. NBC reported July 4th that the Pentagon held up a shipment of weapons for Ukraine for a week amid concerns about the capacity of U.S. stockpiles. It said the move blindsided lawmakers, allies, and officials in Kiev and was a 'unilateral step' by Hegseth. Trump, who held an angry Oval Office argument with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky in February where Vice President JD Vance accused Zelensky of not being thankful, on Monday called the war a 'horrible, horrible thing.' 'And I'm not happy with President Putin at all,' he said. Just hours before Trump announced the U.S. would be sending weapons, White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt had dismissed a question about whether Trump had ordered the change or if the Pentagon did it without his approval. 'This was a standard review by the Pentagon of all weapons and all aid and all support that the United States is providing,' he said, adding that it applied to regions around the world. 'When the Secretary of Defense took office, he directed the Pentagon to conduct this review to ensure that everything that's going out the door aligns with America's interests,' she said. 'So it's a pause to review, to ensure that everything the Pentagon is pushing out there is in the best interest of our military and our men and women.' The Pentagon confirmed the change, saying at Trump's direction the DOD 'is sending additional defensive weapons to Ukraine to ensure the Ukrainians can defend themselves while we work to secure a lasting peace and ensure the killing stops,' spokesman Sean Parnell said. During the NATO summit, Trump fielded a question from Ukrainian Myroslava Petsa of the BBC, who asked if the US would sell Patriot missile defenses that Ukraine is using to defend against repeated Russian drone and missile attacks. Trump called it 'rough stuff.' The Telegraph reported Monday that Ukraine would get a third of the Patriot defense interceptors it was seeking. Trump had shared his frustration after his last Putin call, telling reporters: 'I didn't make any progress with him at all.' On Friday, shortly after they spoke, Russia unleashed its largest drone attack of the war on Kiev. Celebrating the news of the shipment was House Republican Rep. Michael McCaul of Texas. 'Glad to see this news. Vladimir Putin is a thug who feigns an interest in peace, then turns around and bombs entire cities. He must be stopped before his aggression extends beyond Ukraine. Thank you, @potus, for projecting peace through strength in every corner of the globe!' McCaul posted on X. Former Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell blasted 'restrainers' in the administration and issued a statement attacking the 'strategic incoherence of underfunding our military and restricting lethal assistance to partners like Ukraine.' 'This time, the President will need to reject calls from the isolationists and restrainers within his Administration to limit these deliveries to defensive weapons. And he should disregard those at DoD who invoke munitions shortages to block aid while refusing to invest seriously in expanding munitions production,' he said. The statement tore into 'self-indulgent policymaking of restrainers' that he said 'has so often required the President to clean up his staff's messes.'


The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Lammy threatens more sanctions on Israel if ceasefire isn't reached within weeks
David Lammy has threatened more sanctions on Israel if a ceasefire in Gaza is not achieved in the coming weeks. Giving evidence to the Foreign Affairs select committee, the foreign secretary also refused to set a timeframe for when the UK would recognise Palestinian statehood, saying he could not 'tie myself to a calendar because it's convenient for a soundbite'. It comes just weeks after The Independent revealed that the Trades Union Congress (TUC), representing unions that finance Labour, issued a joint statement with its Canadian and French counterparts calling on the UK government to change its position. On Tuesday, the foreign secretary was asked by Labour MP Alex Ballinger at the Commons Foreign Affairs Committee: 'If we do not get the ceasefire we're all praying for in the coming weeks…' 'No, we have to get the ceasefire,' Mr Lammy interjected. 'But if that is not the case and we see the abomination that you've described and the intolerable continuation of the situation in Gaza, will the government go further to take measures against Israel?' Mr Ballinger asked. 'Yes we will,' the foreign secretary responded. It comes after the UK slapped sanctions on two Israeli ministers over 'egregious abuses' of human rights in Gaza, placing a travel ban and an asset freeze on Itamar Ben-Gvir and Bezalel Smotrich. The action, which was taken alongside Australia, Canada, New Zealand and Norway, was criticised by Donald Trump's secretary of state Marco Rubio, who said the move did 'not advance US-led efforts to achieve a ceasefire' and called for the measures to be reversed. There is also growing pressure from a number of senior Labour figures – including Commons foreign affairs chair Dame Emily Thornbury – on the UK to follow the example of Ireland, Spain and Norway last year to officially recognise Palestine as a state. Pressed on when the UK government would recognise Palestinian statehood, Mr Lammy said: 'I'm not going to set it to a set timeframe, because I've explained that this is a moving, live situation. There are delicate ceasefire negotiations underway. I've explained the issues that sit within that, and whether we will get a… ceasefire. I'm hopeful that we will. 'And alongside French and Saudi colleagues, we are discussing recognition, but my indication and my instinct is I actually want things to change the situation on the ground. 'I don't think I and the committee disagree with that, but there will be a judgment call, and I'm not going to tie myself to a calendar because it's convenient for a soundbite. There's a judgment call that, quite properly, you would expect the government to think very hard about.' He said that 'despite the recognition movement, actually what we've seen is further annexation on the West Bank' and 'it has not led to get us getting closer to a process, it's led to further annexation'. The TUC's joint statement, seen by The Independent last month, made three demands, including recognising Palestine's statehood. They called for an immediate and permanent ceasefire, and for the government to ensure the Israeli government meets its obligations under international humanitarian law.


The Guardian
2 hours ago
- The Guardian
Palantir accuses UK doctors of choosing ‘ideology over patient interest' in NHS data row
Palantir, the US data company which works with Israel's defence ministry, has accused British doctors of choosing 'ideology over patient interest' after they attacked the firm's contract to process NHS data. Louis Mosley, Palantir's executive vice-president, hit back at the British Medical Association which recently said the £330m deal to create a single platform for NHS data - ranging from patient data to bed availability - 'threatens to undermine public trust in NHS data systems'. In a formal resolution the doctors said last month this was because it was unclear how the sensitive data would be processed by Palantir, which was founded by Trump donor Peter Thiel, the firm's 'track record of creating discriminatory policing software in the US' and its 'close links to a US government which shows little regard for international law.' But Mosley dismissed the attack when he gave evidence to MPs from the Commons science and technology committee on Tuesday. Palantir has also won contracts to handle mass data controlled by the Ministry of Defence, police, local authorities and Thiel, a libertarian,named the company after the 'seeing stones' in The Lord of the Rings trilogy. Thiel has previously said the British public's affection for the NHS was a case of 'Stockholm syndrome' but was not speaking for Palantir, said Mosley. Palantir also provides artificial intelligence-enabled military targeting systems as well as software to integrate and analyse data scattered across different systems such as in the health service. 'I think the accusation that we lack transparency or this is secretive is wrong,' Mosley said. 'I think that BMA has, if I may be frank, chosen ideology over patient interest. I think our software is going to make patient lives better by making their treatment quicker, more effective, and ultimately the healthcare system more efficient.' In 2023 the government awarded Palantir the contract to build a new NHS 'federated data platform' but concerns have been raised by some local NHS trusts that the system was no better than the existing technology and could even reduce functionality, the website Democracy for Sale reported. Palantir was also one of the many technology companies which the Guardian revealed last week recently met with the justice secretary, Shabana Mahmood, to discuss ideas to help solve the crisis in prisons and probation from inserting tracking devices under offenders' skin to assigning robots to contain prisoners. During the hearing Mosley was challenged by the chair, Chi Onwurah MP, over whether it was the right company to be involved in the NHS when it was also working for the Israel Defense Forces in Gaza, through its military applications. Mosley declined to give operational details about what Palantir does for the Israeli authorities. Its products include a system called Gotham that 'supports soldiers with an AI-powered kill chain, seamlessly and responsibly integrating target identification'. Onwurah said cultural change was needed in the NHS in order to drive uptake of the new data systems. She asked Mosley: 'Do you really think that Palantir is the organisation to bring together 42 integrated care boards, over 200 NHS Trusts to champion NHS values, to bring them together around one federated data [platform] and, in the future, a single patient record?' 'I think the question of trust should really be about our competence above all,' Mosley said. 'Are we delivering [what] we have promised to deliver? Are we making the patient experience quicker, more effective, more efficient? And if we are, then we should be trusted with that.' The Liberal Democrat MP Martin Wrigley said the interoperability between the data systems Palantir provides for health and defence was 'profoundly worrying'. The Conservative MP Kit Malthouse wanted to know if a military could target particular individuals with particular characteristics by using Palantir's ability to process a large pool of data. Mosley said: 'We provide an enormous amount of control and governance to the organisations that use our software for that purpose to manage precisely the kind of risks that you're talking about.' Malthouse said: 'That sounds like a yes'. It also emerged during the hearing that Palantir continues to employ Global Counsel, a lobbying firm co-founded by Britain's current ambassador to Washington, Peter Mandelson. Mosley denied that a visit to Palantir's Washington DC office by the British prime minister, Keir Starmer, was arranged by Mandelson, saying 'it was done through the proper channels'. Mandelson stepped down from Global Counsel in 'early 2025', the consultancy's website says.