Center options for Rangers with No. 12 pick in 2025 NHL Draft: Jack Nesbitt, Roger McQueen

Yahoo

20-05-2025

Now that the interesting new NHL Draft Lottery is complete, the New York Rangers have an already documented decision to make on whether to retain the No. 12 overall pick or send it to the Pittsburgh Penguins to close the circle on a pair of trades made this season. If the Rangers hold on to this year's first-round pick, the decision to take the best center available seems to be the most likely course of action.
Though this draft doesn't seem to be as deep as next year's, it's not often the Rangers find themselves with an opportunity to select this high in the first round. And that gives them the chance to land a quality center, even if several are gone by time that 12th pick is on the clock.
Immediately following the lottery, nhl.com held their own mock draft with draft gurus Adam Kimelman and Mike Morreale making their picks. Each projected the Rangers to select a big center, Jack Nesbitt and Roger McQueen.
Assuming one or both of these centers fall to pick 12, let's breakdown the options between Nesbitt and McQueen.
Advertisement
Related: Why Rangers must take best center available if they keep No. 12 pick in 2025 NHL Draft
Jack Nesbitt
Windsor Spitfires; 6-foot-4, 185 pounds
NHL.com Analysis from Adam Kimelman:
'The Rangers need to get younger through the middle of the ice, and Nesbitt was able to use his size and skating to stand out on a strong Windsor team this season. He plays a smart 200-foot game to go with his strong offensive skill set.'
Nesbitt may not have the same acceleration, but I see a lot of Filip Chytil in the Windsor Spitfires center. Aside from having the similar build and left handedness, the 18-year-old is basically a slower (yet efficient) but stronger version of Chytil, that projects to be solid 3C with 2C upside.
He has enough momentum in his big stride to drive through the neutral zone. Though Nesbitt may not drive play at an elite level, he makes up for that in compete and high IQ, and is solid in all three zones. He's not afraid to get dirty to protect his net, and uses his smarts in the offensive zone to provide consistent puck support. Nesbitt has a deceptive shot, just like Chytil, and can find the open man when he draws attention as the puck carrier.
Nesbitt's certainly not afraid to take a hit to make a play, but like Chytil, could protect himself better once he fills out. He'll have no problem over time gaining muscle and perhaps adding to his acceleration to be an effective forward in the NHL. Once he does, similarities to Jamie Benn have been stated already, a late pick who needed some seasoning in his own right.
After finishing the season fifth on Windsor with 64 points (25 goals, 39 assists) in 65 games, Nesbitt had 10 points (one goal, nine assists) to go along with 30 penalty minutes in 12 OHL playoff games.
Projected timeline to the Rangers lineup: 2-3 years
Roger McQueen
Brandon Wheat Kings; 6-foot-5, 197 pounds
NHL.com Analysis from Mike Morreale:
Advertisement
'There's a lot to like about the right-handed center, who has size, a big shot and deft scoring touch to complement an extremely good motor. McQueen could be a steal at this point in the draft. He had 20 points (10 goals, 10 assists) despite missing 51 games.'
Once he fills out more and adds 15 pounds or so of muscle, the maturity of McQueen's game will dictate how quickly he's an effective NHL hockey player. He has great hands for his size and could be the guy who goes as high as sixth overall to the Philadelphia Flyers, per Kimelman's mock draft.
McQueen has a strong shot that he can beat goalies from anywhere, even on the zone entry. On the power play, he is very effective on the half wall as a scoring threat. Opposing players have to respect his mix of size, hands and creativity. Simply, he's a handful.
Before the season, McQueen was projected as a top-10 pick. However, McQueen is now viewed as a high-risk, high-reward player because he only played 17 games due to a back injury that sidelined him for five months. Teams will be enticed to take McQueen sooner, but if the injury leaves him sitting there at 12, Drury shouldn't hesitate.
He's more of a play driver than Nesbitt, so that and his larger upside makes McQueen my pick if deciding between the two. Both should be effective, but McQueen seems to have the pedigree to be a solid right-handed top-six center. While his style compares to Kirby Dach, hopefully his injury history doesn't.
It should be noted that McQueen returned in the WHL playoffs, scoring one goal in three games. Brandon lost in five games to Lethbridge in the first round.
Projected timeline to the Rangers lineup: 1-2 years