NTU penalises 3 students over use of AI tools; they dispute university's findings, Singapore News
They were penalised for academic misconduct as the assignments contained non-existent academic references and statistics or broken web links, the university said.
All three students, who were enrolled in a module on health, disease outbreaks and politics, were investigated in April. They were given the opportunity to present their cases during a formal review, NTU said on June 22 in response to queries from The Straits Times.
Two admitted to using Gen AI tools while the third claimed to be unaware that the platform they used — which markets itself as an AI-powered essay-writing service — fell under that category, NTU said.
But the three students told ST that they were accused of academic fraud over citation-related issues despite submitting evidence of their writing process or intent. They also raised issues with the disciplinary processes.
A spokesperson for NTU's School of Social Sciences said the course's instructor — whom ST understands is Assistant Professor Sabrina Luk — had "explicitly prohibited" the use of AI tools for written assignments throughout the semester.
The professor's briefing slides to students, which were seen by ST, said: "The use of ChatGPT and other AI tools are not allowed in the development or generation of the essay proposal or the long essay.
"You will receive a zero mark for the assignment if you are caught using ChatGPT and other AI for writing assignments."
NTU said students were reminded multiple times that using Gen AI would result in a zero grade for the assignment, a sanction that was formally communicated to all three students in early May. It accounted for 45 per cent of the overall grade for the module.
The university added that citing non-existent sources "undermines the credibility and authority of academic writing", and is a serious form of academic misconduct.
NTU did not respond to questions about the situation, including how it assesses citation or reference errors, the rules regarding citation generators and AI summarisers, and instances where students can use AI.
Its response comes after a Reddit post by one of the students on June 19 went viral. In the post, she claimed she was accused of using AI for a final essay for a particular module because she had made errors in her citations and used a reference organiser.
A reference organiser is a software tool that helps collect and organise references and citations.
The student who posted on Reddit told ST she had provided proof of her writing process but was not met with leniency. This included a time-lapse of her writing recorded by Draftback, a Google Chrome extension that records one's writing process.
She was told she had committed academic fraud, resulting in a permanent academic warning and a drop in her grade point average.
The Year 3 public policy and global affairs student, who requested to remain anonymous, said she tried making a formal appeal to the school's academic board. However, her attempts to reschedule the necessary consultations before appeal deadlines were unsuccessful.
In response to NTU's June 22 statement, she said that all three students had provided updated citations of the sources they used - challenging the issue of them using "non-existent sources". She added that the professor had acknowledged these updates.
In an e-mail exchange seen by ST, she had sent the professor the updated sources and a final essay that corrected the citation mistakes.
"I deeply regret not double-checking my citations and rushing through the process," her e-mail said, adding that she understands the "importance of academic integrity".
In response, the professor thanked her for the journal articles and the updated final essay in an e-mail.
The Year 3 student also claimed she was "shut down" whenever she tried to present her case, and the professor had told her there was "no negotiation".
"When I appealed through the academic integrity officer, there wasn't even a panel," she said, adding that this happened over a brief e-mail exchange.
A second student from the same degree course told ST he was accused of academic fraud over allegedly fake or inaccurate citations despite his explanations and evidence suggesting otherwise.
The Year 4 student said his professor had initially deducted 10 marks from his assignment after accepting his account that he had used AI tools to locate information, not to generate content.
However, he said that NTU's School Academic Integrity Officer overruled the decision and issued a zero grade without a hearing, which gave him a formal misconduct record.
The student said he appealed the decision without success.
The third student, who was also from the same course, told ST she was accused of academic misconduct over allegedly fake and inaccurate citations.
The Year 4 student said she had used the website citationmachine.net to compile her references. She said her essay did not contain any AI-generated content or fabricated sources.
She said she had disclosed using ChatGPT to assist with background research when her professor asked if she had used any generative AI tools after she submitted her essay.
The student said she was given a formal review before receiving a zero for the assignment and a formal record of misconduct. She alleged the professor raised her voice at her during the hearing, and she felt she was not given a fair chance to explain herself.
She said her subsequent attempts at contacting the school were ignored.
In March 2024, ST reported that students enrolled in Singapore universities have been allowed to use AI tools to complete their assignments. However, they cannot flout rules on academic honesty and plagiarism, among other things.
All six autonomous universities, including NTU, have adopted this position.
[[nid:718541]]
This article was first published in The Straits Times . Permission required for reproduction.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Straits Times
21 minutes ago
- Straits Times
US approves $400m in arms sales to Ukraine
Find out what's new on ST website and app. Ukrainian servicemen fire an M101 howitzer towards Russian troops, at a position in Ukraine's Kharkiv region. WASHINGTON - The United States on July 23 announced the approval of US$322 million (S$411 million) in arms sales to bolster Ukraine's air defences and its armoured combat vehicles. The announcement of the sales comes after Washington temporarily halted some weapons shipments to Ukraine earlier this month even as Kyiv faced heavy Russian missile and drone attacks. The sale of Hawk air defence equipment and sustainment will cost up to US$172 million, while Bradley Infantry Fighting Vehicle equipment and services will total up to US$150 million, the US Defence Security Cooperation Agency (DSCA) said. The proposed Hawk equipment sale 'will improve Ukraine's capability to meet current and future threats by further equipping it to conduct self-defence and regional security missions with a more robust air defence capability,' DSCA said. And the Bradley equipment and services will help meet Ukraine's 'urgent need to strengthen local sustainment capabilities to maintain high operational rates for United States provided vehicles and weapon systems,' it said. The State Department approved the possible sales and the DSCA provided the required notification to the US Congress, which still needs to sign off on the transactions. The latest proposed military sale to Ukraine follows another announced in early May valued at US$310.5 million for F-16 training and sustainment. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Judge asks prosecution for more information on Kpods in first case involving etomidate-laced vapes World In landmark opinion, World Court says countries must address climate change threat Singapore 5 teens arrested for threatening boy with knife, 2 charged with causing hurt Singapore Male victim of fatal Toa Payoh fire was known to keep many things, say residents Sport Bukayo Saka the difference as Arsenal beat AC Milan at National Stadium Singapore HDB launches 10,209 BTO and balance flats, as priority scheme for singles kicks in Singapore Over 1.15 million Singaporeans aged 21 to 59 have claimed SG60 vouchers Singapore Cyclist charged after allegedly hitting elderly pedestrian, killing him Russia's President Vladimir Putin launched the full-scale invasion of neighbouring Ukraine in 2022 and has shown little willingness to end the conflict despite pressure from the United States. Under former president Joe Biden, Washington committed to providing more than US$65 billion in military assistance to Ukraine. But President Donald Trump – long sceptical of assistance for Ukraine – has not followed suit, announcing no new military aid packages for Kyiv since he returned to office in January. AFP
Straits Times
21 minutes ago
- Straits Times
Brazil to join South Africa's Gaza genocide case against Israel at ICJ
Find out what's new on ST website and app. BRASILIA - Brazil is finalizing its submission to join South Africa's genocide case against Israel's actions in Gaza at the International Court of Justice, the foreign ministry said in a statement on Wednesday. South Africa filed a case in 2023 asking the ICJ to declare that Israel was in breach of its obligations under the 1948 Genocide Convention. The case argues that in its war against Hamas militants Israel's military actions go beyond targeting Hamas alone by attacking civilians, with strikes on schools, hospitals, camps, and shelters. Other countries – including Spain, Turkey, and Colombia – have also sought to join the case against Israel. In its statement, the Brazilian government accused Israel of violations of international law "such as the annexation of territories by force" and expressed "deep indignation" at violence suffered by the civilian population. Israel denies deliberately targeting Palestinian civilians, saying its sole interest is to annihilate Hamas. Lawyers for Israel have dismissed South Africa's case as an abuse of the genocide convention. The Israeli embassy in Brasilia did not immediately reply to a request for comment. Brazil's National Israeli association CONIB said in a statement in response to Wednesday's decision that "the breaking of Brazil's long-standing friendship and partnership with Israel is a misguided move that proves the extremism of our foreign policy." Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Judge asks prosecution for more information on Kpods in first case involving etomidate-laced vapes World In landmark opinion, World Court says countries must address climate change threat Singapore 5 teens arrested for threatening boy with knife, 2 charged with causing hurt Singapore Male victim of fatal Toa Payoh fire was known to keep many things, say residents Sport Bukayo Saka the difference as Arsenal beat AC Milan at National Stadium Singapore HDB launches 10,209 BTO and balance flats, as priority scheme for singles kicks in Singapore Over 1.15 million Singaporeans aged 21 to 59 have claimed SG60 vouchers Singapore Cyclist charged after allegedly hitting elderly pedestrian, killing him Brazilian President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva has long been an outspoken critic of Israel's actions in Gaza, but Wednesday's decision carries added significance amid heightened tensions between Brazil and Israel's ally the United States. The Trump administration announced 50% tariffs on all Brazilian goods this month. A diplomat familiar with the thinking of the Lula administration told Reuters that Brazil does not believe its decision to join South Africa's case will impact its relationship with Washington, however. The United States has opposed South Africa's genocide case under both former President Joe Biden and Trump. In February, Trump signed an executive order to cut U.S. financial assistance to South Africa, citing in part its ICJ case. REUTERS
Straits Times
an hour ago
- Straits Times
Forum: Explore targeted enhancements of CDC voucher scheme
Find out what's new on ST website and app. I refer to the letter ' Should CDC vouchers be used on non-essential items? ' (July 11). The writer pointed out the uneven reach of the CDC voucher scheme, with some businesses remaining outside the reach of current support measures. The scheme is now limited to essential spending at supermarkets and designated HDB heartland merchants and hawkers. While this remains important, it may not reflect the broader and changing spending habits of consumers. Expanding the scheme's eligibility or introducing targeted enhancements could better support Singapore's evolving economic and community landscape. For example, some community favourites like pasar malams – an integral part of heartland culture – are excluded. Many independent food and beverage (F&B) establishments, particularly those located outside the HDB heartland, continue to face rising costs yet remain ineligible. To address this gap, one enhancement could be a dedicated initiative for F&B businesses, aimed at stimulating demand and support for this vital sector. As more businesses adopt e-commerce, voucher eligibility could also be extended to selected online platforms, ensuring that assistance can reach businesses regardless of their physical location while still maintaining appropriate safeguards. To ensure responsible use of the vouchers, a verification framework could be introduced – requiring small businesses to submit documentation such as their Acra annual return filings, valid business registration, and tax compliance documents – ensuring that support reaches genuine enterprises while maintaining transparency. CDC vouchers have been instrumental in easing the financial burden of Singaporeans while supporting local merchants. As we celebrate SG60, it is timely to explore enhancements to make the CDC voucher scheme more inclusive and aligned with the needs of every Singaporean. Top stories Swipe. Select. Stay informed. Singapore Judge asks prosecution for more information on Kpods in first case involving etomidate-laced vapes World In landmark opinion, World Court says countries must address climate change threat Singapore 5 teens arrested for threatening boy with knife, 2 charged with causing hurt Singapore Male victim of fatal Toa Payoh fire was known to keep many things, say residents Sport Bukayo Saka the difference as Arsenal beat AC Milan at National Stadium Singapore HDB launches 10,209 BTO and balance flats, as priority scheme for singles kicks in Singapore Over 1.15 million Singaporeans aged 21 to 59 have claimed SG60 vouchers Singapore Cyclist charged after allegedly hitting elderly pedestrian, killing him Norman Tan
