From a Lygon era: Why I can't cop a Silvagni at Collingwood
Carlton lost the great Alex Jesaulenko to St Kilda as a consequence of a political storm after the 1979 premiership, the season after another celebrated Blue and future coach, Robert Walls, crossed to Fitzroy.
Four-time Carlton premiership hero David 'Swan' McKay was a teammate of Jezza and Walls in those glorious and tumultuous times. In his view, the defection of a third generation Silvagni to Collingwood would be worse than the Blues losing his more decorated teammates.
'It was bad enough to see Wallsy end up at Fitzroy and Jezza at St Kilda,' said McKay, who played alongside Jack Silvagni's late grandfather, family patriarch Sergio Silvagni, in the fabled 1970 premiership.
'To have a Silvagni ending up at Collingwood would be even worse.'
Would it really be worse? Not so – Jezza leaving was as wrenching as Ron Barassi's exit from Melbourne. But I share McKay's perspective that it would be jarring – read, flat-out wrong – to see Jack Silvagni running around for the Pies.
The Silvagnis are not merely 'another' Carlton family. They are the clan most identified with Carlton, whose history on the field – and in supporting roles at the club – is deeper and longer than others. They also have been crucial in fostering the bonds between Lygon Street/the Italian community and the Blues.
Today, it's a safe assumption that more Carlton fans – certainly Millennials and Gen Z – would fret about the prospect of seeing Charlie Curnow in another club's jumper than watching the son of SOS in the despised black-and-white stripes.
Curnow is arguably Carlton's premier player, a rare forward who gets people up and out of their seats when he's firing. To lose him would be terrible – unless, of course, the Blues could prise someone younger of similar value in return, e.g. Max Holmes, Errol Gulden or Hugh McCluggage, which is about as feasible as Joe Daniher coming out of retirement to play for Melbourne.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
News.com.au
14 hours ago
- News.com.au
‘We'll lose the fans': Wayne Bennett's simple solution to State of Origin eligibility debate
South Sydney coach Wayne Bennett has weighed in on proposed changes to State of Origin eligibility while also calling for calm as English recruit Lewis Dodd prepares to make his first start at halfback after a rough first year in Australia. Dodd was signed for three years on a lucrative deal but has played just four games off the bench this season despite the Rabbitohs going through a horror injury run in 2025. He'll finally start in the No.7 jersey against the Sharks with Jamie Humphreys in concussion protocols, with Bennett refusing to make any comments about Dodd's future before he sees how he performs. 'We're all going to be a lot smarter after tomorrow night, so let's wait until tomorrow night and answer some questions then,' he said, with suggestions the club could try to move him on at the end of the year. 'He's been good since he's been here. He's trained well, is well-mannered and has been highly respectful of the other players and his teammates. Nothing has changed for him. 'It could be a big month for him.' While Bennett didn't want to comment on Dodd's future, he was strong on Origin eligibility rules after it emerged that the Australian Rugby League Commission was considering making changes to stop players from having to choose between the Blues or Maroons and international sides England and New Zealand. As it stands, Origin stars like Stephen Crichton, Payne Haas and Jarome Luai can represent the Blues and then play for Samoa at the end of the year because of their tier 2 status. That loophole isn't available to guys like Victor Radley, who chose England over NSW, while there have been plenty of Kiwis who have been blocked from representing their state, while others have chosen to represent Tonga or Samoa so they can also play Origin. Bennett, who was in the mix to coach Australia in this year's Ashes series, has no issue with guys playing both formats but wants players to pick a country and stick with that choice for the rest of their careers. 'I don't believe they're going to play with the rules of Origin itself, and that's really important because the minute the fans realise it's not the genuine Queensland v NSW that it is, then we'll lose the fans,' Bennett warned. 'That's the great thing about it, the rivalry is real and it's not false, so we need to maintain that. 'The off side of that is players leaving that arena to then go and play for Tonga, Samoa, England, whatever. 'I'm happy for them to do that, but they can't do it as they're doing at the moment where you play for Tonga because they're second tier. If you play for England, it's first tier, so you can't swap nations. 'My point with it is that Origin eligibility won't change, and after that if you want to play for England and you qualify for England, then you do that. 'I'm happy for that because it makes the international game stronger, but I just don't want to see them playing for England and then coming back to play for Tonga because they're a second-tier nation. 'It's served its purpose and it's time to move on from that situation.' Fans would have loved to have seen Kiwis legend Benji Marshall play Origin, but he still wouldn't have been eligible even under the proposed changes given he moved to Australia after his 13th birthday. Regardless, he said he was never jealous given he's proud of his heritage. 'I always found it to be an Australian thing,' the Wests Tigers coach said. 'I just thought it was respectful to what it was that players from Australia played in that. 'We were always fans growing up in New Zealand. There was NSW and Queensland, but there was no wanting to play for them. I always wanted to play for New Zealand.'
Perth Now
15 hours ago
- Perth Now
Magpies won't ‘stand still' on recruiting stars
Collingwood coach Craig McRae says he won't 'stand still' in chasing rival players after reports the Magpies are interested in luring Carlton defender Jack Silvagni. Silvagni, a famous Carlton name, is a restricted free agent at season's end and has reportedly been tabled a four-year extension by the Blues. The 128-game Blue has been sidelined with groin soreness but had previously been enjoying a career rejuvenation in defence. McRae has been an open book when it comes to the Magpies' stance on recruiting rival players and doubled down again on Friday. The premiership coach said whether it was Silvagni or another player, the Magpies were always looking to bolster their list. 'I've said opening many times about looking for free agents, unrestricted free agents is something we want to continue to explore,' he said. Collingwood coach Craig McRae was open about his club's interest in recruiting rival players, including Carlton's Jack Silvagni. Michael Klein Credit: News Corp Australia 'Whether it's Jack or someone else, we'll step into that because we don't want to stand still. 'We want to better than what we are now and next year – we want to look at avenues to bring players in that we think can do that.' McRae confirmed he was part of list management discussions and said he would meet with Silvagni if the Blue was the right fit in black and white. 'I am heavily involved in those situations,' he said. 'Just making sure this is the right platform and environment for players to make them feel like they can come and be the best version of themselves. 'I would meet with Jack, yeah, if that was something that was important to us.' Carlton is set to lose ruckman Tom De Koning to St Kilda and it also was reported to have shut down forward Charlie Curnow exploring a move to Gold Coast. The potential arrival of Silvagni would be a huge boost to Collingwood, which has reshuffled its cards in defence as a result of injury this year.
The Advertiser
15 hours ago
- The Advertiser
AFL players will adapt to May's appeal verdict: Goodwin
Simon Goodwin remains hopeful Melbourne star Steven May will beat his rough conduct charge but insists players will adapt to a changing landscape if the club's appeal fails. May was handed a three-match ban by the AFL Tribunal on Wednesday night over the high-speed collision that left Carlton's Francis Evans with concussion, a broken nose and a missing tooth. But the All Australian defender has maintained the ball was always his focus and will take his case to the league's Appeals Board next week. "We think he had a play on the ball and it was a football incident," Demons coach Goodwin said on Friday. "From my perspective, that's ultimately the argument that we'll go with. "Clearly there's some legal stuff that they'll go through in terms of the case as part of the appeal. "But you can see it's divided a lot of the public and I think it's one of those cases where everyone wants it to go through the appeals (process) and see what the outcome is going to be." Goodwin said May was "devastated and shattered". "Right from the outset when he first came to the bench, he was a little bit confused and thought he'd done the right thing and gone at the footy," Goodwin said. "He was shattered, he was disappointed with the outcome and clearly frustrated. "This is part of the process, go through the appeals, get the clarity required and we'll all move forward post that." Goodwin said players will adapt with the more information they get from the AFL about how they are required to act in certain scenarios. The 2021 premiership coach referenced the aerial contest between Fremantle captain Alex Pearce and Port Adelaide's Darcy Byrne-Jones, which caused similar controversy to the May-Evans collision. Pearce was handed a three-match ban before overturning it on appeal. "This is part of the game," Goodwin said. "We're learning more and more about the game and what's required in the game, and what the players need to do in the game, especially around concussion. "But if you look at the Alex Pearce case, these cases go all the way through to the appeals and you get more information." May is recovering from his own concussion, ruled out of Sunday's clash with St Kilda after an accidental knee to the head from Carlton's Tom De Koning. "He seems in good spirits and he's obviously stepping through his protocols in the right manner," Goodwin said. Simon Goodwin remains hopeful Melbourne star Steven May will beat his rough conduct charge but insists players will adapt to a changing landscape if the club's appeal fails. May was handed a three-match ban by the AFL Tribunal on Wednesday night over the high-speed collision that left Carlton's Francis Evans with concussion, a broken nose and a missing tooth. But the All Australian defender has maintained the ball was always his focus and will take his case to the league's Appeals Board next week. "We think he had a play on the ball and it was a football incident," Demons coach Goodwin said on Friday. "From my perspective, that's ultimately the argument that we'll go with. "Clearly there's some legal stuff that they'll go through in terms of the case as part of the appeal. "But you can see it's divided a lot of the public and I think it's one of those cases where everyone wants it to go through the appeals (process) and see what the outcome is going to be." Goodwin said May was "devastated and shattered". "Right from the outset when he first came to the bench, he was a little bit confused and thought he'd done the right thing and gone at the footy," Goodwin said. "He was shattered, he was disappointed with the outcome and clearly frustrated. "This is part of the process, go through the appeals, get the clarity required and we'll all move forward post that." Goodwin said players will adapt with the more information they get from the AFL about how they are required to act in certain scenarios. The 2021 premiership coach referenced the aerial contest between Fremantle captain Alex Pearce and Port Adelaide's Darcy Byrne-Jones, which caused similar controversy to the May-Evans collision. Pearce was handed a three-match ban before overturning it on appeal. "This is part of the game," Goodwin said. "We're learning more and more about the game and what's required in the game, and what the players need to do in the game, especially around concussion. "But if you look at the Alex Pearce case, these cases go all the way through to the appeals and you get more information." May is recovering from his own concussion, ruled out of Sunday's clash with St Kilda after an accidental knee to the head from Carlton's Tom De Koning. "He seems in good spirits and he's obviously stepping through his protocols in the right manner," Goodwin said. Simon Goodwin remains hopeful Melbourne star Steven May will beat his rough conduct charge but insists players will adapt to a changing landscape if the club's appeal fails. May was handed a three-match ban by the AFL Tribunal on Wednesday night over the high-speed collision that left Carlton's Francis Evans with concussion, a broken nose and a missing tooth. But the All Australian defender has maintained the ball was always his focus and will take his case to the league's Appeals Board next week. "We think he had a play on the ball and it was a football incident," Demons coach Goodwin said on Friday. "From my perspective, that's ultimately the argument that we'll go with. "Clearly there's some legal stuff that they'll go through in terms of the case as part of the appeal. "But you can see it's divided a lot of the public and I think it's one of those cases where everyone wants it to go through the appeals (process) and see what the outcome is going to be." Goodwin said May was "devastated and shattered". "Right from the outset when he first came to the bench, he was a little bit confused and thought he'd done the right thing and gone at the footy," Goodwin said. "He was shattered, he was disappointed with the outcome and clearly frustrated. "This is part of the process, go through the appeals, get the clarity required and we'll all move forward post that." Goodwin said players will adapt with the more information they get from the AFL about how they are required to act in certain scenarios. The 2021 premiership coach referenced the aerial contest between Fremantle captain Alex Pearce and Port Adelaide's Darcy Byrne-Jones, which caused similar controversy to the May-Evans collision. Pearce was handed a three-match ban before overturning it on appeal. "This is part of the game," Goodwin said. "We're learning more and more about the game and what's required in the game, and what the players need to do in the game, especially around concussion. "But if you look at the Alex Pearce case, these cases go all the way through to the appeals and you get more information." May is recovering from his own concussion, ruled out of Sunday's clash with St Kilda after an accidental knee to the head from Carlton's Tom De Koning. "He seems in good spirits and he's obviously stepping through his protocols in the right manner," Goodwin said.
