‘A disgrace and a slander' - President Higgins on criticisms of Netanyahu's policies being labelled anti-Semitic
President Higgins, who visited Gaza in 2006, was heavily critical of the inaction of some other nations, given Israel's heavy-handed military tactics on a nation enduring starvation and famine-like conditions.
'There are nine countries still holding back on even a ceasefire. What is happening in Gaza at the moment? Well the nation's 81pc of people have been displaced,' he told the Irish Independent.
'They have been put into temporary accommodation that is being bombed. Their soil is being destroyed, their hospitals have been bombed.'
He spoke about the unfairness that if someone spoke out against Israel's stance on Gaza and the Palestinians, they were labelled antisemitic.
He and others naturally condemned the October 7 2023 attacks by Hamas but 'if you criticise President Netanyahu's policies, you are then described as being antisemitic'.
'That is a disgrace and a slander. And it has been a slander against Ireland, against individuals, including myself, people who have worked all their lives in relation to human rights activity,' he said.
He also alleged that a 'propaganda campaign against Ireland is now active in the United States'.
'So that when we are seeking to have meetings with people interested in investing in Ireland, they are being contacted in advance with suggestions saying, 'You must open by asking (them), 'Why is Ireland so against the United States' position on Israel?''
He referenced his recent speech at the National Famine Commemoration in Limerick's Kilmallock. He spoke at the time about the failures of the UN Security Council and said it was time for the UN General Assembly to step in.
ADVERTISEMENT
'If the Security Council doesn't act, the General Assembly can have special measures for peace. It can have a special session and it can over-ride the security council,' he said.
'And in fact contrary to what has been said - that this has only been used in the case of Korea – it has been used 11 times. And now is the time. Today is the day for food and medical aid and water to be made available and I salute all those who are trying to do that.'
He also spoke about the controversial US and Israeli-backed aid group, the Gaza Aid Foundation, whose chief Jake Wood resigned this week.
'Its head has resigned because he has said he cannot work with an agency that's not in accordance with international law, that militarises aid and so on,' he said.
He also said there was little hope of the Gazans being able to produce their own food in the near future.
'You have to remember the devastation being imposed on the Palestinian people by rendering the land of Gaza unusable. Figures show that nearly 80pc of it cannot produce food again,' he said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
29 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Letters: Gaza is a humanitarian disaster zone – observing reality is not antisemitic
That this should now be a common reaction is a mark of how dangerously narrow the conversation has become and how effective the Israeli government has been in conflating legitimate criticism with bigotry. The world is watching an immense humanitarian disaster unfold. The mounting civilian death toll, the chaos of aid distribution and the absence of any viable plan for Gaza's future are not matters of opinion; they are documented realities. To point to them is not to erase October 7, or to excuse Hamas; it is to insist that collective punishment cannot be the policy of any democracy that claims the rule of law. Many of Israel's closest allies are beginning to see this. The shift in Western public opinion, especially among the young, is not because of some sudden outbreak of latent antisemitism, but because people have eyes, ears and a conscience. Enda Cullen, Tullysaran, Co Armagh Substance abuse levels are growing: children need to be educated on dangers The Health Research Board reports that more people than ever are in treatment to help them tackle alcohol and drug abuse. Its annual report on problem drug and alcohol use covers an eight-year period from 2017 to 2024. It's reported that more than 8,500 people were treated for alcohol abuse last year. Alcohol remains the drug that most people need help with, but cocaine use alongside alcohol is also rising significantly. It seems that younger people are more inclined to poly-drug use, where the older demographic tends to be more alcohol-dependent. As a clinician, I have become accustomed to seeing people who may be experiencing a concern, like pain from an injury, post-traumatic stress disorder, anxiety or depression, and instead of addressing the root cause, one sees how substance misuse temporarily numbs pain or psychological health concerns. ADVERTISEMENT One might hear this being referred to as 'self-medicating', but it's a dangerous coping mechanism. All children and young people have a right to effective drug and alcohol education that not only teaches them the facts about substances and their effects, but equips them with the skills, strategies and attributes to manage their lives. John O'Brien, Clonmel, Co Tipperary Inflation may be up by only 1.6pc officially, but our pockets tell a different tale Is the inflation index becoming fake news these days? We are told by the CSO that inflation rose by 1.6pc to the end of July, and that at the same time foodstuffs rose by 4.6pc ('Shoppers buy cheaper cuts as food prices rise at three times inflation rate', Irish Independent, August 1). Now, I know that inflation is measured by a basket of items, not just foodstuffs, but it is taking the biscuit to say inflation only rose by 1.6pc. Pocket inflation to me is the real measure. Aidan Roddy, Cabinteely, Dublin 18 Social Democrats and the Labour Party are finally pulling in same direction It is no surprise that the Social Democrats are standing by acting party leader Cian O'Callaghan's decision to re-admit Eoin Hayes to the party after his eight-month suspension, despite giving incorrect information to the media about the sale of his shares in a US software company that supplied technology to the Israeli military. He will reinstate their numbers and this will be advantageous for the purpose of committee membership and chairs. Eight months was not a long time to spend in political purgatory. According to Tabitha Monahan's article, O'Callaghan's parliamentary secretary Martha Ní Riada was not very impressed. It is interesting to see that the Labour Party has joined the Social Democrats in its endorsement of Independent Socialist candidate Catherine Connolly. I believe this is the correct option for Labour as it had no credible candidate of its own. This could be a start to the unity of the left. We will just have to see if the numbers will strengthen. Thomas Garvey, Claremorris, Co Mayo Catherine Connolly only needs Sinn Féin to row in and it's a two-horse race Well done to the Labour Party for its decision to back Independent TD Catherine Connolly in her bid for the presidency. The onus now falls on Sinn Féin to complete the opposition line-up against the Fine Gael (and, so far, the only government party candidate) Mairead McGuinness. This could now turn out to be a two-horse race. If so, the famous races on all this week at Ballybrit may augur well for the Galway girl. John Glennon, Hollywood, Co Wicklow In rush to erase the Triple Lock, it seems we have forgotten our past Which will hit the tape first, the Coalition's goal of the Triple Lock or the slow bicycle race called the Occupied Territories Bill? The Triple Lock is puzzling, talking about freeing us up to militarily involve ourselves in wars of our choice. Wars of our choice tend to be wars of the US and UK's choice. Ironically, the plain people of the nation want the OTB passed, but find legal obstacles along the way. However, the Triple Lock seems locked and loaded before Halloween falls. We are a neutral nation that once carried moral clout. Playing war games with nations smeared in supporting current genocides wasn't what Connolly and Pearse envisaged. Or have the Soldiers of Destiny forgotten entirely their past? John Cuffe, Co Meath Shinners' lack of respect and tone when talking in Dáil shames the party When Leo Varadkar was taoiseach, he made an insightful comment about Sinn Féin's behaviour and attitude in the Dáil at the time. The party always engages in demonising and putting down the Government in a way that is not parliamentary or at all cordial. It is actually dull and boring and hypocritical, given they are talking about stuff like respect for those who need hospital treatment, for example. Could the party please take some time out this August to think about how it acts in the Dáil and the tone it uses when speaking? Liam Doran, Clondalkin, Dublin
Irish Independent
29 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Now even Israel's most blind defenders are admitting the truth of what the state they support so fiercely is doing in Gaza
Britain announced it is ready to follow suit, unless Israel agrees to a ceasefire and commits to a two-state solution. President Donald Trump appears to have had a visceral reaction to the photographs of suffering children, dismissing Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's claim that 'there's no starvation in Gaza,' and saying, 'Those children look very hungry. … That's real starvation stuff. I see it, and you can't fake that.' Influential MAGA voices have sounded the alarm, too, including Marjorie Taylor Greene, who became the first Republican in Congress to call what's happening in Gaza a 'genocide". Former Trump adviser Steve Bannon sees a deeper political shift: 'It seems that for the under-30-year-old MAGA base, Israel has almost no support," told Politico. Though this might be overstating the shift, Bannon is right that Israel is haemorrhaging support among conservatives. Even before the starvation crisis broke through in international media, 50pc of Republican and Republican-leaning adults younger than 50 said they had an unfavourable view of Israel, up from 35pc in 2022. Trump said the US would work with Europeans to set up food distribution centres in Gaza. Netanyahu ordered a pause in fighting in three areas of Gaza to allow 'minimal' aid to enter. For thousands of Palestinians, this will have been both too little and too late. Israel's temporary resumption of aid comes after it cut off supplies in March. Once acute malnutrition sets in, the damage can be long-lasting, particularly in children. Bodies ravaged by hunger struggle to process even basic nutrition. At least 111 people, including 81 children, have died of starvation, according to Gaza's Health Ministry. The priority now must be to prevent more suffering. The only way that can happen is with a durable ceasefire and an end to a war that has taken the lives of more than 60,000 and perhaps tens of thousands more, according to a recent study published in the Lancet. The problem is that Netanyahu has had strong incentives to prolong the war. By July of last year, top generals determined that Israel's key objectives had been met. The war's continuation served no discernible military purpose. Netanyahu pressed on anyway because ending it would have meant political suicide within his own far-right coalition. In other words, 12 months of war – and all the resulting destruction – did not need to happen. The world is waking up to this perverse reality. Even some of Israel's fiercest defenders, such as journalist Haviv Rettig, have acknowledged the reality of 'desperate hunger' after denying the evidence for months. Amit Segal, chief political correspondent for Israel's Channel 12, wrote recently that 'Gaza may well be approaching a real hunger crisis.' These are reluctant admissions, filled with caveats. I, myself, am reluctant to commend them for the barest minimum of moral awareness and human decency. But it matters. I have Palestinian friends who respond, understandably, that the newly outspoken critics of Israel's conduct are acting in bad faith and that they should have been speaking out when it could have made a difference for the thousands of Palestinians who have already died or who are already starving. They have a point. But at the same time, The pro-Palestinian movement must be a big tent and welcome anyone willing to question their past positions and update them in the face of incontrovertible evidence of Israel's crimes against humanity. My hope is that more of Israel's most ardent supporters will come to see how this war – this genocide – is putting a permanent moral stain on a state that they believe in and have dedicated themselves to defending. Until now, whenever I provided pro-Israel hard-liners with evidence of Israel doing bad things, they would insist that there must be an explanation. Their belief – akin to a faith, really – is that Israel is good, therefore it is not capable of committing something like genocide. It is hard to reason with people whose belief is based on projection, rather than facts. An anecdote from Shaul Magid, a professor of Jewish studies at Harvard, is instructive here. He recalled: 'I once asked someone I casually know, an ardent Zionist, 'what could Israel do that would cause you not to support it?'. He was silent for a moment before looking at me and said, 'Nothing.'' But when does nothing become something? Presumably, there is a red line for Israel's supporters. And, for many, it is being breached. Only Washington commands the kind of influence that could meaningfully change Israel's behaviour. But administration after administration has been unwilling to use that leverage. Those of us who pray for a better future for Palestinians are in the uncomfortable position of placing our faith in Trump's unpredictability, which is never a good place to be. But it's where we are. It's too little, too late. But it's also not too late. The dead cannot be brought back, but the living can still be saved. For their sake, we must be willing to take yes for an answer, even when it comes from unexpected quarters. And there's one unexpected quarter that matters most, now: the Trump administration. The moral arc of the universe might bend toward justice, but it doesn't bend on its own – and it doesn't bend fast enough. If Trump, of all people, can be the instrument of ending this catastrophe, then we must swallow our pride and our doubts and pray that his visceral reaction to hungry children becomes something more than words.
Irish Independent
29 minutes ago
- Irish Independent
Trump to impose ‘shock and awe' economic penalties on Russia's trading partners, says senior Republican
Senator Jim Risch, the chairman of the powerful Senate foreign relations committee, said the US president would make good on his pledge to impose crippling economic penalties on Moscow's trading partners by August 8. The US president this week shortened his deadline for hitting Russia with the most severe sanctions on its oil experts to date, giving Vladimir Putin 10 days to reach a deal to end the war in Ukraine. 'When and if secondary sanctions hit, it's going to be shock and awe,' Senator Risch told The Telegraph. The so-called secondary sanctions − which cut short the president's previous 50-day timeframe − were slated to slap 100pc tariffs on buyers of Russian oil, with the biggest customers being India and China. However, Mr Trump appeared to water down his pledge on Wednesday, announcing that India would be hit with a 25pc tariff. India has 'always bought a vast majority of their military equipment from Russia, and are Russia's largest buyer of energy, along with China, at a time when everyone wants Russia to stop the killing in Ukraine − all things not good!' he wrote on Truth Social. 'India will therefore be paying a tariff on 25pc plus a penalty for the above, starting on August first.' The 25pc tariff is another drop after a Republican-backed bill initially proposed imposing 500pc tariffs against Russia and its allies, which was later revised to 100pc by Mr Trump. While Mr Trump confirmed he would proceed with fresh sanctions, he conceded they may have little effect on Putin's mindset. 'I am not sure it bothers him or if it has any effect, but we are going to do it,' he said. Depending on the figure, imposing sweeping sanctions on Russian oil exports has the potential to disrupt global oil supplies given that Moscow ships 4.5pc of the world's crude oil, according to the International Energy Agency. Mr Trump told reporters aboard Air Force One on Tuesday that he was not worried about potential chaos in the oil market, pledging to boost domestic production to offset any impact.
