Slow recovery from latest knock leaves McGovern's future in hands of concussion panel
'Our club doctors, in conjunction with the AFL chief medical officer, have recommended referral to the AFL concussion panel to help inform a safe way forward in the interest of his current and future welfare.
'We are awaiting a date for the panel to convene and assess Jeremy, and there are a range of outcomes that could result from their report. The club requests Jeremy's privacy is respected at this time while this confidential process unfolds.'
McGovern, among the league's best defenders in his prime, has been restricted to 34 games since the start of the 2023 season.
Last October, former West Coast teammate Luke Edwards stepped away from the game to focus on his recovery from multiple concussions. Then aged 22, Edwards suffered three concussions, his last being in the round-20 western derby in what was his 12th appearance of the season.
He joined Collingwood duo Nathan Murphy and Josh Carmichael, Melbourne premiership player Angus Brayshaw and Western Bulldogs draftee Aiden O'Driscoll as players who had careers cut short in 2024 because of concussion. Former Eagles Brad Sheppard and Daniel Venables both retired in 2021 because of concussion. – AAP
Greenberg doubles down on cricket opposition to Hobart stadium roof
Daniel Brettig
New Cricket Australia chief executive Todd Greenberg has declared roof designs for the proposed Macquarie Point stadium are 'unacceptable' for any form of cricket to be played at the venue in daylight hours, a fresh hurdle for the AFL's 19th team.
Greenberg and Cricket Tasmania chief executive Dominic Baker co-signed a submission in response to an independent assessment of plans for the stadium in Hobart, which the AFL has insisted must have a roof as a condition of entering a Tasmanian team into the league.
The May 8 submission, seen by this masthead, argues forcefully that it would not be possible to play any form of cricket in the stadium during daylight hours in summer due to the 'grid-like' roof pattern and the shadows they cast.
CA and Cricket Tasmania have also rejected proposed remedies from the Macquarie Point Development Corporation as 'unworkable'.
Loading
Baker and former CA chief Nick Hockley presented a similar argument to the Tasmanian government in March, but Greenberg's involvement has strengthened cricket's opposition.
'The proposed roof structure casts a grid-like pattern of shadows that moves across the field of play, particularly on the cricket pitch block, throughout the day, presenting an unacceptable playing, operational and broadcast environment for all forms of cricket,' the letter states.
'While MPDC and its team have explored mitigation options for the shadows, we are of the view that they are either unworkable, in that they do not eliminate the shadows, or they are temporary in nature introducing other significant potential problems relating to playing conditions, venue operations and broadcast quality.'
Greenberg and Baker go on to declare that the Tasmanian government's economic modelling for the stadium's benefits are currently based on a level of cricket content that could not be achieved under the current roof design.
'The extent to which cricket can be played in the stadium and how many matches may be played each year forms part of the cost-benefit analysis considered in the draft report,' the letter states.
'Until such time as stadium design discussions progress to a point where our current concerns can be overcome, CA and CT are unable to confirm that the content assumptions contemplated by that analysis are reliable nor that they can be achieved.
'Both CA and CT are committed to a pathway towards achieving International Cricket Council accreditation for the Macquarie Point Stadium, and in our view a design option that does not have a roof, or that has an operable roof is the best way to achieve that and secure cricket as a significant user of the stadium that can provide numerous benefits to the project and the state.'
Why Smith didn't train with Cats
Michael Gleeson
Bailey Smith did not join Geelong's main training session on Tuesday ahead of the much-anticipated clash with his former club on Thursday night.
But the high-value recruit, who has had an outstanding start to his career at the Cats, is in no danger of missing the game against the Western Bulldogs under lights at Kardinia Park.
Smith alarmed track watchers by failing to join the training session ahead of what is not only a spicy first encounter with his old club but a game that is the match of the round between two top finals contenders.
Loading
Smith, however, trained indoors doing touch work, mindful of the fact the Cats are on a quick turnaround with just five days between their win over Port Adelaide on Saturday and Thursday night's game. While Smith is an elite athlete with the blend of high-end speed and endurance, he did miss the entirety of last season because of a knee reconstruction, so is being carefully managed on short breaks.
The Cats will lose Paddy Dangerfield and Jack Bowes for the clash after they both suffered hamstring strains in last week's win. Defender Tom Stewart is set to be available to return from his knee injury. While Bowes' time on the sidelines is yet to be determined, an injury update released by the club on Tuesday said skipper Dangerfield was only expecting a short lay-off.
'Following scans on Monday, Pat is expected to miss the next one to two weeks with a low-grade right hamstring strain,' Geelong's football manager Andrew Mackie said.
'I would consider it': Little could return to Essendon board
Danny Russell, Jon Pierik
Essendon coach Brad Scott is unfazed by reports in the past 24 hours linking former chairman Paul Little and James Hird to a possible return to the club.
Seven's Agenda Setters reported on Monday night that Little, who led the club from 2013-15, was open to a return to the board currently led by David Barham and that he could return with Hird in tow.
'You never say never to anything,' Little told Seven. 'There may come a time when there is a need for a restructure.
'If I felt I could add value to the club, and if they felt I could help, then I would consider it.'
But on Nine, owner of this masthead, Hird said in a statement: 'It's news to me and I haven't spoken to Paul Little for months. I nearly fell off the couch when I heard it.'
Speaking at the Hangar on Tuesday morning just three days after his side's abysmal 91-point loss to the Western Bulldogs, Scott said he had learnt not to become distracted by outside noise.
'This might surprise you, but I haven't had any issues with the last 24 hours whatsoever,' he said.
He said he did not react to the reports nor did he seek out Barham or CEO Craig Vozzo for reassurance.
'The risk in any of that is that it distracts me from the task at hand,' Scott said of the Bombers' Dreamtime at the 'G clash at the MCG on Friday night.
'I've been really overwhelmed with the level of support and follow-through [from the club].
'And really, the things that I've made clear that were non-negotiables when I came to the club, around things like stability and support for all levels of the football club, our board and executive have delivered on those things.
'I just need to focus on my job and let all the other stuff go on in the background and not let it distract me or anyone else who's in a position of coaching, or the executive at the club.'
Scott will come face to face with media commentator Hird as a guest on Nine's Footy Classified on Tuesday night.
When asked what he expected to say to the Bomber great and former coach of the club, Scott laughed.
'Channel Nine will be rapt. You will have to tune in,' he said.
Pushed further, Scott said he had had a long-term association with the 1996 Brownlow medallist.
Loading
'We've known each other for over 30 years,' Scott said. 'I mean, we don't spend a lot of time together, but he's now a member of the media, and I try to be as respectful to all members of the media as a collective.'
Asked about Hird, he said: 'I consider him a friend both inside, but more importantly, outside of football'.
Eyebrows were raised when the Bombers extended Scott's contract early this season, a move the club said was all about stability as the Dons turn to the draft to strengthen their list after years of stagnation. The latest report will do little to foster stability, though.
Club great Matthew Lloyd said on Footy Classified: 'It's not good for the club. James obviously denied that, and you believe James in that situation, and this is what happens when you lose by 91 points, unfortunately things like this happen, whether it's from a coterie member or someone around the club.
'It's the last thing those within the football club need because they just want to get on with being the club they hope to be.'
Beveridge contract extension 'may not be too far away'
Jon Pierik
Western Bulldogs coach Luke Beveridge has suggested a contract extension is not far away.
The 2016 premiership coach is off contract this year, and is keen to remain at the Whitten Oval.
The Bulldogs and Beveridge have delayed discussing details in depth, preferring to concentrate on the season at hand. The Dogs are fifth on the ladder and are a genuine premiership threat despite having dealt with injuries to key personnel.
Beveridge said fulfilling the recommendations of an off-season review by Peter Jackson had been important, and this had now unlocked the possibility of a contract extension.
'I know we've both been talking, the club and I, in similar terms around stability and then sustainability ... the opportunity of success comes along,' Beveridge told Fox Footy.
'I think we're stable, but again, we're stable this week. Not that you need a hell of a lot of luck, but you've got to ride your fortunes. I think we're sort of morphing into this partnership again where we're looking at sustainability and thinking, 'Out of the Peter Jackson review, how healthy are we off the field as far as our operational resources go, and the club's vision of what's ahead?'
'I think we're reasonably content we're on the right path, so as far as formalising something goes, it may not be too far away.'
The Bulldogs and Beveridge are expected to open serious discussions – and potentially formalise a contract taking the coach into his 12th season and beyond – during the mid-season bye.
'Possibly, but we haven't really talked any terms and conditions,' Beveridge said.
The Bulldogs have been without prime movers Marcus Bontempelli, Liam Jones, Adam Treloar, Cody Weightman and Sam Darcy at various stages of the season. Darcy, who had been enjoying a breakout season before he hurt his knee in round six, is still on the sidelines, but could return next month.
There were initial fears the emerging forward would miss the entire season. However, he ran on Monday, and told Beveridge he was tracking well.
Loading
'It's such a unique situation – to bruise and dint the bone with a hyperextension. He had some lateral ligament damage, and then a bit of medial ligament damage as well, so that was probably the sorest part of his knee,' Beveridge revealed.
'Initially, the contemplation with regards to surgery meant it was a longer timeline, but he hasn't had surgery and he ran today. I spoke to him as he was walking around the sidelines afterwards, and said that he's feeling good ... he's lost some conditioning [and] was in a brace for just over a week.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
West Australian
24 minutes ago
- West Australian
GEORGIE PARKER: South Australian icon Barrie Robran not widely recognised because he did not play in the VFL
I awoke to a text from my mum last week: 'Barrie Robran has died. I am devastated.' She is an avid North Adelaide fan and passed that down to us kids, so I know all about Robran and how good he was. 'The best South Australian to have ever played the game,' I've been told by Mum and my Grandpa — and confirmed by none other than Ron Barassi. Bruce McAvaney simply described Robran as the 'Bradman of footy.' When Robran passed away, South Australia lost one of its most respected footballers: a three-time Magarey Medallist, seven-time premiership player, and the first SANFL inductee to be elevated to Legend status in the Australian Football Hall of Fame. For much of his career, Robran turned down lucrative offers from Victoria, staying in my home state of South Australia. He didn't need the VFL to prove his greatness — he was that good. Robran was, by any measure, a giant of the game. The news of his death made national headlines, with AFL CEO Andrew Dillon offering a touching tribute. Yet, outside of South Australia, it did seem his death passed with relatively little fanfare. Partly, I'm sure, because he kept a low profile and shied away from publicity. But I also can't help but think that if someone of his calibre had played in the VFL — even with his quiet existence after his playing days — it may have been higher up the news bulletin order. This is not just a matter of nostalgia for me, my family, and those who support the North Adelaide Roosters or South Australian players in general. It's something that always bubbles away under my skin: the AFL, in building itself as the national competition, has slowly airbrushed away the history of the leagues that laid the groundwork for its success. The VFL flags, the VFL awards, and the VFL history exist — very loudly and proudly — but the stories of the other state leagues, particularly the SANFL and WAFL, which are fiercely followed and proud competitions in their own right, are too often treated as a side piece rather than as integral parts of the game's progression to what it is today. The VFL was just one of several — not the only — elite competitions across the country before the AFL. In South Australia, the SANFL was not a feeder league. It, along with the VFL and the WAFL, were premier leagues in their respective states, with interstate matches fiercely contested. History outside of the VFL matters, and it's frustrating that it feels so secondary to the AFL. Sport is richer when it remembers where it came from. It builds identity. Clubs like Port Adelaide didn't start in 1997. Their cultures, rivalries, and supporter bases stretch back decades — and deserve to be told with the same prominence as the VFL clubs' histories. None of this means turning back the clock. But it does mean respecting the parts of the game that didn't originate in Melbourne. It means treating figures like Robran not as state-based legends, but as national icons — just like we do for the VFL equivalents. We've created a wonderful national competition that encompasses the entirety of this great land. We've combined all these proud leagues, so can't we also tell the stories of those who made the game great in those places long before the AFL arrived, with the same amount of gusto we give to those who played for Collingwood or Carlton in the same era? I don't know if I'm alone in this feeling as an 'interstate' supporter, but I feel as though we are the second cousins in all of this. The ones you don't really know much about, but your parents said you need to invite anyway. Robran never needed the VFL to validate his career, so I guess he wouldn't be too worried about my gripe. But it's a real shame that his legacy isn't showcased to the extent it probably should have been — and that a whole generation of kids will walk past his statue out the front of the Adelaide Oval and say, 'Mum, who's that?' rather than smiling at it with pride, like I do.
News.com.au
3 hours ago
- News.com.au
‘Never seen that': Collingwood tactic causes stir after Fremantle defeat
Collingwood rolled the dice with a tactic many footy commentators had never seen before in the frenzied final moments of their loss to Fremantle. The Magpies' lost back-to-back games for the first time in 12 months in their Sunday showdown at the MCG, giving up a 22-point lead in the final quarter as the fast-finishing Dockers ran over the top of them to win a thriller by one point. FOX FOOTY, available on Kayo Sports, is the only place to watch every match of every round in the 2025 Toyota AFL Premiership Season LIVE in 4K, with no ad-breaks during play. New to Kayo? Get your first month for just $1. Limited-time offer. Essendon icon James Hird on Sunday night praised Collingwood for the club's late tactical switch despite the team falling short. The Brownlow medalist exposed the team's risky move to avoid committing to tackles in the final minutes as they chased a match-winning goal. Speaking on Channel 9's Footy furnace, Hird highlighted moments where Collingwood players deliberately held back from tackles in order to avoid ball-ups and stoppages. 'Collingwood do 'one percenters' better than everyone else,' Hird said. 'You look at these couple tackles here, the group tackles where the players are held. They tackle here and then he (Steele Sidebottom) backs off. They're backing off because they want to keep the ball in motion. 'This is why Collingwood, even though they lost, for me is such a well coached team. Every part of the game is coached down to the minutia of that. 'That must have been practiced and I reckon they would have gone back and said if we're a goal down with two minutes to go, we do not want stoppages, we want the ball in motion. 'How do we keep the ball in motion? This is the way we do it.' Leading footy journalist Tom Morris said he had never seen the tactic before. Hird responded by saying: 'I've seen it, but not to this extent. That's why Craig McRae is up there with the best coaches in the competition along with a couple of others because his coaching staff are teaching their players in moments how to be so successful.' It wasn't enough to get the Pies over the line with the Dockers' win setting up a hot fight to finish on top of the ladder. Collingwood did everything but beat the Dockers as McRae's men finished with massive buffers in contested possessions (151-131), tackles (86-65) and inside 50s (63-40), but they were undone by their lack of forward efficiency. 'This is one of those games you look at, 'OK. We've got some work to do', and I'd rather be learning those lessons now than learning them later on in the year,' McRae said. 'It just didn't feel like we connected that well this week again, but it's one of those hard games when you dominate so much of the territory, you're winning it back and you go into such density, so it makes it really hard to score. 'But I can't help but feel frustrated at that game because you feel like you did so much right and then you don't get the nourishment of a win. 'I also would've thought we did enough right to get the job done today.' Collingwood are renowned as the close-game specialists since McRae took over in 2022, but after only losing four of 25 games decided by six points or less in the previous three seasons, they've now fallen short in three such games this year. 'Yes and no,' McRae said when asked if he was still backing the method that had served them so well in tight finishes heading into 2025. 'This is not something you've ever got handled, because every game is opportunities live and delayed moments. 'Managing those moments will be forever something we need to do, and if the scoreboard's an indication, we haven't managed it well enough. 'Have we lost our spark? You'd hope not.' Collingwood have taken the liberty of resting players over the past fortnight, given their lead at the top of the ladder was 10 points prior to Round 17, but now that it's shrunk to two, McRae insisted he wouldn't change the way they approached the management of his charges. 'We'll do what's best for our group for what that looks like and when it needs to be in that situation,' McRae said. 'Hard to manage at the moment too many because we haven't got too many others available but the reality is we'll keep doing what we're doing ... it's a long year.' The premiership coach took comfort from the fact that his side suffered some similar hiccups late in the 2023 season before going on to win the flag that year. Meanwhile, McRae forecast forward Tim Membrey and onballer Tom Mitchell would both be available for their clash with Richmond next week.
News.com.au
5 hours ago
- News.com.au
Gold Coast Suns coach Damien Hardwick says his team will learn from and not shy away from Adelaide shellacking
Gold Coast coach Damien Hardwick is adamant Sunday's 'kick in the nuts' in Adelaide won't derail the Suns' charge at a maiden finals berth despite an injury blow to star recruit Daniel Rioli. The Suns went goalless in the first half, for the first time in club history, and lost by 61 points to finals rivals the Crows a week after arguably the best win in the club's history against Collingwood. A typically forthright Hardwick didn't mince words in his post-match assessment. 'Every good side I've been a part of gets a kick in the nuts at some stage and today was our kick in the nuts,' Hardwick said. 'We didn't kick very well, we didn't take our chances, and they did. 'You've got to take your chances when you play away, and we had some outstanding looks going across the arcs, and we just stuffed them up. 'Sometimes it's the (crowd) noise and you think you've got less time than what you actually have, and we just didn't execute that well enough. 'So, the things we'll take into account is we're still a side that is learning how to win those big games. 'This year we've been good at stages, but we've been disappointing too and tonight was probably one of those disappointing ones.' While the scoreboard was damning at halftime, and still didn't paint a pretty picture at the final siren, Hardwick didn't feel it was an accurate reflection of the contest. Gold Coast generated plenty of scoring opportunities, with one more inside 50 than Adelaide at halftime and six more entries by the end of the match. 'They exerted more influence on the scoreboard than we did, it's pretty simple, I thought the periods that we had sustained dominance, we just failed to score,' Hardwick said. 'And a little bit of that was on us, with some execution going across the arcs, and some of it was the Crows' good defensive play. 'But the game should have been closer than what it actually was … the scoreboard probably reflected a different game, I thought, from a contest point of view than it should have been.' As a result of his post-siren altercation with Riley Thilthorpe after the Suns' controversial win earlier in the year, Mac Andrew was public enemy No.1 for Crows fans who booed him loudly throughout. Thilthorpe kicked two goals and Andrew gave away another to Luke Pedlar for an undisciplined act, but Hardwick was fine with the focus the key defender brought on himself. 'He's probably one of our best players tonight, so I'm prepared to back him in with all that sort of stuff,' Hardwick said. 'I understand that's how it is, he's one of the best key position players in the land and him and Riley are going to have many, many battles over the next 10 to 12 years. 'And we all get the pleasure of watching it, which is great. 'It doesn't worry him. You know what the very best players do? They get a rise off it. So, keep yelling at him and all that sort of stuff. 'He'll just get better and better.'
