Cal HC asks Odisha govt to file affidavit in opposition to migrant workers detention claim
The Odisha government strongly denied before the court the contention that they were illegally detained.
The court was informed that the two migrant workers over whom the habeas corpus petition was filed Sainur Islam and Rakibul Islam have already returned to their residences.
Alleging that the two were illegally detained in Odisha, the petitioners' lawyer claimed that they are entitled to compensation.
This contention was disputed by the Advocate General of Odisha.
A division bench presided by Justice Tapabrata Chakraborty directed the Odisha government to file an affidavit in opposition to the contention of the petitioners by August 20.
The petitioners were directed to file their reply to the contention of the Odisha government in its affidavit by August 27.
The court directed that the matter will come up for hearing again on August 29.
Odisha Advocate General Pitambar Acharya, appearing before the court through the virtual mode, submitted that there was no arrest of the persons over whom the habeas corpus petitions were filed.
He stated before the court that the law encrafted in the Foreigners' Act authorises the civil authority to do certain things in respect of the suspected persons whose citizenship is in doubt.
He stated that there was no arrest and that it was a lawful verification of documents as provided in the law, claiming that it was a frivolous petition.
Acharya stated that the Odisha government has already submitted a status report on the matter before the court.
Appearing for the West Bengal government, senior counsel Kalyan Banerjee stated that the opinion about a person's citizenship must be reasonable.
The division bench had on July 10 directed the Odisha government to place before it relevant documents on whether the two had been detained or were missing.
They were directed to answer that if they have been detained, whether such detention was in connection with any court's order and the grounds for that.
The Odisha government was also asked to answer whether there has been any correspondence between the West Bengal and Odisha governments.
After the order was dictated, Banerjee claimed that this was not a simple habeas corpus petition.
Acharya stated that this was not an issue between the state governments of Odisha and West Bengal.
He said that it is not about the citizenship of any of the two states, but of the nation.
When Banerjee claimed that several Bengalis have been detained in Odisha over citizenship issues, Acharya said, "Bengalis are our neighbours and brothers and sisters. Most of the Odia people are very fond of Bengalis."
He said that the current Chief Justice of the Odisha High Court is a Bengali.
"We are not opposed to you, why are you opposing us?" Acharya asked, to which Banerjee said, "We must know how many Bengalis have been detained in this process."
Banerjee further claimed that the alleged targeting of Bengali-speaking migrant workers in some states has become a national issue now.
This article was generated from an automated news agency feed without modifications to text.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
42 minutes ago
- Time of India
Bengalis who got NRC notices at forefront of TMC protests
Jalpaiguri: Uttam Kumar Brajabashi of Dinhata and Nishikanta Das of Mathabhanga — who received NRC notices from the foreigners tribunal in Assam — on Sunday were at the forefront of protests by Trinamool Congress against "targeting" of Bengali migrants by BJP, in Cooch Behar's Jorai on the Assam-Bengal border. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Arati Ghosh from Baxirhat, who left her in-laws' house in Assam's Barpeta in 2019 after her NRC application was rejected, was also present. Dinhata MLA Udayan Guha, former Natabati MLA and Cooch Behar municipality chairman Rabindranath Ghosh, and former Cooch Behar MP Partha Pratim Roy took part in the demonstration along with Cooch Behar Trinamool resident Avijit De Bhowmik. After the rally, Trinamool supporters held a meeting where netas expanded on how BJP was harassing Bengali-speakers across the country. Assam govt had alleged Brajabashi was an illegal immigrant who entered India between 1966 and 1971. Brajabashi claimed he was born in 1975 and never went to Assam. Septuagenarian Nishikanta Das was also served a notice by the foreign tribunal. Although he appeared produced an Aadhaar card, EPIC and ration card at the hearing, the tribunal rejected these. Ghosh left Assam before getting a notice, saying she did not have the documents Assam govt was looking for.
The Hindu
an hour ago
- The Hindu
Mamata launches ‘language movement', condemns targeting of migrant's family in Delhi
West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee condemned the targeting of a migrant's family in Delhi on the day her party launched a 'language movement' to protest against the targeting of migrants from the State in BJP-ruled States. 'Atrocious!! Terrible!! See how Delhi police brutally beat up a kid and his mother, members of a migrant family from Malda's Chanchal. See how even a child is not spared from the cruelty of violence in the regime of linguistic terror unleashed by BJP in the country against Bengalis! ,' the Chief Minister said on social media. Ms. Banerjee wanted to know, 'where are they [BJP led government] taking the country now?' On Sunday (July 27, 2025), protest marches were organised across the State in line with plans announced by the Trinamool Congress chairperson. Ms. Banerjee had on July 21, at a Martyrs Day rally, announced the start of a 'language movement' against the targeting of migrants in the BJP-ruled States. The Chief Minister had called for protests every weekend till the next year's Assembly polls. Language movement From the streets of Kolkata to districts across the State, hundreds of people participated in the protests which the Trinamool has described as a 'language movement.' Some protesters also held posters highlighting the Bengali alphabet implying that BJP-ruled States are targeting migrants for speaking in Bengali. Migrants from West Bengal have been detained in different States like Odisha, Haryana and Delhi on suspicion of being Bangladeshi nationals. Some migrants from West Bengal have also been pushed into Bangladesh. The Trinamool Congress chairperson has claimed that there is a directive issued by Ministry of Home Affairs to detain migrants and so far about 1,000 workers from the State has been detained in BJP ruled states. Along with the protests against migrants the Trinamool Congress has also raised concerns about the possibility of a SIR (Special Incentive Revision). 'The protest against SIR isn't just a reaction, it's a rejection of @BJP4India's plan to introduce the NRC through the backdoor! BJP is targeting poor, marginalised citizens with illegal notices, beyond their jurisdiction. It's a calculated attack on Bengal's identity, a violation of constitutional rights, and a war on the powerless,' the Trinamool Congress tweeted from its official handle, adding, 'We will defend every voice they're trying to erase!'
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
Detainees being released, but crackdown on ‘illegal immigrants' continues in Gurugram
In a major crackdown, the Gurugram police have detained individuals for allegedly staying in the city without valid documents as part of a special drive being carried out in adherence to orders from the Ministry of Home Affairs to identify and deport 'illegal immigrants'. Over the past week, hundreds of suspected 'illegal immigrants' were reportedly sent to detention centres for verification of documents. However, the drive has drawn widespread criticism over the alleged harassment of detainees and targeting of Bengali-speaking migrant workers from Assam and West Bengal. A visit on Sunday (July 27, 2025) to the special holding centres designated by the district administration showed that many detainees were being released. The special holding centre in Gurugram's Sector 10A, a dimly-lit hall at a community centre, stood empty with only a pile of carpets and a few packets of 'pav (bread)' lying in a dark corner. 'There were around 70 Bengali-speaking people kept in this room three days ago. Most of them were from Assam and West Bengal. They were all kept locked inside this room with four policemen keeping guard outside. But they were all let off two days ago,' said Krishna, the security guard at the community centre. Pritam, the lone sanitation worker at the centre, recalled struggling to keep the premises clean with numerous detainees sharing a single toilet. 'It's good that they have gone. The police personnel have also left. I hope they won't return,' he said. Three other such centres have been set up in Gurugram's Sector 40, Manesar's Sector 1, and Badshahpur to detain Bangladeshi nationals and Rohingya refugees found to be staying illegally in the country. The holding centre at Manesar is also currently empty. According to the security guard, 35 of the 45 detainees were released by the police a couple of days ago, while 10 were taken away in a police vehicle. A constable deployed at the centre said despite the reduced number of detainees, 10 police personnel remained deployed there. 'The holding centre has not been shut. No fresh raids are being carried out as the police are busy holding the two-day Common Eligibility Test across the State. More detainees could come tomorrow (Monday) morning,' said the constable from the Pataudi police station. He added that he was part of the team conducting raids to identify and apprehend 'illegal immigrants', but declined to be identified. 'Special teams have been constituted in each police station to hold the raids, which are mostly conducted in the early hours of the day. The raids have been going on for the past 20 days, but these centres were set up a week ago,' he said. At the centre in Gurugram's Sector 40, several policemen were found playing cards and they said there was currently only one detainee. 'We are here as more detainees could come,' one of them said. Gurugram Police spokesperson Assistant Sub-Inspector Sandeep Kumar confirmed that the drive was still ongoing and suspects would be brought to the holding centres for further probe. 'Only those suspected of staying illegally in the country are brought to these centres. Those without identity documents or found making calls to Bangladesh, raising suspicion, are detained for further investigation,' he said. Basra, a 50-year-old meat shop owner in Chakkarpur's 'Macchi Mandi', said there have been no fresh police raids in the area over the past two days. 'The police teams came two or three times last week to check documents, but there have been no raids now,' he said. Meanwhile, Nuh MLA and former Haryana Transport Minister Aftab Ahmed condemned the treatment of migrant workers from Assam and West Bengal, mostly Muslims, during the verification drive, calling it 'inhuman, shameful, and unfortunate'. Mr. Ahmed alleged that the drive was creating an environment of fear, forcing people to flee Gurugram. Drawing a parallel with the treatment of non-Marathi speakers in Maharashtra, he claimed the Gurugram police were similarly targeting citizens in Haryana. He added that he has brought this matter to the attention of the State Director General of Police.
